Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not necessarily! But it does mean Woo! You might find that Woo is harshly mocked at JREF.


GB

You might be shocked to learn that strong emergence is actually science.

A Mathematical Theory of Strong Emergence Using Multiscale Variety

We argue conceptually and then demonstrate mathematically that it is possible to define a scientifically meaningful notion of strong emergence. A strong emergent property is a property of the system that cannot be found in the properties of the system’s parts or in the interactions between the parts. The possibility of strong emergence follows from an ensemble perspective, which states that physical systems are only meaningful as ensembles rather than individual states. Emergent properties reside in the properties of the ensemble rather than of any individual state. A simple example is the case of a string of bits including a parity bit, i.e. the bits are constrained to have, e.g., an odd number of ON bits. This constraint is a property of the entire system that cannot be identified through any set of
observations of the state of any or all subsystems of the system. It is a property that can only be found in observations of the state of the system as a whole. A collective constraint is a property of the system, however, the constraint is caused when the environment interacts with the system to select the allowable states. Although selection in this context does not necessarily correspond to biological evolution, it does suggest that evolutionary processes may lead to such emergent properties. A mathematical characterization of multiscale variety captures the implications of strong emergent properties on all subsystems of the system. Strong emergent properties result in oscillations of multiscale variety with negative values, a distinctive property. Examples of relevant applications in the case of social systems include various allocation, optimization, and functional requirements on the behavior of a system. Strongly emergent properties imply a global to local causality that is conceptually disturbing (but allowed!) in the context of conventional science, and is important to how we think about biological and social systems.
 
What makes believing in a power greater than oneself inherently religious?

Can groups achieve what individuals cannot?

Maybe. But if that's the case, why bother with a Religious Programme like AA? You can just form a group of Alcoholics that help each other without the Woo.

What's so hard about that? And why is it so hard to just admit that AA is a Religious Organization?


GB
 
slingblade-

"God" refers to the power greater than oneself.

If that power is not supernatural, is AA still religious?

Yes! Because the Primary Texts of AA make it clear that the Higher Power refers to God, not the other way around.

Look how PO'd AA got when an AA group started passing around the Secular 12 Steps instead of the GSO approved literature. They booted that group out of AA. That should tell you something.

Any group that does not use AA's Religious literature is not affiliated with AA.


GB
 
Yes! Because the Primary Texts of AA make it clear that the Higher Power refers to God, not the other way around.

Look how PO'd AA got when an AA group started passing around the Secular 12 Steps instead of the GSO approved literature. They booted that group out of AA. That should tell you something.

Any group that does not use AA's Religious literature is not affiliated with AA.


GB

Again, the "Primary Texts" do not hold the same exalted position in AA as other Scriptures do in most religions; they are the narratives of the founders and usually nothing more.
 
You might be shocked to learn that strong emergence is actually science.

A Mathematical Theory of Strong Emergence Using Multiscale Variety

I was referring to the phrasing "like magic" in it's original context. I am quite familiar with Group Dynamics. And your article is just another way of looking at Group Dynamics with a bunch of long words.

I am not against groups (well, not against other people being in groups, I tend to have a George Carlin attitude about being in groups). If you want a group, form a group.

Clearly AA's Religious Programme can be chucked out of the window if it is only Group Support systems at play.

GB
 
Again, the "Primary Texts" do not hold the same exalted position in AA as other Scriptures do in most religions; they are the narratives of the founders and usually nothing more.


You are so wrong. AA's Scriptures have EXACTLY the same "exalted position" you find in other religions. If they didn't, they wouldn't be handed out at every bloody meeting. If they didn't they wouldn't be AA.

How hard is that to understand???

GB
 
I don't know how you could miss the key part of the following post. I mean, what the hell, you quoted it yourself and never got beyond the first sentence.

Yes! Because the Primary Texts of AA make it clear that the Higher Power refers to God, not the other way around.

Look how PO'd AA got when an AA group started passing around the Secular 12 Steps instead of the GSO approved literature. They booted that group out of AA. That should tell you something. Any group that does not use AA's Religious literature is not affiliated with AA.
GB
 
Last edited:
Again, the "Primary Texts" do not hold the same exalted position in AA as other Scriptures do in most religions; they are the narratives of the founders and usually nothing more.

As far as meetings in the USA, you are simply wrong. Incorrect, wrong, not-right, however you want to interpret it. I personally have been to over 11,000 meetings all across the USA - this gives me a strong (perhaps, among the viewers of this thread, even a singular) ability to comment on the process and methods of AA as a whole.
I have also been involved - recently involved, officially involved - in AA world services at nearly the highest levels. I've created districts from scratch in several states, begun AA relationships with more than 6 major regional hospitals. I've spoken in front of more than 1000 AA members at a time - by invitation. I've been directly involved in the creation of several of the pamphlets you see at your meetings (assuming you purchase AA literature) material that I've come to regret I had any involvement in. - Ive been at the meetings where their contents, and the contents of Public Service Messages, have been created.
I am even slightly involved in creating a few new ones, whose contents I am not at liberty to reveal - and that's all I say about that.

The point is, if you go to an AA meeting - any AA meeting anywhere in the USA, and make the 2 statements that I have previously (and continue) done, you will receive massive, intense, and immediate out-group responses.

AA is a Faith Gaining Program whose members & officials claim has the side effect of eliminating the drink problem - a claim not supported by the evidence available. It has at least a 95% failure rating, and our efforts should be directed to finding those things that really work - no false faith required.

No religion required.

For those few who've forgotten those statements, here is one of them - I'll leave it to others to read the thread for others:

1. "I do not need a higher power or any God/gods to get, maintain, and stay sober. And since there is no evidence of any such creature, neither do you"

Try it sometime - and see what reaction you get. Do it 100's of times, as I have, then come back and talk to me, at which point I might pay more attention.
 
For those few who've forgotten those statements, here is one of them - I'll leave it to others to read the thread for others:

1. "I do not need a higher power or any God/gods to get, maintain, and stay sober. And since there is no evidence of any such creature, neither do you"

Try it sometime - and see what reaction you get. Do it 100's of times, as I have, then come back and talk to me, at which point I might pay more attention.

I have done it 100s of times and continue to do so.
I think that qualifies me to dispute your claims, in fact reject them outright as BS.

You have told flagrant lies on a number of occasions, why would anyone believe you.

Yoiu claim these exulted positions within the supposed heirarchy of AA, and given all the paradoxes, mystery, evasions and contradictions, I find these claims hard to believe. Additionally, you make these claims far too often which makes my doubts even greater.

I ask you again ....

Acvtually I have never heard of the ABCs, perhaps Tinyal could show me where these came from? They seem a inaccurate excerpt of some of the steps. Perhaps Tinyal could also show me where it says these are compulsory or similar. I doubt he can (in fact I know he can't).

And while your at it...

Did you do the steps and accept God Tinyal?
If not, how did you do your program?


All that aside, I wish to thank you:

You are proof of everything I (we) have been saying about the "suggestions" and 'options'.
You are proof of the fact that AA has some foundations in Christianity but in practice, religion is not required.
You are proof of the adage "take what you need and leave the rest".
You are proof that to do AA, one does not need to embrace God
You are proof - I assume by your silence - the 12 steps are not necessary for recovery within AA.
You are proof that AA accepts all comers, (not however that other members have to agree).
You are proof that the traditions work.
You are proof that the majoriy of members accept a PGTO and/or a HP, and that does not have to be God, nor is it compulsory.
You are proof that the only requiremenbt for membership is a desire to stop drinking.
You are proof that one works their own program, not the program of others.
You are proof that AA works if you work it.

Thank you, thank you and thank you again, for all your efforts.
 
Last edited:
Someone on this thread is proof that religion destroys the power of reason.
kboom.gif


Toss out the Religion in AA and you have nothing left but the group. It's as simple as that. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure it out.

Anyone on this thread who believes you don't need religion for sobriety, chuck out your Big Book and your 12 Steps then tell all the non-Theists in your group to do the same.

Then you can all hang out together and support each other without the embarrassment of being forced to abandon logic pretending you don't belong to a religious organization.


GB
 
slingblade-

"God" refers to the power greater than oneself.

If that power is not supernatural, is AA still religious?


If it's not human, and it's surely not animal, then it's supernatural.

Quoting the material you quoted:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

Even strong emergence is human power. A high form of it, perhaps, but still human. "No human power" means supernatural. Twist it nine ways from Monday, it's still not human, and therefore is supernatural.
 
If it's not human, and it's surely not animal, then it's supernatural.

Quoting the material you quoted:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

Even strong emergence is human power. A high form of it, perhaps, but still human. "No human power" means supernatural. Twist it nine ways from Monday, it's still not human, and therefore is supernatural.

Nature or the laws of nature could be a higher power. That isn't supernatural and it isn't human.
Education could be a higher power. That isn't supernatural and it isn't human.
The fellowship of AA could be a higher power, that isn't supernatural - we could argue that it is or isn't human.
Medicine or psychology could be a higher power. That isn't supernatural and it isn't human.
Fate (or whatever you would like to call it) could be a higher power. That might be supernatural, it sure isn't human.
God could be a higher power. That is supernatural and it isn't human.
Add anything you like here - anything will suffice; if it works for you, run with it.

People choose things like these all the time. I am certain they wont fit your criterion, but no-one really cares if they do or not. Neither you, me, AA or the big book dictate their programs, or by extension their respective HPs or PGTOs.

Cheers.
 
If you want it to be, sure. Whatever blows your skirt up mate, is fine with us. :)

So far, you've told me I haven't a clue, and now this "blows your skirt up" bit of indignity.

I haven't attacked you personally, only your arguments.
Is this really the way you want to conduct your argument? With insults to my intellect and thinly-veiled sexist innuendo? Really? You couldn't stick with "whatever floats your boat," and avoid the tacky comment about my supposed skirts?

AA is clearly religious. GB is quite correct: remove the 12 religious steps and the religious Big Book, and what's left? If they're "suggested" and "optional," then the program would work just fine without them.

I'd suggest you back off from the personal crap, and stick to the argument.
 
If it's not human, and it's surely not animal, then it's supernatural.

Quoting the material you quoted:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

Even strong emergence is human power. A high form of it, perhaps, but still human. "No human power" means supernatural. Twist it nine ways from Monday, it's still not human, and therefore is supernatural.

Plants are supernatural? Bacteria? Uni-cellular eukaryotes? All non-living matter?

I do understand that it is a bit of a stretch to call the emergent properties of human communities "not human", but what you, and other posters who assert than AA has to be religious because its "Primary Texts" mention "God", have done is ignore that one of the other threads of the narrative is that of many alcoholics trying to control their alcoholism on their own and failing individually but succeeding when they got together to help one another. Whether they did so by externalizing the power that they found within the group and calling it "God" is largely irrelevant, because the power that they found within the group is what kept them sober and that power is not supernatural nor is it inherently religious.
 
Nature or the laws of nature could be a higher power. That isn't supernatural and it isn't human.

It also makes no sense in this context. Calling nature a higher power that you call upon to remove your shortcomings is calling upon a supernatural, non-human power to work god-like miracles in your life.

Education could be a higher power. That isn't supernatural and it isn't human.

Education isn't something humans do? Then who conducts this education, and who receives it?

The fellowship of AA could be a higher power, that isn't supernatural - we could argue that it is or isn't human.

A fellowship of humans is human.

Medicine or psychology could be a higher power. That isn't supernatural and it isn't human.

Medicine doesn't exist without humans to discover it, produce it and consume it. Of course it's human. And medicine isn't part of the AA program. No doctors or pills or prescriptions involved.

Fate (or whatever you would like to call it) could be a higher power. That might be supernatural, it sure isn't human.

Definitely supernatural.

God could be a higher power. That is supernatural and it isn't human.

Gods are invented, fictional, definitely supernatural, and religious.

Add anything you like here - anything will suffice; if it works for you, run with it.

Again, the question is: why do people insist that AA is not religious?
It isn't about what "works for me." Is it, or is it not religious?

It calls upon god to perform supernatural, non-human change in a person's life. That's prayer. That's religious.

People choose things like these all the time. I am certain they wont fit your criterion, but no-one really cares if they do or not. Neither you, me, AA or the big book dictate their programs, or by extension their respective HPs or PGTOs.

And yet again, the question is: why do people insist that AA is not religious?

It isn't about what people choose, it isn't even about the people within the program, and it isn't about fitting my criteria.

Is it, or is it not a religiously oriented program?

AA is very clearly a religious program. Even if the people within the program choose not to express or utilize religion, the program itself is of a religious bent and nature.
 
Plants are supernatural? Bacteria? Uni-cellular eukaryotes? All non-living matter?

What plant do you call upon to remove your shortcomings and return you to sanity?

Can you not see how your statement is such a non-sequitur in this discussion that it's very hard to take seriously? How can you even come to the conclusion that I was insinuating plants must be supernatural because they aren't human or animal? Try to stick with the point, please: the higher power that performs change upon your addiction, returns you to sanity, is god as you understand him.

What's that got to do with plants, Mijo?

I do understand that it is a bit of a stretch to call the emergent properties of human communities "not human", but what you, and other posters who assert than AA has to be religious because its "Primary Texts" mention "God", have done is ignore that one of the other threads of the narrative is that of many alcoholics trying to control their alcoholism on their own and failing individually but succeeding when they got together to help one another. Whether they did so by externalizing the power that they found within the group and calling it "God" is largely irrelevant, because the power that they found within the group is what kept them sober and that power is not supernatural nor is it inherently religious.

And yet again, that's the people using the program, not the program itself.

Do you gentlemen simply not understand we aren't talking about the religiosity of the people using the program, but whether the program itself is of a religious bent?

Can we not talk about the program itself?
 
What plant do you call upon to remove your shortcomings and return you to sanity?

Can you not see how your statement is such a non-sequitur in this discussion that it's very hard to take seriously? How can you even come to the conclusion that I was insinuating plants must be supernatural because they aren't human or animal? Try to stick with the point, please: the higher power that performs change upon your addiction, returns you to sanity, is god as you understand him.

What's that got to do with plants, Mijo?

Are you seriously not rembering what you said?

If it's not human, and it's surely not animal, then it's supernatural.

Quoting the material you quoted:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

Even strong emergence is human power. A high form of it, perhaps, but still human. "No human power" means supernatural. Twist it nine ways from Monday, it's still not human, and therefore is supernatural.

You said that something that was not human or was not animal was supernatural.

And yet again, that's the people using the program, not the program itself.

Do you gentlemen simply not understand we aren't talking about the religiosity of the people using the program, but whether the program itself is of a religious bent?

Can we not talk about the program itself?

Yeah, first there is no "the program". Each person's program is individual to that person. Some people work the steps; some don't. Some understand "God" as a supernatural power; others don't. What seem to be going on here is that there is a fanatical focus on the word "God" and a complete inability to consider the following phrase: "as we understood (understand) Him".

To me, "God" (and I mean the word "God") is just a shorthand for "Higher Power" or "Power greater than oneself". There is nothing inherently supernatural about the latter two. In fact, there are numerous examples of atheists benefitting from AA and continuing not to believe in supernatural entities. If AA were inherently religious, how would this be possible?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom