So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
How is it different from here? I went there a bit long ago when it first started but it was easier to come to just one board so I stopped going there.
 
But when someone says that RW (allegedly) tried to get each Skepchick to contact the speakers, is that a defined group of women or does it just mean that RW tried to get some female skeptics she knew at TAM to do it.

....
First we have to establish these emails were actually sent. It still seems far fetched.

From the Dear Richard blog in SkepChick I cited above:
In that post, Rebecca asked you to write letters to Richard Dawkins the explain your disappointment, anger, confusion and disapproval. Some of those letters are published after the jump. And please post your own letters to Richard Dawkins in the comments. **Edit: We will be adding letters as we go, so stay tuned for updates!

"Mindy" from SkepChick wrote that blog entry. There are 15 Bloggers noted on the site, 14 gals and one guy.
 
I deeply admire Rebecca Watson for having found a way to immunize herself against any criticism forever. Any disagreement is obviously a manifestation of the impotent tears of Man-Children Who Just Don't Get It, or worse, the Victorian masochism of self-loathing, obsequious daddy-issue women blind to their servility.

I hate the internet.

You know, in a way the internet is the most sophisticated source of knowledge ever designed by man1. But at the same time it allows anyone to say anything they want, often anonymously. So all this knowledge is lost within a sea of noise. Finding it is fast becoming an art.

1: The masculine in this post is being used to encompass both males and females.
 
I may have missed it, but has anyone explained what signals (other than verbal) women send out to indicate they're possibly open to the suggestion of having casual sex with a man?

Do men send any non-verbal signals about their availability for casual sex? If so, what are they?
 
You know, in a way the internet is the most sophisticated source of knowledge ever designed by man1. But at the same time it allows anyone to say anything they want, often anonymously. So all this knowledge is lost within a sea of noise. Finding it is fast becoming an art.

1: The masculine in this post is being used to encompass both males and females.

No, both definitions of "man" work in that case.
 
I may have missed it, but has anyone explained what signals (other than verbal) women send out to indicate they're possibly open to the suggestion of having casual sex with a man?

Do men send any non-verbal signals about their availability for casual sex? If so, what are they?

Non-verbal signals? You mean like baboons?
 
Or more gender correct, even, to say "designed by humyns". Wouldn't want to upset anyone with the use of "man" in a word.

:rolleyes:*



*(not at you, SG...Belz was making a point with his subtext)
I'm not one of those feminists that feels the need to extend gender neutrality in the language to mess with phonetics. And "huperson" seems a bit if a stretch. ;)
 
I may have missed it, but has anyone explained what signals (other than verbal) women send out to indicate they're possibly open to the suggestion of having casual sex with a man?

Do men send any non-verbal signals about their availability for casual sex? If so, what are they?

What is it with your hangup over peoples' availability for casual sex?
 
I think her rising star's part of the reality star phenomenon; largely a product of internet blogs, the web's answer to reality tv. She blogs and video-blogs regularly about herself and her life, serial candor which gives fans a personal connection. When she was member here, anytime she had done anything, or anything crossed her mind -- I remember she started a thread "I have a turnip" -- you could be sure there would be a thread about it (and I don't mean that to be disparaging; that sort of casual conversation over the net is fun; I think I posted a recipe in the turnip thread). I think she has a good sense of humor, more in touch with pop culture than academics such as Dawkins are typically, so is easier to identify with for skeptics her age and non-academics. She's obviously put a lot of work into the skepchick site, a lot of work into marketing it and herself, and deserves a lot of credit for being successful at it.

Hmmm...that segues nicely into something I was going to mention earlier. I'm on a road trip with my kids, so I started listening to the Point of Inquiry interview last night (plus Rebecca's new video) when my kids were with me in the hotel room (and I was too lazy to dig out my earphones). And my eighteen year old daughter, who is totally immersed in the video blog culture, recognized the voice and asked, "you don't actually watch that woman's videos, do you?" "Why not?", I said. "Because she's an idiot," she said. Now, I don't pass any of what goes on at the JREF on to my kids, so she had to have discovered the whole mess from the vblogosphere. And she had to have come to her conclusions independent of mine. Upon quizzing her, she discovered it because one of the vblogs she watches is someone called "The Amazing Atheist". I tried watching it last night, but the wi-fi sucked so bad that I could only watch about 5 seconds at a time and I eventually gave up.

All this kind of surprised me because my daughter is not the atheist/skeptic type. But she does like to get involved in causes, so the critical thinking exercises we've gone through have been about getting reliable information about whether a cause is just. She still likes going to the church youth group at a local Methodist church, even though she told me that she came to the conclusion she didn't believe in God a while ago (note, I don't tell my kids what to believe...mostly). So realistically, my daughter should be the Skepchick's ideal target audience - not involved in skepticism, but interested in causes, and comfortable using the Internet culture to learn about and spread activism. And they managed to totally turn her off.

I've already mentioned my problems with some of the ill-considered marketing for her site in light of complaints about EG's lack of consideration for her comfort, and in passing a troubling history of cliquish "attack the attacker" in the face of even well-meant criticism (just the latest example at TAM, where a couple of attendees mentioned that each Skepchick had emailed the dozen or so presenters asking them to set aside a portion of their talk to denounce Dawkins for his comments -- I'm sure Neil deGrasse Tyson appreciated that); however, since they seem destined to be a prominent face of skepticism for the near future at least, optimists might chalk it up to growing pains, and hope any important issues that have been raised get a fair and rational hearing once everyone's calmed down and grown up a little (even me, if that's possible). Maybe even a good thing in the long run? (Can leopards change their spots? Leotards their socks?) We'll see.

Add my name to the list of those who would be interested in some confirmation of these e-mails.

Linda
 
I may have missed it, but has anyone explained what signals (other than verbal) women send out to indicate they're possibly open to the suggestion of having casual sex with a man?

Do men send any non-verbal signals about their availability for casual sex? If so, what are they?

Basically, it consists of looking at the other person with an expression of disgust on an elevator.:o

But seriously, it depends on the person. There are women who are not very confident about their attractiveness and women who don't know how to use nonverbal language to indicate that they're open to that. That doesn't mean they don't want to be sexualized, objectified or even have sex. Then, some women in some circumstances might not want to have sex, but enjoy being sexualized and objectified in a polite way (traduction: some women feel flattered when men approach them, then say "no", and tell their female friends how a guy hit on her).

Other that nightclubs and the type of places where these type of approaches are expected, I'd suggest that people first engage in an interesting conversation. Or even a conversation. :) If you can distinguish an expression of disdain from an expression of interest, that's something. You can avoid further efforts. You also might like to know that there's something called hypocrisy, which is very common in social exchange, that may mislead you, and that a woman who seems to be indicating interest in you might be thinking "what an ugly, boring guy". But that's not your fault (being misled, I mean).

Then the range of possible reactions is wider than you might expect. The possible outcomes vary from being perceived as a potential rapist to actually having consensual sex.

It's a little complicated, but you know, don't do that.
 
Last edited:
What is it with your hangup over peoples' availability for casual sex?
He's asking a legitimate question. He's been told not to "do that" using the example of coming on to a woman and he wants to know how he's supposed to tell which women are open to invitation and which aren't.
 
Basically, it consists of looking at the other person with an expression of disgust on an elevator.:o

But seriously, it depends on the person. There are women who are not very confident about their attractiveness and women who don't know how to use nonverbal language to indicate that they're open to that. That doesn't mean they don't want to be sexualized, objectified or even have sex. Then, some women in some circumstances might not want to have sex, but enjoy being sexualized and objectified in a polite way (traduction: some women feel flattered when men approach them, then say "no", and tell their female friends how a guy hit on her).

Other that nightclubs and the type of places where these type of approaches are expected, I'd suggest that people first engage in an interesting conversation. Or even a conversation. :) If you can distinguish an expression of disdain from an expression of interest, that's something. You can avoid further efforts. You also might like to know that there's something called hypocrisy, which is very common in social exchange, that may mislead you, and that a woman who seems to be indicating interest in you might be thinking "what an ugly, boring guy". But that's not your fault (being misled, I mean).

Then the range of possible reactions is wider than you might expect. The possible outcomes vary from being perceived as a potential rapist to actually having consensual sex.

It's a little complicated, but you know, don't do that.
Great post. It would seem that the wide variation of genetic predispositions coupled with a wide range of disparate environmental variables including popular culture, parental indoctrination and peer pressure would result in many different attitudes and verbal as well as non-verbal queues. Which is to say that I'm glad I'm married.
 
Hmmm...that segues nicely into something I was going to mention earlier. I'm on a road trip with my kids, so I started listening to the Point of Inquiry interview last night (plus Rebecca's new video) when my kids were with me in the hotel room (and I was too lazy to dig out my earphones). And my eighteen year old daughter, who is totally immersed in the video blog culture, recognized the voice and asked, "you don't actually watch that woman's videos, do you?" "Why not?", I said. "Because she's an idiot," she said. Now, I don't pass any of what goes on at the JREF on to my kids, so she had to have discovered the whole mess from the vblogosphere. And she had to have come to her conclusions independent of mine. Upon quizzing her, she discovered it because one of the vblogs she watches is someone called "The Amazing Atheist". I tried watching it last night, but the wi-fi sucked so bad that I could only watch about 5 seconds at a time and I eventually gave up....
Now I'm curious to ask my 22 yr old son if he's heard of SkepChick or RW. Almost anything I ask him about, he's already seen it online, but we surf on completely different beaches. He's an atheist and he knows about my interest in critical thinking but those are not topics he finds much interest in. He comes across Dawkins' name enough to be familiar with him.


I checked out The Amazing Atheist. Hmmm.... I kind of like this guy.

I picked this one first. The title is "It's Only Sexist When Men Do It":
(WARNING, lots of NSF work or young kids words)

It's no surprise he's video blogged negatively about RW. He did not disappoint.

This one is titled, "Don't take this the wrong way"
His take on RW is "there's this religious girl ..." Wow! He calls her religion 'from the church of radical feminist atheists'.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom