So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm a gamer.
I don't go to Gencon, Comicon, Blizzcon, or any other con any more as I can't handle the unwashed mouth breathers anymore. They make me uncomfortable. I don't expect anytime soon that they will not be at these conventions either, and I won't tell them not to be there. There are a bunch of people there I like and would love to hang out with, but my ability to tolerate others has diminished.

This is my shortcoming.

From my perspective and to use a gaming term;

This is whole incident Nerdrage.
 
She just went to the elevator, if you hurry you can still catch her... :D

:) On a related note, I rode the elevator at the Con exactly twice, after which I remarked to a fellow Conventioneer (male) how much I disliked elevators, not for the mechanical issues, but for feeling trapped in such close quarters with unfamiliar people.
 
See Linda's reply to TraneWreck above. First one needs to establish the reason for the imbalance with more than an anecdotal impression. And your conclusion about the meaning of Dawkin's comments goes well beyond what the evidence supports.

Yeah, I've read Dawkin's comments several times and it looks like he is trying to make the same point I tried to make. It was reasonable for Rebecca to be annoyed and to make the suggestion, "guys, don't do that". It wasn't reasonable for Rebecca to hold that up as an example of what is meant by objectification or hatred of women. Or at least, if she wanted to make that argument, that she make an effort to explain how so. We already have examples of hatred against women and they seem to be nothing like what she described. What she described seemed to be more like how we feel if someone chews gum in our ear (okay, that doesn't bug me so much, but it seems to bug Richard).

I realize that I could be wrong, in which case I'll be happy to throw Richard under the bus. :)

Linda
 
I realize that I could be wrong, in which case I'll be happy to throw Richard under the bus. :)
Only if it has one of the athiest signs, though? Right?

(sorry one of the MSM articles linked in the thread had a picture of Dawkins in front of a London bus with the Athiest sign, so that is what I thought of.)
 
I'm sorry but most people usually get made fun of when they invoke this arguments. As I said before socially awkwared is not an excuse for idiocy. You have a brain. You can think two seconds before speaking.


If you have Asperger's your brain doesn't work the same way as other people.

I work with geeky scientists, one who has Asperger's syndrome.

While he is a brilliant men and has learned how to interpret facial expression, it has taken him most of his life to work out what some of the most basic human emotions relate to the facial expression.

He still upsets people with some of his comments as he doesn't react to 'normal' human situations in the manner you would expect.

I also think that Asperger's syndrome is far more prevalent than people realise, and there will be a higher percentage in certain groups, like scientists and sceptics.
 
:) On a related note, I rode the elevator at the Con exactly twice, after which I remarked to a fellow Conventioneer (male) how much I disliked elevators, not for the mechanical issues, but for feeling trapped in such close quarters with unfamiliar people.

I hate them, too, whether my fellow rider is male or female. I actually get a little anxiety from it. I tried a trick I learned, to get me through similar anxious moments; I just recall something funny and it distracts and relaxes me. Unfortunately, in an elevator, going up 19 floors, is not a good time to recall Ellen Degeneres' suggestions for things to say in awkward elevator moments, "Hey, you want to smell something?" Now I am creepy elevator gal, cracking up at seemingly nothing, which I am sure, it threatening to my fellow occupant.
 
If you have Asperger's your brain doesn't work the same way as other people.

I work with geeky scientists, one who has Asperger's syndrome.

While he is a brilliant men and has learned how to interpret facial expression, it has taken him most of his life to work out what some of the most basic human emotions relate to the facial expression.

He still upsets people with some of his comments as he doesn't react to 'normal' human situations in the manner you would expect.

I also think that Asperger's syndrome is far more prevalent than people realise, and there will be a higher percentage in certain groups, like scientists and sceptics.

Sounds like he has Dissociative Identity Disorder, too. The poor guys! :D
 
I hate them, too, whether my fellow rider is male or female. I actually get a little anxiety from it. I tried a trick I learned, to get me through similar anxious moments; I just recall something funny and it distracts and relaxes me. Unfortunately, in an elevator, going up 19 floors, is not a good time to recall Ellen Degeneres' suggestions for things to say in awkward elevator moments, "Hey, you want to smell something?" Now I am creepy elevator gal, cracking up at seemingly nothing, which I am sure, it threatening to my fellow occupant.

Don't do that...

:p
 
Yeah, I've read Dawkin's comments several times and it looks like he is trying to make the same point I tried to make. It was reasonable for Rebecca to be annoyed and to make the suggestion, "guys, don't do that". It wasn't reasonable for Rebecca to hold that up as an example of what is meant by objectification or hatred of women. Or at least, if she wanted to make that argument, that she make an effort to explain how so. We already have examples of hatred against women and they seem to be nothing like what she described. What she described seemed to be more like how we feel if someone chews gum in our ear (okay, that doesn't bug me so much, but it seems to bug Richard).


This is how I read what happened too.
 
Yeah, I've read Dawkin's comments several times and it looks like he is trying to make the same point I tried to make. It was reasonable for Rebecca to be annoyed and to make the suggestion, "guys, don't do that". It wasn't reasonable for Rebecca to hold that up as an example of what is meant by objectification or hatred of women. Or at least, if she wanted to make that argument, that she make an effort to explain how so. We already have examples of hatred against women and they seem to be nothing like what she described. What she described seemed to be more like how we feel if someone chews gum in our ear (okay, that doesn't bug me so much, but it seems to bug Richard).

I realize that I could be wrong, in which case I'll be happy to throw Richard under the bus. :)

Linda

Objectification and hatred are two really, really different things (although there is some small overlap.)

Objectification is externalizing the subject. Seeing them as an object to fulfill your needs. There are many examples of this and they run the gamut from annoying (catcalling - reduces a person to something that exists to provide attention or eye-candy) to dangerous (rape - reduces a person to an object that exists for power/sexual gratification.)

Hatred is hatred. It doesn't have degrees.

At no point in her original video did Watson accuse anyone of hatred. She did accuse the elevator guy of objectification. But she most certainly did not say that all men do this. She said that, with the exception of EG, everyone had been great.
 
"Hey, coffee?"
"Nup. Stuffed."
"K."


??????
More like:

R: *long talk mentioning how she dislikes women being hit on in conventions*
R: "Ok folks, I'm tired, going to bed. Night everyone." *walks out to elevator*
EG: *follows in elevator* "Hey, wanna join me in my bedroom? Uh, I mean, for coffee and talk... right, that's it."
R: "Um. No thanks..."
EG: "Oh, ok."
R: *facepalm*

ETA I am simply not convinced that asking someone to have a coffee is propositioning anything other than having a coffee.
Coffee was available at the bar. They could have gotten an isolated table and discussed there, but he asked her to his room.

It was reasonable for Rebecca to be annoyed and to make the suggestion, "guys, don't do that". It wasn't reasonable for Rebecca to hold that up as an example of what is meant by objectification or hatred of women.
Very good point.
 
Objectification and hatred are two really, really different things (although there is some small overlap.)

Objectification is externalizing the subject. Seeing them as an object to fulfill your needs. There are many examples of this and they run the gamut from annoying (catcalling - reduces a person to something that exists to provide attention or eye-candy) to dangerous (rape - reduces a person to an object that exists for power/sexual gratification.)

Hatred is hatred. It doesn't have degrees.

At no point in her original video did Watson accuse anyone of hatred. She did accuse the elevator guy of objectification. But she most certainly did not say that all men do this. She said that, with the exception of EG, everyone had been great.

She made multiple references to misogyny and misogynists which means "hatred of women", as well as referring to sexual objectification. Which is why I said both.

I don't think that the references to misogyny in the original video were directed at Elevator Guy. She extended misogyny to include the elevator incident at the CFI talk (and in her blog entries) when she brought in the critical blog and video responses to her original video.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Surely you are not suggesting that it is the presence of small talk that distinguishes any of these cases?! And again, how is any of that supposed to help "that guy" who has already had the experience of engaging in small in talk in elevators without women cowering in the corner begging not to be raped?

I'm suggesting that just because the verbal content of the statement was seemingly innocuous, that doesn't make Rebecca's apprehension any less valid.

Rebecca wasn't cowering in the corner, she was deeply uncomfortable. The discomfort was heightened by the nature of the converstion and the fact that she was a captive audience.

How do you talk to women in elevators? Certainly not by propositioning them without any prior contact. Asking about business would have been good--where is your next speaking engagement? are you going to TAM...whatever. If she wants to continue the coversation when you leave the elevator, great, if not, let her go.

I really don't think it's that complicated. The content of the coversation doesn't automatically mean your intentions are pure, but the content can certainly cause more apprehension. I doubt very seriously we ever would have heard of "Elavator Guy" if he had said, I enjoyed your talk, are you going to write a book or anything?

I'm trying to understand how the guy can get some idea of how he comes across, because this is difficult to discover.

Have friends, talk to people, listen to what women say. If nothing else, a whole lot of men are now aware of a set of behaviors a good number of women find objectionable. Whether they choose to respect that opinion is up to them.

The issue of proper interpersonal relations is obviously a vastly complicated hornet's nest. That doesn't mean there aren't clear examples. It's hard to explain why propositioning a woman you've had no prior contact with in an enclosed space late at night would cause a good number of women to be uncomfortable other than the ways that have been offered.

I agree that it's reasonable. I don't think the advice which has been given has been useful or helpful for the reasons I outlined. So far, I get the impression that men should picture all women as weak and vulnerable so as to understand their perspective.

That's why the environment is important. Everyone is weak and vulnerable given the proper circumstances. The reality of sexual assault in America in the 21st century causes more women to legitimately fear a wider variety of those circumstances than men.

Notice, however, that the weak and vulnerable ones in this equation are the men. It's so difficult to talk to women in public that we must be allowed confrontation out of the public eye in whatever means we choose.

Here's a basic rule of thumb: Getting two people alone together should involve the willfull choice of both.

Sometimes that happens by chance. In those circumstances, be respectful until both parties are able to freely choose.

Lot's of gray area there, but EG ain't one of them.
 
Last edited:
....
Objectification is externalizing the subject. Seeing them as an object to fulfill your needs. There are many examples of this and they run the gamut from annoying (catcalling - reduces a person to something that exists to provide attention or eye-candy) to dangerous (rape - reduces a person to an object that exists for power/sexual gratification.)

....
And if a man or a woman just happens to like sex for the sake of physical gratification? What is wrong with that? I'm glad I grew up with the generation that made feeling guilty about enjoying sex** for the sake of sex a thing of the past.

It's only when you see the other as only good for sex and you apply it to a whole class of people that one can label it objectification.

And speaking of the current last half century, would it have been OK for Rebecca to hit on a guy she found interesting in the same elevator?


(**I'm also glad I missed the HIV pandemic. So I'm not advocating unsafe sex. But I am all for guilt free sex if that's your thing.)
 
What century are you in? As an adult woman, I think I could handle a guy making a pass in such a situation without fear.
I've no doubt you could! :D
Someone could join the elevator with said person leaving the chat and at the same time give off vibes one should be concerned about, but to claim this is automatically worrisome is ludicrous.

No, but this situation had enough danger signals it was reasonable for Rebecca to be concerned. These are some danger signals that I try to look out for:

1. You are alone with a man where you can't be seen or heard by others and you can't exit immediately.
2. The man knows who you are even though you don't recognize him.
3. The man has indicated that he would like to have sex with you.

None of these signals are worrisome by themselves. All three of them present would be worrisome to me. Like Rebecca, I would be very uncomfortable until I was no longer alone with him.

It's a hotel! People use the elevator. Men talk to women they haven't been formally introduced to. The world is just not that scary one should fear every encounter with a guy you haven't met. The proof is in the fact NOTHING BUT ASKING HAPPENED!!
Who has said that one should fear every encounter with a guy you haven't met? What I think people have been trying to say is that many women, in particular women who have been the victims of a sexual assault (a sizeable minority of american woman) are quite likely to be afraid of being confined alone with a man they don't know who has indicated he wants to have sex with them. I don't know the statistics, but I know that many sexual assaults don't begin until after the guy has requested sex and been turned down. You could think of it as a common prelude to rape. Clearly the vast majority of men not only prefer a willing partner and wouldn't dream of insisting after the woman made her 'no' clear, but not all men are like that.

Had this been a simple coincidence, two people going to their rooms at 4 am, are you suggesting a gentleman would wait and take the next elevator car so as to not frighten the vulnerable little female in the elevator? That's rather sexist.
No. It's been suggested that it's a courteous thing for men to do. Kind of like men opening doors for women. Is that considered sexist these days? Does it even ever come up anymore?

What I've seen recommended (elsewhere, not here) is that a women who gets a 'vibe' that worries her should get off the elevator with the stranger and take the next one. Don't worry about hurting his feelings, the advice is not to get into a confined space with a stranger that makes you uncomfortable. That seems quite sensible to me. Getting off the elevator is something that a women can do for herself, she needn't rely on the courtesy of strangers.
 
You know what's weird? Dawkins has been a speaker at many conferences. He has probably had some fan approach him and ask to speak to him privately as he is leaving the room. But he didn't use that as an example, he used being on an elevator with someone who is chewing gum.

I am not trying to make a point with this. There is nothing that can come from this observation that has not already been mentioned. It's just a little strange.
 
And if a man or a woman just happens to like sex for the sake of physical gratification? What is wrong with that? I'm glad I grew up with the generation that made feeling guilty about enjoying sex** for the sake of sex a thing of the past.

It's only when you see the other as only good for sex and you apply it to a whole class of people that one can label it objectification.

And speaking of the current last half century, would it have been OK for Rebecca to hit on a guy she found interesting in the same elevator?

Just so we're clear, I agree with all of that. The generalization from this goofball to "men" as well as interpreting his behavior as misogyny is weird. He might be a misogynist or he might not, but that episode doesn't really prove it.

I also see no reason why I can't be interested in a woman both because of her thoughts and ideas and because I find them attractive. But that's neither here nor there.

I do, however, think that a lot of the reaction has revealed some serious problems within "our community" or whatever the hell we're talking about.
 
Last edited:
And if a man or a woman just happens to like sex for the sake of physical gratification? What is wrong with that? I'm glad I grew up with the generation that made feeling guilty about enjoying sex** for the sake of sex a thing of the past.

It's only when you see the other as only good for sex and you apply it to a whole class of people that one can label it objectification.

And speaking of the current last half century, would it have been OK for Rebecca to hit on a guy she found interesting in the same elevator?


(**I'm also glad I missed the HIV pandemic. So I'm not advocating unsafe sex. But I am all for guilt free sex if that's your thing.)

If they have both agreed to enjoy sex together for purely physical gratification, neither is objectifying the other. They are two people engaged in a mutually beneficial relationship to which each has consented. Both of their needs have been considered. Even though their needs at the moment can be reduced to "I want to enjoy your body." The example I gave was rape in which one person has been reduced to an object.

ETA: And seriously, what is it with you and consent? Consent isn't a remnant of archaic prudery. It is the most basic form of respect.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom