Ban circumcision in San Fran???

You are still wrong. That is not persecution of all religions.

I like how you speak with such authority, as if all others simply have opinions, while you have the unbreakable truth.

that said, I disagree. I believe that when you restrict the rights of one religion, the rights of ALL religions are in danger.
 
ok, no one out right said they support clitoral-reduction surgery. but no one came out against it either.

so, those of you who are against male-baby circumcision, are you also against clitoral-reduction surgery?

Yes.
Now, why do you think it good to circumcise a baby rather than wait until he is able to give informed consent?
 
I like how you speak with such authority, as if all others simply have opinions, while you have the unbreakable truth.

that said, I disagree. I believe that when you restrict the rights of one religion, the rights of ALL religions are in danger.

I am speaking of facts. Persecution of some religions, or all but one religion, or one religion, is not persecution of all religions. It is not a matter of authority. It is the truth.
First you said it was persecution of all religions, now you say the rights of all religions are in danger where the rights of one are restricted.
Leave the bloody goalposts alone!
 
I like how you speak with such authority, as if all others simply have opinions, while you have the unbreakable truth.

that said, I disagree. I believe that when you restrict the rights of one religion, the rights of ALL religions are in danger.

So when those Mormon guys in Utah are forbidden the right to have sex with teenage girls, how does this put the rights of the average Baptist in danger?

EDIT: What about the average Buddhist?
 
Yes.
Now, why do you think it good to circumcise a baby rather than wait until he is able to give informed consent?

#1. I fully support clitoran reduction surgery.

#2. I fully support the right of parents to decide to circumcise their male baby.

as far as FGM, I don't know that much about it yet, but I am against any surgery designed to reduce the person's sexual pleasure or sexual activity. But as far as what I see in level 1a, which simply removes the hood and leaves the clitoris alone, I guess I could maybe be ok with that.

...maybe. but it again depends on what the purpose is.

..........ok, I have now read that many women actually choose to have female circumcision level 1a, performed on themselves, in order to fully expose the clitoral hood. this suggests to me that such a procedure does not lead to a painful situation. I then read that this procedure used to be done to girls in the Western world, in order to discourage masterbation. I'm confused.
 
Last edited:
http://sfappeal.com/news/2011/04/re...uits-against-proposed-sf-circumcision-ban.php

looks like this possible ban, may indeed unite religious groups like never before.

I expect everyone from Methodists, to Presbyterians, to Episcopaleans to join the charge against religious persecution.

Your implication is that the majority of people supporting the ban are Anti-Semitic.

Evidence?

If you don't have it, then shut up.



There is ONLY one question to be resolved: Are you in favour of chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy?

Everything else is a Red Herring.


GB

ETA: If you answer my question in the affirmative, by logical extension you would have to support the Religious Freedom of Satanic Cult members who practice chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy as a Religous Ritual.
 
Last edited:
If you don't have it, then shut up.

people here have accused me of hating babies & hating children.

people here have accused me of supporting child abuse.

people here have accused me of being a Conspiracy Theorist.

people here have accused me of being evil, due to my views.

.......please tell them to shut up as well.
 
people here have accused me of hating babies & hating children.

people here have accused me of supporting child abuse.

people here have accused me of being a Conspiracy Theorist.

people here have accused me of being evil, due to my views.

.......please tell them to shut up as well.

No! I don't care what other people said to you.

The question I asked is for you to provide evidence for your assertion that the majority of people supporting this ban are anti-Semitic.

If you don't have the evidence, you have no right to make this accusation.

GB
 
And I want to know why one person's alleged right to do something to someone else's body trumps that other person's right to do whatever he wants to his own body.

Rolfe.
 
#1. I fully support clitoran reduction surgery.

#2. I fully support the right of parents to decide to circumcise their male baby.

as far as FGM, I don't know that much about it yet, but I am against any surgery designed to reduce the person's sexual pleasure or sexual activity. But as far as what I see in level 1a, which simply removes the hood and leaves the clitoris alone, I guess I could maybe be ok with that.

...maybe. but it again depends on what the purpose is.

..........ok, I have now read that many women actually choose to have female circumcision level 1a, performed on themselves, in order to fully expose the clitoral hood. this suggests to me that such a procedure does not lead to a painful situation. I then read that this procedure used to be done to girls in the Western world, in order to discourage masterbation. I'm confused.


There's nothing to be confused about. You have admitted that it is fine with you if people chop off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

GB
 
There's nothing to be confused about. You have admitted that it is fine with you if people chop off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

please don't mistate what I say.

I said that its ok for parents to remove their child's foreskin, as long as the purpose is not to harm the child.
 
Would you fully support a parent who wanted clitoral reduction surgery performed on a baby who had no abnormalities (ie normal size clitoris)?

I'm not sure. The article I have read on Wiki doesn't say whether or not removing the clitoral hood causes a painful situation. It says that some women choose to have this surgery performed in order to permanently expose the clitoris (for reasons of sexual convenience?). Its also says that this procedure used to be done in the West to reduce masterbation.

therefore, I have no idea if the surgery actually causes permanent harm.
 
please don't mistate what I say.

I said that its ok for parents to remove their child's foreskin, as long as the purpose is not to harm the child.

I didn't misstate what you say. You just confessed that you are fine with people chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

If you aren't fine with it, then you will obviously support the ban.


GB
 
I can think of a lot of harm people can do, even when it's not their conscious purpose to cause harm.

It does cause harm. It's blindingly obvious it causes harm. The motives and intentions of those who blindly cause such harm do not make it harmless.

Rolfe.
 
I didn't misstate what you say.

sure you did.

I didn't say that I believe that anyone has a right to cut off any part of any other person's anatomy. That's your dishonest re-writting of my views.

I said that parents have the right to remove their child's foreskin, as long as it is not for harmful purposes. I see the foreskin as no different than an earlobe.

sorry if that offends you, but its my opinion.
 
sure you did.

I didn't say that I believe that anyone has a right to cut off any part of any other person's anatomy. That's your dishonest re-writting of my views.

I said that parents have the right to remove their child's foreskin, as long as it is not for harmful purposes. I see the foreskin as no different than an earlobe.

sorry if that offends you, but its my opinion.

Don't lie!

GB

ETA: You just confessed that you are fine with people chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

The only reason you don't like me saying it this way is because it's True, and you can't face the truth.
 
Last edited:
It does cause harm. It's blindingly obvious it causes harm.

I have no foreskin, and I think I'm doing just fine. Penis works perfectly. I see no harm in this procedure.

However, if someone wanted to remove their child's foreskin because they saw foreskin as a good thing that makes sex feel good, and they don't want their child to enjoy sex, then I would be against that procedure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom