Ban circumcision in San Fran???

wow, you seem to be suggesting that the only reason a Gentile doctor would declare male-baby circumcision benign or beneficial, is due to fear of being called an anti-Semite. yikes.


I don't think the BMA policy called it either of these things. I think it was a bunch of weasel words about fitting in to communities and things like that.

Your reaction says everything about where you're coming from. Playing the victim, oh dear these horrible people don't like me abusing my baby, but it's all because they're anti-Semitic, not because I want to mutilate my new-born boy and cause him extreme pain.

Rolfe.
 
Here's a film that, IMHO, helps to shed more light (of understanding) vs. heat (of flame wars) on the subject.

NOT SAFE FOR WORK:
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/The_Film.html

The beginning is not that great, but I think the middle and end of the film makes it worth watching.

Some highlights:

37 minute point: Starts talking about the function of the foreskin. It includes a an interview with a man who got circumcised at the age of 27 and he gives his opinion about sex before and after the cut.

45 min mark -- The interviewer/film director's father, a religious Jew, talks about how he never thought there were health benefits to circumcision and that he only believes it should be done because its a mitzvah (commandment) in the Torah.

55 min mark -- Some comments basically saying that the debate of circumcision, when circumcision is done for religious reasons, is that of the rights of the individual vs. the rights of the community.

There's filmed Q&A here:

http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/Q&A.html

I watched the one under the March 25, 2008, JCC of the Upper West Side of Manhattan: NY title.

Covered additional points -- worth watching if you have time.
 
now, does anyone have anything.....from a renowned medical institution or agency in the West, that says that circumcision causes more bad than good..and should be discouraged if not made illegal?

Interesting. Why do you specify "West"? And why are you just tossing quotes out there with little justification? Many of us still question the "cultural" argument, and still do when it comes from medical establishment.

To me, this reeks of confirmation bias. Did you really read all these positions before you made your decision, or are you just posting them as you Google across them?

Incidentally, I can give you policy quotes from medical organizations that oppose wide-spread child circumcision:

Preamble: The Australasian Association of Paediatric Surgeons does not support the routine circumcision of male neonates, infants or children in Australia. It is considered to be inappropriate and unnecessary as a routine to remove the prepuce, based on the current evidence available.

Due to religious beliefs, Jewish children are circumcised by the seventh day of life, as a mark of dedication to God. [sic] Children born into the Muslim faith will likewise be circumcised for religious reasons, although the timing for the procedure is less clearly defined. There are Christian groups in other parts of the world, who insist on ritual religious circumcision, as well as tribal or cultural customs promoting male circumcision.

We do not support the removal of a normal part of the body, unless there are definite indications to justify the complications and risks which may arise. In particular, we are opposed to male children being subjected to a procedure, which had they been old enough to consider the advantages and disadvantages, may well have opted to reject the operation and retain their prepuce.

Linky.

After the controversy, the Kuopio University Hospital decided to adhere to its policy of not circumcising. The Finnish Medical Association has come out against the procedure, and many Finnish hospitals concur.

Linky.

You can find many more at these websites, but I think dueling block quotes is a rather substandard way of debating. People here have been trying to address each of the arguments already, and these organizations are usually explicit about viewing the matter from a restricted viewpoint. For instance, many like the BMA stated that their members had differing ethical views, and thus they as a whole took a more neutral position without any firm scientific evidence. These bodies exist for a certain purpose, and we are debating more than what they consider.

I already asked before if you really considered their statement that medical evidence was a wash for pro v con to be something in your favour. I am of the crazy belief that non-therapeutic surgeries on children should be discouraged. You like "parental rights", I do not. I would ask that you please inform me as to where these RIGHTS in general and in this case specifically come from and are justified before you hide behind the phrase. If it is from society, as everyone in this thread has been saying, there is nothing absurd about calling for social change. Progressing, you know :p .
 
Last edited:
one baby has this medical problem. I feel horrible for this baby.

what percent of baby-male circumcisions lead to such a problem?


Are you saying that web site made that up? I don't know how many cases like that there are. There wouldn't even have been one though, if parents didn't have this irrational desire to perform cosmetic surgery on their newborns' genitalia.

Babies have died, too, Thunder.

What if that had happened to your child? It happened to someone's child. Someone just like you, probably. Thought he was entitled to chop bits of his son's body, thought he was doing it for the boy's own good.

I wonder how he felt afterwards?

Rolfe.
 
one baby has this medical problem. I feel horrible for this baby.
One is one too many. To say you feel horrible for that baby is quite disgusting. You are frantically advocating the very thing that caused that baby's suffering.
No baby ever suffered any injury from not having a medically unnecessary circumcision.
Of course Thunder has me on ignore, but he studiously ignored this the several times I said it prior to that.
 
so, lets see where the pathetic insults now stand, with the opponents of baby-boy circumcision.

those who support it are or have:

-eyesight problems.
-evil.
-barbaric.
-child abuse.
-hating children.
-hating babies.
-anti-Semitic.
-Conspiracy Theorist.

-and now, if they are a male and were circumcised, they are not a real man.

wow, your method of debate is quite interesting. what do you guys call it?

Yes! Our methods have demonstrated that you have no valid argument for supporting chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

You've slung so many insults and unsupported accusations that you have no moral high ground.

GB
 
Are you saying that web site made that up?

no, I'm saying that its a clearly biased site.


....and none of its damn links work. this thing reminds me of a 9-11 Truther site from 2002.

got anything from a well-respected Western medical organization or agency?
 
Last edited:
One is one too many. To say you feel horrible for that baby is quite disgusting. You are frantically advocating the very thing that caused that baby's suffering.
No baby ever suffered any injury from not having a medically unnecessary circumcision.
Of course Thunder has me on ignore, but he studiously ignored this the several times I said it prior to that.


Overcomes the ignore thingy.

Rolfe.
 
http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...rcumcision2006.jsp#Nontherapeuticcircumcision

The British Medical Association on circumcision when not a medical necessity.

Non-therapeutic male circumcision
Male circumcision that is performed for any reason other than physical clinical need is termed non-therapeutic (or sometimes “ritual”) circumcision. Some people ask for non-therapeutic circumcision for religious reasons, some to incorporate a child into a community, and some want their sons to be like their fathers. Circumcision is a defining feature of some faiths.

There is a spectrum of views within the BMA’s membership about whether non-therapeutic male circumcision is a beneficial, neutral or harmful procedure or whether it is superfluous, and whether it should ever be done on a child who is not capable of deciding for himself. The medical harms or benefits have not been unequivocally proven but there are clear risks of harm if the procedure is done inexpertly. The Association has no policy on these issues. Indeed, it would be difficult to formulate a policy in the absence of unambiguously clear and consistent medical data on the implications of the intervention. As a general rule, however, the BMA believes that parents should be entitled to make choices about how best to promote their children’s interests, and it is for society to decide what limits should be imposed on parental choices. What those limits currently are is discussed below, together with the legal and ethical considerations for doctors asked to perform non-therapeutic circumcision.

Some Religious parents think that going to doctors is against their Religion. The State calls that Criminal Negligance.

GB
 
no, I'm saying that its a clearly biased site.

got anything from a well-respected Western medical organization or agency?


See what Tsukasa Buddha posted.

But your dishonesty is noted. You want to dismiss cases that show what evil you are promoting, because they are publicised by people who disagree with you.

News flash. Homoeopaths make the same argument. Oh, that debunking of my pet study can be ignored, because it's on a sceptic web site. Oh well that's OK then.

No, the maimed baby doesn't magically not exist just because the people who put the photos online disagree with you, Thunder.

Rolfe.
 
I knew you'd indicate you'd read that post of mine, even though you have been systematically ignoring everything else I posted in this thread.

I said plenty about circumcision earlier in the thread. I didn't get any response at all from the person (or people) in favour of the practice.

Playing the victim...


again, who's playing the victim?
 
too late. its already been reported. I'm tired of the abuse.

Yes! You're so tired of "abuse" you insult anyone anytime you manage to get a dig in.

You're very lucky that I'm a nice Jewish boy that my mother raised to treat people with kindness.

Now if you would just admit that you favour chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy to yourself (and us), you would actually have to face the reality of what you are endorsing.


GB
 
Interestingly, the BMA is much less mealy mouthed about circumcision for medical purposes:

Unnecessarily invasive procedures should not be used where alternative, less invasive techniques, are equally efficient and available. It is important that doctors keep up to date and ensure that any decisions to undertake an invasive procedure are based on the best available evidence. Therefore, to circumcise for therapeutic reasons where medical research has shown other techniques to be at least as effective and less invasive would be unethical and inappropriate.

Male circumcision in cases where there is a clear clinical need is not normally controversial. Nevertheless, normal anatomical and physiological characteristics of the infant foreskin have in the past been misinterpreted as being abnormal. The British Association of Paediatric Surgeons advises that there is rarely a clinical indication for circumcision. [Go to reference 5] Doctors should be aware of this and reassure parents accordingly.
http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...cision2006.jsp#Circumcisionformedicalpurposes

So circumcision should only be used for medical purposes as a very last resort and is very rarely indicated. But if the parents just want it done for no medical reason.... well that's just fine.

:rolleyes:
 
But your dishonesty is noted. You want to dismiss cases that show what evil you are promoting, because they are publicized by people who disagree with you.

and your dishonesty is noted, as you simply disregard ANY and ALL evidence and professional opinions/views...from HIGHLY respected and regarded Western medical agencies and organizations, simply because they disagree with you...


..and because they surely are dominated by Jews or have a minority of intimidating, threatening Jews.

these tactics are 100% analogous to the crap we get in the 9-11 CT section, by Truthers.
 
Last edited:
again, does anyone...

and I mean ANYONE...have any report from a renowned Western medical agency or organization that states that male infant circumcision creates more harm than good..and should be discouraged if not made illegal?

What we have is the fact that some medical agencies have the same double standards as you.

GB
 
http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...cision2006.jsp#Circumcisionformedicalpurposes

So circumcision should only be used for medical purposes as a very last resort and is very rarely indicated. But if the parents just want it done for no medical reason.... well that's just fine.

I never thought I'd be accusing a Mod of a strawman, but I am right now.

Strawman.


this, is what the MBA really says:

The Association has no policy on these issues. Indeed, it would be difficult to formulate a policy in the absence of unambiguously clear and consistent medical data on the implications of the intervention. As a general rule, however, the BMA believes that parents should be entitled to make choices about how best to promote their children’s interests



the MBA, 100% believes that the decision of whether or not to perform a baby-male circumcision, should be left to the PARENTS.
 
Last edited:
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa0802556

The New England Journal of Medicine declares the "potential public health benefits of circumcision":

Conclusions

In addition to decreasing the incidence of HIV infection, male circumcision significantly reduced the incidence of HSV-2 infection and the prevalence of HPV infection, findings that underscore the potential public health benefits of the procedure. (ClinicalTrials.gov numbers, NCT00425984 and NCT00124878.)



I mean, come on guys, its the New England Journal of Medicine we're talking about here. :)

Yes! It's Shocking! :eye-poppi

I can't believe that such a highly respected and an otherwise august Publication would support chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

GB
 
The Hippocratic oath first says: do no harm
The doctors at the NIH, the AAP, the BMA, and the New England Journal of Medicine, would be VIOLATING THEIR OATH, if they knowingly advised society to leave it to the parents to make the decision, if they believed that ANY harm could actually be done by the procedure.

That said, being that the NIH, the AAP, the BMA, and the NEJM all seek to defer to the parents to make the decision, due to the lack of overwhelming evidence of harm being caused, I will trust these four organizations over my own unprofessional opinion.

Yes! It's absolute Insanity. How can they violate their Hippocratic oaths like that? :eek:


GB
 
it appears that I somehow forced him into it, by ignoring every single post of his in this thread. I'm sorry, I didn't mean it.

Rolfe is female, and she has mentioned it in this thread. So much for taking notice of her arguments. Are you going to apologize to her?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom