How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
How about this, or this?

I believe those were two of the laws the Federal Government used to convict the Liberty Dollar people.

Neither of those apply.
The problem with liberty dollar was that they were encouraging people to pass the coins (and notes) off as USD- bit coin does not do this indeed bit coin can't do this. There have been (and are) plenty of alternative currencies used throughout the world including in the USA- none of them are particularly successful but few of them are illegal.
You may be able to argue that bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme and therefore illegal but that would not make ownership or use of bitcoins illegal, just the overall operation of the scheme.
 
Can you give an example of a law which would make possession of the bitcoin software illegal?
I know that bitcoin is not legal tender, but that doesn't make bitcoin "illegal tender".

Start here[url].

Legal tender is a pretty narrowly defined concept and plenty of currencies operate without being legal tender. For instance, there is no legal tender in Scotland, yet they manage to use Sterling ok.

That is inaccurate. Sterling coins are legal tender in Scotland, but no banknotes. Bank of England notes, as well as those issued by Bank of Scotland, RBS and Clydesdale Bank, are legal currency.

Scottish money is a quirk, and other countries act differently. In most systems central banks have a monopoly on the issuing of legal tender.
 
That was admitted uninformed speculation.

Care to be specific?

The fact of the matter is that there are a number of alternative currencies in circulation which have not run into legal difficulties.

Care to name just a few? Your understanding of the legal currency intricacies in Europe and in Scotland makes me suspect your expertise in this area. Remember that each jurisdiction has its own rules on currency.

Those that have done so have been the ones which pretend in some way to be government issued or government backed. There is no indication that bitcoin comes at all close to counterfeiting.

It is a currency, governments tend to have a monopoly on issuing legal tender and legal currency. In the U.S. there is such a monopoly. In Europe, there are different rules, but to issue electronic money you have to be an approved Electronic Money Institution.
 
Wow, lotsa crap happened over the weekend.

Leif Roar said:
I believe that assertion is wrong. There are feedback mechanisms in the system, yes, but there's no dampening. The system would fluctuate wildly (if it would ever survive long enough to do so.)
Could be. I'm no economist, so I can't quantify what might dampen the downswing (people, having stopped mining coins, start again) side of the oscillation. Personally I'd figure once someone invests hardware in the system (on the upswing side), they're likely to stick with it, which should dampen it well enough, to my mode of thinking.

The upswing side though, I can argue. I don't think I explicitly specified this before, but in bitcoin paradigms the mining difficulty is not a function of time, but a function of coins mined. Double the total computer power and you temporarily double the coins mined, yes, but you're also halving the time constant. Those machines will fall to 50% output after one year of operation, not two. Effectively you're just stepping forward a bit on the exponential curve. The chance for wild oscillations in this manner, I feel, is low. By the time one tier of machines becomes unprofitable to run, there should be another waiting to be purchased, so the process is unlikely to "hit a wall."

John Albert said:
What happens when the bitcoin supply reaches its prescribed limit of 21 million bitcoins? No more new bitcoins means no more mining opportunity. With noting left to mine, there will be no more incentive to contribute to the transaction workload.
Nice wall of text. There's a number of very salient points you're making, I just wanted to pull out this one because it's flatly wrong. Look up "transaction fees," and picture what the libertarian reaction will be when they realize their sacred cow relies on a tax to keep running.

Leif Roar said:
And as if to just rub it in: "[...] it has emerged that details of more than 60,000 users have been stolen from the Mt Gox exchange. The compromised information includes hashed passwords."
The compromised information was hashed passwords. md5 hashed passwords. Unsalted md5 hashed passwords. That I'm inferring from the description they scraped off the website somehow instead of "hacking" proper.

For those of you to whom that was gibberish, this was a very, very basic security mistake. md5 hashing was broken years ago, without even salting it they could literally just look up the real password. The best comparison I can think of would be parking your Rolls Royce on the wrong side of town, then flipping a quarter at a cheerful-looking street urchin and asking them to "Watch it for me, will you? There's a chap."

It was "reverted," ironically enough, by asking paypal to renege on their backing agreement by reversing the charges, then rolling back the database to before the breakin.
 
MD5 has been broken for awhile, so it's is hardly ever used in cryptography anymore. But its low collision rate still makes it useful for simple verification of the integrity of transferred or compressed files.

Are you sure they hash their passwords in MD5? I thought these Bitcoin developers were supposed to be cryptogeniuses.
 
Last edited:
Bitcoin uses sha256 for everything.

MtGox.com, the 3rd party website which was compromised, used md5 hashing. So do a disturbing number of other sites, but whatcha gonna do.
 
Anybody who believes that bitcoin is just a flash in the pan is indulging in wishful thinking. As long as the algorithm is uncrackable, there will be a role for bitcoin. The role hasn't been clearly defined yet but that often happens when new technology is introduced.
 
why in the world would I or anyone else want to use a currency whose price is as variable and arbitrary as this? Normal fiat currencies certainly have their problems, but they're not going to triple or halve their values in a month just because someone decided to cash out.
 
why in the world would I or anyone else want to use a currency whose price is as variable and arbitrary as this? Normal fiat currencies certainly have their problems, but they're not going to triple or halve their values in a month just because someone decided to cash out.
The value of bitcoin will stabilize once people learn the difference between bitcoin itself and the idiotic bitcoin repositories (which no-one has to use) who lack the sense to have proper encryption on their files.
 
the problem is that those "idiotic bitcoin repositories" make up a massive amount of the value of Bitcoin, and the people running them (and using Bitcoin in general) are staggeringly naive about data security. Someone said to me that Bitcoin in a month are making all the errors and experiencing all the crises that a standard currency experiences in a decade.

Whatever the supposed practical elements of bitcoin may be, it's a currency promoted and operated by naive fools and backed by people speculating on a currency with graphics cards from NewEgg. Right now it's essentially a toxic brand and with good reason.
 
None of that contradicts anything I have just posted. Presently, a lot of "naive fools" are getting burned because they don't know better. How bitcoin will be used once the fools give up on it is still anybody's guess but there are plenty of people who have reason (whether legitimate or not) to conceal their wealth from those who would take it off them.

If you are into speculating, now is the time to do it. Otherwise, wait until the dust settles.
 
Anybody who believes that bitcoin is just a flash in the pan is indulging in wishful thinking. As long as the algorithm is uncrackable, there will be a role for bitcoin. The role hasn't been clearly defined yet but that often happens when new technology is introduced.

I do not believe the technology behind it will be abandoned...and bitcoins will still "exist" in some sense. But I do not predict it becoming or remaining a viable medium of exchange.
 
How bitcoin will be used once the fools give up on it is still anybody's guess but there are plenty of people who have reason (whether legitimate or not) to conceal their wealth from those who would take it off them.

THe problem is that for BitCoin to be any use in this situation you would have to be able to exchange it for either goods and services or for actual money, and people would need to have confidence in it for either of these to be possible.

It's going to take a lot for it to lose both the stigma it had to begin with and the additional stigma it's gained in the last few weeks, and frankly I've seen very little reason its reputation is going to get better. Right now its anonymity is a problem rather than a feature, because the anonymity is making it much easier to steal.
 
Libertarian News reports:




The article goes on to explain how to use the new currency and why it is superior to all other currencies in existence.

This will change the face of the planet.

So you want me to sign up for and buy Bitcoins to buy a Bitcoin t-shirt? What else can I do with Bitcoins besides buy something to wipe my ass with? And then when I want to buy something like a car I'll have to re-convert my Bitcoins to dollars?

Seems inflammatory, but c'mon. I know you go to great lengths to say "this is not a scheme!" but it really really seems like one.
 
The legal status of Bitcoin is not clear, the Electronic Frontier Foundation had been accepting them for donations, but yesterday stopped and is giving away what they have received to avoid potential legal problems.

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/06/eff-and-bitcoin

1. We don't fully understand the complex legal issues involved with creating a new currency system. Bitcoin raises untested legal concerns related to securities law, the Stamp Payments Act, tax evasion, consumer protection and money laundering, among others. And that's just in the U.S. While EFF is often the defender of people ensnared in legal issues arising from new technologies, we try very hard to keep EFF from becoming the actual subject of those fights or issues. Since there is no caselaw on this topic, and the legal implications are still very unclear, we worry that our acceptance of Bitcoins may move us into the possible subject role.
 
Only if you know where I have hidden my CD-Rom. :D

ah, this is one of these "I'm all right jack" moments where because a problem won't affect you it doesn't affect anyone, right?

Newsflash: a currency that can only be used by the very tech savvy and security conscious is a crap currency that nobody will use.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom