Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

Something can't come from nothing. Ergo, God.

Steve S

But, but... What about God? Where does he come from?

Oh, God? Yeah, about that -- he doesn't have to come from anywhere. He's eternal. Next question!
 
This really smells of - I dont know what cosmologists are saying, so therefore they must be wrong
 
Yahoo answers is mainly populated with teenagers and others with that level of intelligence. Questions like what is in the OP are far too complex.

If you want a vote for your answers then PM me and I will vote for you. I too am on Yahoo answers.
 
Read post #1 thoughtfully with full intelligence alert, then consult me for any word you don't know, or anything else at all you cannot comprehend.

What are the squishy things in tapioca?
 
Pffft, this one's easy. He's asking for a simple pithy equation that proves the Big Bang theory. Something nice and simple like d=vt or even E=mC^2. And when it's not given that's his aha, gotcha! moment.

Never mind that Yahoo answers is the last place he's likely to get it, never mind that the math would fill pages, never mind that the math would go over the heads of 99.9% of people alive.

It's the same tired old argument you hear about evolution. Where's the transitional fossil between A and C? Well here's B. Hah! Now you have two more gaps! Where's the transitional fossil between A and B and B and C?

Add in a dash of personal incredulity, argument from ignorance, god of the gaps and you've got a nice pot of crazy stew. Enjoy.
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing...

You ask a question which contains misconceptions from the start, you use unecessarilly convoluted language, you misuse idiomatic English, your post contains several redundancies which detract from the sense, and you veer into derails about recipes - and for some reason you are surprised that people just raise their eyebrows and go back to playing solitaire?

If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions.

Your very first sentence, proposing that the universe came from nothing, contains an incorrect premise so your question as posed cannot be answered.

Perhaps you should rephrase your question removing all assumptions, redundancies, idiom and recipes.



Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.


Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.


You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"​


Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.




Yrreg
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.

Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.


You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"​


Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.




Yrreg

Yes.
 
I have never been able to derive an equation for Yahoo answers. It's all very mysterious. What was before Yahoo answers? How did it come to be? I am just asking for the mathematical equation, nothing complicated, just an equation.
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.
There are three separate assumptions involved in your question, so it is not possible to give a straight yes or no answer. This is because your question is flawed, not because there is anything wrong with the answer.

Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.
Firstly, you are being unnecessarily insulting. Given that you have been suspended from here in the past for insulting people, this is not a very wise course for you to take. Secondly, vacuity and vanity are not synonymous. I am neither vacuous nor vain, kindly do not suggest that I am.

You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"
Did you forget about the bit that said "without assumptions"? You are making an incorrect assumption that there was nothing, and then there was something. This is not what the Big Bang theory says. It is posited that there was energy, compressed into a singularity. Not nothing. Therefore the answer to your question has to be no, that is not how the universe began at t=0; however this does not imply that there is or was any kind of creator.

Your answer must be simply yes or no, <snipped redundancy>.
OK, No. Not nothing and no creator.
Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.
Insults do not win a debate, rather, they show the paucity of your argument. I will refrain from reporting this post; I will not be as generous should you post any further insults to anyone on this board.
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.


Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.


You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?
"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"
​
Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.




Yrreg

I don't know.

Ooh, that didn't even hurt. See Yrreg, it's okay to admit that there are things we don't know. Maybe some people claim to know them, but not me. I am prepared to listen to those people, if they give me some evidence to support what they say they know. However, if my request for evidence is "answered" with hand-waving, evasion, or insistence that I just take things on faith, then I'm not going to listen to them anymore. Unless they come back with evidence.

But, at least for now, I don't know how the universe came into existence, or whether there was a creator (or Creator).

And I'm okay with that.
 
You have not answered the simple question, your nose is a part of...

He's trying to avoid answering the rebuttals to his argument in this thread.

As for what he's asking, I don't know how accurately I'm parsing it. It looks as though he's asking for the math equation describing the formation of the universe (in typical creationist fashion, the idea of saying "I don't know" is anathema to him). From the looks of things (since he was answered with "mockery, parody, and evasions"), he didn't like the answers he recieved. But that's the question he asked on Yahoo. I think what he's asking here is why his follow-up question appears to have vanished.

And there's a recipe for beef stew in the mix.

All-in-all, I'm not sure what yrreg wants in this thread.



Edit: Also this. Very much this.

Well said, Agatha! :clap:




You have not answered the simple question there, your nose is a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no? instead you mire yourself in the vain display of superfluities thus irrelevancies and wherefore inanities in re my thesis:
The universe is the evidence for God's existence.​

But I am sure you love to display your paraphernalia from logic 101 which is usually not about productive intelligent thinking but how to use logic as a gimmick.



Go back to that thread and answer this very simple question without insisting on something like I am into equivocation whatever, namely:

Is the nose in your face a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no?​


You flee from that question in terror because your innate productive intelligence tells you that facing the fact of that question will lead you to the existence of God from the evidence in the existence of the universe.



Flee, flee, flee, like Dawkins your false teacher, he knows that he cannot tackle with Craig because he Dawkins does not possess the mental acuity, the command of genuine logic and eloquence, and the treasury of wisdom and learning of Western civilization, so he runs away putting up a lot of shadow covers which are nothing but mockery, parody, and evasions.

But for all his running he cannot hide, he is all naked notwithstanding his availment of shadows to cover his nakedness, namely: no mental acuity, no genuine mastery of solid logic and eloquence, and no adequate learning, when he compares himself with Craig.



So, X, take to flight, and stop availing yourself of shadow cover-ups, you are all naked what withal all the shadow attempted cover-ups which are so many irrelevant and thus useless display of your rancid rote logic-ese.



I have met people like you among atheists, nothing but stale hot air when it comes to genuine productive intelligent thinking, spewing logic-ese in place of some original personal genuine thinking worth the bandwidth they are using up wastefully.


Perhaps I should go back to my nap, anyway I will read the rest of the posts here, I might still come to an intelligent productive message.




Yrreg
 
You flee from that question in terror because your innate productive intelligence tells you that facing the fact of that question will lead you to the existence of God from the evidence in the existence of the universe.



Flee, flee, flee, like Dawkins your false teacher, he knows that he cannot tackle with Craig because he Dawkins does not possess the mental acuity, the command of genuine logic and eloquence, and the treasury of wisdom and learning of Western civilization, so he runs away putting up a lot of shadow covers which are nothing but mockery, parody, and evasions.

But for all his running he cannot hide, he is all naked notwithstanding his availment of shadows to cover his nakedness, namely: no mental acuity, no genuine mastery of solid logic and eloquence, and no adequate learning, when he compares himself with Craig.



So, X, take to flight, and stop availing yourself of shadow cover-ups, you are all naked what withal all the shadow attempted cover-ups which are so many irrelevant and thus useless display of your rancid rote logic-ese.



I have met people like you among atheists, nothing but stale hot air when it comes to genuine productive intelligent thinking, spewing logic-ese in place of some original personal genuine thinking worth the bandwidth they are using up wastefully.


Perhaps I should go back to my nap, anyway I will read the rest of the posts here, I might still come to an intelligent productive message.




Yrreg
You sound like a spurned lover.
 
Flee, flee, flee, like Dawkins your false teacher, he knows that he cannot tackle with Craig because he Dawkins does not possess the mental acuity, the command of genuine logic and eloquence, and the treasury of wisdom and learning of Western civilization, so he runs away putting up a lot of shadow covers which are nothing but mockery, parody, and evasions.

But for all his running he cannot hide, he is all naked notwithstanding his availment of shadows to cover his nakedness, namely: no mental acuity, no genuine mastery of solid logic and eloquence, and no adequate learning, when he compares himself with Craig.

William Lane Craig? You're right, you should nap.
 
Last edited:
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.


Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.


You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"​


Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.




Yrreg

Can I have some of that stew?
 
You have not answered the simple question there, your nose is a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no? instead you mire yourself in the vain display of superfluities thus irrelevancies and wherefore inanities in re my thesis:
The universe is the evidence for God's existence.​

But I am sure you love to display your paraphernalia from logic 101 which is usually not about productive intelligent thinking but how to use logic as a gimmick.



Go back to that thread and answer this very simple question without insisting on something like I am into equivocation whatever, namely:

Is the nose in your face a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no?​


You flee from that question in terror because your innate productive intelligence tells you that facing the fact of that question will lead you to the existence of God from the evidence in the existence of the universe.



Flee, flee, flee, like Dawkins your false teacher, he knows that he cannot tackle with Craig because he Dawkins does not possess the mental acuity, the command of genuine logic and eloquence, and the treasury of wisdom and learning of Western civilization, so he runs away putting up a lot of shadow covers which are nothing but mockery, parody, and evasions.

But for all his running he cannot hide, he is all naked notwithstanding his availment of shadows to cover his nakedness, namely: no mental acuity, no genuine mastery of solid logic and eloquence, and no adequate learning, when he compares himself with Craig.



So, X, take to flight, and stop availing yourself of shadow cover-ups, you are all naked what withal all the shadow attempted cover-ups which are so many irrelevant and thus useless display of your rancid rote logic-ese.



I have met people like you among atheists, nothing but stale hot air when it comes to genuine productive intelligent thinking, spewing logic-ese in place of some original personal genuine thinking worth the bandwidth they are using up wastefully.


Perhaps I should go back to my nap, anyway I will read the rest of the posts here, I might still come to an intelligent productive message.




Yrreg

You seem to think a lot more of Dawkins than most of us here do. I mean other than burning a candle and incense to His book while kneeling and chanting DAWK! DAWK! DAWK! every day at sunrise, noon and evening, I hardly ever think of Him.
 
Thanks, rjh01, just stay here and interact with me intelligently, and also go to...

Yahoo answers is mainly populated with teenagers and others with that level of intelligence. Questions like what is in the OP are far too complex.

If you want a vote for your answers then PM me and I will vote for you. I too am on Yahoo answers.


Thanks, rjh01, just stay here and interact with me intelligently, and also go to other thread God's existence, and man-made concepts and words.

No need to correspond by PM, best we talk in the open for everyone's participation in our thoughts.



I hope you are not into stale hot air after this initial good point you make.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom