Ban circumcision in San Fran???

This is merely your opinion. Others believe the harm is quite significant.

Given this disagreement, how do we determine who should make the final decision on the matter?

Rolfe.

I know it is a matter of opinion. And that is the entire problem I have with this whole thing. how can we go from opinion, to something that is objectively scientific-based? If those who want a ban so badly, it is kind of up to them to show the evidence of just how harmful and risky the procedures are. The problem is, all of the evidence and data collected thus far, are inconclusive.

Since I am a rather fierce Constitutionalist (if that be a word), I need good objectively-based scientific evidence that is conclusive. Otherwise, I just don't see how a ban can have any merits in stepping on the toes of parents and religions.

Who decides the matter? I believe the parents should. I also believe that if you feel so strongly against the practice, you should do what you can to get what information is out there, to the parents. And your reasoning behind the immorality of circumcision. Hopefully, you can be persuasive enough to get the numbers down, and eventually have it where only those who practice it for religious purposes are doing it.

And getting the information out in a professional, unbiased manner certainly will be far more persuasive than being contemptuous. If someone gets in your face, and tells you how WRONG you are, and how BAD and IDIOTIC your opinions and actions are, you will only entrench the behavior, and polarize the situation even further. Your job in creating a prohibition would be much easier, if you didn't polarize and alienate people. In fact, your job would be a hell of a lot easier.

I do appreciate your change of heart after my appeal several pages ago. I really honestly do! The first two paragraphs is the reason why I don't think we can go any further with this conversation. You have your opinions, which I highly respect your attempt to make sure newborns are as safe and sound as possible. But I have my opinion that whatever inconclusive clinical harm it does to babies, is not enough to limit a religious practice. I think Avicenna hit on something a few posts ago, and will check it out a bit later. ;)
 
Last edited:
If those who want a ban so badly, it is kind of up to them to show the evidence of just how harmful and risky the procedures are.


Rationally, that's not how it should work. It ought to be up to those who want to mutilate newborn babies to show that this harmless. Which quite clearly it is not. How many dead babies are OK? How many bortched surgeries are OK? How many adults feeling violated and mutilated is OK? None at all, and if you had any intellectual honesty you'd realise that.

And I'd say the same about ear piercing, and I'd say that fails too. Wait till the individual is old enough to decide.

Rolfe.
 
Rationally, that's not how it should work. It ought to be up to those who want to mutilate newborn babies to show that this harmless. ...snip...

I disagree - if we look at what the actual situation is at the moment i.e. male genital mutilation is legal, it is rational to expect those seeking a change to put forward their arguments. Now of course one of those arguments is that male genital mutilation is being carried out for irrational reasons.
 
Rationally, that's not how it should work. It ought to be up to those who want to mutilate newborn babies to show that this harmless. Which quite clearly it is not. How many dead babies are OK? How many bortched surgeries are OK? How many adults feeling violated and mutilated is OK? None at all, and if you had any intellectual honesty you'd realise that.

And I'd say the same about ear piercing, and I'd say that fails too. Wait till the individual is old enough to decide.

Rolfe.

No, I think you ahve it backwards. That is not how it works.

If a neighbor came up to you, and said "hey! You have to cut down your tree!"

"Why?" you ask.

"Because it is harming my grass!" says the neighbor.

You: "I see you have some brown splotches on your lawn, but that isn't necessarily because of my tree."

Neighbor: "It is causing harm to my grass, because it is sucking up all the ground water!"

You: "prove to me that my tree is harming your property. Show me incontrovertible evidence that this is so."

Neighbor: "No, you have to prove to me that your tree is not doing any harm to my grass."

I rather think the neighbor has it backwards. The neighbor is the one with the problem, not you. Therefore, it is up to the neighbor to prove the cause of his problem. If the tree is truly not causing any harm, that is bordering on asking someone to prove that something does not exist. If no harm exists, you cannot really prove that it does not. Kind of like religious folks asking scientists to prove the non-existence of God.

In any case, the people who want change, are the ones responsible for doing the work in providing evidence of how, exactly, and why a current practice causes harm to society or an individual, and imposes on the rights of others as spelled out in the Constitution.
 
I disagree - if we look at what the actual situation is at the moment i.e. male genital mutilation is legal, it is rational to expect those seeking a change to put forward their arguments. Now of course one of those arguments is that male genital mutilation is being carried out for irrational reasons.

Yes, you are right. But the arguments agaisnt it are clear and straightforward and would be sufficient in other case.

If I chopped off my child's earlobes all thew whining in the world about religious freedom wouldn't get me very far. We have established standards for causing unnecessary harm to others - and the exceptions for circumcision need to be justified if they are to be upheld.
 
I disagree - if we look at what the actual situation is at the moment i.e. male genital mutilation is legal, it is rational to expect those seeking a change to put forward their arguments. Now of course one of those arguments is that male genital mutilation is being carried out for irrational reasons.

Yes, and I am now fully open to seeing proof that is does cause death directly, or indirectly through infection, if done in a professional, clinical environment.

If you can prove that it causes deadly infections if done by a rabbi inside of a synagogue, then I can see passing regulations on how circumcisions must be done. Maybe stipulate that if it is to be done in a synagogue, that synagogue must provide a clinical facility (a medical room) of some kind, with clinical tools. They must also be assisted by a clinical professional as well, in order to make sure the procedure is carried out to perfection. Of course, those few regulations I just posted are roughly thought up within 5 minutes.
 
Yes, you are right. But the arguments agaisnt it are clear and straightforward and would be sufficient in other case.
If I chopped off my child's earlobes all thew whining in the world about religious freedom wouldn't get me very far. We have established standards for causing unnecessary harm to others - and the exceptions for circumcision need to be justified if they are to be upheld.

Totally agree with that, as I've said before it is classic cognitive dissonance, the pro-circumciser obviously understands what is mutilation of a child and understands why we (society) prevent that no matter what the views of the parents.
 
Yes, you are right. But the arguments agaisnt it are clear and straightforward and would be sufficient in other case.

If I chopped off my child's earlobes all thew whining in the world about religious freedom wouldn't get me very far. We have established standards for causing unnecessary harm to others - and the exceptions for circumcision need to be justified if they are to be upheld.

I am still waiting for the proof that earlobe cutting is exactly the same as circumcision. I am waiting for the proof that there is a religion that cuts off ears of their newborns. I am waiting for the confirmed reports that circumcisions are the direct cause of deaths.

Until you have said proof, restricting a common practice that is religiously motivated just because you think it is immoral is not good enough of an argument. I am more than willing to concede to some regulations, and perhaps an outright ban until this is done.

As I have said, Avicenna probably stumbled upon something. But from what I have read, the health organizations, (such as the WHO, and the AMA, and even foreign health departments) all say pretty much the same thing: The harm it causes a baby is inconclusive. And most health organizations in countries in which it is still legal, do not recommend a ban due to the inconclusiveness about the safety of circumcisions. They inform doctors they should provide unbiased facts about any risks and benefits about circumcision, and respect the parents' rights to decide. Especially if the decision is religiously motivated.
 
I disagree - if we look at what the actual situation is at the moment i.e. male genital mutilation is legal, it is rational to expect those seeking a change to put forward their arguments. Now of course one of those arguments is that male genital mutilation is being carried out for irrational reasons.


Yes, I agree. I was looking at is as if it were a de novo argument, as that is how it seemed to be being phrased. Which is why I said "ought".

If someone were to say, out of the blue, I want to cut bits off my newborn baby, we wouldn't be running around trying to find out if it was harmless, we'd be making him prove it was harmless.

And he'd fail, just on basic presumptions.

As you say, the problem is that we're looking at a mutilation that is established practice. I still want the burden of proof to be on the people who want to continue what is quite self-evidently an interference with the rights of another human being, namely the baby.

Rolfe.
 
Yes, and I am now fully open to seeing proof that is does cause death directly, or indirectly through infection, if done in a professional, clinical environment.

If you can prove that it causes deadly infections if done by a rabbi inside of a synagogue, then I can see passing regulations on how circumcisions must be done. Maybe stipulate that if it is to be done in a synagogue, that synagogue must provide a clinical facility (a medical room) of some kind, with clinical tools. They must also be assisted by a clinical professional as well, in order to make sure the procedure is carried out to perfection. Of course, those few regulations I just posted are roughly thought up within 5 minutes.

I'm not interested in making those types of arguments; I would rather just argue for the stopping of medical procedures which are not carried out for medical reasons. And that is already pretty much established in countries like the USA & UK but there are just a few exceptions left that allow medical procedures to be undertaken for irrational reasons. Male genital mutilation is one of them and since female genital mutilation has been stopped (by making it illegal in countries like the USA) there is already a precedent in place for such a change no matter what irrational reasons some parents may have for wanting their child to undergo a non-medically indicated medical procedure.
 
As you say, the problem is that we're looking at a mutilation that is established practice. I still want the burden of proof to be on the people who want to continue what is quite self-evidently an interference with the rights of another human being, namely the baby.

Ineed. But as we've just been told, a baby is more comparable to grass than to a person, so that's going to be rather difficult I guess...
 
Totally agree with that, as I've said before it is classic cognitive dissonance, the pro-circumciser obviously understands what is mutilation of a child and understands why we (society) prevent that no matter what the views of the parents.

Not even a Supreme Court Justice would understand fully the term "mutilation," as I have pointed out numerous times. When you say "mutilation," it can mean anything. And clearly, "mutilation" is a subjective term. The removing of a limb from a statue, for instance, making it "imperfect," is purely subjective. Because it is a piece of art. And all art is subjective.

Subjective arguments are not good enough to persuade me that there should be a prohibition on a very specific religious practice.

Anyway, gotta go for the day. Caio!
 
The removing of a limb from a statue, for instance, making it "imperfect," is purely subjective. Because it is a piece of art. And all art is subjective.

How about timeless art that doesn't require any modification? Kind of like a newborn baby boy - a priceless piece of art that is forced to be 'modified' because you determined (via an invisible sky daddy - not artistic taste) it is imperfect.

You have determined that it is imperfect. The child has not.
 
Not even a Supreme Court Justice would understand fully the term "mutilation," as I have pointed out numerous times. When you say "mutilation," it can mean anything. And clearly, "mutilation" is a subjective term. The removing of a limb from a statue, for instance, making it "imperfect," is purely subjective. Because it is a piece of art. And all art is subjective.

Subjective arguments are not good enough to persuade me that there should be a prohibition on a very specific religious practice.

Anyway, gotta go for the day. Caio!

You are mistaken - there is already precedent for it in the USA where female genital mutilation has been criminalised.
 
In his case, it isn't even an invisible sky daddy. His religoin does not mandate circumcision, and indeed banned the practice until quite recently. He seems to be going to bat for people of religions other than his own.

Rolfe.
 
You are mistaken - there is already precedent for it in the USA where female genital mutilation has been criminalised.

And here is an example, doesn't seem to be bothered by claims that mutilation is too subjective, that the supreme court couldn't deal with it and so on:

§ 16-5-27. Female genital mutilation


(a) Any person:

(1) Who knowingly circumcises, excises, or infibulates, in whole or in part, the labia majora, labia minora, or clitoris of a female under 18 years of age;

(2) Who is a parent, guardian, or has immediate custody or control of a female under 18 years of age and knowingly consents to or permits the circumcision, excision, or infibulation, in whole or in part, of the labia majora, labia minora, or clitoris of such female; or

(3) Who knowingly removes or causes or permits the removal of a female under 18 years of age from this state for the purpose of circumcising, excising, or infibulating, in whole or in part, the labia majora, labia minora, or clitoris of such female

shall be guilty of female genital mutilation.

...snip...

I would say it would be even easier to create a similar definition for male genital mutilation.
 
Not even a Supreme Court Justice would understand fully the term "mutilation," as I have pointed out numerous times. When you say "mutilation," it can mean anything.

No, it means "mutilation". Circumcision is a form of mutilation. That you don't want this to be pointed out doesn't change that.

And clearly, "mutilation" is a subjective term.

No.

The removing of a limb from a statue, for instance, making it "imperfect," is purely subjective. Because it is a piece of art. And all art is subjective.

Are you really this desperate now?

Subjective arguments are not good enough to persuade me that there should be a prohibition on a very specific religious practice.

... since you are not being rational and since you fail to grasp even the most basic concepts being discussed here that should hardly matter.
 
In his case, it isn't even an invisible sky daddy. His religoin does not mandate circumcision, and indeed banned the practice until quite recently. He seems to be going to bat for people of religions other than his own.

Rolfe.

I actually stopped by my mother's house for lunch and casually mentioned this topic (maybe not fitting conversation to have over soup?). She mentioned she had me circumcised because A) I was [raised] Catholic (and that's what has always been done in our family) and B) it's easier to clean.

Do Catholics even know that they don't have to do it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom