"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?


So, it does not matter to you, that your God kills more unborn babies than abortionists do ?

Why did you not answer my question concerning the justification of your assertion, Skeptical Greg?

Please give me any acceptable basis for your assertion first, Skeptical Greg,
and then, if you like, we can pursue your question and I will answer, Skeptical Greg.

Somehow I have a feeling that 154 will continue to put more effort into avoiding the question as opposed to answering it.
 
Somehow I have a feeling that 154 will continue to put more effort into avoiding the question as opposed to answering it.
I'll answer, without hesitation, but can you help SG to substantiate if the question is even true? Does it even matter to you if the question is true? Arisia, is that question true?
 
So you were just being facetious when you said that you would adopt an unwanted child?

Should have said that right from the beginning.
 
So you were just being facetious when you said that you would adopt an unwanted child?

Should have said that right from the beginning.
No, absolutely not, I was not being facetious.
However, I never said that I would adopt that child or baby.
By what logic did you draw either of those conclusions?
 
Last edited:
Once again, I'm pro-choice. But I think it's making a distinction without a difference to divide a 32 week-old fetus from a coma patient based on any of this. A fetus has a family. It's impossible for it not to have a family. And it can have a name. Visit any cemetary to see the names of fetuses who died before birth. I went to a funeral after a mother miscarried at 5 months.
Does a fetus who's going to be given up for adoption have a family? Oh sure, the fetus has a mother, but it's not a member of a family in the same way that Aunt Bessie is. You don't invite it to weddings or have it sign your christmas card. And a name isn't conferred until a certificate of live birth or stillbirth is issued. Neither of my fetuses had a name before they were born; of course, I didn't even know if they would be male or female.
And a birthday? Some cultures don't even celebrate birthdays. If you're referring to having been born, this is just defining the terms in a way that lets one win. If I call anything that gets past the 20 yard line a "touchdown," then my team won today.
So you don't think a birthday is in any way important? It's actually the dividing line between being a fetus and being a person. You get a certificate and you can apply for a social insurance number and be considered a dependent for tax purposes. None of that happens before an actual date of birth when you stopped living off your mother's body and started living on your own.
How is having done some living in the material world different from being about to do some living in the material world?
Are you really asking this? Do you have any memories of the things you've done? You probably even have some pictures, school records, that kind of thing. That's completely different from a fetus who has done absolutely nothing.
And what does that make those very sick babies who are born and remain unconscious? Do they never gain personhood?
I would classify them as persons (were I queen of the world) with the right to medical care. They are still issued birth certificates and can be counted as dependents for tax purposes or welfare benefits.
Funny you should mention that. As a family and elder law attorney, I spend a great part of my workday stripping the property from elderly, ill and unconscious people.
I'm sure that happens. But I'm sure it's not a matter of, "So and so is in a coma. Dibs on her bank account." You're not just saying that somebody is no longer a person and has no longer has a right to their own property.
I see nothing in the definition of a comatose patient (whether he will or will not recover) that necessarily differentiates him from a fetus - unless of course you just say "birth is necessary for personhood by definition." But I see no necessarily true reason to say such a thing.
No difference? So if you see a comatose patient in the hospital, you sometimes do a double take because for a second you thought you were looking at a pregnant woman? A fetus is living inside a woman's body. Sometimes I wish holodeck technology of some kind was possible so that men could understand exactly what it's like to have a creature living inside their abdomen. Once it happens, you'll understand how a fetus is nothing like a baby, and most definitely nothing like a comatose patient.
not a siThus, to my mind, the pro-choice position is not going to win based on concepts of personhood. I think it would be easier to defend the idea that "personhood" does not, in and of itself, confer an absolute right to life.
But so far the pro-life side is "winning" based on the concepts of personhood. A fetus is not legally counted as a person.

And Sun Countess,
I ask for your answer to this previous question:
Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?
Sure they have. I've said it myself. But only to people who I wanted touching my belly. (Oh yes, another "blessing" of pregnancy is having acquaintances and even complete strangers assuming that my belly is suddenly public property.) Earlier in the pregnancy, I referred to them as my little embryos. Maybe that makes me weird. Whichever, a woman referring to a fetus as a "baby" doesn't magically mean that it's not a fetus, any more than a man calling his dog his "baby" or "child" makes it anything other than a dog.

I'll answer, without hesitation, but can you help SG to substantiate if the question is even true? Does it even matter to you if the question is true? Arisia, is that question true?
Approximately half of all conceptions result in spontaneous abortion (miscarriage). Most of those are before the woman is even aware that she's pregnant, but approximately 10 - 15% of women will miscarry after eight weeks.
 
I know that you meant, or at least I reasonably assume that you meant "crows."

Nope. Greg meant chickens. Chickens come home to roost, crows don't. So your reasonable assumption is not reasonable. ;)
 
Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?

Sun countess says she has but I have never heard it. When it is wanted it is a baby if it is not wanted it is an embryo.

I don't understand how anyone who has given birth to a baby they wanted can feel an embryo is not a living being who deserved a chance at life.
 
Somehow I have a feeling that 154 will continue to put more effort into avoiding the question as opposed to answering it.

True.
A long time back I asked about the means he has to cater for the multitudes of unwanted babies.
Never had an answer.
 
Sun countess says she has but I have never heard it. When it is wanted it is a baby if it is not wanted it is an embryo.

I don't understand how anyone who has given birth to a baby they wanted can feel an embryo is not a living being who deserved a chance at life.

Quick question: Have you ever given birth to a baby?
 
This just confirms every punitive description of pro-lifers. Well done.

Don't have time to talk, but I'm right so listen up: you little ladies need to keep your legs crossed or wear a condom, otherwise you get a baby, like it or not. Take care now, I don't care much what you have to say in response.

Oh, boys: if she remembers your name you may have to pay child support. Be careful 'bout that.

Sorry I haven't been back but I have a real life too. I'm not going to go through 5+ pages of posts and so if I don't answer questions, sorry.

What I want to do however is finish off with these thoughts:

There are 43 million women in the US who are sexually active and do not want to become pregnant. [1]
In 2005 the US there are 1.2 million abortions [2], this seems to be a reasonably static number.

Based on that, 1 in 36 non-pregnancy wanting, sexually active women in the US suffer a totally unwanted pregnancy each year (assuming that there are few women having multiple abortions in a single year.)

We also know that properly used contraceptive is way better than this, so why is the rate so high?

7% of all sexually active women are at risk for unintended pregnancy but are not currently using contraceptives. 85% of these will get pregnant, that's 2.5 million pregnancies, already twice the number of abortions a year, though according to studies only around 20% of these are aborted (about 50% of all US abortions[3].)

Another 6.5% use poor forms of contraceptive with high failure rates even when performed perfectly.

In fact only 58% of sexually active US women use an effective form of contraceptive, and most do so poorly (87% of pill users and 86% of condom users who have abortions report having used their method poorly or didn't know if it was poor or not.) Only 13.5% use multiple forms of contraceptive, which is far more effective. Just using the pill and a male condom can drop the rate from 9% and 15% of pregnancy over a year of use respectively to 1.5% with poor usage. Use them correctly and that rate drops to just 0.006%.

Consider this. If the availability of contraception was improved and people were shown how to use it correctly, and did use it, it could drop the total number of accidental pregnancies in the US to just 645,000. Get people to use it correctly and it could be just 2500! What would be the effect on abortion rates if this could be done?

Now I have been accused of believing that women should be punished for getting pregnant, or that tightening the controls over abortion would somehow "make me feel better", both of which are untrue, however I can't stop people believing what they will. I do believe that just like the rest of the Universe, people move towards doing the least effort, and in a permissive society that they will gravitate to what they perceive to be the path of least effort (not saying that abortion actually is the path of least effort, it's not. Not bothering with contraceptives at all or not using them right is the path of least effort and the one taken.) It's already quite clear that the majority of people either don't use, or poorly make use of contraceptives. Now some might argue that this is a result of poor education; however I believe that it is also because there is no incentive to actually use it and learn to use it properly. I want to be clear about this, contraceptives very rarely fail, what fails are people in their use of them. Get type of contraceptive and the use right and a lot of the problem vanishes.

I want to make it clear, I can certainly accept that there are cases were abortion is required when it is discovered that the life, health, or mental wellbeing of the mother is in serious danger should she carry to term. I can also accept that there is a very good case to be made where the child is the result of sexual abuse or attack because of the mental dangers of the mother having to carry to term. However I also believe that there are many cases where if abortion was not such an easily available option, the pregnancies would never have occurred in the first place because the mothers would have been far more careful about their and their partner's actions, meaning that there would have been no need for those abortions to have happened.

Personally I'd like to see much better education (and not just teenagers) along with readily available, easy to use, very cheap, methods of contraception for everyone. This would hopefully reduce the need for abortion, but I also know human nature, and while a believed "easier" option is available, few people are willing to take the harder route. I think that we already see this with the current poor use of contraceptives.

Would there be people caught out by things changing? Almost certainly, and that'd be unfortunate, but the reality is that whether you move from a permission society to a more resistive one, someone gets caught in the middle until things stabilise at the new line of what behaviours is allowed. It might be considered by some to be hard-hearted, but unless you are willing to accept that there will be those caught up in the change and left in an unhappy position, the only change that can ever occur is to become more and more permission with our society, and to be honest, a lot of social experiments over the past 30 years have resulted in failure, from literacy levels to violent crime.

I also have to note that it seems very telling that people are willing to attack my position (and on occasion me) but they refuse to answer any of the questions posed to them.

As I said, this is my last word on the matter, I have better things to do that spending hours looking up statistics that are quite clear and having to defend a position that in my mind is merely common sense.
 
Why are you so intolerant and judgmental?

He will judge between us. I accept His Judgment. See you there.


And this from someone who called every member of the human race who does not agree with him/her "whores", and who clearly does not think that is a term for a job of work?

If there were a god, 154, and if he did judge between us, you are toast. ;)
 
1. It's already quite clear that the majority of people either don't use, or poorly make use of contraceptives....

2.However I also believe that there are many cases where if abortion was not such an easily available option, the pregnancies would never have occurred in the first place because the mothers would have been far more careful about their and their partner's actions, meaning that there would have been no need for those abortions to have happened.
Ladies and gentlemen, with the above, I present to you the statistical fallacy.
It is the numbers which decide if a woman can choose whether or not to continue an unwanted pregnancy. If only one abortion happens it is okay, but large numbers are not.
Picture, if you will, the selection line: yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes ,yes ,yes, yes.. sorry dear, but no, there have been too many abortions today, so you are sentenced to having an unwanted baby: but be assured, it is not a punishment. You were just the wrong number in line.
1. No, it is not quite clear. The majority of people? Really? the majority of people have unwanted pregnancies?
And even if this were true, what is its relevance? If one person failed to use effective contraception, would she be allowed an abortion? Two people? What is the trigger number where abortions are not allowed, because the naughty people did not use contraception
2. Believing something does not make it true. But since you use the argument, I believe nobody chooses abortion as an easier option than contraception. I win.
 
I really don't care for the concept of "personhood" in this debate because it is regarded as an all or nothing category which renders the debate very black and white and polarised. I prefer to think in terms of the amount of harm done. I think an early embryo is so undeveloped that it cannot have a great amount of harm done to it - whereas forcing a woman to carry said embryo to term does a lot of harm to the woman. As the foetus becomes more mature, these relative harms shift, and can also be altered by the circumstances of the woman, and whether or not the foetus has a severe disability. I believe this leads to a more nuanced debate, less polarization and therefore even leads some people to change their minds.

The evidence for this last assertion is that I was one of those who changed their mind (while I was still a catholic) because I began to think about it in those terms. The arguments about a foetus not being a person until birth, and about a woman having the absolute right to control their own body had previously been unpersuasive to me because they didn't address my own viewpoint in the slightest.
 
Last edited:
And there are consequences for people who harm or kill a fetus which doesn't belong to them.

And there are consequences for people who harm or kill a child which DOES belong to them. You think the two situations are different because you think children are people and fetuses are not. But not everyone shares that opinion. The problem is that you can't even acknowledge that this is what they believe, and that given such a belief, opposition to abortion follows naturally.

Huh? If we outlaw abortion, then yes, somebody else is telling other people when and with whom they must breed, namely at the time and with the person who created the pregnancy.

Wow. Can you twist logic any further? If I don't tell you who to have sex with or whether or how to use birth control, if in fact those choices remain yours, then how on earth am I telling you with whom you must breed and when? I'm not.

The state outlawing abortion would restrict your options. But it would NOT do what you claimed it would do.

No it's not the central issue.

Yes, it is.

There is no compelling reason to say that a fetus is a person with rights or responsibilities.

There is no reason you find compelling. But there are reasons that others find compelling. And that is enough to make the question central to the debate, even if you don't want it to be, even if you don't think it should be. It is.

But that doesn't mean I have to live under them.

I'm not suggesting otherwise. Nothing about recognizing the beliefs of your opponents requires that you agree with them. I'm not asking you to agree that fetuses are people. You're protesting a point I never made.

The anti-choice people conflate babies and fetuses all the time.

And that excuses you from conflating babies and children... how?

It doesn't. Don't use other people's bad behavior to excuse your own.
 
The central question in this debate is one I NEVER hear anyone asking.

Why do we prohibit the killing of "persons"?

If there's a law preventing cargo trucks from taking a certain tunnel, it's there because those trucks are too tall any debate on whether a given vehicle should be labeled a cargo truck for this purpose will be about the height of the vehicle, otherwise it won't be rational or useful. If you want to consider a car with a trailer to be a cargo truck, you're welcome to, but if that trailer isn't tall enough to pose a problem, then it isn't relevant to the situation.

Likewise, in asking whether a fetus is a person, any definitions of "personhood" that you use, must focus on those qualities that necessitate the prohibition on killing humans. You can draw the line anywhere you want to for semantic purposes, the first contact of sperm and egg, exit from the womb, graduation from college. But unless those qualifications directly speak to the reasons for a prohibition on killing, then your definition does not constitute a convincing argument.
 
And there are consequences for people who harm or kill a child which DOES belong to them. You think the two situations are different because you think children are people and fetuses are not. But not everyone shares that opinion. The problem is that you can't even acknowledge that this is what they believe, and that given such a belief, opposition to abortion follows naturally.

No it doesn't. Persons dont get to live inside other people's bodies: they don't even get to demand your kidney, even it if is a perfect match and you can get by fine without it. So even if you sincerely believe a foetus is a person you cannot thereby say that opposition to abortion follows inevitably
 
Persons dont get to live inside other people's bodies

Except for fetuses, it's not possible. And unless you want to permit abortions up to the point of birth (and the consensus is that we shouldn't), then yes, fetuses do get to do exactly that.

they don't even get to demand your kidney, even it if is a perfect match and you can get by fine without it.

Last time I checked, fetuses didn't remove organs from their mothers. Perhaps you've heard differently.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom