So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
It was RW, who upon hearing this different opinion to hers, went on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women, and being common enough among our community to be affecting the attendance of women at formal events.

I completely agree, this is where it started, and this is where I completely disagree with RW.
 
Man dismisses man's stated preference in favor of his own, without considering other man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering other woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses man's stated preference in favor of her own without considering man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Man dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Context, can't judge a scene without it! Pick some up today!*


*Side effects may include empathy, thinking in grays, seeing the whole picture, and in some rare cases, nausea and vomiting. Void where peremptory.

What do you mean? We have all the context we need. Elevator Guy and George Hrab, me and Rebecca Watson, me and George Hrab, Elevator Guy and Rebecca Watson - all in the original context. Substitute "I don't know how you roll..." for "don't take this the wrong way..." for the me and Rebecca Watson scenario.

Now, answer my question.

Linda
 
It is sexism because despite how far our culture has come in equality, there are those men who think women still need protecting and those women who think equality means not having to deal with unpleasant situations. It's mutually reinforcing and quite insidious.

That's a good point and it makes sense (makes sense as in "explains what we see", not as in "justifies what we see").

Linda
 
Hard to answer in this form, because as it is stated these are just four cases of various annoyances.

But woman or man discriminates against man based on his sex, consciously or unconsciously, or woman or man discriminates against woman based on her sex again consciously or unconsciously, that would be sexism.

The point in the elevator incident, as I understood it, is that RW feels that it illustrates one occasion were she and (in similar cases) other women are not respected as persons by male members of the skeptic community because they are women.

The peculiarities of this disrespect can vary. It could be as assumed in the elevator incident, that her stated intent to go sleeping, and her need for safety are inconsiderately ignored by someone who proposes to her in the way described, which is creepy to her, and to various commenters on her blog.

It could express itself like in the context-matters list, where Jen McCreight among other things is annoyed when she is complimented for her looks after a presentation, instead of for her lecture. ( I really can understand this. )

Or it could present itself more as a systemic occurence like PZ Myers describes it in his blog-entry about a panel at an American Atheists meeting in Huntsville, Alabama.

Annoyance is, I think, in all cases I dug out a result, not a cause of the problem, a symptom, not the illness, if it is one.

I don't understand how Rebecca was discriminated against. Can you elaborate on that?

Linda
 
You appear to be doing what Checkmite has been doing, viewing the first video in isolation to the rest of the initial part of this debate. The thing that initiated this debate included the initial video, the response by McGraf and and Stclairose in the blogosphere and RW's further discussion of the elevator incident in the Student Conference.

Were it simply RW's video and the couple blogosphere replies who disagreed with her take on the incident, it would have in all likelihood faded away at that point.

It was RW, who upon hearing this different opinion to hers, went on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women, and being common enough among our community to be affecting the attendance of women at formal events.

This.

Repeat as necessary.

Linda
 
I know you're like a kid with a new toy at Christmas with the bordello thread, but perhaps you could spare a moment from your gleeful victory dance to explain where the hypocrisy lies? It seems to me so far that your entire argument is:

1. Rebecca Watson has complained of sexism.
2. But one woman once accused Watson of sexism herself.
3. Therefore, Watson is a hypocrite.

By that logic, as long as I can find one person in this thread (or anyone else) who has accused you of sexism, you will never be able to complain of sexism again lest you be branded a hypocrite.
Once accused her? That's a distortion of Noblecaboose's well articulated concern:
Noblecaboose on the Skeptopia blog said:
I thought it was not an appropriate theme for a party at an event where women are already in the minority. By dictating the role of the women (i.e. prostitutes, i.e. sex objects) they basically reduced the women in attendance to their sexuality alone.
Isn't that exactly what RW is complaining about men doing?



You did get the glee with a shiny new toy right. ;)
 
Last edited:
That's one way to look at it, here's another.

Guy catches same elevator as woman. Knowing he will never have another chance to ask this woman out, because he will probably never see her again in his life, he asks himself, "what are the chances?"

If he doesn't ask - 0%

Asking and getting shot down - < 100%

Asking and having her say "yes" - > 0%

Clearly the only thing to do is ask.

And having had more than one woman sleep with me on the first date, I can understand why he did it.

What I don't understand is her bizarre reaction to something so mundane as being asked out. I think the woman has some issues.

So men have the right to ask women for sex at any time and place?
 
Which is odd, because I didn't say "you", but "people". I would've thought it was clear I wasn't talking about you specifically.

Some people said "she isn't speaking for all women". The bit you mentioned (low attendance because of 'this kind of situation') certainly does speak for a lot of women.
I apologize but I am still lost. Feel free to leave it at that. But if it matters to you, looking at your original post, the problem might be I can't tell what "that" refers to in "after that comment".

Nevermind, I think I get it upon seeing your next post.
 
Last edited:
...*Sigh*. The elevator incident, or more precisely the class of situations it represents, and the perceived threat of rape are linked somehow. RW though didn't equate them. On the contrary, she was quite clear that she doesn't consider chatting her up a rape attempt.

The hyperboles on this topic, look to me as if they are mainly from the detractor's side. Really, none of the feminists said 'All men who are interested in women are rapists'. And even the frequently attacked text about 'Schrödinger's Rapist' mainly points out that the rape statistics hint at rape being a very real possibility for women, that it is wiser for them to err on the side of caution when assessing male strangers, and that it would be nice if the guys could understand this.

I don't want to take position there on either side, because as far as I am concerned I never had any sexual contact I didn't at least implicitly agree to (Implicitly because of two instances were I either thought that being wined and dined establishes an obligation or where it was emotionally easier to sleep with the guy, than to become really rude in my decline. Juvenile foolishness in both cases and nothing that gave me any unsurmountable trouble). I could only relate to this second hand. But hey, I am a man, and for a few reasons we can discuss in another post, I think it is different for girls.

No, stop. I think it is different for many girls ( and possibly some dudes ). Skeptic Ginger for example apparently has no problems in this regard either, which is great. More power to her. I still don't think she represents a majority.
...Except for a woman apparently being creeped out and feeling extremely uncomfortable in this case. But hey, since when are people's feelings important, when we ask how we can interest them in participating in the skeptics community, or when a roll in the hay is at stake? :D

Oh yes, and there are at least two women on this board alone who wouldn't have been creeped out. Isn't this proof enough that those feminist complaints are without any rational base? :D
There are two ways to consider a rational basis for a fear. It is rational if the risk is real. If the risk is perceived but not real, that explains the basis for the fear, it makes it understandable, but if one defines rational thinking as evidence based then perceived risk is not always real risk. In fact, very often perceived risk and real risk are miles apart (in both directions). Perceived risk is explicable, but not always rational.

Given RW's example on its face, (excluding other cues from a man that might contribute to a threat assessment), is there evidence women are attacked in nice hotels in Dublin late at night on a frequent enough basis to warrant a woman fearing a man in the elevator with them under similar circumstances?

Is Dublin a particularly dangerous place for women alone at night? Is the danger widespread or only confined to certain neighborhoods like most cities? Are 4 and 5 star hotels particularly unsafe at night for women alone in Dublin?

Is "rational basis" dependent on the majority perception, or the evidence?



... The complaint is in my opinion not without merit and her calling him a 'wealthy old heterosexual white man' is flippant but not purely an insult. It serves, as I read it, to point out in what regards RD is privileged towards various other people.
My take was that rather than address RD's argument, RW dismissed it with an ad hom. "You aren't a women, you don't experience the prejudice women experience, you couldn't possibly understand" is a rather weak argument.

AND, he is a vastly more influential speaker than RW, and from this I can understand that his perceived casual dismissal hit her pretty hard. Richard Dawkins dismissing your problems as petty, is the social equivalent to the big mallet, and I am actually glad that the skeptics community is a disrespectful enough pack to call their alpha to task in such a case. The Privilege Delusion has a series of nice links in the first line, that are quite interesting, and they make a good case for RW having a point. As for 'talking about it 'most of the time': I didn't find anything demanding first priority for feminism in skeptical debate. I did find a lot demanding that it isn't ignored, which is a position I agree with.
How does this compare to RW's calling out McGraw and the community's response?
 
Once accused her? That's a distortion of Noblecaboose's well articulated concern.Isn't that exactly what RW is complaining about?

There's two big problems here.

First, Noblecaboose's concern was not "exactly what RW is complaining about," unless you extrapolate it to a very general level such as "sexism" or "discouraging women from attending skeptical conferences." There is a substantial difference between some people throwing a party that nobody is obligated to attend and propositioning someone directly in an elevator at 4 am.

Second, even assuming the first point, it's only hypocrisy if RW was guilty of whatever NC was accusing her of. The mere accusation is insufficient.

It's also worth pointing out that RW didn't (and couldn't) participate in that thread. (In fact, mr_ottle complained in that thread that it was "cowardly" for NC to raise that concern in the JREF forum rather than at the Skepchick site or by personal communication. I suppose if one is looking for parallels, we can call that the counterpart to RW's speech at the CFI conference.) So we don't know if RW simply dismissed NC's concerns with an attitude of "well, I'm not offended by the party's theme, so therefore it's ok."

The Skepchick representatives who did post there seemed to be defending it more along the lines of "we didn't intend and that way, and it's really not that kind of party -- the costume recommendations are pretty broad and don't expect women to strictly follow the "bordello" part of it. There were some "drive-by" comments to the effect of "lighten up, what's the problem" that I agree were too dismissive.

I thought -- and said at the time -- that NC brought up a concern that was worth discussing, and that the Skepchicks are (or at least, were at that time -- maybe they're changing) "guilty" of promoting a brand image (all that "hot drunk girls hit on nerdy guys" stuff) that some women legitimately find uncomfortable. I didn't and don't see how that amounts to sexism on the part of the Skepchicks -- I think all that it means is that (1) the Skepchicks maybe needed to rethink whether they really intended to project the image that others were perceiving; and (2) people shouldn't treat the Skepchicks as the One True Voice of Female Skeptics, as there's probably a need for other groups that don't rely on the "sexy" image.

But I don't think that corresponds very well to ElevatorGate. There's a big difference between saying "I don't like the way you dress/act/promote your organization because it reflects on other women," and saying "I don't like the way I was treated by [Elevator Guy, Stef McGraw, Richard Dawkins, etc.]"
 
I know you're like a kid with a new toy at Christmas with the bordello thread, but perhaps you could spare a moment from your gleeful victory dance to explain where the hypocrisy lies? ---

A general remark re the bordello thread: the reason I had linked to it earlier in the thread, before Skeptic Ginger's rediscovery and dance of glee, ;) was to point out what seemed to me hypocrisy in a Skepchick's comments about the OP of that thread, Noblecaboose:
You're assuming this [criticism of the Skepchicks' marketing strategy] is new. For some (such as Noblecaboose) it was a final straw.
This is the same Noblecaboose that posed semi-nude on the last Skepchick calendar?

The salient point in this exchange for me is now the leader of the Skepchicks (and the entire group? not sure their rules on orthodoxy and how strictly they're enforced) seems to have changed her outlook on the way her group was sexualizing itself (I think, though I'm not aware of any definitive statement on the matter -- maybe they're still fine with "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" as a slogan? -- in the wake of Elevator-gate, I would guess no), to have had a change of opinion similar to what Noblecaboose had. Obviously, the leader, Rebecca Watson, like Noblecaboose, has appeared semi-nude in Skepchick calendar(s). Parallel cases. Is she now then being held up to ridicule by Skepchick mr.ottle with remarks such as: "This is the same Rebecca Watson that posed semi-nude on the last Skepchick calendar?"

If she is, fine... well-done mr.ottle on being consistent with your ridicule of those who'd claim their outlooks have changed. If not, I would say mr.ottle owes Noblecaboose an apology, if he's honorable (and he strikes me as a decent enough guy from other posts, when his dander's not up), which he might want to post both here and over at her skeptical blog in case she doesn't read it, as she and her husband left the forum after this ridicule (not just from mr.ottle, it should be said; other Skepchick 'groupies', for lack of a better word, joined in), ridicule whose very echoes now ridicule the ridiculers (mercy -- may no one ever have to type that phrase again).

===
:viking1
 
Last edited:
You mean at the reasonably safe bar, where are all the socializing happens? With possibly other night owls and the bartender around?

Well, first you just acknowledged her feelings of being tired and her intention to go to bed by referencing them ( 'No ....stay' ). Her likely feelings of anxiety in the elevator don't apply at the bar, so you don't have to consider them there.

So, no you weren't inconsiderate of the feelings relevant to this situation in your example. You merely made a counterproposal, which she can safely decline, even if you should be secretly the big bad wolf, because the bartender would shoot you if you try to devour hotel guests.
.

Now you're in danger of mixing everything up and getting the same lack of clarity that RW did in her moan.

If its sexist and objectification then it doesn't matter where it happened or how threatened she felt or her levels of anxiety. Its STILL sexist and objectifying. Equally if it isn't then it still isn't.

If the issue is that she felt threatened then that's a different issue to whether she was sexualised or treated in a sexist way. Mixing up the different things is how we get from 'some guy in an elevator hit on me. Sheesh!' to 'You all think rape is great!'
 
So men people have the right to ask women people for sex anything at any time and place?

Yes, they have that right, at least in the USA subject to very few restrictions. It's called communication. The context determines if it's welcome or unwelcome, and that is an issue of manners.

Everyone keeps assuming EG was after sex, which is sexism itself:

"Don't take this the wrong way" apparently means "I want sex."

"I find you interesting" apparently means "I want sex."

"I would like to talk" means "I want sex."

"We could share some coffee" means "I want sex."

Why? Because it is a man speaking to a woman. The blatant sexism of assuming EG was after sex very much undermines feminism. It's certainly possible he was entirely insincere, and I would not blame any woman for considering the possibility. All she had to say is, "No, thank you," and be done with it. Had he persisted, that would be another matter entirely since we have moved from the realm of uncertain possibly ambiguous communication to very certain communication.

Will someone please tell me how someone who genuinely found RW interesting and wanted to gab for a while knowing full well the conference would soon be over would have said? In exchange, I'll tell you what I would have said had I wanted to get into her pants.

"You certainly seem to draw a crowd wherever you go. Bright and beautiful - what an intoxicating combination. I'm going to have a nightcap from the honor bar in my room before turning in. Care to join me?"

And once again, even if he had said that, a simple "No, thank you" is all that is required. No harm. No foul.
 
Yes, they have that right, at least in the USA subject to very few restrictions. It's called communication. The context determines if it's welcome or unwelcome, and that is an issue of manners.

Everyone keeps assuming EG was after sex, which is sexism itself:

"Don't take this the wrong way" apparently means "I want sex."

"I find you interesting" apparently means "I want sex."

"I would like to talk" means "I want sex."

"We could share some coffee" means "I want sex."

Why? Because it is a man speaking to a woman. The blatant sexism of assuming EG was after sex very much undermines feminism. It's certainly possible he was entirely insincere, and I would not blame any woman for considering the possibility. All she had to say is, "No, thank you," and be done with it. Had he persisted, that would be another matter entirely since we have moved from the realm of uncertain possibly ambiguous communication to very certain communication.

Will someone please tell me how someone who genuinely found RW interesting and wanted to gab for a while knowing full well the conference would soon be over would have said? In exchange, I'll tell you what I would have said had I wanted to get into her pants.

"You certainly seem to draw a crowd wherever you go. Bright and beautiful - what an intoxicating combination. I'm going to have a nightcap from the honor bar in my room before turning in. Care to join me?"

And once again, even if he had said that, a simple "No, thank you" is all that is required. No harm. No foul.


Do you want to have sex with me? No harm. No foul.
 
Last edited:
blauregen said:
I must have missed this gem. Care to give me a source?
I feel that was an extraordinarily unfair characterization of what she said. She said disagreeing about her statement is sexism.

It's on her Frequently Answered Questions, at http://skepchick.org/2011/07/frequently-answered-questions/

Here is the relevant part. This is Watson referring to another person's words and endorsing them:

EDIT: Commenter karenx just posted something that I failed to address, and she did it in a better way than I would have. So here it is as #11:

Hitting on stranger in an elevator–creepy

Criticizing (and vilifying) the woman who says not to creepily hit on strangers in elevator for having the nerve to suggest guys change their behavior–sexist

Now, lets's recap. The quote Watson endorses is "Criticizing (and vilifying) the woman."

To me, "the woman" is pretty obviously 1) a human being, 2) a woman, and 3) Rebecca Watson, for one.

If you are going to argue that it is unfair, let alone "extraordinarily" unfair to think that "the woman" means "the woman," then I think that it's going to be a rough slog for you to justify that conclusion using reason. I'd like to see it. You might be able to make an IMO rather weak statement with the "for saying" subclause. It would be rather weak, because that is just a presumption about why people criticize Watson's public persona. It may appeal to people who are not really interested in why Watson's public persona is being criticized, but it would amount to a straw man. The straw man might be appealing to some people who, from an ideological or political basis, have decided that Watson is only being criticized for a particular statement, ignoring all the other statements that she's made.

In any event, the criticism referred to is not about the statement. It's about the woman.

None of that is meant to address her broader points about sexism, just to point out that she wasn't saying disagreement with RW=sexism. It was disagreement with a specific position vis a vis women = sexism. Which may or may not be true depending on the statement.

Criticizing.
The.
Woman.

It's right up there. You can follow the link. You can look at the Google cache.
 
Last edited:
A general remark re the bordello thread: the reason I had linked to it earlier in the thread, before Skeptic Ginger's rediscovery and dance of glee, ;)
Darat gets the credit along with Linda for pointing it out to me. Sorry if I missed your earlier reference. :)
 
Last edited:
I don't know for sure, but most likely EG was an attendee at the conference wearing a badge at least at some point. It's a very nice hotel. The chances of someone being "sinister" (and foolish) enough to attack a person on an elevator is extremely slim.
And yet Greg Laden or Melissa McEwan seem to regard it as possible, so your assumption isn't exactlly undisputed.
Mostly by refering to things that have happened somewhere other than in Ireland, let alone Dublin specifically.
 
Time to pull some people back to the facts in this case. I went back to the beginning to reply to a post in my other related thread and some of what I wanted to remind people of belonged here and not in that thread. Some of this overlaps what I posted there. For those that were reading 50 pages back this was part of the discussion. There are probably people who have joined the thread late that don't know all the details.

Watson on naming names at the CFI conference
approaching a single woman in an elevator to invite her back to your hotel room is the definition of “unsolicited sexual comment.” But those are unimportant details in comparison to the first quoted sentence, which demonstrates an ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification. The former is great – be attracted to people! Flirt, have fun, make friends, have sex, meet the love of your life, whatever floats your boat. But the latter involves dismissing a person’s feelings, desires, and identity, with a complete disinterest in how one’s actions will affect the “object” in question.
A lot of what is being debated here is Watson's definition of an "unsolicited sexual comment". Clearly here she is specifically claiming EG was sexually objectifying her. I don't see how one interprets RW's comments any other way. And I, for one, don't agree with RW's assessment of the incident.

Watson on naming names at the CFI conference
I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another....
It's important to stop here and read Stef McGraf's supposed dismissive comment RW quoted and was referring to:
My concern is that she [RW] takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What’s wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let’s review, it’s not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she’d like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I’m assuming did say), “No thanks, I’m tired and would like to go to my room to sleep.”
This is "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny"?

No, that was someone disagreeing with RW's take that EG was sexualizing her with an unsolicited sexual comment indicative of sexual objectification and not sexual attraction.

For review, RW's initial video comment transcribed by Stef McGraw:
Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and--don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner...
EG's words according to RW were very benign.

RW makes her assessment based on the setting and whatever she has assumed EG must have heard her say earlier and must have understood that she meant. RW is certain she knows a lot about EG's motives and EGs underlying knowledge about RW. RW is calling McGraf's different take on EG, "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny".

It is an absurd ludicrous accusation. Clearly RW is not expressing any tolerance of those that don't see EG the way RW saw him.


The rest of McGraf's comments are here if anyone is interested. They don't say much more:
Watson is upset that this man is sexualizing her just after she gave a talk relating to feminism, but my question is this: Since when are respecting women as equals and showing sexual interest mutually exclusive? Is it not possible to view to take interest in a woman AND see her as an intelligent person?...

...If you really want social equality for women, which is what feminism is, why not apply the same standards to men and women, and stop demonizing men for being sexual beings?
 
Nice post, SG. I agree with Stef's point of view, by the way.

It's important to stop here and read Stef McGraf's supposed dismissive comment RW quoted and was referring to:This is "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny"?

Whoa, whoa, hold your horses there! That must be a straw man person!

Wait. It's not. She actually did that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom