The Bible Is Like A Turd Filled BLT Sandwich

Leumas

Banned
Joined
Jul 8, 2011
Messages
8,588
You have an apparently appetizing Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato sandwich in your hand and are about to munch on it.

Unfortunately as you bring it up to your mouth……. it smells WRONG.

On closer inspection you find that there is between the layers of appetizing ingredients some TURD….smelly disgusting wet turd.

Also intermingled in the layers there are a few human toes and a few shards of glass.

The question now becomes???????? Do you pick away all the TURD, TOES and GLASS and close the sandwich back up and proceed to munch on the remaining scrumptious ingredients?

Some may imagine a situation where a miserable, degraded, lowly, pathetic, deprived person would actually proceed to eat the sandwich.

But what would you call a person who is offered a clean sandwich but chooses to continue eating the polluted atrocity instead and rejects the new uncontaminated one?

The Bible is full of turd…..scientific and moral turd.

The Bible is full of severed toes….. the toes of the millions of people who were tortured and extirpated through the centuries who called attention to the turd in the Bible…… The toes of the genocided races and violated little virgins in the name of YHWH.

The Bible is full of shards of glass…. the sprinkled contradictions and assertions that can be used by vile imposters to justify their actions that have shredded lives and futures of entire populations and have kept any people they controlled as miserable serfs under the yoke of crowned robbers and holy beggars.


A person who thinks that the Bible is validated because it has some truths is electing to eat a turd sandwich…..

Mentioning names of real kings and cities along with maxims that have been established by humanity from its inception does not make a fable a true fact.

Harry Potter does not exist and even if he did he is not a wizard just because the book of his Chronicles mentions London and outlines how nice he was.

Imagine a person arguing that we have located London and we even have proven the existence of Charring Cross station with platforms 8 and 9. We have not YET located platform 8.5 but that does not mean it does not exist.

It is just a matter of time….or perhaps some people removed it to build platform 10.... Or maybe someone will forge it one day and continue to point to the discovery even after it is proven to be a forgery.

But in any case….lack of evidence is not evidence of lacking….. and let’s give the story the benefit of the doubt due to FAITH in Harry Potter….wasn’t it such a lovely elevating story.

Why do you want to tear down? What do you offer in its place? Is it not better to have the richness of faith in Harry Potter than to just have nothing???

Is it not better to eat a turd filled BLT sandwich than not eat one at all?

If one is willing to eat his culture's turd sandwich, why is he not willing to eat a turd sandwich from other cultures? or at least let them eat theirs in peace?
 
It's platform 9 and three-quarters at King's Cross Station, not 8.5 at Charing Cross. Hope that helps.

Can I respectfully suggest you do a bit of reading around this forum; the analogy between the Bible and Harry Potter is not new here.
 
It's platform 9 and three-quarters at King's Cross Station, not 8.5 at Charing Cross. Hope that helps.

It depends on which version of the Harry Potter books you have been reading.

Also have you read it in its original language? You see in the time of Harry, 9 and 3/4 may have actually meant 8.5 if you only understood the cultural background of wizards instead of your limited mugul (spelling??) one.

Also we only discovered Charring Cross not King’s Cross....but the reference in the books in fact meant to be Charring Cross....it was a scribal error.

In earlier manuscripts of the books (discovered recently ) it was C[…] Cross. […] means missing script…. But C in old wizardly parlance could also be a K and so it might still be King’s Cross and we shall preserve this right to change it back if we ever discover King’s Cross one day.


Can I respectfully suggest you do a bit of reading around this forum; the analogy between the Bible and Harry Potter is not new here.

The thrust of the post is the turd sandwich not the harry potter analogy which is used as a secondary (albeit poignant) argument.
 
I sure hope you feel better for getting that off your chest Leumas lest what arguably ranks as the most desperately absurd and ill-crafted analogy goes to waste! :rolleyes:
 
Nothing to see in here but turds eating turd sandwiches.
Open wide
:jaw-dropp
 
The question now becomes???????? Do you pick away all the TURD, TOES and GLASS and close the sandwich back up and proceed to munch on the remaining scrumptious ingredients?


Well that's life innit?

But maybe I'm missing something. Perhaps you can present some examples of all the turd-, toe-, and glass-free sandwiches life offers?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Nominated the OP for TLA--it was amusing.

I've never seen the Harry Potter analogy but it really wouldn't bother me if I had. It's the nature of a discussion forum for repeating topics that have already been discussed. "Nothing new under the sun" and all that. ;)

I don't think life offers turd-free sandwiches but it's not a life analogy--it's a theology analogy. A perfect God would make a turd-free sandwich. To throw out the turd while still asserting the sandwich chef is perfect is illogical...cognitive dissonance.
 
Well that's life innit?

But maybe I'm missing something. Perhaps you can present some examples of all the turd-, toe-, and glass-free sandwiches life offers?

Respectfully,
Myriad


Well, I think it's an apt analogy regarding how some (most?) who follow the bible take from it only the parts they like, and discard the rest. Which is a funny way to treat the holy words of one's Omni-god, isn't it? Rather as if one thinks a god won't mind one ignoring some of the things he said, deciding for oneself which things god meant, and which he really didn't.

I don't think it was meant to be an analogy for all of life. I could be wrong.
 
I have heard the trick with a turd sandwich is this: The more bread you have, the less turd you have to eat.
 
While I understand the anger and frustration behind the OP, and somewhat agree with the sentiments expressed therein*, I am happy to say that the OP is not one that I could have written*.

* I was only able to read the OP, quickly, once. It hurt. That the bible is a nasty piece of work, I agree. The notion of a turd sandwich was distractingly unappealing, however. I totally missed any Harry Potter reference (I really enjoy the Harry Potter series). The OP poster will have an 'interesting' sojourn in the forums.
 
I prefer the Potter analogy over the, ahem, sandwich analogy. The latter was so unpleasant to read I skipped ahead to the more amusing, and equally pointed, Potter stuff.
 
It's platform 9 and three-quarters at King's Cross Station, not 8.5 at Charing Cross. Hope that helps.

Can I respectfully suggest you do a bit of reading around this forum; the analogy between the Bible and Harry Potter is not new here.

But Harry Potter is more fun!:D
 
The Bible is a compendium of legendary and real (if skewed) history, political / religious propaganda, poetry, fiction, aphorisms etc. Yes, its "science" is what you would expect from an Iron Age culture. Thus, the Bible shouldn't be used as a science text. It is from a culture far different from our own, one that, for example, condoned slavery. Thus, one must winnow it to try to find anything morally applicable to today's culture.

That said, Leumas, I think your real quarrel isn't with the Bible, but rather, those who use it as a basis for an abusive agenda. While this may seem like prying, can you tell us if your resentment of the Bible comes from personal experience, such as a fundamentalist upbringing?
 
You have an apparently appetizing Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato sandwich in your hand and are about to munch on it.

Unfortunately as you bring it up to your mouth……. it smells WRONG.

On closer inspection you find that there is between the layers of appetizing ingredients some TURD….smelly disgusting wet turd.

Also intermingled in the layers there are a few human toes and a few shards of glass.

The question now becomes???????? Do you pick away all the TURD, TOES and GLASS and close the sandwich back up and proceed to munch on the remaining scrumptious ingredients?

Some may imagine a situation where a miserable, degraded, lowly, pathetic, deprived person would actually proceed to eat the sandwich.

But what would you call a person who is offered a clean sandwich but chooses to continue eating the polluted atrocity instead and rejects the new uncontaminated one?

The Bible is full of turd…..scientific and moral turd.

The Bible is full of severed toes….. the toes of the millions of people who were tortured and extirpated through the centuries who called attention to the turd in the Bible…… The toes of the genocided races and violated little virgins in the name of YHWH.

The Bible is full of shards of glass…. the sprinkled contradictions and assertions that can be used by vile imposters to justify their actions that have shredded lives and futures of entire populations and have kept any people they controlled as miserable serfs under the yoke of crowned robbers and holy beggars.


A person who thinks that the Bible is validated because it has some truths is electing to eat a turd sandwich…..

Mentioning names of real kings and cities along with maxims that have been established by humanity from its inception does not make a fable a true fact.

Harry Potter does not exist and even if he did he is not a wizard just because the book of his Chronicles mentions London and outlines how nice he was.

Imagine a person arguing that we have located London and we even have proven the existence of Charring Cross station with platforms 8 and 9. We have not YET located platform 8.5 but that does not mean it does not exist.

It is just a matter of time….or perhaps some people removed it to build platform 10.... Or maybe someone will forge it one day and continue to point to the discovery even after it is proven to be a forgery.

But in any case….lack of evidence is not evidence of lacking….. and let’s give the story the benefit of the doubt due to FAITH in Harry Potter….wasn’t it such a lovely elevating story.

Why do you want to tear down? What do you offer in its place? Is it not better to have the richness of faith in Harry Potter than to just have nothing???

Is it not better to eat a turd filled BLT sandwich than not eat one at all?

If one is willing to eat his culture's turd sandwich, why is he not willing to eat a turd sandwich from other cultures? or at least let them eat theirs in peace?

This could have been a 6/10 , really it could of, but what kept it at a solid 3/10 was the misuse of the word turd.

For **** sake people, turd is the singular, as in " Oh darn, i stepped on a turd." when talking of multiple pieces of feces or multiple collequial uses of the word Turds is the appropriate word. As in " Oh my god this party is full of turds." or " There was a back up of turds in the sewer main."

A re write would bring it up to readable.
 
This could have been a 6/10 , really it could of, but what kept it at a solid 3/10 was the misuse of the word turd.

For **** sake people, turd is the singular, as in " Oh darn, i stepped on a turd." when talking of multiple pieces of feces or multiple collequial uses of the word Turds is the appropriate word. As in " Oh my god this party is full of turds." or " There was a back up of turds in the sewer main."

A re write would bring it up to readable.


Well, I was thinking that he could get writing lessons for his 13th birthday.
 
Well, I think it's an apt analogy regarding how some (most?) who follow the bible take from it only the parts they like, and discard the rest.


The bacon comes from pigs that were horribly mistreated, living their lives in small stinking pens, before being slaughtered. It's full of cholesterol, nitrites, and salt. Growing the lettuce required fertilizer and pesticides (or else, it is likely full of insect parts), and costly shipping and storage, and it has little nutritional value. The tomatoes were picked by exploited migrant farm workers. Does that mean one shouldn't enjoy a nice BLT? Not at all, but there's plenty of metaphorical crap you have to pick out of it (or at least, overlook) to gain that enjoyment.

My point isn't that a turd-contaminated sandwich is not an apt analogy for how many Christians use the Bible, my point is that it is an apt analogy for just about everything in the world. (There's some oft-cited "somebody's law", I forget who the somebody is, that 80% or 90% of everything is crap.) But since it applies that generally, how apt an analogy is it really?

Which is a funny way to treat the holy words of one's Omni-god, isn't it?


Maybe. But the Bible has to exist in the world. Bibles are words written down by humans in human languages, rendered in ink on paper and copied by humans or by printing presses. They're not written in secret holy runes scribed by starlight on sheets of crystallized angel song. So, I'm not surprised they have common characteristics with everything else that exists in the world. (And yeah, many Christians venerate the literal words, and often even the manufactured objects, to excess. I regard that as a form of idolatry -- as does the Roman Catholic church, so that in and of itself hardly makes me a radical Christian.)

Rather as if one thinks a god won't mind one ignoring some of the things he said, deciding for oneself which things god meant, and which he really didn't.


I have no way of knowing for sure if God minds or not, or of doing anything about it if He does. The ancestral lineage of the churches in which I received my Christian education have not promoted Bible literalism for millennia, if ever, and currently emphasizes personal moral revelation over any scriptural or religious authority, so it seems I'd be in a lot of company in the deep doo-doo if all that turned out to be wrong in the eyes of God. On the other hand, it means I don't support slavery, oppression of women, holy war, bronze age tribal justice, or anything else just because the Bible includes words to that effect. What's odd is that there seem to be so many people preferring that I did.

Back to the original metaphor: are you saying that I should be eating the whole sandwich turds and all? No thanks. Or that I shouldn't have to pick out the turds? Well, I do, they're in there and wishing won't make them go away. But I wouldn't have to if I found myself a turd-free sandwich instead? Okay, sure, but unfortunately no such thing appears to exist.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom