Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
This is merely your opinion. Others believe the harm is quite significant.
Given this disagreement, how do we determine who should make the final decision on the matter?
Rolfe.
I know it is a matter of opinion. And that is the entire problem I have with this whole thing. how can we go from opinion, to something that is objectively scientific-based? If those who want a ban so badly, it is kind of up to them to show the evidence of just how harmful and risky the procedures are. The problem is, all of the evidence and data collected thus far, are inconclusive.
Since I am a rather fierce Constitutionalist (if that be a word), I need good objectively-based scientific evidence that is conclusive. Otherwise, I just don't see how a ban can have any merits in stepping on the toes of parents and religions.
Who decides the matter? I believe the parents should. I also believe that if you feel so strongly against the practice, you should do what you can to get what information is out there, to the parents. And your reasoning behind the immorality of circumcision. Hopefully, you can be persuasive enough to get the numbers down, and eventually have it where only those who practice it for religious purposes are doing it.
And getting the information out in a professional, unbiased manner certainly will be far more persuasive than being contemptuous. If someone gets in your face, and tells you how WRONG you are, and how BAD and IDIOTIC your opinions and actions are, you will only entrench the behavior, and polarize the situation even further. Your job in creating a prohibition would be much easier, if you didn't polarize and alienate people. In fact, your job would be a hell of a lot easier.
I do appreciate your change of heart after my appeal several pages ago. I really honestly do! The first two paragraphs is the reason why I don't think we can go any further with this conversation. You have your opinions, which I highly respect your attempt to make sure newborns are as safe and sound as possible. But I have my opinion that whatever inconclusive clinical harm it does to babies, is not enough to limit a religious practice. I think Avicenna hit on something a few posts ago, and will check it out a bit later.
Last edited: