Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Originally posted by Homeoskeptic
"From all the exposure recently (e.g., the BBC Horizon program, 'negative trial results on Arnica, and associated bad press reportage), one could be forgiven for thinking that any attempt to reconcile homeopathy with science is simply a waste of time. After all, even though plenty of trials have been done, many of which support homeopathy, it must be patently obvious to anyone with even half a brain, that no amount of testing is going to persuade non- believers that homeopathy works or, on the contrary, dissuade believers that it doesn't. So, why bother? Scientifically speaking, we haven't even begun to scratch the surface of what homeopathy is really about and to predict that ultimately when we do, homeopathy and science will both benefit.

OK, in the context of homeopathy, what is 'science'? Bigger and better double blind placebo-controlled trials (DBPCTS) on potentised remedies, as the conventional scientific community would wish? I don't think so.
There would be a deafening outcry for ever more DBPCTs if they should favor homeopathy, and "Nya, nya, we told you so!” if they shouldn't, simply underlining the strength of feeling that homeopathic issues generate (and objectivity can sometimes be the first casualty in this debate). In my view, ever more DBPCTs merely prolong a stultifying and inconclusive ideological trench warfare between two opposing factions - on the one hand, conventional biomedicine and its hard-line reductionist (i.e., Newtonian) determinism, and on the other, homeopathy and any other CAM whose mechanism of healing doesn't neatly fit in with bio-medicine's reductionist paradigm.
HS, let's get one thing straight here:
Scientists aren't interested in making the homeopaths look like fools. they just want to find out if homeopathy does as claimed. If it does, they will be the first to endorse their findings too.
Unlike you, we don't have any vested interest in it. We don't make our living scamming gullible people with sugar tablets and bottles of water, so we don't care either way if homeopathy is proven to work or not. You however ...

And despite your false claims, there really aren't "many trials which support homeopathy". In fact, the one thing we kept asking you lot over at H'pathy, and which you could never provide, was details or even links to trials which came up favorably for homeopathy. All you could come up with was three measely meta-analyses that just showed that there might have been something there, but it could just have been dumb luck. Conclusion on all three studies "Further study will prove if there really was anything there". Further studies never got published because they probably showed it actually was just coincidence.
 
Originally posted by geni
Nope there are a number of people who have posted sceptical stuff and got banned after one post.
Now see, that doesn't count, because they posted skeptical stuff, I didn't, I just asked them to answer the question, and if they knew any good positive trials (which of course, they know is trolling, but not from a newbie point of view :D).

In other words, they are now banning newbies that ask annoying questions. Pretty soon, people genuinely asking for help will be banned for asking too many explanations. It seems we may be getting somewhere after all. :)
 
exarch said:
One post. I got banned after one post. Is that a new record?
No. Just go ask BSM how many of his socks got banned after one post. I lost count. (And I wasn't always sure it was him.)

He posted once as "Equus asinus" because Divina had just told him that he better call himself "Jackass" next time. (Periplaneta is "cockroach", and I think she knew this.) All Equus asinus posted was a single smilie. But I just checked and in fact that sock amazingly enough isn't banned. Maybe they'll rectify that now I've pointed it out.

Rolfe.
 
I was trying to find a sentence in Naturalhealth's latest rant that was lucid enough to quote and discuss, but I failed utterly.

OK, it's been said before, many times, but here goes again.

We don't care whether you call homoeopathy an art or a science. We don't give a damn how it works, as a first approach. Molecules, energies, doesn't matter. We only want to know that it works.

Just show, to a reasonable level of statistical significance, and repeatably, that a group of people who got their prescribed remedy had, on average, a better chance of getting better than a similar group of people who only thought they got their remedy. Should be easy. Should be a piece of cake, if you can do even a tenth of what you claim to be able to do.

That sort of trial is amazingly sensitive. It can, and has, demonstrated effects which were rare enough or subtle enough that nobody just randomly working their way through cases had even guessed were happening. And it doesn't care a toss what the mechanism of action is.

Anything capable of producing the self-evident effects you claim for homoeopathy should stick out a mile in a trial like that.

The reason you're still arguing isn't some strange difference of philosophy, or any prejudice against you. It's because you're so closed-minded that you can't accept when your pet theory has been totally and completely debunked.

Bill Hoyt is right. Nobody is suppressing homoeopathy. The one thing scientific workers want to achieve in their lives is to be the first one to answer a mystery. If they really thought there was a mystery in homoeopathy they'd be all over it like a rash. The entire might of the medical establishment would be unable to lift a finger against this, even if they wanted to (believe it or not, what the medical establishment wants most is to cure disease, and it doesn't care how so long as the method is safe and effective, it's just that homoeopathy was given up on long ago as ineffective). It would be the physicists and the chemists who would be most interested, because it's their disciplines which are most overturned by the concept. It would make cold fusion look like a kindergarten science afternoon.

But all we have is a few mavericks in the biological sciences (mostly making complete fools of themselves, like Benveniste) paddling around in the shallows. Because the real basic scientists know perfectly well that there's no career advancement in trying to find out a mechanism for an effect that doesn't exist.

By the way, have you decided yet whether you want the Million Dollars, Naturalhealth? If I knew I could do something that would be certain to win it, by golly, I'd have a go.

Rolfe.
 
Kumar said:
Surprising, it means Dr.jkr was absolutely wrong in telling no presence of sugar.
Yes. He was absolutely wrong.

He understands this less well than you do, Kumar. Throwing sugar in the sea has nothing to do with homoeopathic dilutions, but because of his poor understanding he doesn't realise this.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe are you dumb? You don't even think acupuncture does anything. no amount of evidence would ever satisfy you. Your mind may be permanently twisted.
 
olaf said:
<s>Rolfe</s> Olaf are you dumb? You <s>don't even</s> actually think acupuncture does anything. no amount of evidence would ever satisfy you. Your mind may be permanently twisted.
Fixed.
 
Kumar said:
What do you mean by--" isn't significantly changed", are you saying that some insignificant changes can be possible? What about magnetic fields & other radiations or rays(like sun rays/X-rays etc.) can these effect the quality of distilled water?
I put it like that because I'm not certain of the subtleties of some of the physics. I don't think it's changed in any way to make it different from other water.

As far as I know, electromagnetic radiation doesn't affect water except to heat it if the wavelength is infra-red. However, I'm sure there are some physics specialists here who can tell you in better detail.

Kumar, what is the point of this? On one hand we have the whole of medicine using molecules it understands to cause effects to happen in biological systems it understands. The subject is enormous, and extremely interesting, and there are many many really obvious effects there to be seen and to study. On the other hand we have homoeopathy, which cannot point to one self-evident effect and say, our remedies can do this, and whose action cannot be distinguished from the natural course of the untreated disease.

You seem to prefer to speculate wildly about extremely unlikely physical effects that might be doing something we totally don't understand, to try to explain something that doesn't seem to exist - that is the "effect" of homoeopathy. Why not put the same effort into studying what is known about biology and medicine, and find out how the body really does work and really does interact with effective drugs. It's really interesting, and unlkike homoeopahty, constructive.

Yes, I know, sometimes real medicines have undesirable effects. The world isn't perfect. When you try to do something, even for the best, sometimes things go wrong. Anything which is capable of having an effect, can potentially have a bad effect. But this is not a reason to give up on effective medicine. It is a reason to try to do it better and to make the bad effects fewer.

The alternative is to follow homoeopathy, a system which uses "remedies" which have no effect at all on the body, and so of course are not able to do harm. (Though paradoxically the homoeopaths believe they can do harm of course, and even inert "remedies" can do harm if badly prepared.)

Badly Shaved Monkey had a good analogy. Imagine you are trying to cut down a tree. You use a chain saw. No, no, say the homoeopaths, chain saws are terribly dangerous, you mustn't even think of using such a thing. Here, use this nice soft feather. That can't possibly hurt you.

We are trying to point out the although the feather can't hurt you, neither can it cut down the tree. The solution is not to keep sawing away with the feather, it is to use the chain saw as carefully as possible, with all the safety gear and safety attachments that come with it.

So we invite you so stop speculating about whether feathers might have some sort of electromagnetic aura that will slice through tree-trunks, and instead find out how the chain saw works and how it can be used safely.

Rolfe.
 
"Energy is the real substance behind the
appearance of matter and forms."
- Dr. Randolph Stone
 
Rolfe said:
As far as I know, electromagnetic radiation doesn't affect water except to heat it if the wavelength is infra-red. However, I'm sure there are some physics specialists here who can tell you in better detail.
A microwave oven operates at approximately 2.45 GHz, and this is certainly electromagnetic radiation and at a *far* lower frequency than infra-red.

However, the working principles of a microwave oven is well known, and relates to water molecules absorbing the radiation, converting it to kinetic energy and therefore heat.

Now, what can microwaves do for homeopathy?
Well, short periods in a microwave should make a most effective succussion machine. After all, molecules are pretty excited in a microwave... :p
 
mroek said:
Now, what can microwaves do for homeopathy?
Well, short periods in a microwave should make a most effective succussion machine. After all, molecules are pretty excited in a microwave... :p
Ah, but too much succussion can be dangerous!

Hahnemann at one point recommended a reduction in succussion:
A long experience and multiplied observations upon the sick lead me within the last few years to prefer giving only two shakes to medicinal liquids, whereas I formerly used to give ten.
Sometimes he struck the vial on a leather book rather than shaking it.

The reason for the use of the sugar pills rather than liquid remedy is apparently because Hahnemann was worried that if liquid remedies were shaken up in transit then they might become too powerful.

Of course nowadays they just touch them to a vortex mixer and call it succussed. What all that electricity is doing to the potency I dread to imagine. Use a microwave and no doubt you'd kill half of Europe!

Rolfe.
 
I reguarly do 1/10 dilutions with mixing inbetween, ye gads to think i am a homeopath and i didn't know it!!!

What have i done to my bacteria? What have i unleashed upon the world?

I'll be cast out of the illuminati for sure!
 
mroek said:
A microwave oven operates at approximately 2.45 GHz, and this is certainly electromagnetic radiation and at a *far* lower frequency than infra-red.

However, the working principles of a microwave oven is well known, and relates to water molecules absorbing the radiation, converting it to kinetic energy and therefore heat.

Now, what can microwaves do for homeopathy?
Well, short periods in a microwave should make a most effective succussion machine. After all, molecules are pretty excited in a microwave... :p

Intresting.

I have asked 'the change in water quality after it cools down/settles. Some taste differance is felt.
 
Prester John said:
I reguarly do 1/10 dilutions with mixing inbetween, ye gads to think i am a homeopath and i didn't know it!!!

What have i done to my bacteria? What have i unleashed upon the world?

I'll be cast out of the illuminati for sure!

Nope. I've delibrately made up a homeopathic remedy in an attemtp to see if I could do myself any harm with one by drinking it. After multiple doses ant potencies of about 50C I didn't notice any effect so I poured the rest down the sink.
 
Originally posted by Kumar
I have asked 'the change in water quality after it cools down/settles. Some taste differance is felt.
I wonder.

Kumar, I can taste a huge difference between plain tap water, that same tap water after it's been in the fridge and when it's been warmed up. Plain warm water, by the way, is disgusting if it doesn't have tea or coffee in it :(

I have heard, and some believe it is an urban legend, that microwaved water, especially in a glass container, can become superheated. This is a stage where the water will become hotter than 100 degrees C, but is unable to start boiling because there are less impurities in glass, and less temperature differences (and convection) than in a cooking pot on a fire, to start of evaporation. The result when disturbing the water with a spoon is apparently similar to what happens when pooring water in a fryer (i.e. big splash of boiling liquid all over the place). It seems people have had serious burn injuries this way.

That's the only weird thing regarding water and microwaves that I've heard of.
 
geni said:

...snip.... 50C I didn't notice any effect so I poured the rest down the sink.

Are you MAD! :eek: You could have contaminated the water supply for millions of people! ;)


One of the chuckles I have with homoeopathists is asking "And what do you do with all your waste product?”.

Can you imagine the outrage a major pharmaceutical would invoke if they poured all their waste products into the local sewers?

Yet here we have a product that is so potent, so effective yet as far as I am aware there is no regulation about how their dangerous waste products are disposed of.

(Mind you I reckon it could be a good earner - I’m quite happy to take away all the homeopathic waste products from any of these multi-million dollar companies, for an exorbitant fee, and dispose of them via a process I will be able to prove is 100% safe for the environment.)
 
Originally posted by Darat
(Mind you I reckon it could be a good earner - I’m quite happy to take away all the homeopathic waste products from any of these multi-million dollar companies, for an exorbitant fee, and dispose of them via a process I will be able to prove is 100% safe for the environment.)
I bet you couldn't drink in a month what they produce in a day. If they make their remedies the way they claim and the way they should be made ...
 
exarch said:
I bet you couldn't drink in a month what they produce in a day. If they make their remedies the way they claim and the way they should be made ...

That's actually a really interesting thought, I wonder if it is possible to find out how much water one of the big-business homeopathic companies uses?
 
Darat said:
That's actually a really interesting thought, I wonder if it is possible to find out how much water one of the big-business homeopathic companies uses?
I'm not so sure. They don't admit to any expiry date or the remedies losing their potency through time. So what if they just kept the n-1 dilution as a "stock" and diluted up from that whenever required? Or maybe the n-2 if that would give better capacity for less storage.

If you look at the Helios web site, they list hundreds of remedies at a wide range of potencies. On a previous thread, Geni worked out how many individual stock items that represented, and it was a lot. I do wonder how they manage to keep all that stuff available without going all the way up from the mother tincture every time - which as you say, would be quite a procedure.

On the other hand, if you just use, say, 5 ml vials to do your diluting, it's not really gallons - 150 ml for a 30C remedy I think. If you need more, then just increase the volume at the very final dilution stage.

Which is where the mind-boggling bit comes in - it's difficult to comprehend that such a small amount of solvent can be used to produce a final dilution equivalent to one molecule in a container several times the size of the planet Earth! Which is why people have difficulty believing what homoeopathy really is, and make the mistake of thinking that a bag of sugar in all the world's oceans is a meaningful analogy (which it isn't, this is well under 12C and comes out at about one molecule in 10 ml).

But then again, someone in an earlier thread had the excellent business plan of supplying homoeopathic remedies at a very competitive price. The idea was simply to supply bottles of the solvent, or bottles of the sugar pills, unlabelled, plus a stock of labels to be affixed as appropriate to the remedy ordered. Much cheaper to produce, and no way at all to tell such a product from the fully-potentised version, and if the patients or prescribers noticed anything, we'd all eat out collective hats. :D

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom