Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Well, you'll notice that I posed it as a question, and not a statement of fact. Since someone else here suggested that Harrit and Jones were refusing to share their samples, the question needs to be asked: Did anyone ask for them?

But fair enough, Mr. Skinny! We have you down as "I DON'T KNOW."
The stuff looks like clay. Did you look up the chemicals Jones has in his chips? The sad part is bringing thermite to a jet fuel fire is insanity. Jet fuel has ten times the energy of Jones's failed paint chips, clay covering, what ever it is. 10 Times the energy is in jet fuel, and the office fires have more energy. Plastics have over ten times the energy of thermite. So you are backing idiots who say thermite did it, when office fires did it, like bringing a knife to a gun fight.

They have carbon in their thermite, there is no carbon in thermite. Darn, you should have read the paper.
 
Well, you'll notice that I posed it as a question, and not a statement of fact.
So, Harrit is a lousy analytical chemist then? Is he even a chemist?

Notice that I phrased this as a question, not a statement of fact.
Since someone else here suggested that Harrit and Jones were refusing to share their samples, the question needs to be asked: Did anyone ask for them?
As previously stated: I don't know.

But fair enough, Mr. Skinny! We have you down as "I DON'T KNOW."
 
Ever pause to consider why, a couple of years after publishing their initial paper, neither Harrit nor Jones have taken the simple, scientific step of testing their paint chips in an inert gas?
After all, if they did this they could PROVE it was really nanothermite giving off the energy, and not some other organics.

Why have they not done this?

Also, years ago Jones mentioned that Jeff Farrer had been in touch with some real nanothermite experts, notably Dr Tillotson. I wonder what Dr. Tillotson had to say about the exchange.....funny that Jones, Harrit and Farrer have gone completely silent about the whole thing.

You'd almost think they'd found out something and didn't want to tell the Truther community about it. But why? What would suddenly cause them to give up when they'd already made allegations for 5 years and lectured everywhere on it? (Harrit still is lecturing)

Perhaps they found out that it really isn't nanothermite. I think that's the real answer.

Back to you, Ergo. ;)
 
This is agument for arguments sake and unproductive. It's time to shut the door on the silly objection being raised here. The important thing is not Sunstealer's replication of Jones experiments; rather, it's the gross errors that Sunstealer identified in the Jones/Harrit paper. Whether or not he tried to independently validate their data is irrelevant; the errors themselves are present in the paper whether or not Sunstealer does his own tests on the chips. No one needs to replicate X-EDS spectra in order to point out that the individual elements Jones/Harrit's data shows as present are those found in kaolinite, and nobody needs to replicate the photomicrography in order to point out that the morphology of the platelets Jones & Harrit identified are entirely consistent with the same. In fact, for both of those it would be stupid to so that because the point of the critique is to show what the authors claimed about was entirely unjustified by the data they presented.

The critique is not of the data; it's of the claims made about the very data the present, as well as the conclusions drawn from that.

What truthers are ignoring is this: The damning analysis is damning because it uses Jones's and Harrit's own data and shows where they got things wrong. No one has to replicate an experiment to show that Jones, Harrit, Farrar, Legge, etc. screwed the pooch in their data interpretation.
 
Last edited:
Thanks!

So, where is the paper that Sunstealer published?

Hell, sport, where is the "peer reviewed" paper that Jones and the rest of the mutts published?

It turns out the peer reviewers were actually Jones' truther buddies.

Ooops.

Keep on plucking that chicken, ergo!
 
These two threads have been merged and I've taken the original thread off of [Moderated] status but if members cannot abide by the Membership Agreement, and remain civil and polite, sans petty sniping and bickering, it will go back on [Moderated] status.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Last edited:
ergo, even if in your mind the correct answer to "what did he get wrong?" is "has Sunstealer published his findings yet?", this thread would be much more interesting if you would swallow your pride and actually tell this layman what he got wrong. I'm honestly interested in your opinions about it.

Otherwise it's just mindless bickering.
 
Just to touch on the subject of the repercussions of the Jones/Harrit paper, please note that Dr Jones has had ample opportunity to answer to the lingering questions, yet has not done so.

It's remarkable that he persisted for a few years culminating in the paper, then has apparently drifted away into the 'free energy' realm. Has he given up on nanothermite because he realizes it isn't in the WTC dust?

I say 'yes'. I think he's smart enough to know that nanothermite is a dead end. His followers generally are not nearly as informed or intelligent, and will continue to plug the dead nanothermite canard for years to come, without a doubt.

REminds me a little of the guys who started the whole 'crop circle' phenomenon - they did it as a hoax, they've admitted it was a hoax, but amazingly crop circle fanatics don't believe them.... boggles the mind, it does.

Jones' latest escapade, for your information:

http://freeenergy.tv/solid-state-devices/dr-steven-e-jones-20x-overunity-circuit-pt-1/
 
Thanks!

So, where is the paper that Sunstealer published?

Where's the Paper that Harrit published in a peer reviewed chemical engineering / scientific journal? Oh right...the Bentham fiasco...yeah...

Please find for me in any one of these journals where his "science" on "thermite" is published and I'll gladly read it with an open mind.

Chemistry
Accounts of Chemical Research
Angewandte Chemie
Bulletin of the Chemical Society of Japan
Canadian Journal of Chemistry
Chemical Communications
Chemical Reviews
Chemistry Letters
Journal of the American Chemical Society
Helvetica Chimica Acta

Physics
Acta Crystallographica-- parts A, B
Advances in Physics
American Journal of Physics
Journal of Physics - parts A-D, G
Nature Physics
New Journal of Physics
Physical Review - parts A-E and Physical Review Letters
Reports on Progress in Physics
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society

Engineering
Advances in Production Engineering & Management
Annual Review of Biomedical Engineering
Fluid Phase Equilibria
Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research
International Journal of Functional Informatics and Personalized Medicine
Journal of Environmental Engineering
Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Journal of the IEST
NASA Tech Briefs
The Post Office Electrical Engineers' Journal
Radioelectronics and Communications Systems

Materials Science
Advanced Materials
Advanced Composite Materials
Advanced Functional Materials
JOM
Journal of Electronic Materials
Light Metal Age
Materials Today
Metallurgical and Materials Transactions
Nature Materials
Science and Technology of Advanced Materials
Computational Materials Science

Any paper at all in any one of these will suffice supporting your idiotic claims. You want to use your brain? Tell me, why would the "scholars for 9/11 truth and justice" need to create their own journal for "peer reviewed" publishing? Why? Why could they not submit their papers to recognized respected journals? Are the journals and scientists and editors of those journals in on it too?
 
So, Harrit is a lousy analytical chemist then? Is he even a chemist?

Yes, he is! He spent his whole career on studying photochemistry. But I don't know wether this qualifies him of investigating this chips. I'd suppose not.

Ever pause to consider why, a couple of years after publishing their initial paper, neither Harrit nor Jones have taken the simple, scientific step of testing their paint chips in an inert gas?
After all, if they did this they could PROVE it was really nanothermite giving off the energy, and not some other organics.

We should not forget that Harrit wanted to carry out tests on the nature of the organic component of his red/gray chips. I haven't read anything on that topic. Did he make any progress?
 
Last edited:
Yes, he is! He spent his whole career on studying photochemistry. But I don't know wether this qualifies him of investigating this chips. I'd suppose not.
I had to look up photochemistry. Like you, I don't know whether this qualifies him or not. I'll have to investigate further.

We should not forget that Harrit wanted to carry out tests on the nature of the organic component of his red/gray chips. I haven't read anything on that topic. Did he make any progress?
I'm in the "I don't know" category on that one as well.

I would love to have a sample of the material they analyzed though.
 
Last edited:
So when/where do bedunkers refute the findings?

The big collective YAWN from respected scientific organizations anywhere on Earth is quite the refutation in my mind. Oh, yea. I forgot. You keep forgetting just how much in the abject minority your little cult is.

Carry on
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom