So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Skepchicks are renowned for their ability to laugh at themselves, right? Wrong? Oh well, after seeing their promotional video, and until they do just a wee bit more to repudiate it maybe and the atmosphere of sexual objectification it likely contributed to now that they've decided they no longer like being sexually objectified, there's this: offered in a spirit of deepest empathy, to reflect the contradictions they must be struggling with in their transformation from party girls to arch-feminists, a lyric set to a grunge tune about struggling with contradictions from some years back (in no way intended to minimize anyone's feelings or experience or the issues swirling about them; knit strictly with material shorn from this thread; one day we'll all look back at this and laaa-ugghhh, surely; so why not today? - heh - gulp):

"Smells Like Teen Skepchick"

[verse 1]
Hike up your skirt
Take off your bras
It's fun to flirt
And get applause

We're over-whored
And into nerds
And like it when you use big words

[bridge: x 4]
marke ting stra tegy
sex sells

[chorus]
On the lift now
It's more dangerous!
Want some coffee?
Gonna rape us!

I feel so small
Elevators!
Want some coffee?
Gonna rape us!

A rich white man
Doesn't get it

Ban his books now
There I said it

Yay! (Waah!) (Waah!)

[verse 2]
We curse at nuts
Like skeptics should
And show our butts
To give you wood

A little booze
Is always fun
And then a lot
Until we're done

[bridge][chorus][guitar solo by PZ "Pharyngula" Myers]

And we forget
How we got here
All covered in sweat
And puked-up beer

We found it hard
Bordello-wise
Our feather's tarred
Let's feminize

[bridge][chorus]

Selfish Genial! Selfish Genial! Selfish Genial...

:g1:
 
The Skepchicks are renowned for their ability to laugh at themselves, right? Wrong? Oh well, after seeing their promotional video, and until they do just a wee bit more to repudiate it maybe and the atmosphere of sexual objectification it likely contributed to now that they've decided they no longer like being sexually objectified, there's this: offered in a spirit of deepest empathy, to reflect the contradictions they must be struggling with in their transformation from party girls to arch-feminists, a lyric set to a grunge tune about struggling with contradictions from some years back (in no way intended to minimize anyone's feelings or experience or the issues swirling about them; knit strictly with material shorn from this thread; one day we'll all look back at this and laaa-ugghhh, surely; so why not today? - heh - gulp):

"Smells Like Teen Skepchick"

[verse 1]
Hike up your skirt
Take off your bras
It's fun to flirt
And get applause

We're over-whored
And into nerds
And like it when you use big words

[bridge: x 4]
marke ting stra tegy
sex sells

[chorus]
On the lift now
It's more dangerous!
Want some coffee?
Gonna rape us!

I feel so small
Elevators!
Want some coffee?
Gonna rape us!

A rich white man
Doesn't get it

Ban his books now
There I said it

Yay! (Waah!) (Waah!)

[verse 2]
We curse at nuts
Like skeptics should
And show our butts
To give you wood

A little booze
Is always fun
And then a lot
Until we're done

[bridge][chorus][guitar solo by PZ "Pharyngula" Myers]

And we forget
How we got here
All covered in sweat
And puked-up beer

We found it hard
Bordello-wise
Our feather's tarred
Let's feminize

[bridge][chorus]

Selfish Genial! Selfish Genial! Selfish Genial...

:g1:

Coffee through the nose funny.
 
Two of those guys came up behind me or to the side of me. I had no chance to make any opinion of them before they started slobbering on me.

There has never been an example of someone accosting me without consent and getting away with it because I found them attractive. Doing something like that makes them unattractive. The nicest thing I might have thought after calming down was "It's really too bad he's an ass."

Sure, but this is a skeptic group, so let's get some population counting right.

If I say that most Nobel Laureates enjoy eating mashed potatoes, it says very little about the population of mashed-potato-enjoyers, unless you invoke Bayes' theorem.

Maybe you've got magic body-language reading skills.

There's no magic about it. I was extremely shy, so I spent a long portion of my life learning about such things. I'm not stupid, so I did it fairly well. Furthermore, anatomically modern humans have been mating far longer than language has even existed.

Maybe the women you accosted didn't want to say anything because they didn't want to seem like a bitch.

Since they tended to grind against me and occasionally went home with me later, I think that probably isn't it.

Of course, you can make up stories if you like, but if you do, then I'm going to have to point out that you are stereotyping men and women, saying that they all behave in the same way all the time, and it's the way you think.

But do you really think that "Go ahead! Kiss strangers with no other introduction! They like it!" is generally good advice? You're telling people that it's OK to assault their fellow human beings which is, btw, illegal.

Nope, and I never said that. I never even came within a parsec. I hardly ever tell people what they should do unless 1) it's directly related to reason, which is the basis of this forum (or at least is not specifically disallowed), or 2) they ask me.

My point is, I think, clear. There was a comment about reading body language. If you accept that there are people who are poor at body language, then it makes sense that there are people who are good at reading body language. I pointed out that men who are good at reading body language are considered dogs.

@sgtbaker questioned that, and it was a fair question.

You have demonstrated it for me. You haven't used the word "dog," but you assume that because I know how to read body language well enough, I must be doing something bad. Either they didn't want to say anything, or I'm advocating illegal behavior, or something bad. It does not seem to be possible for you to think that the women I kissed wanted to be kissed, and so I did it, and a good time was had. I have to be bad in some way.

Which is pretty much my point. Statements about reading body language are nugatory, because it doesn't matter if a man is good or bad at reading body language, he must be something bad either way.

And all this is based on a model of what women do. You behave and interact and react in a certain way. However, there are women who don't behave and interact and react in the same way. So when you tell other people that it's a bad idea to assume that every women is the same, there is great irony.
 
How very odd. I've had strange men grab me and kiss me. As a swift knee to the nuts is not actually easy under such circumstances, they got the sharp heel to the top of the foot. And some yelling about what the f was wrong with them and, on one notable occasion, chased into the street with a cricket bat.

Oh and then there was this one time I was trying to get a very inebriated girl to the bathroom and some random guy blocked our path until we kissed him on the cheek. "C'mon, just a little one, right there." and got a shirtful of vomit. That was actually pretty awesome.

It seems like a negative to me, but maybe that's what they were going for?

Where are you at? And what are you doing? You're in a club right?. .

Sidenote. If your looking for a normal relationship in a pub, club, rave, and or party stop it. Look elsewhere.
 
The Skepchicks are renowned for their ability to laugh at themselves, right? Wrong? Oh well, after seeing their promotional video, and until they do just a wee bit more to repudiate it maybe and the atmosphere of sexual objectification it likely contributed to now that they've decided they no longer like being sexually objectified, there's this: offered in a spirit of deepest empathy, to reflect the contradictions they must be struggling with in their transformation from party girls to arch-feminists, a lyric set to a grunge tune about struggling with contradictions from some years back (in no way intended to minimize anyone's feelings or experience or the issues swirling about them; knit strictly with material shorn from this thread; one day we'll all look back at this and laaa-ugghhh, surely; so why not today? - heh - gulp):

"Smells Like Teen Skepchick"

[verse 1]
Hike up your skirt
Take off your bras
It's fun to flirt
And get applause

We're over-whored
And into nerds
And like it when you use big words

[bridge: x 4]
marke ting stra tegy
sex sells

[chorus]
On the lift now
It's more dangerous!
Want some coffee?
Gonna rape us!

I feel so small
Elevators!
Want some coffee?
Gonna rape us!

A rich white man
Doesn't get it

Ban his books now
There I said it

Yay! (Waah!) (Waah!)

[verse 2]
We curse at nuts
Like skeptics should
And show our butts
To give you wood

A little booze
Is always fun
And then a lot
Until we're done

[bridge][chorus][guitar solo by PZ "Pharyngula" Myers]

And we forget
How we got here
All covered in sweat
And puked-up beer

We found it hard
Bordello-wise
Our feather's tarred
Let's feminize

[bridge][chorus]

Selfish Genial! Selfish Genial! Selfish Genial...

:g1:

You are a bad, bad man and this bad, bad song is so nominated. :D
 
Where are you at? And what are you doing? You're in a club right?. .

Sidenote. If your looking for a normal relationship in a pub, club, rave, and or party stop it. Look elsewhere.

Bartender for a lot of it. But once at an abortion rally because I "looked sad." (Although, to be fair, that guy was sort of a terminal skeazebag.)
 
Of course he's a bad man. And it's a bad song. That's why it's okay. If it was a creepy man and a creepy song it would be bad right?

The smilie sez "Hey I'm being flip here!"

I'm just not feeling all sooper-serious and pedantic. Sue me.
 
The smilie sez "Hey I'm being flip here!"

I'm just not feeling all sooper-serious and pedantic. Sue me.

Not gonna sue you. Just thought this was a serious subject. Good to know it's not.

ETA: Q. If February is Black History Month and March is Women's History
Month, what happens the rest of the year?

A. Discrimination.
 
Last edited:
...

(ETA: DJ mentions that this was drafted a couple of months ago--I wonder what drove that?)
It's pretty generic. Could be there was a complaint or two over the years which warranted a comment. Perhaps it was just moved to a more prominent place.
 
There are people, in this very thread, who think that propositioning a woman without any other introduction is a time honored tradition that more often leads to sexual satisfaction for both, then dismay or embarrassment to either.

There's a guy, in this thread, just a small ways up saying that it's OK to hug and kiss total strangers if you are good enough at reading their body language.

There are people who didn't think that any woman has any reason to feel uncomfortable in any elevator, ever. Do you think that being in any small enclosed space with someone who is backing away will change their mind?

Oh and then there's Buzzo who has adopted "Hitting on someone isn't rape!" as his rallying cry for TAM 9. In the past people have asked that he be barred for his behavior. Now he's got internet-rage logic on his side.
There are a number of absolutes in your post that are made of straw.
 
So recently I was assaulted by coworker. I have told this person several times not to touch me but he cotinued to do so. He finally pushes me to far when he pushed me while I was going down the stairs. I turned and threw him across the foyer and told him. This is the important part.This is the important part.

"You *********** touch me again I will *********** kill you"

No problems since then.
 
....I don't think that there would be equally large numbers of women at Western comic book conventions geeking out over X-Men and Batman and whatnot if it was not for cultural prejudice specifically against women reading comics. I suspect that for much broader and deeper reasons, which could equally well be biological or cultural, women are less likely to want to geek out over that subject matter......
Just speaking from my own perspective, most of these cartoons bore me immensely. I'm pretty sure it isn't due to any cultural prejudice given that isn't one of the strongest motivators in my life.
 
There are a number of absolutes in your post that are made of straw.

Those are attitudes, not absolutes. Some of those attitudes may have led to an environment that resulted in a formal request to refrain from molesting, harassing, folding and/or spindling your fellow attendees.

But hey, we know all ready, you likee the sex and you aren't terrible particular and there is no way for you to ever feel uncomfortable with a fellow human evar. That's great, the world needs more hippies. Have at!
 
Not gonna sue you. Just thought this was a serious subject. Good to know it's not.

ETA: Q. If February is Black History Month and March is Women's History
Month, what happens the rest of the year?

A. Discrimination.

Oh, so now I'm the authority and if I chill out the entire subject is no longer serious. Such. Awesome. Power!
 
I'm not trying to broaden your claim. But you do seem to be unable to see things from my perspective. I wouldn't fear a hotel elevator at 4 am, especially if I had just left the hotel bar where I was having a conversation with a group of people. If I was comfortable in that bar, chances are I'd feel comfortable in the rest of the hotel.

And 5500 posts ago I pointed out that this is fine. It isn't my interest to make you afraid. If you don't care, great, but that doesn't mean the apprehension that other women feel in those situations is irrational or should be ignored.

I get it you disagree. That's fine. But I would like you to recognize that your perception that women should fear a guy in an elevator at 4 am given the relevant scenario says to me you think women are more vulnerable than I think they are. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of hotel elevators in foreign countries and it is not something to fear. TraneWreck is wrong.

It's not just about disagreement, you cannot, for the life of you, accurately represent my position when you complain about it. At no point have I said women should fear elevators.

I said a woman's perspective of a specific situation in which the elevator environment (confined, no exit) played a central role, was a legitimate perspective.

You have to eliminate all relevant evidence to this situation and generalize my claim to ALL elevators in the world and ALL women. For the thousandth time, that's not my argument. If you were disagreeing with me and accurately representing my view, I wouldn't care, but this is just silliness. You throw out these insulting little comments like, "You think all women are weak." I know you can do better than this, I've seen you do better.

You may be trying to soft-pedal your initial comment, or even emphasize the isolated encounter over the scary hotel elevators. But the bottom line remains, you have a perception of how dangerous the world is for women that I'm telling you is inconsistent with my experience. You aren't the only one with your perception. Lots of women think the world is scarier than it is as well.

Inconsistent with YOUR experience, not inconsistent with a sizeable percentage of women.

Recall that this is all about a woman's perspective. I'm offering statistical fact to support the reasonability of Rebecca Watson's apprehension in that elevator. I know it sucks, but it's really the case that 1 in 6 American women will be sexually assaulted in their lifetime, and that number is likely low because of under-reporting.

Why are you holding me responsible for the facts of the world? If you haven't experienced any of that, awesome, but generalizing from one's own experience is not a proper method of reasoning, especially for a skeptic.

As a matter of fact, lots of people view the world as a much scarier place than it actually is. The news tells us about rapes and murders and we get the idea these things are common when they are actually rare. I've been to the city and I've seen the elephants, and nothing bad happened. A woman traveling alone in foreign countries is for the most part just as safe as a woman traveling alone in their own country.

And what does that have to do with anything? This is you generalizing the argument again. It mysitifies me that you are completely unaware of doing this.

Rebecca wasn't "just traveling" in a foreign country, recall that she was clear that 99% of her time in Dublin was wonderful. She was confronted by a specific situation, reasonable emotions in that circumstance are not necessarily reasonable emotions for "just traveling." You continually ignore the pertenant facts and generalize the argument. It just happened, read that paragraph of yours again if you don't believe me.

We just disagree about how vulnerable women should feel.

Seriously, how many times do I have to explain this?

Let me use this example again, because it doesn't involve women:

Native Americans were famously used to construct sky-scrapers because some percentage of them were not afraid of heights, and could work in exposed areas without safety gear. If I were working on those buildings, I would be completely terrified and I'd need safety gear.

My fear and the request for safety gear are both perfectly reasonable. It's a legitimately dangerous activity, I could easily fall. Additionally, the fact that I experience fear in THAT situation, doesn't mean I'm a weakling scared of my shadow in all other aspects of life.

Though there is a real danger, the Native Americans are under no obligation to feel the same fear I do.

So let's go through this slowly: IN THE SAME WAY, women, like you, are not wrong for feeling no apprehension in similar circumstances. You don't have to be afraid. Again, I am not saying you, or any woman, SHOULD be afraid.

Nevertheless, like me on a skyscraper, a woman who does feel fear is being perfectly reasonable.

These two situations are perfectly compatable. You can experience no fear and that's perfectly legitimate, and Rebecca Watson can be uncomfortable, and that's perfectly legitimate.

I don't know how to be any clearer than that. I am NOT SAYING women should be afraid in elevators.

Of course there are specific scenarios anyone is right to feel nervous about. But you keep insisting a hotel elevator at 4 am is one of those scenarios and it isn't. Could it be? Sure. As could a particular encounter with a scary guy. But you said dangerous was the default position. I don't agree.

Where did I say that? I'm betting you've eliminated some valuable context.

Rebecca Watson, not me, felt afraid in that elevator. I've simply pointed out that this apprehension was not irrational. It was legitimate. I don't know why you're so intent on dismissing the perspective of women. Seems sexist to me.
 
My impression is that women are generally not very interested in getting their hands oily while working the innards of motorized vehicles. Just like most men don't want to be hair dressers. I don't see a problem with different genders having different interests.

But that's not quite the argument. Do women not want to get their hands oily because of genetics or because of the society we've constructed.

I grew up near a military base. There are a lot of women that would laugh at the description you provided. They were given the opportunity to join the army (even as people said, "my impression is that women just don't want to wear gear and get all dirty and live in tents."), and now they repair tanks, fly plains, inspect missiles...they do absolutely everything men do, and a lot of them enjoy it.

Sometimes they even, gasp, get their hands oily.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom