Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Okay, I know you can't answer a simple question.


see, here's the thing: if you really cared about the thread, and didn't instead simply see it as an opportunity to take random, childish and useless shots at me, you would know that I answered your question the first time you asked it.
 
ok, so you are against surgery on an enlarged clitoris, for a baby.

now, why do you want a poor little girl to have to grow up with an enlarged clitoris, that looks like a small penis?

I couldn't imagine growing up with such a thing, if I was a girl. It would be torture. I would question my sexuality, my biology, and I would certainly be made fun of by other girls in communal showers.

why would you want to put a child through such a thing?

:(


You probably can't imagine being a girl. I can.

You've described something abnormal, abnormal enough to affect a child's development. Now if a doctor were to advise parents that early surgery was advisable, then how is that in any way comparable to parents, themselves, going and demanding that a normal part of their little boy be cut off?

But even then, I still say it. Babies grow. Wait and see what it grows into. The later you leave it, the easier the surgery because you don't have to allow for so much unpredictability. It may turn out fine, and acceptable, better than you thought. Or it may not bother the girl at all.

Or if she's bothered by it, she can ask for the surgery herself, at that point.

Now in what way is that any sort of parallel to what you want to do to perfectly normal baby boys before they're old enough to make up their own minds?

Rolfe.

ETA: Communal showers? For goodness sake. I've never been in a communal shower in my life.
 
Last edited:
But even then, I still say it. Babies grow. Wait and see what it grows into. The later you leave it, the easier the surgery because you don't have to allow for so much unpredictability. It may turn out fine, and acceptable, better than you thought. Or it may not bother the girl at all.

Or if she's bothered by it, she can ask for the surgery herself, at that point.

I could imagine such an abnormality causing a child to feel highly insecure, and unable to express their feelings. They might feel that they were made such a way as a punishment.

Children are not mature enough to make such decisions, or be relied on to ask for such a decision to be made, even if deep down its really what they want.

This is why I believe in parental rights, because children are not psychologically nor intellectually developed enough to make such important decisions about their own bodies or their own lives.


I do not understand how you could want to leave such a decision, to a child. There are reasons why the law has codified parental rights. I think I have spelled out a few of them.

ETA: Communal showers? For goodness sake. I've never been in a communal shower in my life.

well, that's unique.
 
Last edited:
but you did indeed misstate me.

I do not believe that simply one person has the right to cut off bits from another person.

I believe that a parent has the right to remove their child's foreskin, as long as it is not for purposes of causing permanent harm.

your misstating of my view, may not be a lie...but it is a strawman.


Which of the following two statements is an example of someone NOT chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy:

#1. I fully support clitoran reduction surgery.

#2. I fully support the right of parents to decide to circumcise their male baby.

You're just blowing smoke and hoping that no-one will catch you out. This is the crux of the matter.

You just don't like me using that phrase because it forces you to acknowledge that it is indeed what you are endorsing.

I just creamed someone with your views on another forum.

He blew all kinds of smoke and hot air, peppered with Red Herrings, and pseudo-philosophy such as the principles of Greek Rhetorical arguments like the Law of the Undistributed Middle.

But in the end all he had was Belief. Belief is not evidence.

You have nothing. Your argument is done.

Other people can argue with your sidetracks and deflections all they want. But they are wasting their time if they do.

GB
 
so, to sums things up:

I believe in the parental right to cirumcise their son, as long as it is not to cause them harm.

I may believe in the right to remove the clitoral hood from a girl, as long as it is not to cause harm. But the jury is still out on that one for me.

I believe in the parental right to amend their child's enlarged clitoris, as growing up with such an abnormality could do serious psychological harm.

Parental rights are enshrined in the Civil Code of every state in the Union. Parents have the right to make decisions regarding their child's upbringing, schooling, location, health, and bodies, that the child themselves cannot legally make until they reach a certain age. This is good..and the way it should be.
 
Last edited:
I could imagine such an abnormality causing a child to feel highly insecure, and unable to express their feelings. They might feel that they were made such a way as a punishment.

Children are not mature enough to make such decisions, or be relied on to ask for such a decision to be made, even if deep down its really what they want.

This is why I believe in parental rights, because children are not psychologically nor intellectually developed enough to make such important decisions about their own bodies or their own lives.

I do not understand how you could want to leave such a decision, to a child. There are reasons why the law has codified parental rights. I think I have spelled out a few of them.


And this thread is about whether the law should be changed. So saying that the law is one way at present is irrelevant.

Even if any of that was true, and as I said you have no idea at all of what it's like to be a girl, girls are far more private people than you seem to imagine, how does the proposed correction of an ABNORMALITY have anything to do with the capricious lopping of of bits of a NORMAL boy?

Who will probably be in the minority in these bizarre communal showers, because of this action.

Rolfe.
 
so, to sums things up:

I believe in the parental right to cirumcise their son, as long as it is not to cause them harm.

I may believe in the right to remove the clitoral hood from a girl, as long as it is not to cause harm. But the jury is still out on that one for me.

I believe in the parental right to amend their child's enlarged clitoris, as growing up with such an abnormality could do serious psychological harm.

Parental rights are enshrined in the Civil Code of every state in the Union. Parents have the right to make decisions regarding their child's upbringing, schooling, location, health, and bodies, that the child themselves cannot legally make until they reach a certain age. This is good..and the way it should be.


And I believe the tooth fairy comes to reward children when their teeth fall out, and that's the way it should be.

But my belief doesn't make it so.

Rolfe.
 
I believe in the parental right to cirumcise their son, as long as it is not to cause them harm.


But we know that in a number of cases it does cause serious harm. How many cases of necrotising fasciitis are you OK with?

Which is more important? The right of an adult to lop parts off someone else's normal body, or the right of an adult to decide for themselves what they want to do with their own body?

Rolfe.
 
so, to sums things up:

I believe in the parental right to cirumcise their son, as long as it is not to cause them harm.

I may believe in the right to remove the clitoral hood from a girl, as long as it is not to cause harm. But the jury is still out on that one for me.

I believe in the parental right to amend their child's enlarged clitoris, as growing up with such an abnormality could do serious psychological harm.

Parental rights are enshrined in the Civil Code of every state in the Union. Parents have the right to make decisions regarding their child's upbringing, schooling, location, health, and bodies, that the child themselves cannot legally make until they reach a certain age. This is good..and the way it should be.

Yes, let's sum things up.

You have Beliefs. Belief is not evidence, nor does Belief give anyone the right to chop off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

You are unable to demonstrate that you DON'T support chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

In short, you have nothing.

GB
 
ok, so you are against surgery on an enlarged clitoris, for a baby.

now, why do you want a poor little girl to have to grow up with an enlarged clitoris, that looks like a small penis?

I couldn't imagine growing up with such a thing, if I was a girl. It would be torture. I would question my sexuality, my biology, and I would certainly be made fun of by other girls in communal showers.

why would you want to put a child through such a thing?

:(
I couldn't imagine growing up with a deformed penis, that looks like something has been cut off, if I were a boy. I would question my sexuality, my biology, and I would certainly be made fun of by entire boys in communal showers. Why would you want to put a child through such a thing?

Do you see just how ridiculous, and desperate, your arguments are?

ETA : Our sexuality is not defined by what our bodies look like.
 
naked? really.

earlobes keep your ears warm? they help the ear catch sound?


Sorry, what?

I said I'd have been pretty narked if my parents had decided to have my earlobes cut off when I was a baby. I like my earlobes the way they are.

Why should my parents have the right to chop off a normal part of my anatomy, even if it isn't obviously functional?

Rolfe.
 
so, to sums things up:

I believe in the parental right to cirumcise their son, as long as it is not to cause them harm.

I may believe in the right to remove the clitoral hood from a girl, as long as it is not to cause harm. But the jury is still out on that one for me.

I believe in the parental right to amend their child's enlarged clitoris, as growing up with such an abnormality could do serious psychological harm.

Parental rights are enshrined in the Civil Code of every state in the Union. Parents have the right to make decisions regarding their child's upbringing, schooling, location, health, and bodies, that the child themselves cannot legally make until they reach a certain age. This is good..and the way it should be.
If that right includes subjecting the child to unnecessary surgery, it is not the way it should be.
That the parents do not intend to do harm is irrelevant. That actual harm ensues is the important thing.
 
Is circumcision harm?

I would argue that causing a body part to permanently function in diminished capacity would constitute harm. In fact, it's typically taken much more seriously than temporary pain.

To help illustrate this point, I would offer the following example:

Let's take Bob, a hypothetical perfectly healthy male. Suppose I were to do something to Bob to cause his eyesight to become diminished, to the point where he cannot read without the assistance of glasses. The manner in which I do this and the reason behind my actions are irrelevant. Call it a religious practice if (and only if) it makes you feel better. Furthermore, we can even say that Bob is my son.

Is it the case, or is it not, that I have harmed Bob?

The purpose of this scenario is not to argue that poking someone's eyes out is the same as circumcision, so please, no red herrings.
 
because I believe in parental rights. do you believe in parental rights?
Thunder, which of these do you think is more important:
1) An adult's right to make choices that affect his own body
2) An adult's right to make choices that affect another adult's body

You've wasted a number of posts pretending to not understand this question, then acknowledging that you understood the question, then announcing that you would answer the question, then not answering the question.

For the record, I think #1 trumps #2.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom