So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
And yet Greg Laden or Melissa McEwan seem to regard it as possible, so your assumption isn't exactlly undisputed.
I also Googled assaults on hotel elevators. It wasn't hard to find examples. So should we toss out our skeptical principles and go for confirmation bias?

Sexual Affronts Are a Known Hotel Hazard for housekeepers.
Sexual assault on a golf course
Sexual assault at grocery store
Sexual assault started at hotel bar

Gee, what a scary world. I better stay home.
Oops.
Sexual assault in home


Denominators are missing here and they are key to assessing the real risk vs the perceived risk.

Thank goodness there are people willing to do the peer review of claims made in skepicss' blogs because we all don't have the time or access to the data. My apologies if this has already been posted. (And yes, I am gleeful over this shiny new toy, too. ;) )

“Hotel Elevator Rape” Is Less Common Than “Man Bites Dog”
But before going into this any further, there’s a question nobody seems to have asked: DO RAPES ACTUALLY HAPPEN IN HOTEL ELEVATORS?
Sure, they have happened. In the history of human race and the billions of hotel stays that have been made, they have happened. But lets get something straight: people have also been struck by meteors on at least two occasions.

[snipped a well researched analysis worth reading]

That is twelve cases of women being assaulted on elevators at hotels, in a period of almost 40 years. Many of these cases the victim managed to get away or the assault didn’t get very far. Granted, it’s possible that there could be others I did not find, and most of the sources I could find were English-language, so that limits the area in question. Still, it this clearly is not something that happens every week or even every year.

Perhaps just as importantly, not a single example can be found which actually fits the MO and circumstances of the situation Rebecca found herself and the fears expressed –
 
Last edited:
So men have the right to ask women for sex at any time and place?

Yes. And women have the same right. And both have the right to say "yes" or "no" as they see fit. Taking that right away from the man in the elevator makes you rather sexist. :D
 
No, I think this hypothesis isn't supported. Last I looked at skepchick.org, it was a blog, not a nation, army or company, and I can't remember RW making any broad statements starting with 'We at Skepchick.org ...' or 'I in my capacity as spokeswoman of ( whatever )...'. As far as I am concerned, she speaks for herself.

People who just speak for themselves don't get invited to be on a panel with Richard Dawkins. They don't get a platform and a podium and a microphone. There are more than six billion of them. In order to get that status, you have to something extra.

Would you be happy if Michelle Bachman had been on that panel? She's an individual who speaks for herself. I don't think she would get to sit at a table with Richard Dawkins, and for good reason.

*Sigh*. The elevator incident, or more precisely the class of situations it represents, and the perceived threat of rape are linked somehow. RW though didn't equate them. On the contrary, she was quite clear that she doesn't consider chatting her up a rape attempt.

Yes, she was clear about that in the first comments. It isn't so clear in the later comments.

Frankly, I don't care much if they are linked or they are not. I think it's important to make a distinction between their being linked, or nor. To simplify, they are, or they are not. If they are, then let there be a case for it. If they aren't. However, to say that they are when the argument is going in a particular way, except that when there are criticisms or disagreements, they all of a sudden magically aren't, is disingenuous and possibly hypocritical.

The hyperboles on this topic, look to me as if they are mainly from the detractor's side. Really, none of the feminists said 'All men who are interested in women are rapists'. And even the frequently attacked text about 'Schrödinger's Rapist' mainly points out that the rape statistics hint at rape being a very real possibility for women, that it is wiser for them to err on the side of caution when assessing male strangers, and that it would be nice if the guys could understand this.

Hmm... "The Guys." Classifying much?

I don't want to take position there on either side, because as far as I am concerned I never had any sexual contact I didn't at least implicitly agree to (Implicitly because of two instances were I either thought that being wined and dined establishes an obligation or where it was emotionally easier to sleep with the guy, than to become really rude in my decline. Juvenile foolishness in both cases and nothing that gave me any unsurmountable trouble). I could only relate to this second hand. But hey, I am a man, and for a few reasons we can discuss in another post, I think it is different for girls.

No, stop. I think it is different for many girls ( and possibly some dudes ). Skeptic Ginger for example apparently has no problems in this regard either, which is great. More power to her. I still don't think she represents a majority.

OK. So what does that mean? @Skeptic Ginger may or may not represent a majority. If she doesn't, so what? Are "we" supposed to appeal to the majority of women? The majority is Christian. The majority is, largely, ignorant.

I don't think I want to see "the majority" when I spend a lot of money to go to a skeptic conference. I want to listen to people who are exceptional. I want to listen to Neil deGrasse Tyson. I don't want to listen to a panel of five randomly selected Black people talk about astrophysics.

Why should I want anything different if they happen to be women?

I must have missed this gem. Care to give me a source?

Answered elsewhere.

[quote[RW wasn't particularly serene in either her response to Stef nor to RD. She is obviously invested in the topic, and reacts emotional. But to paraphrase PZ Myers: Science isn't always calm and serene debate. They scream a lot there. I guess the same goes for discussion of social problems.[/quote]

I was a research scientist for 13 years. I know this. However, when I was in that particular setting, I enjoyed being around people who were trained in science.

The complaint is in my opinion not without merit and her calling him a 'wealthy old heterosexual white man' is flippant but not purely an insult. It serves, as I read it, to point out in what regards RD is privileged towards various other people.

It's stupid, because he's the same color that she is.

Let me dissect it: 'White' is true for both, and in the context of RW's problem insignificant. It would be significant in the context of Dawkin's reply, because he referenced a practice mainly seen in third-world-countries as worse, and whether he wanted it or not, it was understood as belittling RW's complaint. As a first-worlder he would indeed be privileged compared to most muslim women.

As would she, and that's pretty much the point.

'Old' is moderately significant. His age signifies the circumstances of his upbringing which was largely before the main waves of feminism, which might make it difficult for him to understand the problem. On the other hand, RD may be occasionally a dick ( although a brilliant one ), but one can hardly accuse him of intellectual inflexibility or inability to learn.

I don't think that she said "old," though she may have. Still, "old" also signifies having a long career and writing a fair number of papers and books. Not that everyone who is old has written so many papers and books, but Rebecca Watson certainly hasn't.

'Heterosexual' is mainstream, and indeed it is an indicator that at least sexually RD likely had no pressing need to question societal norms regarding genderroles and similar topics.

Again, she didn't say this. As an aside, there are some huge names on this forum who are not heterosexual by any stretch of the imagination.

'Man' constitutes a privilege in my eyes. We still live in a largely patriarchal society. Not as bad as last century around this time, but nevertheless true. And there are enough conservative (religious) groups who would love nothing more than turning the wheel back.

Wowie zowie, Batman. You can always find people who want to turn the wheel back. What does that have to do with the price of pigs in Pakistan?

As a whole though the expression signifies RD's place on the social food chain ( very high ), and with his wealth, his membership in various ingroups and his fanbase, he commands respect in several ways. He is a prime example of an alpha male. I don't begrudge him. He certainly earned a lot of this place, and because he isn't in the habit of slaughtering youngs who might threaten his position, I see no harm in it.

BUT, the tribulations and problems of the alpha-male ( the animal that eats first and has to deal with the politics of his pack ) are a lot different than those of us sub-alpha males or of the females. And it seems reasonable to me, that he has problems to recognize the significance of problems those lower on the ladder face.

However, and this is the main point, he is only supposed to recognize the significance of problems of a particular kind, White middle-class Western women. That's what we are specifically being asked to recognize, that Watson's discomfort on an elevator in a nice hotel is of Supreme Significance, compared to which the sufferings of women in some Islamic countries are trivial.

AND, he is a vastly more influential speaker than RW, and from this I can understand that his perceived casual dismissal hit her pretty hard.

And she got to sit next to him on a panel in the first place. Why?

I am glad that you have such a nice group. :) I don't know whether it is representative either though.

It's not representative. What difference does that make? Does the fact that it's not representative make it bad? Maybe it would be good. I don't hear much from Watson to this effect.

Any atheist group could make themselves into a healthy place, with lots of sane women, simply by going there and paying attention to the way they do it and doing the same thing. It's simple. It's cheap, as the fees are almost nothing, but you have to stay at the Super 8, which doesn't even have an elevator. It wouldn't be hard. We've gotten an international audience, and James Randi himself came to speak.

But people don't seem to want to do that. They seem to want to be ticked off at all the sexism and all the bad men. They want to have something to complain about. They want to say "sexism" and "misogyny" and "raperaperaperapeRAPERAPERAPERAPE!!!!!"

Now, if people get enjoyment and personal satisfaction from being all angry and having a lot of drama, who am I to tell them to stop? It's their choice. It is my right, however, to laugh at them when they whine about it.
 
How is politely asking if a woman would like to come back to your room for a coffee and a chat about what she had been talking about sexualizing or objectifying her?

blauregen said:
Ok, I'll give it a try. From the beginning, phrased like this it isn't, but let's apply a little systemic thinking to your two situations and observe how a few changing conditions influence the system.

a) is always bar-condition
b) is always elevator condition

1) Timeframe:
a) around 9-12pm ( rather typical bar-time for making social contacts )
b) 4am ( rather untypical time to meet new people )

2) Basic mood:
a) chipper ( reasonable assumption for sitting at the bar and sipping drinks).
b) tired and wanting to sleep. ( reported by RW )

3) Expectation:
a) The woman in question sits at a bar. Chances are good that she expects to be talked to, or even being chatted up. The bar is, after all commonly agreed upon as a typical place for making social contacts.
b) The woman is tired and wants to go to bed for the purpose of sleeping. Because the elevator isn't a typical place for making social contacts ( most people who are strangers to each other actually avoid eye contact there ), she does not expect to be chatted up, especially since there was ample opportunity to do it the last few hours at the bar.

4) Security
a) There is at least one additional person, the bartender. The area has in most cases an easily available exit ( fire security ) and the risk for the woman to be cornered, should the guy chatting her up be of the sinister type, is rather low.
b) There are intermittently available exits, which can be time-delayed accessed via a control panel, which could be easily blocked by a malign person of at least her strength. The cabin itself is too small for effective evasion. No other persons are in the cabin. Due to it being 4am the chance of other persons being on random corridors is negligible.

Now those differences, only indicate why the woman in question may feel a lot less comfortable with a come on in the elevator than in the bar. Rape is after all a very real possibility, and most girls are extensively cautioned against it. It doesn't make it sexist to chat her up in the elevator.

But all those informations are readily available to you, in both cases. ( Relaxed and smiling often means chipper and hanging shoulders and eyes slowly closing oftens means tired, if it isn't said explicitly ).

And choosing the elevator-approach over the bar-approach, is therefore at least very inconsiderate. And being that inconsiderate of the women's likely feelings, which seem easily enough predicted, because you consider your desire to bed her much more important, is in individual cases egocentric and as a general approach to women sexist.

Did that help?

...you have done a really poor job of answering the question. Maybe some definitions could help.

Sexualize: to make sexual, endow with a sexual character or cast
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sexualizing

Objectify: to treat as an object or cause to have an object reality
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/objectify?show=0&t=1310854811

You have made an argument that Elevator Guy is inconsiderate:

Inconsiderate: Careless of the rights or feelings of others.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/inconsiderate

Now there is a very simple reason why you couldn't answer his question directly: its because there is no evidence at all from the information provided that "politely asking if a woman would like to come back to your room for a coffee and a chat about what she had been talking about is sexualizing or objectifying her." in order to have evidence of that: we need to have some context from Elevator Guy, would you not agree?

So what you have proven here, objectively, is that you can write lots of words. How they relate to the question posed? I have no idea. You have to do a lot of word twisting, squirming and wriggling to go from "sexualised and objectified" and all you can come up with is "inconsiderate." And that is, of course, if you make the assumption that Elevator Guy (who, if he exists, has not been given the opportunity to defend himself) was attempting a chat up line and not just asking for coffee.

As you yourself say:

From the beginning, phrased like this it isn't

And thats all that really needs to be said.
 
In case anybody is vaguely interested, Dawkins is speaking at TAM 9 as I write this. I hear RW and others are at the bar instead, but as far as I can tell a very large percentage of the 1600+ attendees are still in the room.
 
Last edited:
In case anybody is vaguely interested, Hawkins is speaking at TAM 9 as I write this. I hear RW and others are at the bar instead, but as far as I can tell a very large percentage of the 1600+ attendees are still in the room.

Did you mean Dawkins?
 
In case anybody is vaguely interested, Dawkins is speaking at TAM 9 as I write this. I hear RW and others are at the bar instead, but as far as I can tell a very large percentage of the 1600+ attendees are still in the room.

You mean some people, RW included, are "boycotting" his speech?
 
You mean some people, RW included, are "boycotting" his speech?

Yes--correct. I believe she called for a general boycott of RD. Too bad, because it was a good speech. Q&A now.

ETA: No Elevatorgate questions.
 
Last edited:
Yes--correct. I believe she called for a general boycott of RD. Too bad, because it was a good speech. Q&A now.

I see you are actually there. I find it childish. It's unproductive and purely emotional, even if RD did wrong (which I don't think he did, but that wouldn't change the fact that it's childish and stupid).
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger, I think its time to go back to being skeptigirl

Though I may disagree with you about 99.9999999999% on the politics stuff, you at least are perfectly rational. We need a female figurehead again after the end of RW, so go for it :)
 
You mean some people, RW included, are "boycotting" his speech?

Maybe she's just an alcoholic...

I "kinda" feel sorry for Rebecca. This whole "mess" is not going to go away, and the way she over-reacted does not speak well for "skeptics" in general...she's rather an embarrassment.
 
Yes--correct. I believe she called for a general boycott of RD.

Not true: she said that she wouldn't be buying or recommending his books anymore; at no point did she request or suggest others do the same. She clarifies this in the FAQ blog post.
 
Not true: she said that she wouldn't be buying or recommending his books anymore; at no point did she request or suggest others do the same. She clarifies this in the FAQ blog post.

When I read the original post, IMO it was a call for a boycott in all but name. I missed the part where she clarified what she meant, so if she said she didn't mean that, I stand corrected.

ETA: I'd normally quote what she said here, but being on a phone (Vegas Internet charges being what they are) makes it difficult.
 
Last edited:
Now there is a very simple reason why you couldn't answer his question directly: its because there is no evidence at all from the information provided that "politely asking if a woman would like to come back to your room for a coffee and a chat about what she had been talking about is sexualizing or objectifying her." in order to have evidence of that: we need to have some context from Elevator Guy, would you not agree?

Pretty much hit the nail on the head. I could tell you that it could be sexist, or could be objectifying, but without hearing from all the parties involved, and without actually having witnessed it for myself somehow, and unless I am the person in Rebecca's position, I simply can't tell you what this specific incident was.

However, I try not to tell someone that what they felt wasn't valid, because I'm not them. I didn't feel it. And if I tell you that I am that person, and I did feel a certain way, I'll be upset if you tell me I'm wrong, and I shouldn't. It's kind of a "how dare you" moment for me.
 
Oh my FSM, I can't resist. Please remember this is exaggerated for effect:

So if a damsel in distress asks for help with being made uncomfortable by elevator guy, your white knight reflex is triggered.

Would your white knight reflex be similarly triggered if that had been a small mild mannered guy intimidated by a body builder female on the same elevator at 4 am?

(Don't lie. :) )

Actually I've been to several body building events, so this one is easy to imagine! Yes. Actually one of my best friends is a gay man, and although he isn't small, about average sized actually, my protective knee-jerk has been triggered for him as well. And for my one friend who is larger than I am. And for my younger brother. And for the mentally handicapped kid on my senior trip who was being picked on by the popular guys.

Not what I said: it's not that somebody might challenge my point, it that I was wary that someone would ignore what I said in favor of a knee-jerk "No you're wrong and I don't need to justify that argument or respond to what you wrote." -- which was indeed the first reply I got, hence the snippiness.

Oh, I see. There was some discussion of that point before, so I missed that none of that was in response to what you said.

I actually appreciate your response, by the way. It's the first time I've seen someone actually attempt to lay out why they find Rebecca's behaviour unacceptable in this thread (I've been lurking since the start, but may have missed something earlier). That said...



...okay, I have two points here: one of disagreement, and one of clarification.


First: I disagree that putting Stef's words after rape threats from extremists is clear cut bullying behaviour. To be clear (from my understanding of what happened), Stef's words were not put alongside the threats, they followed them. The message was, again from accounts I've read, not "This person is as bad as people who threaten rape," but was instead, "Those are extreme examples, and those guys are bad; we are not that bad, but we still have some worrisome opinions in our community -- here's one and here's why it's worrisome to me."

To the best of my knowledge, Watson has never said anything about Stef McGraw to draw an equivalence between her and extremists. The way that criticism was presented seems textbook to me as well: present praise first (I.e. "we are not these guys") before the criticism ("but that doesn't mean we're flawless").

I think Avolon explained it rather well. She did something sort of like 'just asking questions'. I posted some links earlier, but here is one of the better ones. This one does all the leg work citing sources about what was said, by who, and when. That's what I used to define my objections to what Rebecca said.

That brings me to my second point, the clarification: you say that Rebecca had your full support until you read what was said. What have you heard that she said? It could be that I'm missing some details here.

See those links, but also look at what Skeptic Ginger lays out here, which is pretty good in regards to what Watson did to McGraf. Links also appear accurate.

It's hard to drop out emotion and be able to say, "you're right about this and this, but wrong about this," to people one respects. But I like to try to stick to verifiable information.

Time to pull some people back to the facts in this case. I went back to the beginning to reply to a post in my other related thread and some of what I wanted to remind people of belonged here and not in that thread. Some of this overlaps what I posted there. For those that were reading 50 pages back this was part of the discussion. There are probably people who have joined the thread late that don't know all the details.

Watson on naming names at the CFI conferenceA lot of what is being debated here is Watson's definition of an "unsolicited sexual comment". Clearly here she is specifically claiming EG was sexually objectifying her. I don't see how one interprets RW's comments any other way. And I, for one, don't agree with RW's assessment of the incident.

Watson on naming names at the CFI conference

It's important to stop here and read Stef McGraf's supposed dismissive comment RW quoted and was referring to:This is "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny"?

No, that was someone disagreeing with RW's take that EG was sexualizing her with an unsolicited sexual comment indicative of sexual objectification and not sexual attraction.

For review, RW's initial video comment transcribed by Stef McGraw:EG's words according to RW were very benign.

RW makes her assessment based on the setting and whatever she has assumed EG must have heard her say earlier and must have understood that she meant. RW is certain she knows a lot about EG's motives and EGs underlying knowledge about RW. RW is calling McGraf's different take on EG, "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny".

It is an absurd ludicrous accusation. Clearly RW is not expressing any tolerance of those that don't see EG the way RW saw him.


The rest of McGraf's comments are here if anyone is interested. They don't say much more:
 
Pretty much hit the nail on the head. I could tell you that it could be sexist, or could be objectifying, but without hearing from all the parties involved, and without actually having witnessed it for myself somehow, and unless I am the person in Rebecca's position, I simply can't tell you what this specific incident was.

We can say that in her initial remarks, Watson didn't say anything about objectifying and sexism. She only talked about being "sexualized" and uncomfortable. She also didn't say anything about fear or rape.

So we can take her at her word, or not. If we take her at her word, then it is possible to find fault with her claim that "sexualization" is what the problem was.

Accusations of "sexism" and "misogyny" only come into it later, as in the Number 11 item in her Frequently Answered (sic) Questions. The charge of sexism there is applied to whoever criticizes her.
 
...
However, I try not to tell someone that what they felt wasn't valid, because I'm not them. I didn't feel it. And if I tell you that I am that person, and I did feel a certain way, I'll be upset if you tell me I'm wrong, and I shouldn't. It's kind of a "how dare you" moment for me.
As a liberated female and a skeptic, it concerns me to see the dangerous foreign country elevator myth perpetuated. I would like women to know they can travel the world alone with some basic caution and they'll be fine.

RW has made it difficult to get this message out. She attacked those people trying to tell her her assessment of EG could have been wrong. Can you tell someone they are overreacting without invalidating their feelings? And don't you think some of us tried to do that but to no avail?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom