Cool. How did you control for confirmation bias?
I'm sorry, I thought I made it clear I wasn't conducting a formal study. I did not control for any sort of bias. You may accept or reject my summarization as you choose. It was not meant to be scientific. You asked how I knew something. I told you. I never made any claim that my opinion was other than my opinion.
I find any predetermined outcome troubling.
Outcome = The behavior of EG is determined to be inappropriate.
Why? If RW had blogged about the guy who farted in the elevator, would you abstain from finding that to be inappropriate? How about if he had pissed there? Would you consider my opinion that such behavior is inappropriate to be a troubling predetermined outcome?
I'm going to apologize here as I see that I was wrong in my understanding of what you are saying. Please forgive me and I'll try again.
You are forgiven. I appreciate the acknowledgment that you did not understand what I was saying.
Interesting. Could you quote me the phrase where you perceived that I was dictating to all women how they should behave? I don't even know what behavior you think I am dictating to them.
I think it's best to make it known how such propositions are perceived (creepy) so that others can avoid being that guy.
How is this not defining the behavior as inappropriate (creepy)?
Okay. I don't see that as being an end result, but a starting point, kind of like I would also consider farting or pissing in the elevator as inappropriate. But if that's what you meant by 'end result', then you are correct.
- Because not all people perceive of this incident as inappropriate.
- There is no objective basis for all people to perceive of this incident as inappropriate.
Is there any behavior that all people would perceive as inappropriate? Is there an objective basis for the way we classify other behaviors as appropriate or inappropriate? I would answer both of those questions with no, so I don't think this implies that we should not use incidents like this to help us define community standards.
While I don't see your concerns as being any more applicable to this incident and discussion that any other, I do appreciate your taking the time to explain your concerns to me.
No single incident such as this one should ever define the thoughts and feelings of all people. Now, is there anything that you don't get about that?
Yes. Why do you feel that defining what is and isn't appropriate within our culture is equivalent to defining the thoughts and feelings of all people? I think the first is typically done without the second.
YES! YES! YES! But that doesn't mean that at the end of the day we have to all agree and codify a law or rule that men cannot ever ask a stranger for coffee while in an elevator at 4:00am
Of course not. Has anyone proposed a law? Or even a formal rule? Why argue against something no one (at least on this thread) has been arguing for? IMO, it's not even implied by the discussion we've had so far.
Defense Atty: Can you give this person fair consideration?
Beth: Of course I can. We should give HIM a fair trial and THEN hang him.
Unfair on your part. Just for the record, the only time I ever sat on a jury, I hung the jury because the prosecutor didn't make his case IMO. I refused to convict without sufficient evidence.
Do you think such behavior should be tolerated or should it be made clear that it isn't acceptable?
You gave me a false choice.
There's a third option between tolerating something and considering it unacceptable? What would that be? There are, of course, options like enthusiastically embracing the behavior or calling for a law against it. Is that what you meant? If so, that's fine. I can interpret such responses as tolerating or considering unacceptable respectively.
Let me set aside your fallacious questioning and get to the spirit of what I think you were asking.
- I DON'T KNOW. My mind is open. I have no predetermined position. I've acknowledged when Meg and others have made good arguments.
- I care very deeply about the well being and concern that women have in this regard.
- I'm a man and though I tend to be skeptical of my views I'm doubly so when it comes to the opinions of women.
- This isn't a jury trial. I likely will hold contradictory positions and continue to analyze as I receive more information.
Do those answers indicate that you think that such behavior should be tolerated or should be considered unacceptable? I simply don't know how to interpret them with regard to what I asked. I don't have any idea what you think was the spirit of what I was asking. Perhaps you could add the questions you are actually answering next time.
What results do you think might be expected with the different courses of action?
I think if we all stayed home and didn't interact with each other no one would be offended. The world isn't that black and white.
That doesn't answer my question. I am actually interested in hearing your opinion if you would care to share it.
Yes it does.
IMO, the question remains unanswered. You responded with a non-sequitor. I still have no idea of what you think would be expected for either of those two courses of action.
I could ask you if the outcome would be different if instead of RW there was a woman in the elevator who was hoping some guy would ask her to his room for coffee?
Yes, you can ask. My response is that I think the outcome would have been different. I also think the probability that such a woman would have been in the elevator at 4am to be extremely small, right up there with the probability that the man just wanted coffee and not sex. What is your opinion regarding the probabilities of those events? How likely do you think the possibility that EG just wanted coffee? How likely do you think the possibility that a random woman in a hotel elevator at 4am is hoping that the guy with her will ask her to his room for coffee?
I gave you my honest opinion. Why don't you think about it.
Because you haven't actually expressed an opinion in the areas I am interested in. You keep not answering the questions I ask and instead either answer completely different questions without telling me what they are or respond with non-sequitors that leave me clueless regarding what your opinion is on the question I asked.