EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Thrasher, you seriously don't see how someone's experience socializing with the community after the lectures would have anything to do with whether or not they attend the conference again?

And also - at least one of the examples I gave was of a skeptical leader - the individual who instructed their staff not to hire women. You don't see how THAT may alter the level of enjoyment?

While I don't agree with the "All Hail Ultra-Feminism!" talk that's going around lately, there ARE real, off-putting examples. Buzz's upskirt cam, for instance, was most definitely at the event itself. Tongue Guy got someone on the way to the conference room. Even if you throw out the examples that aren't good enough or whatever (though, really, a lot of the reason people come to TAM is to socialize with like-minded people since many of us are ostracized for our beliefs or lack thereof), there are still plenty to be had.
 
I don't nor is that my goal here.

Excuse me, I'm not the one promoting anything. I'm trying to find specific data to confirm someone else's claim since they haven't.

It would help if you actually read the OP instead of trying to take it from mid-thread that you know what the thread is about.

I think you might need to take five and chill out. You are reading all sorts of crazy things in to my post that are simply not there, and as a result you are attacking straw men.

I suspect that you aren't firewalling properly between things I have said and things other people have said.

Sexual assault is not the claim. The claim is that sexism is so bad at skeptical/atheist/freethinker events it accounts for 'some' of the unequal gender proportions at these events. Since hardly anyone making that claim has a single specific example, I do think it is valid to conclude they have not made their case.

The idea I'm supposed to prove the negative because I've dared to formally ask for evidence of their claim is ludicrous and shows you haven't understood the purpose of this thread.

This is solely your misreading. I have not argued that you have any such burden of proof.

Oh well, you and a lot of other people who are taking an unsupported claim as supported and the failed attempt to find very much supporting evidence as a failure to prove the unsupported claim was indeed, unsupported. You are more than welcome to provide evidence supporting the claim I don't find much evidence supporting.

And yet you totally misconstrue the purpose of this thread. Great.

This is just wrong too. I have made no such assertion, and in fact I've explicitly said that the people arguing that sexism in the skeptical community is a problem have not made their case.

As for whether I've misconstrued the purpose of the thread, I think this too is simply a mistake on your part. I've been discussing whether and how we can move from anecdotes to a rational belief, which is immediately relevant to the purpose of this thread.

When you launch these sorts of semi-coherent attacks on people who are agreeing with you on all the major points at issue in the thread, you don't do yourself or your thread any favours.
 
Thrasher, you seriously don't see how someone's experience socializing with the community after the lectures would have anything to do with whether or not they attend the conference again?
I didn't say I couldn't see it. I said I find it illogical. I didn't stop attending college because of my experiences at frat parties, so why would I skip hearing lectures from James Randi and Richard Dawkins because another attendee puked all over me at a bar after hours?

There is no need whatsoever to do anything after hours with attendees. If you go out to a bar, expect bar things to happen. If you want to have a quiet scholarly discussion, organize it.


And also - at least one of the examples I gave was of a skeptical leader - the individual who instructed their staff not to hire women. You don't see how THAT may alter the level of enjoyment?
I don't understand why you are asking me that considering that I wrote, "I am very concerned about what happens at the event itself."

While I don't agree with the "All Hail Ultra-Feminism!" talk that's going around lately, there ARE real, off-putting examples. Buzz's upskirt cam, for instance, was most definitely at the event itself.
It should have been brought to the attention of the organizers, and he should have been banned from attending.

Tongue Guy got someone on the way to the conference room.
Ditto.


Even if you throw out the examples that aren't good enough or whatever (though, really, a lot of the reason people come to TAM is to socialize with like-minded people since many of us are ostracized for our beliefs or lack thereof), there are still plenty to be had.
I haven't thrown out anything.

And, quite honestly, I don't buy the whole wanting to socialize with "like-minded" people stuff since it seems to mean getting drunk at a bar. Maybe TAM is different and people sip cognac while discussing the real significance of cholesterol and heart disease. The pictures I found on Flickr, however, paint a very different picture (not just the bordello party). Those pics look just like the parties and club outings I've been to at non-skeptical conferences. People getting hammered and having a good time. There's nothing wrong with that, but I'm thinking that when Rebecca Watson autographed that guy's ass, they weren't discussing the finer points of whether atheism is a belief or non-belief system.
 
Being married, even if it is to another forumite, does not automatically make someone non-creepy. He was married at the time of these incidents.
That's why I'm counting him.

So, I guess it depends upon how you're counting frequency of sexist incidents. Why are you counting PEOPLE instead of occurrences?

'Cause if you do it as number of incidents, the breakdown would be five for one person, dozens for the other.

There is also Buzz's upskirt cam, and a handful of other, less serious, offenses. There is, for instance, at least one skeptical leader who "can't work with women" because said person cannot be as frank with women as men. This individual went so far as to inform their staff not to hire women.

SG, it should be becoming very obvious that there is a whole bunch of stuff it's in my best interests not to discuss. I know you are looking for evidence and all that, but most people are going to be EXTREMELY unwilling to discuss any of this - and for good reason, too.
It is not obvious there is "a whole bunch of stuff you don't want to discuss". I can't judge any of it unless you describe at least something. I have made suggestions how you could note incidents without naming names. Whatever you need to do to disguise said incidents is up to you.

If, OTOH, you feel it will reflect upon you, sounding like you are complaining or something, you are welcome to send me info via a PM, again, without names. And for that matter, so can anyone who has the same concerns. I will only post a description of the incidents, no names, no names of people who share the information. I will give a total at the end like 3 people reported 8 things or whatever the number is so we know how many people are reporting.

As for how to count the incidents, I'm not going for a number here. By count, I meant separate reports, not how many times one person creeped women out. The end result here will be merely descriptive.

But I am concerned that you are describing obnoxious people rather than sexist incidents, per se. Honestly, drunks are common at conventions. If it is drunks or jerks keeping women from attending that really is a different issue from sexism. But I'll still describe your anecdotes in the summary and let people decide for themselves.
 
Thrasher, you seriously don't see how someone's experience socializing with the community after the lectures would have anything to do with whether or not they attend the conference again?
That wasn't his point.

And also - at least one of the examples I gave was of a skeptical leader - the individual who instructed their staff not to hire women. You don't see how THAT may alter the level of enjoyment?
I took that description as a specific sexist incident like the comments about "Boobquake".
 
I think you might need to take five and chill out. You are reading all sorts of crazy things in to my post that are simply not there, and as a result you are attacking straw men.

I suspect that you aren't firewalling properly between things I have said and things other people have said.
...Forgive me but you are the third person to complain about the limitations of some study I never proposed to do.

In the OP, I stated what I wanted: ...to look for evidence of the sexism-is-hurting-us hypothesis before I reject it based on my own experiences and underlying assumptions.

I don't see that I said anything there about a study, nor did I say I planned to promote any data. I'm looking for the damn data no one making the claim offered before I (not you, not anyone else) dismiss their claims based on my personal experiences.

This is solely your misreading. I have not argued that you have any such burden of proof.
No, you merely implied the data I was seeking wouldn't support my claim. But I didn't make any claim.


This is just wrong too. I have made no such assertion, and in fact I've explicitly said that the people arguing that sexism in the skeptical community is a problem have not made their case.

As for whether I've misconstrued the purpose of the thread, I think this too is simply a mistake on your part. I've been discussing whether and how we can move from anecdotes to a rational belief, which is immediately relevant to the purpose of this thread.

When you launch these sorts of semi-coherent attacks on people who are agreeing with you on all the major points at issue in the thread, you don't do yourself or your thread any favours.
If you are indeed "discussing whether and how we can move from anecdotes to a rational belief", fine. What's your plan?

If you were reading along you might have seen my post that said I had no resources or access to the data one would need to do what needs to be done. You might have also seen that I said the collection of evidence in this thread was extremely limited as to what it could tell us. But it was better than nothing.
 
What's the point of that? I am looking for evidence not examples. Are you also of the mistaken notion that anecdotes are not evidence?
I'm of the notion that, without any formal studies having been done by psychologists or sociologists or such, the kind of answers people could give here would be their own examples from experience, and that word doesn't make it sound as if you were pretending to a level of scientific rigor that you're not, so it wouldn't have gotten the obsessive badgering from the "but this doesn't really count" folks.

The community doesn't change just because the time of day does.
Yes, it does. Even if you don't count the same person behaving in two different modes as a change, there are different people present at different times. I, for example, might go to TAM someday for the discussions & such, but there's practically no chance I would be near one of those booze-gulping Tau-Alpha-Mu "parties" I keep hearing about. Filtering out people means you get a different set of people.

There's a guy in the skeptical community who goes out of his way to get women drunk, offers to walk them back wherever, and then just ushers them to his room. This individual lies about several key things as well - things that would really make a difference. After some asking around, I believe the women he has done this to numbers in the dozens. I should add - this is not a TAM-related thing.
I know that the wooing began at official events, and continued later so that alcohol would be involved.
What you've described sounds like the women in question are choosing their own behavior. Unless you're employing excessive euphemisms, he's not doing anything wrong to them. To act like he is means instead of "the invitation is creepy/sexist/bad if it was going to be rejected", we have "the invitation is creepy/sexist/bad if it was going to be either rejected or accepted". What's the real objection to this story, the fact that it demonstrates something about women's behavior that you're not comfortable seeing demonstrated?
 
...Forgive me but you are the third person to complain about the limitations of some study I never proposed to do.

Actually I didn't do any such thing. Since it seems no matter what I say you will misinterpret it completely to turn it in to an attack on your position, I can't see any way this dialogue can possibly be productive and therefore I decline to continue it.
 
By contrast, I believe it was Rebecca Watson who had the workshop at TAM where people made angry vaginas. I could see how people could take offense at such blatant sexuality. Granted, it was an optional session, but I'm sure some were made uncomfortable riding an elevator alone with somebody carrying a two-foot replica of a vagina.

First I've heard of it. I did a Google Search. I didn't find evidence that she started it, but I did find evidence that she commented about it approvingly.

I guess we have an answer. Elevator Guy should have said, "want to see my angry penis?" That would have been just peachy.

Unless one is a sexist, which of course Watson is.
 
Thrasher, you seriously don't see how someone's experience socializing with the community after the lectures would have anything to do with whether or not they attend the conference again?

Once again, that's not the point. Thrasher also mentioned the Angry Vagina thing, which could also easily put people off.

ETA confirmed at https://skepticalteacher.wordpress.com/tag/rebecca-watson/ And this was not at a social gathering, but on a panel about Feminism and Skepticism.
 
Last edited:
Is the sexism real specifically within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities or is it an imaginary boogyman created out of unsupported assumptions and misinterpretations of benign incidents?

The latter.

BTW, ur cute. Wanna get naked??? **









** ITS A JOKE PPL! :) Sorry if someone's already done it, I havent read the thread.
 
Here's an article that includes some historical perspective as well as additional evidence

Codes of Conduct: A Brief History of Civility, Inclusivity, Sexism and Skepticism
http://www.csicop.org/specialarticl...ry_of_civility_inclusivity_sexism_and_skeptic

SG, does this anecdote count as 'evidence' in your opinion:

In 2009 her reasons for leaving the Australian Skeptics were reported in the Sydney Morning Herald as being due to not being given a contract or an office and because “meetings and correspondence were rife with inappropriate and sexist comments about women.”
 
Here's an article that includes some historical perspective as well as additional evidence

Codes of Conduct: A Brief History of Civility, Inclusivity, Sexism and Skepticism
http://www.csicop.org/specialarticl...ry_of_civility_inclusivity_sexism_and_skeptic

SG, does this anecdote count as 'evidence' in your opinion:
That would be a specific incident, so yes.

But it does help to see the context in the Sydney Herald article:
Stollznow, an Australian who is a research associate at the University of California, Berkeley, was appointed executive officer, which encompasses the editor's job, in the middle of last year. But after arriving in Sydney in January, she resigned in April. Stollznow told the Diary she was unhappy at not being given a contract or an office and that "meetings and correspondence were rife with inappropriate and sexist comments about women".
She also says the group has withheld pay. The president of Australian Skeptics, Eran Segev, denied the organisation was sexist and said the dispute was the result of "a gap of expectations". This included the start date, which he said had led to the pay dispute. "We think she did a wonderful job with the magazine," he said. Stollznow says she "will do whatever I have to do" to recover the money she believes is owed.


I met Kylie at TAM 5. I think that blog commentary of hers is reasonable and well thought out. She goes on to say:

Of course, our experiences may differ for many reasons: Dylan Keenburg of “Woo Fighters” reported from TAM8 that “Harriet Hall noted that she has never had discrimination experiences within the skeptic community,” while “Pamela Gay argued that by working toward integrating gender parity and cultural diversity into the skeptic community, there would be more diverse role models and that would result in skepticism reaching more people in the United States.”
I know Harriet well. We shared a cabin on the Galapagos cruise and she lives nearby so I see her at out skeptic events. Both Hall and Eugenie Scott are well respected female skeptic voices.


@ Kevin and some others:

There are some misunderstandings being expressed here about the anecdotal evidence I seek. I am not judging the validity of these anecdotes. The idea is only to go one level up from "I feel it, I believe it, I've experienced it" to getting some specifics we can judge for ourselves.
 
That would be a specific incident, so yes.

But it does help to see the context in the Sydney Herald article:


I met Kylie at TAM 5. I think that blog commentary of hers is reasonable and well thought out. She goes on to say:

I know Harriet well. We shared a cabin on the Galapagos cruise and she lives nearby so I see her at out skeptic events. Both Hall and Eugenie Scott are well respected female skeptic voices.


@ Kevin and some others:

There are some misunderstandings being expressed here about the anecdotal evidence I seek. I am not judging the validity of these anecdotes. The idea is only to go one level up from "I feel it, I believe it, I've experienced it" to getting some specifics we can judge for ourselves.

You have received numerous specifics. You have judged all of them as insufficient. I can not see how it would be possible to present an example in which empathy would be given to the women who had these experiences. Many are following your example, further blame has been added, gross behavior hand-waved away, or a given different (always unflattering) analysis.

You have even started to set predetermined guidelines for what might be accepted as possible sexism under the exact correct specifics. But those are based on incidents that, had they happened would have been well-publicized. There is little possibility that stories will be found to match.

Based on your previous reactions and the impossible limitations you have set for what constitutes "sexist" behavior, I have to wonder what is the point of all of this?
 
You have received numerous specifics. You have judged all of them as insufficient.

Prove it. Cite the specifics along with Skeptic Ginger's dismissals. I don't read the thread as you see it. The only dismissal I recall was her pointing out that academia and work environments are not necessarily parallel to the "skeptical community" and events/gatherings she was inquiring about.
 
Point of order, ladies and gentlemen.

I see a few posts up that RW is posited as having a below average threshold for creepiness.

I'd like to offer the following as a counter to that.

RW likes to hang around skeptics
Many skeptics are geeks
Some geeks are a bit creepy

It is quite possible that RW has an average to above average creepy tolerance, which puts EG in the average to above average in creepy quotient.

Does this make sense?
 
Point of order, ladies and gentlemen.

I see a few posts up that RW is posited as having a below average threshold for creepiness.

I'd like to offer the following as a counter to that.

RW likes to hang around skeptics
Many skeptics are geeks
Some geeks are a bit creepy

It is quite possible that RW has an average to above average creepy tolerance, which puts EG in the average to above average in creepy quotient.

Does this make sense?

Well, to give you an idea of her tolerance for creepiness, last time I was in London we had lunch together and hung out for the rest of the day...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom