So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let me understand you properly: Are you saying that you are in support of these restrictions at the workplace and conventions like TAM and nowhere else?

I'm in support of these guidelines being imposed at the workplace, and additionally I don't see anything wrong with any event organizer setting such guidelines in order to maintain a chosen atmosphere at their event if they wish.

If your motivation for attending TAM is to get some sex, I can see how this rule would make things inconvenient. The rule against "disparaging based on race, disability, sexual orientation" and the like, is similarly inconvenient for those who intended to go to TAM in order to exercise their Constitutional right to make fun of gay people. But TAM is a voluntary event; nobody is forced to attend to the exclusion of going somewhere else where making unwelcome sexual advances or making fun of gay people aren't against the "rules".

If worse comes to worst and you go to TAM without sex on your mind at all, but by the second day suddenly you just got an itch that you're jonesing to scratch...dude, you're in Vegas. Walk outside; you'll find countless numbers of fellows offering any number of cards with numbers and addresses of strangers who are guaranteed to not be offended by your sexual advances.

Or are you suggesting that these restrictions should obtain elsewhere? Say, perhaps, if I go to Vegas on my own, hear some people talking in a bar, follow one woman from the bar to an elevator, and then proposition her. Is that okay if I'm not a TAM attendee?

It doesn't violate any rules that you agreed to follow by "attending" anything, no. You should however be prepared for the possibility that you might end up an example in someone's blog.
 
That's funny, I was thinking the same thing about a three week debate sparked by a single woman who said, "Don't do that...it makes me uncomfortable."

Well quite. I'm not sure if you are agreeing with me or disagreeing with me but the three week debate was what I was referring to.

Of course at any point the single woman could have come back and posted 'look guys this is getting out of hand. I was just giving an offhand example of something that makes me a bit uncomfortable. No need for all the drama'.

But an invitation to make a comment (in general) isn't necessarily sexual. And so the following comment could then be both sexual, and invited.

This is when it's very important to have a wingman. Their role is to invite you to make a comment, at which point you're free to make a sexual comment to whomever you like.

Also, at the end of lectures/talks it's often the case that the attendees are invited to ask questions/make comments. This the opportunity for the entire audience to congratulate the hotel receptionist on her bazoombas.

When I read your first line I was already to argue and then you went and spoiled it by being amusing. Bad form:P
 
No. Objectifying is not caring about a person's feelings. Casual sex could be, in fact, taking them into account.

Could be but not always. Are we now going to suggest that EG might have had rose petals sprinkled on the bed?
 
Well quite. I'm not sure if you are agreeing with me or disagreeing with me but the three week debate was what I was referring to.

Of course at any point the single woman could have come back and posted 'look guys this is getting out of hand. I was just giving an offhand example of something that makes me a bit uncomfortable. No need for all the drama'.

While I certainly agree that people ran with this one, I also find it odd that you could come to conclusions about her "real" motives in her reaction, and then show how funny it is that 4 million other blogs can pick up something and run with it, mold it to fit their reality.

She comes across to me as a bit self-obsessed and attention seeking.

Her follow ups to me suggest that her main emotion here was not fear, or being creeped out but rather annoyance that 1) someone had the temerity to not treat her in the way she wanted to be treated and 2) that others would question her right to throw a minor hissy fit in response to 1.

She also could have responded the way you suggested but to be fair, other people could have just responed, "I may not have felt threatened but I wasn't there..."
 
Isolated? It was a 5 star hotel with dozens if not hundreds of rooms!

This is why discussion is worthless. We have a group of people pathologically unable to deal with the actual facts of the situation.

How was this man supposed to get an unwilling woman from the elevator to his room without the risk of her screaming her head off and waking lots of people?

Probably by staying in the elevator. Or with threats, "scream and I'll stab you." Or simply by doing it and getting lucky: no one wakes up, no one cares.

Who knows? It's worth pointing out that by the time some intervening savior--someone in another room, a security guard hearing the screems...etc.--makes an appearance, some harm has necessarily been caused. It should be fairly obvious that placing someone in the position of minimizing damage is already way too far.

As a pick-up technique it was poor; as a strategy to commit rape it was abysmal.

We could get into the actually studies on rapist behavior and deal with the approach in some detail, but subtlety is clearly not welcome in this setting, so what's the point? Recall that no one has accused EG of being a rapist, just that his behavior was concerning. It was concerning because it matched, quite closely, many of the common behavioral elements that rapists engage in (yes, that was contained in a link already).


http://www.911rape.org/campus-rape/what-students-need-to-know/stranger-rape-vs-acquaintance-rape

Seems like a better strategy would have been to gain her confidence and lower her defences by chatting to her in the bar and then suggested a private meeting later on.

Let's try to work our way through some elementary reasoning on this.

What is the driving factor behid acquaintance rape outnumbering stranger rape? Is it the fact that once you get to know someone, the urge to rape grows? Is it because rapists don't want people to think they're sluts?

Or is it an issue of opportunity? If two people are acquainted, they are likely to find themselves alone. The victim (be it man or woman) will be more likely to voluntarily let their guard down and make themselves vulnerable.

NOtice the situation in the elevator: that opportunity is present. Acquanitance rape tends to be numerically superior for the exact same reason most auto accidents occur close to one's home--there is simply more opportunity for an incident to occur.

Thus, if that opportunity is supplied, the calculation becomes quite different. Perhaps someone has done a statistical analysis of stranger vs. acquaintance rape holding the variable of opportunity constant, but I haven't seen it. It would be interesting.
 
Last edited:
That's funny, I was thinking the same thing about a three week debate sparked by a single woman who said, "Don't do that...it makes me uncomfortable." Sounds rather reasonable not much like a hissy fit. Ironic, though, isn't it?

It doesn't, and many people have said as much. One of the more annoying problems in all this has been the 'excluded middle' going around. It comes from people supporting Dawkins lumping in his critics in with rabid Rebecca supports and Rebecca supports lumping all her critics in with those throwing rape accusations, or defending EG. It's annoying to see people repeat points about how something is defending elevator guy, or not defending him well, when defending him or his actions was never the point they were making.

What's worse is that many ideas have been conflated and lumped together. Rebecca has be criticized for what she did and said about Rose St.Clair, Steff McGraw, and Paula Kirby. These for some reason are called misogyny and sexism, and combined with rape threats. Why?

Then there are the people who actually are arguing that Rebecca mentioning the elevator incident was an over reaction. I don't think it was, but I'm not about to call those people sexist because they believe it was. Now some of them undoubtedly are sexist, and are saying those things because of it. Some of the comments are insanely sexist and wrong. That these comments by trolls and idiots are held up as 'proof' that the 'other side' is sexist is a line of reasoning unbecoming of any skeptic. Some might argue that the 'other side' doesn't condemn them enough, but that could be because their reasoning is so insanely wrong that it doesn't really need to be called wrong. Just point at it and laugh. (Ladies, don't do this. :p)

There are a lot of people who are trying to have a realistic discussion and getting shouted down by Rebecca, by Dawkins, and by supporters of each. fls and bookitty are getting a lot more flack than either deserves for example.

All 'sides' have said some perfectly reasonable things that get objected to, straw manned, and then replied to with non-sequiters. It's staggering that so many people with opinions and stances so damn close together can fight so hard, and emotionally.
 
This whole thing has been surprisingly interesting. I've followed this thread, all of the links in it, and most of the links in those pages. I had briefly mentioned the mess to my wife earlier (mostly ended up being "Richard Dawkins was a dick AGAIN?") but we spent a lot more time talking about it yesterday. Our eventual conclusion was that being hit on was a lot like being called by a telemarketer: the answer is probably no, and many people find it more and more irritating as frequency increases. So... don't be elevator guy, please, especially with public figures.


A random pile of thoughts. At this point, after reading so many things, I can't remember who all claimed what. I worried about this for a while, and then decided I didn't care what RW or RD said. The discussion seems more interesting on the periphery where they're not directly involved.

- It's reasonable to be irritated after being hit on AGAIN. It may not seem fair that you're getting an unexpectedly harsh response, but it doesn't seem fair that you're person-to-reject #517 either...

- It's reasonable to just be uncomfortable/awkward being hit on at all

- There's a great video by Steven Pinker about language that's partially about sex vs "coffee" that was linked from a page linked from one of the pages Tyr linked to. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-son3EJTrU.

- It's perfectly legitimate to feel uncomfortable/threatened in the elevator situation, even though you could argue about how rational the discomfort is.

- EG sexualised RW: assuming it was "coffee", yes. Is this bad?

- EG's proposition was almost certainly doomed to failure, whether it truly was an invitation for coffee or not. Following a complete stranger from some public place to a hotel room isn't super bright, regardless of gender. Changing the invitation to be to an all-night coffee house would have been a better bet, even it was still almost certainly going to be turned down.

- EG objectified RW: no.

- EG was a misogynist: bloody ridiculous.

- Other people making critical comments about RW are misogynists: not any of the authors of things I read. It seems reasonable to call someone like Dave Sim a misogynist. Even disliking and critically commenting on some behaviour stereotypically associated with women is not, on its own, misogyny. I'm not sure anything even came this close...

- Saying RD couldn't understand the threat of sexual assault because he was a privileged white male was a giant face-palming pile of fail. "You just can't understand!" is a weak argument at the best of times, and this example is part of the reason why: you might just be totally wrong.

- RW is perfectly free to be tired of being hit on, and publicly let people know that she's not interested in an attempt to minimise it. It will be interesting, however, to see whether she up-sells her ideas with sex in the future... There is a clear distinction between talking about sex and "listen to me about this unrelated thing because I'm sexy."
 
One claim you haven't evaluated yet -- Watson was a bully in her attacks on McGraw in her keynote speech.
 
Could be but not always. Are we now going to suggest that EG might have had rose petals sprinkled on the bed?

I don't think I've ever asked for an object for permission to use it, and if it answered back, I wouldn't take no for an answer. :p

(This is my attempt to make fun of the term 'objectification'.)
 
I don't think I've ever asked for an object for permission to use it, and if it answered back, I wouldn't take no for an answer. :p

(This is my attempt to make fun of the term 'objectification'.)

I get that you are being playful but your description of objectifying sounds more like rape.
 
One claim you haven't evaluated yet -- Watson was a bully in her attacks on McGraw in her keynote speech.

Yeah, that's where I get off the Watson bandwagon. I think her stance on EG guy is correct, I even think a lot of what McGraw said was wrong, but why use your keynote speach to haraungue a student that can't reply?

I get the argument about being specific, but pick on your equals. Obviously Dawkins hadn't made his ill-advised statements at that point, but arguing with him would have been very appropriate, arguing with a YouTube video just isn't the sort of thing someone should have to pay money to watch.

Even so, that argument still could have been dealt with absent the singling out of someone lower on the food chain. EG was uncouth, but so, too, was that.
 
I get that you are being playful but your description of objectifying sounds more like rape.

Rape would be something someone treating a person like nothing better than an object would probably engage in. While some might argue that objectification is a spectrum, even on the light end of it it's hard to fit EGs actions with the term.

But in my head I was picturing someone arguing with their computer, asking it to turn on and accepting it when it said 'no'.
 
Rape would be something someone treating a person like nothing better than an object would probably engage in. While some might argue that objectification is a spectrum, even on the light end of it it's hard to fit EGs actions with the term.

But in my head I was picturing someone arguing with their computer, asking it to turn on and accepting it when it said 'no'.

You don't argue with your computer? :D
 
I get that you are being playful but your description of objectifying sounds more like rape.

Depends on what he was using the object to do, doesn't it?

If the object is being used for visual stimulation, it's leering (which in an office environment might be sexual harrassment).

If the object is being touched, it's groping (sexual assault).

If the object is being used for sex, it's rape.

Propositioning a woman is not, by itself, objectification -- it's the opposite, in that it's implicitly acknowledging her entity status and right/ability to accept or decline the interaction. Leering, or other behavior surrounding the proposition (such as catcalling and other forms of verbal assault), may be objectification. But the asking certainly isn't.
 
But her initial "complaint" was hardly a cry of rape and oppression. How can a calm "please don't do that" be considered an overreaction to anything?

Is there a point to cherry picking only the first video? RD's comments were not next in the sequence of events. Nothing happened until RW called out some video blogger by name at the CFI Student Leadership Conference. That's when the fan started flinging excrement.
You may recall that last week I [RW] posted this video, in which I describe an unpleasant encounter I had with a fellow atheist that I thought might serve as a good example of what men in our community should strive to avoid ... [snipped recap of the incident]

The night prior to my talk, I happened across a video rebuttal from a woman who I was told would be at the CFI conference. [there's a link to the video in this Skepchick blog post] I was pretty frustrated, seeing a young woman who I’m sure is intelligent be so incredibly dismissive of my experience and that of other women in this community, and so uneducated about the fundamentals of feminist thought. She ends the video by asking, “What effect do you think it has on men to be constantly told how sexist and destructive they are?”...

My response to her question at the time was that I never called all men sexist and destructive, nor did I do it constantly. In fact, in my video I specifically said that most of the conference attendees – men and women – were awesome. What I should have added is this: for the men (and women) who are behaving in sexist and destructive ways, I hope that pointing it out to them has the effect of making them consider their actions and stop being sexist and damaging.

Perhaps you were unaware this came before's posts in PZ's blog, Always Name Names, where the "Dear Muslima" post appeared.

Clearly RW didn't like the fact not all young women followed the feminist doctrine of RW.
 
Last edited:
I thought someone might have (some days I've just scanned down pages of this thread!), but the whole "foreign country - scary!" thing seemed to be coming up again, so I thought I'd chip in a reminder.
I only meant to say, hear hear, not to suggest anyone should torture themselves reading 48 (now 50) pages of this thread. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom