Ban circumcision in San Fran???

A query (and my apologies if this has been addressed, I don't want to have to search 46 pages for an answer)...

So the OP implies that San Francisco - a City, in a large State, is going to impose a ban on something. Fine.

If someone is passionate about getting their son circumcised (religious beliefs or otherwise) how are they going to prevent this person from taking their child out of the city for the procedure?

It doesn't strike me as a particularly enforceable piece of legislation (if indeed that is what it is.)

I don't have any kids, am not going to have any kids, and am not particularly passionate one way or another. Preponderance of evidence appears to be that there is little to no medical reason or benefit for the procedure. It would seem its a religious issue at that point (except in cases where there are adhesions or a medical need for the procedure) - and if it becomes a religious issue, well... danger Will Robinson...

-AH
 
If someone is passionate about getting their son circumcised (religious beliefs or otherwise) how are they going to prevent this person from taking their child out of the city for the procedure?

They probably aren't; I can't see how that would be legal. However, it seems to me that a great many boys are circumcised because their parents just see it as the normal thing to do. Those same parents, if it's illegal, won't have their son circumcised, because it isn't the normal thing to do.

And that's probably enough to discourage a majority of cases, where the parents don't actually care that much one way or the other. In the UK, circumcision is now very rare for anything other than religious reasons, not because of the law, and not necessarily because of attitude shifts, but because the National Health Service decided not to offer it as a standard medical procedure. Once doctors weren't offering to do it for free, most people simply didn't bother.

Dave
 
San Francisco's proposed circumcision ban galvanizes religious opposition
June 10th, 2011

(CNN) - The nation’s largest evangelical Christian umbrella group has come out against San Francisco’s proposed circumcision ban, evidence that the voter initiative is beginning to galvanize national religious opposition.

Thursday’s announcement from the National Association of Evangelicals was noteworthy because Christians are not religiously mandated to practice circumcision, as are Jews and Muslims.

“Jews, Muslims, and Christians all trace our spiritual heritage back to Abraham. Biblical circumcision begins with Abraham,” said National Association of Evangelicals president Leith Anderson. “No American government should restrict this historic tradition. Essential religious liberties are at stake.”

"The proposed ban violates the First Amendment’s guarantee to exercise one’s religious beliefs,” Anderson said in a statement.

http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2011/...umcision-ban-galvanizes-religious-opposition/
 
I see you changed your mind and came back, Thunder.
Why do you think it good to circumcise ababy for no medical reason rather than waiting until he can give informed consent?
 
Demonising your opponents as religious persecutors is one of way of 'debate', I suppose; if you are otherwise devoid of coherent argument.
 
Why are the Christians getting involved? Is circumcision a Christian ritual? Or are they just standing in moral support of any perceived "attack" on religion?
 
Why are the Christians getting involved? Is circumcision a Christian ritual? Or are they just standing in moral support of any perceived "attack" on religion?


Likely to be the latter, though if you look at the bizarre series of posts from Nihilianth earlier in this thread, anything's possible. I first started posting here to point out to him that if he thought circumcision was a requirement of Roman Catholicism (which he apparently did), his priest had misled him.

Rolfe.
 
Likely to be the latter, though if you look at the bizarre series of posts from Nihilianth earlier in this thread, anything's possible. I first started posting here to point out to him that if he thought circumcision was a requirement of Roman Catholicism (which he apparently did), his priest had misled him.

Rolfe.

Exactly right. I can't see the Catholic Church joining the protest.
 
Hmmm. They have enough form in child abuse as it is....

I was circumcised. Do you plan on filing a criminal complaint against my parents for child abuse?

should we remove children from their parents, if their parents circumcised them?

perhaps we should send penis-investigators around the country to all schools, looking for circumcised penises, so we can put their parents in prison and move the kids to a foster home?


why do you hate Jews & Muslims soo much?
 
Last edited:
I see you changed your mind and came back, Thunder.
Why do you think it good to circumcise ababy for no medical reason rather than waiting until he can give informed consent?
 
because an attack on one religion, is an attack on all religion.

Not always. Christians burning Korans is hardly a case of an attack on one religion being an attack on all religions.
Muslims bombing Jews...
Hindus killing Muslims...
 
I see you changed your mind and came back, Thunder.
Why do you think it good to circumcise ababy for no medical reason rather than waiting until he can give informed consent?

Because parents have the right to do so, according to Thunder. How that right is bestowed is still a mystery to me.
 
Not always. Christians burning Korans is hardly a case of an attack on one religion being an attack on all religions.
Muslims bombing Jews...
Hindus killing Muslims...

you are right. I should have instead said: "an attack upon the religious freedom of one religion, is an attack upon the religious freedom of all religions".

thank you.
 
you are right. I should have instead said: "an attack upon the religious freedom of one religion, is an attack upon the religious freedom of all religions".

thank you.

Still incorrect. Muslim countires limiting the rights of Christians is not an attack on the religious freedom of Muslims.

Why do you think it a good thing to circumcise babies rather than allowing them to make an informed choice when they are old enough?
 
yes, just like how a mother has the right to have labor induced, her baby's body almost completely removed from her womb except for the head, and than have a needle shoved into its head to have its brain sucked out and skull collapsed.

its amazing what we let parents do to their children.

If you want to discuss abortion, start another thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom