God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

You are into an obsolete question.

Have we found out yet what made god?


You are into an obsolete question.



That is the tragedy with atheists, they don't have any new fake ideas except the same old canards which have been disposed of time and again, except for their ignorance and stubbornness with words, repeating the same objections time and again.

And never bothering to read the history of objections already refuted time and again.


They are so many Johnn come lately.



When your trickster Bertrand Russell was faced with the concept of a necessary being, he declared arbitrarily that he does not accept the concept, period, which means he prefers to put his head in the sand like the proverbial ostrich -- not true because ostriches don't really put their heads in the sand the way Russell does at the mention of the concept of a necessary being.


Find out what is the fact with ostriches putting their heads if at all in the sand in the face of danger.


[ They are into camouflage, but not like Russell into denial. ]





Yrreg
 
Start with my concept of God, present your objections in logical statements.


Why bother?

Only those who believe that they will 'live' eternally have enough time to waste on this garbage.

The rest of us are busy living our lives.
 
You are into an obsolete question.



That is the tragedy with atheists, they don't have any new fake ideas except the same old canards which have been disposed of time and again, except for their ignorance and stubbornness with words, repeating the same objections time and again.

And never bothering to read the history of objections already refuted time and again.


They are so many Johnn come lately.



When your trickster Bertrand Russell was faced with the concept of a necessary being, he declared arbitrarily that he does not accept the concept, period, which means he prefers to put his head in the sand like the proverbial ostrich -- not true because ostriches don't really put their heads in the sand the way Russell does at the mention of the concept of a necessary being.


Find out what is the fact with ostriches putting their heads if at all in the sand in the face of danger.


[ They are into camouflage, but not like Russell into denial. ]





Yrreg


So, no?
 
Distill your thoughts into one tough objection instead of so much useless prattle.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Before anything else, we are talking about the concept of God not the existence of God.


You can acquaint your mind to that concept, it is now in your mind.

You are asking where that concept comes from, for the present we will not go into where it comes from, the fact is that it is here already, and you say that you can have it in your mind.

I have it also in my mind.


What can you say about that concept of God:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

Is it a possible concept or an impossible concept, meaning, is there a possibility that there can be an entity in objective reality that corresponds to the concept?

You want to ask me where it comes from, but for the present put that question in abeyance, for the fact is that it is here and I have it in my mind and you also have acquainted your mind with it.

What you and I want to do now is to examine the concept to determine whether it is a possible concept or not, understanding by a possible concept as one that can correspond to a possible entity in objective reality.

Can you comprehend me?

Gerry


It is not a possible concept as you've outlined, no.


Originally Posted by yrreg
You are saying nothing useful, do you at all have a concept of God?

If not and you want to exchange thoughts with me about God, first at least get acquainted with a concept of God.

I recommend the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

Otherwise, you are going the direction of atheists who are completely and exclusively into mockery, parody, and evasions instead of rational logical substantially relevant speech in the issue of God or no God.


Yrreg


The mistake you're making is that you are thinking that the secondary relational characteristic ('maker') is a sufficient definition for this god concept and it is not. You're not providing any information with which to make a judgement of whether or not this god concept is even capable of being a 'maker' or of even 'being' (as in, 'existing') at all.

You also fail at demonstrating there is a something that is separate from our universe (the 'made' from the 'maker') in the first place.



Distill your thoughts into one tough objection instead of so much useless prattle.


Try to see the biggest view of incompatibility among the components in my concept of God as namely:

The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

Here, do it this way:

The
maker
of
everything
in
the
universe
that
is
not
God
Himself.
​

See any word that in its conceptual import excludes any other word in its conceptual import?




Yrreg
 
Distill your thoughts into one tough objection instead of so much useless prattle.


Try to see the biggest view of incompatibility among the components in my concept of God as namely:

The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

Here, do it this way:

The
maker
of
everything
in
the
universe
that
is
not
God
Himself.
​

See any word that in its conceptual import excludes any other word in its conceptual import?




Yrreg

That is the tragedy with Yrreg, he doesn't have any new fake ideas except the same old canards which have been disposed of time and again, except for his ignorance and stubbornness with words, repeating the same objections time and again.

And never bothering to read the history of objections already refuted time and again.
 
That is the tragedy with Yrreg, he doesn't have any new fake ideas except the same old canards which have been disposed of time and again, except for his ignorance and stubbornness with words, repeating the same objections time and again.

And never bothering to read the history of objections already refuted time and again.

Does he ever get to the point?

Hey Gerry, OK, we all accept that your God concept is the God that you want to talk about.

What were you going to say about it?
 
Are the Ryokan who styles himself Resident Buddhist, now you are into your new...

Originally Posted by X
Why not just define god as the maker of the universe?




If I remember right, that was his first definition - but he was then plagued by questions whether God then made himself, or if not who made God? etc.. That last bit, about not making God part of the universe, was tacked on after that.



Are the Ryokan who styles himself Resident Buddhist, now you are into your new reincarnation as a somewhat innocent but curiously delighted baby?


You remember what I have time and again told you and your fellow naive pseudo thinkers without any grasp of the history of ideas, what is the difference between sensu aienti and sensu neganti?


I said that God is the maker of the universe but that does not mean that God is not a part and parcel of the universe He made, the universe that after creation of the components that do have a beginning in God is to my scaffold of a mental contraption roomy enough as to contain God but not to thereby imprison God; so that God is both immanent in the universe and also transcendent to the universe.


You guys don't have any grasp of the history of ideas of God and also of the issue of God or no God, but you are always regurgitating rancid matter from your deceitful masters best sellers, who laugh at you all the way to the banks.




Yrreg
 
Wow, you've got better eyesight than me - yrreg's argument is still just a vague blur to me...

Problem is, on past experience, even when it's close enough to touch with a barge-pole, it still looks like a blur - much bigger, but still a vague blur :D


It's his usual argument: Proof of god by redefining god to be something we (atheist illogical unintelligent naive pseudo-thinker ignorant stubborn) accept, therefore Christianity is true.



Oh, and yrreg: You might want to tone down the insults. Maybe you'll be able to make it to the crux of your argument one day without being suspended for rudeness.

To speed you on your way: I will, for the sake of argument, accept your definition of god as the maker of the universe. And I won't delve into the "where did god come from" question.

But be forewarned: the moment you start adding attributes to this god which you have neither explained nor supported, I will jump on your argument like a dog on bacon.
 
No evidence to the blind or with blindered eyes.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Start with my concept of God, present your objections in logical statements.




OK.

My objection to your concept of God: There is no evidence for it.



No evidence to the blind or with blindered eyes.


Tell me if you do ever have sired a baby, isn't the baby evidence of a father?



But you forgive me never seemed to have ever sired a baby, what with your faith in karma and reincarnation and nirvana which are all into never mama.



See, you guys are always into evasions, I am asking you guys to put the question of God's existence in abeyance, until we have come to agreement on a common concept of God.

But as is your routine of evasions, you run into the bush of demanding the proof of God's existence.


How illogical on your part, when we have not yet come to any agreed on concept of God.

That will be just into talking past each other's heads, and that has always been your trick or limitation of mental grasp on how to think productively.


You have noticed that your brethren who are fake astrophysicists are into parallel universes, which parallel universes cannot have access to us and neither we to them, and they are each into their own peculiar laws of physics, when they these fake astrophysicists with their sleight of the hand math should have just kept to the universe if they have any idea of honesty to reality where we are living in and are part and parcel of.

How evasive or naively limited in their capacity for logical thinking but not of deceit even just self-deceit.




Yrreg
 
Distill your thoughts into one tough objection instead of so much useless prattle.


Try to see the biggest view of incompatibility among the components in my concept of God as namely:

The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

Here, do it this way:

The
maker
of
everything
in
the
universe
that
is
not
God
Himself.
​

See any word that in its conceptual import excludes any other word in its conceptual import?




Yrreg

Are
we
perhaps
seeing
the
birth
of
a
new
style
of
argument
from
Yrreg
?

"
Of
course
it's
not
the
same
old
argument
,

Just
look
how
different
it
is
!
"
 
No evidence to the blind or with blindered eyes.


Tell me if you do ever have sired a baby, isn't the baby evidence of a father?

You provided a definition for your god, and I ask you for evidence for this god. How can this be being blind? Isn't it logical to ask?

If you met someone who had never heard of the concept of gods, and you explained it to him, wouldn't it be rational for this person to ask if there was any evidence for such a being? Should he just accept your word for it?

If we never questioned things, where would our civilization be right now?

Oh, and I can provide evidence for the existence of my father. Can you provide evidence for the existence of your god?

But you forgive me never seemed to have ever sired a baby, what with your faith in karma and reincarnation and nirvana which are all into never mama.

I have no idea what you're trying to say here...
 
Last edited:
Here is the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's relation to the universe:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Can you have any acquaintance in your mind with the thought expressed in that concept of God?


I agree with you completely that this is an absolutely perfect definition of the concept of God. And I agree with you completely to set aside for now the question of whether such a being exists, noting only that this concept encapsulates the idea of God.

I further agree that if such a thing were shown to be real then, by definition, God exists.

So, what next?


P.S. Welcome back.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you completely that this is an absolutely perfect definition of the concept of God. And I agree with you completely to set aside for now the question of whether such a being exists, noting only that this concept encapsulates the idea of God.

I further agree that if such a thing were shown to be real then, by definition, God exists.

So, what next?

People have been saying this literally for years, and Yrreg never takes it further. Clearly, it's the wrong reply and he's looking for something else.
 
You have noticed that your brethren who are fake astrophysicists are into parallel universes, which parallel universes cannot have access to us and neither we to them, and they are each into their own peculiar laws of physics, when they these fake astrophysicists with their sleight of the hand math should have just kept to the universe if they have any idea of honesty to reality where we are living in and are part and parcel of.

How evasive or naively limited in their capacity for logical thinking but not of deceit even just self-deceit.

Oh, those astrophysicists think they're so smart, but they're clearly not smart enough to fool old Yrreg! :)
 
You make lots of categorical allegations without any logical foundation.

Originally Posted by yrreg
If you don't have grudges against God in any way, why not go away and have a life?


I am away, living my life.

Quote:
Your words reek of grudges against God.


Wow, you must be right - clearly I'm in denial about being full of grudges against God so what should I do?

Quote:
Okay, go and examine my concept of God, and give your objections sans the emotional overloads, and don't engage in rhetorical questions.


I have no particular objections to the concept of God as maker of everything that isn't God. Although I'm curious to know how the concept can be made to work - e.g. if God created spacetime itself, then there wouldn't have been any time in which God could comtemplate the act of creation, and no time in which the act of creation could occur, also there would be nowhere for God himself to exist prior to that. If God exists outside of spacetime (somehow - that would need explaining), then he hasn't created everything that isn't himself, because he hasn't created this place outside spacetime where he exists...

Stuff like that...


You make lots of categorical allegations without any logical foundation.

1. I have no particular objections to the concept of God as maker of everything that isn't God.

2. Although I'm curious to know how the concept can be made to work

3. - e.g. if God created spacetime itself, then there wouldn't have been any time in which God could comtemplate the act of creation, and no time in which the act of creation could occur,

4. also there would be nowhere for God himself to exist prior to that.

5. If God exists outside of spacetime (somehow - that would need explaining), then he hasn't created everything that isn't himself, because he hasn't created this place outside spacetime where he exists...

​


To 3. You see, you assume that God cannot create outside time, when you know that time itself has a beginning therefore it needs to have an agent to have brought it to its beginning.

To 4. You see, you assume that God cannot create outside space, when you know that space itself has a beginning therefore it needs to have an agent to have brought it to its beginning.


But you get correctly and I am happy for you that you accept my concept of God as namely:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


That is what I want you to do with concepts whatever they are, judge them whether there is an intrinsic possibility or not, of their corresponding to any possible entities in objective reality outside the realm of concepts.

You see, reality is made up of two things: potential entities and actual entities.

An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.


You say creation cannot take place outside time and space, there is no impossibility there, unless you first establish that creation outside the environment of time and space is impossible in its very concept.

Proof of that: that creation can be done outside the environment of time and space is that they have a beginning to their existence.



Okay, do more thinking, and without your overload of grudges against God.






Yrreg
 
That is what I notice time and again with atheists, they are either foolish or unintelligent, wanting to go into all kinds of objections against Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies, and with Russell's teapot, when if they were possessed of a bit of practical wisdom and common intelligence, they should go to the God of Christians in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, that one where we who are into the issue of God or not God are living in and are part and parcel of.

You have been granted acceptance of the Christian God concept argument, so why don't you move forward here and present your case point by point.


You ask: "So, now that I have accepted your proposition of a being who created this universe but is not contained by it what next? Where do we go from here?"

Starting with evidence would be a step forward here.


What I maintain is that God is a part and parcel of the universe and also transcendent to the universe.
As a matter of fact, for my own insight God in one state of his existence is identical to the universe, so that the universe in that state of God's existence is convertible with God.

Now, this is the position where you argue from..We get that, so make your case.
 
Last edited:
It is a fact that there are foolish and unintelligent humans, yes, no?

You should remember your problem with your control issues and how they have gotten you suspended and put on probation before.

If you have no logical arguments to make, if the best you can do is name-calling people who disagree with you, maybe you're arguing for the wrong thing.

Now, answer the question. Why do you call the Big Bang god?


Now, suppose you tell me where I said that the big bang is God?



And by the way, "It is a fact that there are foolish and unintelligent humans, yes, no?"


And if I call some posters here atheists that is as being foolish and unintelligent, it is in reference to their thinking about God or no God.

Or are you so absolutely certain that atheists are not all foolish and unintelligent in their thinking on the issue of God or no God, i.e. in their concepts of God and also in their practice of rational logical intelligent productive thinking?

That is your prerogative, but your prerogative is no reason why others do not also have the reciprocal and counter prerogative to think otherwise.


Okay, you can call me also foolish and unintelligent, if that is going to help you feel better.


I would not mind at all as to gripe if you put it an nth time in your next post that my ideas are foolish and unintelligent; because I know the worth of my ideas on the basis of non-foolishness and intelligence, and no one has convinced me otherwise, except etc.



Okay, let's all calm down, just call me foolish and unintelligent on the basis of your evaluation of my ideas, to get even with my evaluating you as foolish and unintelligent on the basis of your ideas.

But let us not sink to the depth of saying that someone is speaking through his a-hole.

Or calling someone a jackass.


Okay, no more will I use the words foolish and unintelligent on atheists, but I will just say you are naive and disingenuous; okay? when I see that your ideas are to my analysis naive and disingenuous.




Now, back to business: so, tell me where I said that the big bang is God?





Yrreg
 
That is most gentlemanly on your part, dlorde; yes let us proceed further.

Originally Posted by dlorde
Wow, you've got better eyesight than me - yrreg's argument is still just a vague blur to me...

Problem is, on past experience, even when it's close enough to touch with a barge-pole, it still looks like a blur - much bigger, but still a vague blur



It's his usual argument: Proof of god by redefining god to be something we (atheist illogical unintelligent naive pseudo-thinker ignorant stubborn) accept, therefore Christianity is true.



Oh, and yrreg: You might want to tone down the insults. Maybe you'll be able to make it to the crux of your argument one day without being suspended for rudeness.

To speed you on your way: I will, for the sake of argument, accept your definition of god as the maker of the universe. And I won't delve into the "where did god come from" question.

But be forewarned: the moment you start adding attributes to this god which you have neither explained nor supported, I will jump on your argument like a dog on bacon.



That is most gentlemanly on your part, dlorde; yes let us proceed further.



At the cost of being accused of repetitiousness, let me just the same repeat the concept of God and the concept of the universe from yours truly, which you elorde have agreed to accept for the purpose of this exercise, to prove the existence of God from the fact of the existence of the universe as evidence.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

​


Okay, here we go, into the expedition to find evidence in the universe pointing to the existence of God corresponding to the concept as maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe, can you agree with me on that?




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom