EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Here is a clue.
YOU don't get to decide whether what someone else experienced is "creepy".
YOU don't get to evaluate other people's motives (which you could never possibly find out anyway).
YOU don't get to decide whether someone else's anxiety about a situation is justified or not.

Just because you wrote it down doesn't make it true. The least you could have done was support your Laws. Since you didn't, I'll just have to address them blindly.

I. Everyone gets to decide how they view a particular situation with the understanding that not actually being there will affect that judgment one way or another. Why?
A) Because in a free-thinking world we need to think and express ourselves because that's how we learn.
B) Because society would be unworkable if we had to cater to every person's idiosyncrasies and since some people are overly sensitive compared to the norm.
C) Because some people will lie and exaggerate for personal reasons.

II. Everyone can, should and does evaluate the motives of other people. It's called life. Why?
A) Because we didn't, dishonest and/or manipulative people could take advantage.
B) Because some people are zealots about things and will say whatever it takes to further their goals.

III. Like with first point above, we can and should consider how reasonable somebody's anxiety is for the same reasons we judge how reasonable their creepiness level is.

If you really want to see absurd your laws are, substitute something else as the source of creepiness/anxiety such as black people or people with tattoos and piercings.

An appropriate response would be something along the lines of "Our colleagues have told us they have been sexually harassed in our community or at our events. What can we do to stop this sexual harassment?"
That's not very skeptical, now is it? If we don't know what we're dealing with, how do we "stop" it? If people start saying they feel "unsafe" at these events simply because Skepti-Bikers sends a delegation, is that a "problem" we need to solve? Should we tell the Skepti-Bikers not to get on elevators with other people because people feel uncomfortable?

These are all professional, smart, accomplished women. Why not just believe them?
Am I sexist because I prefer to evaluate the events on their merits rather than by who is recounting it?

And Thrasher, I have to say I think some of your comments here are sexist.
You didn't "have" to say it. Who are you to tell me that my feelings aren't valid? :rolleyes:

On the one hand you say that the stated example of women getting interupted in a meeting might not be sexist because the women were all just acting "meekly" (so it's her own fault if she gets interupted),
I never used any form of the word meek, so why did you put it in quotes?

When men interrupt men, is that sexist? Women interrupting men - sexist? Women interrupting women - sexist?

Am I sexist for realizing that that people interrupt people for a variety of reasons, and that if you don't want to be interrupted, you need to learn to speak up when it happens, regardless of whether you sit or stand up to pee or why the other person is interrupting?

and then you turn around and question how an adult woman could possibly get plied with alcohol by a man (again, so what she gets is her own fault)
Am I sexist because I think each person should be responsible for how much alcohol they consume and don't buy into the notion that women are so weak-willed that they can't turn down a drink from a man? I wouldn't accept "he was plying me with drinks" from my son if he throws it out there as an explanation for coming home drunk, so I'm certainly not going to accept it from my daughter.


Add this to "We also don't know if the women who attend these events have a lower threshold for creepiness" (so their testimony really can't be relied upon)
Am I sexist for pointing out that we don't know what people consider creepy until they tell us? I never once said that their testimony cannot be relied upon. As Skeptic Ginger said, I want to hear the facts, not their conclusions. I can believe everything they say (I take RW's description at face value) and come to a very different conclusion about the creepiness level. Disagreeing doesn't mean I think they are unreliable.

and "Then don't hang out in the hotel bar until 4:00 AM. If you do, expect those things that happen in and around a bar at 4:00 AM to happen but with more frequency." (again with the "it's her own fault" thing.)
Am I sexist for pointing out that conduct at a bar and conduct at an educational session/lecture are two completely different contexts? If you go back, that's what I was talking about because it was claimed that people choose not to attend the lectures/seminars because of what happens after hours in bars.

Are you starting to see a pattern here? I do. I sincerely hope you will take these comments as an opportunity to examine and evaluate your own deeply held beliefs about women.
Yes, I see a pattern where women are treated like delicate flowers who are not to be questioned when it comes to how men treat them. If just one woman says it's wrong, then, damn it, it's wrong. How dare I or anyone else ask them to present the facts and then state our own opinions?

There's plenty of sexism in this thread, and it's coming from people such as yourself who seem to think women need special treatment. Go read Meg's Laws again, only this time apply them to someone not wanting to get in a cab driven by a black man. Apply them to a man who says he's creeped out by women showing cleavage or wearing dresses cut above the knee.

Hell, apply Meg's Laws to a man who thinks a woman in a halter top and mini-skirt accepting a drink from him at the bar is probably quite willing to go back to his hotel room. After all, she knows that studies show that nearly all men on a college campus were up for casual sex with a stranger. She knows men find legs and boob sexually appealing. She knows that by accepting a drink she's willingly taking a drug that lowers her inhibitions.

So, when you say he's in the wrong for feeling like she's expressing a willingness for sex, apply your laws.

YOU don't get to decide whether what someone else experienced is "sexual flirtation".
YOU don't get to evaluate other people's motives (which you could never possibly find out anyway).
YOU don't get to decide whether someone else's feelings about a situation are justified or not.

So, that settles it then. At the next TAM, the JREF needs to announce a dress code for women. Remember, a TAM attendee said that her thin shirt revealed that the A/C was working quite well. Seeing that would make me uncomfortable because my eyes will want to look but my mind says I shouldn't. That causes me anxiety. It's a little creepy when a woman doesn't properly cover herself. I mean, she knows that at least some are going to stare, so why is she going out like that?

Got a problem with that?

Here is a clue.
YOU don't get to decide whether what someone else experienced is "creepy".
YOU don't get to evaluate other people's motives (which you could never possibly find out anyway).
YOU don't get to decide whether someone else's anxiety about a situation is justified or not.
 
Thrasher,

Obviously you didn't understand what I am saying. These are not "Meg's Laws". These are basic rules that are understood and followed when sexual harassment or hostile environment cases are investigated in work place situations or organizations in general. Despite your opinion about how things should be run, evidence is not trotted out for every Tom, Dick, Harry or Sue to evaluate and debate for themselves, because that in itself can create an even more hostile environment. Is that really so difficult to understand?

So, no. You don't actually get to decide for yourself how to view a particular situation, what people's motives were, or whether someone else's anxiety or "creepiness level" is reasonable or not.

I really seriously and genuinely recommend that you take a few minutes and google some terms like "sexual harassment" or "hostile environment" and educate yourself a little about what it is rather than making up things for yourself. There are many many excellent publications and documents available for everyone to read. Adding the terms "best practices" or "guideines" will also lead to a wealth of information about how to deal with it.


If you really want to see absurd your laws are, substitute something else as the source of creepiness/anxiety such as black people or people with tattoos and piercings.

That's not very skeptical, now is it?

I think this just says a whole lot more about your own fears than it does those of "a reasonable person". And no, you're not being very skeptical here. Sexual harassment is not about discomfort about who a person is or what they look like. It's about their behavior and actions.


If we don't know what we're dealing with, how do we "stop" it?

It really can be as simple as "Don't assume any other person is at TAM for any reason other than the stated mission of TAM" (education, meeting like minded people, celebrating critical thinking) or "Treat every person you meet there as you would a co-worker" or, in case you treat your co-workers with a great deal of familiarity, "Treat every person you meet with the same respect you would treat your boss" or "Even though YOUR reason for attending this event is to hook up with a member of the opposite sex, don't assume that is anyone else's goal" or "Don't assume that what you consider to be acceptable behavior, especially if it involves touching another person, staring at or discussing another person's body parts, or making sexual overtures is considered acceptable behavior by everyone around you."


You didn't "have" to say it. Who are you to tell me that my feelings aren't valid? :rolleyes:

I didn't say your feeling aren't valid. I said your words were sexist.


I never used any form of the word meek, so why did you put it in quotes?

I put the word "meekly" in quotes because that is the exact word you used.

Without knowing more about the dynamics of the situation, who can say it's sexism? For all we know the women all took the interruptions meekly.


Am I sexist for realizing ..


Am I sexist because I think ..


Am I sexist for pointing out ..

Am I sexist for pointing out ..

You start to look pretty sexist when you the majority of your comments are spent defending the male's behavior and criticizing the female's behavior.

Yes, I see a pattern where women are treated like delicate flowers who are not to be questioned when it comes to how men treat them. If just one woman says it's wrong, then, damn it, it's wrong. How dare I or anyone else ask them to present the facts and then state our own opinions?

Straw man. Slippery slope. How about just saying "Hmm. A woman has said that x behavior is offensive to her. Perhaps I should think about that and keep it in mind, in case I am unintentionally offending other women by my own behavior." ??

There's plenty of sexism in this thread, and it's coming from people such as yourself who seem to think women need special treatment.

No one is asking for "special treatment" How about respectful treatment? If you wouldn't slap your male coworkers butt, make comments about his "cans", leer at his body parts, or shout out comments about his boobs while he is making a presentation, maybe you shouldn't be doing that to the women around you, too. If your first conversation with a coworker isn't to ask for casual sex, perhaps it shouldn't be your first comment to a woman you meet at a skeptical event, either.


So, that settles it then. At the next TAM, the JREF needs to announce a dress code for women. Remember, a TAM attendee said that her thin shirt revealed that the A/C was working quite well. Seeing that would make me uncomfortable because my eyes will want to look but my mind says I shouldn't. That causes me anxiety. It's a little creepy when a woman doesn't properly cover herself. I mean, she knows that at least some are going to stare, so why is she going out like that?

Very silly straw man. Again. This really isn't that hard. It's not about how people look. It's about what they do and say.
 
It really can be as simple as "Don't assume any other person is at TAM for any reason other than the stated mission of TAM" (education, meeting like minded people, celebrating critical thinking)

Which includes making two-foot-long felt replicas of Angry Vaginas.
 
"Don't assume that what you consider to be acceptable behavior, especially if it involves touching another person, staring at or discussing another person's body parts, or making sexual overtures is considered acceptable behavior by everyone around you."

A pretty good rule. Does it also work for what you or others consider to be unacceptable behaviour?

You start to look pretty sexist when you the majority of your comments are spent defending the male's behavior and criticizing the female's behavior.

Really? If a person considers a man acted correctly and a woman acted incorrectly and comments as such then there is a high probability it can only be motivated by sexism and not by, for example, a consideration of the relative merits of each person's behaviours?

Straw man. Slippery slope. How about just saying "Hmm. A woman has said that x behavior is offensive to her. Perhaps I should think about that and keep it in mind, in case I am unintentionally offending other women by my own behavior." ??

And what if you consider it and think that the woman was just being a whiny, attention seeker with ridiculously low standards of what constitutes offence? Am I OK to ignore it then or should I just accept she must be right because of her genitalia?
 
If this line of thinking continues, TAM 10 will be a very sombre affair. E.g., don't offer to buy anyone a drink because it might be considered bribery and/or sexual harassment. Don't ask anyone to accompany you alone because it might be considered sexual harassment. Etc.

Just sit down, listen to the speakers, clap and then go back to your room.

Alone.
 
Thrasher,

Obviously you didn't understand what I am saying. These are not "Meg's Laws". These are basic rules that are understood and followed when sexual harassment or hostile environment cases are investigated in work place situations or organizations in general.
You are wrong. Read what the EEOC and courts say about the reasonable person standard. The courts wrote that Title VII does not serve "as a vehicle for vindicating the petty slights suffered by the hypersensitive."

Your laws are your invention. If you can show some evidence to support your assertion, please do.




I really seriously and genuinely recommend that you take a few minutes and google some terms like "sexual harassment" or "hostile environment" and educate yourself a little about what it is rather than making up things for yourself. There are many many excellent publications and documents available for everyone to read. Adding the terms "best practices" or "guideines" will also lead to a wealth of information about how to deal with it.
Oh, the irony!! The reasonable person (and reasonable woman) standards completely contradict your claims that the complainant's complaint must be taken at face value.


I think this just says a whole lot more about your own fears than it does those of "a reasonable person". And no, you're not being very skeptical here. Sexual harassment is not about discomfort about who a person is or what they look like. It's about their behavior and actions.
Right, which is why we have to examine the totality of the situation and apply an objective standard. Just because someone says they felt a certain way doesn't mean it was reasonable, contrary to your claims. So if someone feels anxiety being asked on a date at work by a biker-dude, that's not sexual harassment if he takes no for an answer and doesn't ask again.


It really can be as simple as "Don't assume any other person is at TAM for any reason other than the stated mission of TAM" (education, meeting like minded people, celebrating critical thinking) or "Treat every person you meet there as you would a co-worker" or, in case you treat your co-workers with a great deal of familiarity, "Treat every person you meet with the same respect you would treat your boss" or "Even though YOUR reason for attending this event is to hook up with a member of the opposite sex, don't assume that is anyone else's goal" or "Don't assume that what you consider to be acceptable behavior, especially if it involves touching another person, staring at or discussing another person's body parts, or making sexual overtures is considered acceptable behavior by everyone around you."
That's a wonderful speech. Of course, since you haven't defined the problem or even determined that one exists, you have no idea if it's going to do any good.


I didn't say your feeling aren't valid. I said your words were sexist.
Since I declared quite clearly that I treat women equally and believe in equality, then you are, in fact, telling me that my feelings aren't valid.


You start to look pretty sexist when you the majority of your comments are spent defending the male's behavior and criticizing the female's behavior.
Way to avoid the substance of my comments and repeat your unfounded assertions. Your comments criticize the male's behavior and defend the female's behavior. Does that mean you are sexist?

I see my comments as putting men and women on equal footing and providing solutions that everyone can apply regardless of gender. It's not sexist to say that I don't buy "he plied me with drinks" coming from either gender. It is, however, sexist to claim that only women can be plied with drinks by a man.

Straw man. Slippery slope. How about just saying "Hmm. A woman has said that x behavior is offensive to her. Perhaps I should think about that and keep it in mind, in case I am unintentionally offending other women by my own behavior." ??
Straw man? No. Read Meg's laws again. Notice, too, that you are making this about men and women such that men need to be sensitive to women without actually considering whether the request is reasonable. That's sexist.


No one is asking for "special treatment" How about respectful treatment?
Yes, you're asking for special treatment because you're telling me I can't evaluate on my own what's reasonable and that I must cater to whatever the woman says.


If you wouldn't slap your male coworkers butt, make comments about his "cans", leer at his body parts, or shout out comments about his boobs while he is making a presentation, maybe you shouldn't be doing that to the women around you, too. If your first conversation with a coworker isn't to ask for casual sex, perhaps it shouldn't be your first comment to a woman you meet at a skeptical event, either.
Where the heck did that come from?


Very silly straw man. Again. This really isn't that hard. It's not about how people look. It's about what they do and say.
No, it's not a straw man. It's an equal application of Meg's Laws with the genders reversed.
 
So, no. You don't actually get to decide for yourself how to view a particular situation, what people's motives were, or whether someone else's anxiety or "creepiness level" is reasonable or not.
Wasn't that part of the curriculum at Mao's reeducation camps?

Okay, so there's really no having a discussion with you. We either agree with you or we "don't get it". Not exactly conducive to the dialectic now is it. But that's fine. You are entitled to contribute anyway you see fit. In the spirit of your posts I'm going to offer you a killer bit of rhetorical device to go with the one I quoted above. I recommend you use it to end each of your posts.

"Now sit down and shut up!"
 
Flippancy aside, interesting, I honestly had never heard of "reasonable woman" standard. Not so surprising since I'm not an atty and only think I know everything.

There's not much on the net that is quickly clear on the subject.

I assume a man could use the standard to evaluate a case right? How would he know what a reasonable woman would consider compared to a reasonable man.

Again, it's interesting. I'd like to know more. I'm a bit skeptical of the idea but that's likely ignorance on my part.

And not surprisingly whilst some advocate for the "reasonable woman" standard others don't and view it as the very opposite i.e. sexist: http://stopvaw.org/hostile_work_env...t_be_severe_and_or_frequent_or_pervasive.html
 
So here we go again...

It's completely reliant on the whims of women whether or not a man's actions are objectionable.

We'd best steer clear of any topic that might be construed in any way to relate to sex, on fear that we might make these tender flowers even slightly uncomfortable.
 
Which includes making two-foot-long felt replicas of Angry Vaginas.

Actually, I really don't know the full story about the Angry Vaginas. I could certainly see how, though, many people might be made uncomfortable by carrying big angry vaginas around.
 
Actually, I really don't know the full story about the Angry Vaginas. I could certainly see how, though, many people might be made uncomfortable by carrying big angry vaginas around.

It was within the context of feminism and skepticism. It was a fairly bold statement even within that context and may have been a misstep.

Like all of the extra workshops, the curriculum including crafts time was announced before TAM. The people who participated choose to do so and knew what they were getting into. Unlike those women who were upskirted, had a tongue stuck down their throat, trusted a fellow skeptic enough to let their guard down while drinking and so forth.
 
If this line of thinking continues, TAM 10 will be a very sombre affair. E.g., don't offer to buy anyone a drink because it might be considered bribery and/or sexual harassment. Don't ask anyone to accompany you alone because it might be considered sexual harassment. Etc.

Just sit down, listen to the speakers, clap and then go back to your room.

Alone.

I really don't get why people keep responding this way. People flirt, hook-up, and start romances even in workplaces and organizations that are outstanding in their ability to be welcoming to women.

Believe it or not, there are lots of ways to start a conversation with a women that don't, for example, revolve around talking about her boobs.
 
I really don't get why people keep responding this way. People flirt, hook-up, and start romances even in workplaces and organizations that are outstanding in their ability to be welcoming to women.

And those people run the risk that they encounter some hyper-sensitive person who runs to HR to make a complaint.

An example of how weird/vindictive/sensitive people can be: my sister was accused of being a racist by a Muslim woman for having hand sanitizer on her desk at work.

Believe it or not, there are lots of ways to start a conversation with a women that don't, for example, revolve around talking about her boobs.

I agree. However, if a person's objective is to have a physical relationship with someone at some point in the not too distant future (or the very near future if at TAM or a conference) it is required to move the conversation onto topics which indicate he or she has a sexual interest in that person.

The complaint from women isn't that men hit on them, it's that men who they don't want to have sex with hit on them. I.e. women think men should know that the woman they're currently talking to considers them too ugly/thick/boring/short/tall/whatever to have sex with.

Some men have been rejected so much that they automatically assume every woman they talk to thinks this way about them. A man like me is the result of what you're endorsing. As I'm already convinced you don't want to **** me, I'll not bring the subject or anything even close to it up if we meet.
 
Last edited:
And those people run the risk that they encounter some hyper-sensitive person who runs to HR to make a complaint.

An example of how weird/vindictive/sensitive people can be: my sister was accused of being a racist by a Muslim woman for having hand sanitizer on her desk at work.



I agree. However, if a person's objective is to have a physical relationship with someone at some point in the not too distant future (or the very near future if at TAM or a conference) it is required to move the conversation onto topics which indicate he or she has a sexual interest in that person.

The complaint from women isn't that men hit on them, it's that men who they don't want to have sex with hit on them. I.e. women think men should know that the woman they're currently talking to considers them too ugly/think/boring/short/tall/whatever to have sex with.

Some men have been rejected so much that they automatically assume every woman they talk to thinks this way about them. A man like me is the result of what you're endorsing. As I'm already convinced you don't want to **** me, I'll not bring the subject or anything even close to it up if we meet.

Shall we look at this from a different angle? The oft-mentioned buzzo seems to have made finding a girlfriend and/or hooking up at TAM his main objective (possibly life-long ambition.) To that end he has employed every tactic that has been discussed here and quite a few that we haven't gotten around to yet.

He is quite arrogant, confident and rude while pursuing this objective. All those adjectives that get tossed around when the "nice" guys grumble about "bad boys." The "nice cans" email and it's pouty follow up could have easily been written by him.

Has it worked? Not at all. He has struck out to a truly astounding degree and created such a reputation for himself that finding a mate within the skeptical movement now seems unlikely - even if he totally changed his ways.

On the other hand, the people I know who have hooked up within the movement all started as friends. They got to talking about something they both enjoyed, found common ground and later common interest. The time between the initial cerebral connection and the later physical one varies greatly, from minutes to months but that initial conversation is a constant factor.
 
I really don't get why people keep responding this way. People flirt, hook-up, and start romances even in workplaces and organizations that are outstanding in their ability to be welcoming to women.

Believe it or not, there are lots of ways to start a conversation with a women that don't, for example, revolve around talking about her boobs.
Jen created the Boobquake event. Not that it justifies later comments, but clearly some of the male conference attendees might have gotten mixed messages about it being OK to talk about boobs.

And this blog-eruption began with an incident some of us view as exactly what you and RW have said is OK: flirting, hooking up and starting romances. It is what McGraf's point of view was.

Despite the belief by some in this discussion that the elevator event was so obviously sexist objectification, it is not a consensus view. To use your words, you and RW do not get to decide for everyone how we view the encounter.
 
Shall we look at this from a different angle? The oft-mentioned buzzo seems to have made finding a girlfriend and/or hooking up at TAM his main objective (possibly life-long ambition.) To that end he has employed every tactic that has been discussed here and quite a few that we haven't gotten around to yet.

He is quite arrogant, confident and rude while pursuing this objective. All those adjectives that get tossed around when the "nice" guys grumble about "bad boys." The "nice cans" email and it's pouty follow up could have easily been written by him.

Has it worked? Not at all. He has struck out to a truly astounding degree and created such a reputation for himself that finding a mate within the skeptical movement now seems unlikely - even if he totally changed his ways.

On the other hand, the people I know who have hooked up within the movement all started as friends. They got to talking about something they both enjoyed, found common ground and later common interest. The time between the initial cerebral connection and the later physical one varies greatly, from minutes to months but that initial conversation is a constant factor.
What is your point? Buzz0 isn't attractive? You cannot draw the conclusion you are drawing here that behavior [X] accounts for the outcome. You have not established a valid conclusion by this anecdote (skepticism 101).
 
Last edited:
What is your point? Buzz0 isn't attractive? You cannot draw the conclusion you are drawing here that behavior [X] accounts for the outcome. You have not established a valid conclusion by this anecdote (skepticism 101).

Attractive? What does that matter? I'm sure that, divorced from his behavior, some women would find buzzo attractive. Eye of the beholder and all that. His looks are not the major contributing factor for failure.

buzzo is a rather unique case in that there is a wealth of evidence available in comparison to the average TAM attendee. He has been repeating the same behavior at the same event for years now and had a consistent result. While it may not live up to your extremely rigid, personal standard of "skepticism," it is interesting enough to mention in the thread that you set up specifically to collect anecdotes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom