Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
FYI, it's going to take me awhile to get through this paper, mostly because it's an EXCELLENT paper and I want to enjoy it. From what I've read so far they described CURRENT and INDUCTION based processes. I haven't been through the whole paper yet, but I'm definitely enjoying it. It's a bit busy at work so bear with me a bit. I will get back to you, but I do want to finish the whole paper. As far as I can tell so far, they are using the term "reconnection" consistently with the way that Somov uses the term. Specifically it's an induced field generation process caused by 'magnetic flux' and particle movements. Cool paper. Thanks again for the reference.
That's really great! When you do decide to comment on that paper, since it is supported with many mathematical equations describing the processes involved, I assume your comments will include a good deal of mathematics.
 
Still waiting.
For what?

If you're waiting for us to tell you how to perform the trivial calculation you are apparently unable to perform, you needn't wait any longer. I'll give you a hint: Consider

[latex]
\[
f(x,y) = \frac{x-1}{x^2 - 2x + 1 + y^2}
\]
[/latex]​
When you have calculated ∂f/∂x and ∂f/∂y, you'll have completed almost 1/8 of the calculation. Please tell us what you get for ∂f/∂x and ∂f/∂y, so I'll know whether you need more hints.
:D

That electrical discharge from your calculations will be included, right?
If you're asking about the large current density at the neutral point, then yes: I will explain the main result of Dungey's 1958 paper, which is in his second section on Lenz's Law.

Please note that Dungey's main result was obtained by considering the signs of the partial derivatives you are apparently unable to calculate. Before you can understand Dungey's 1958 paper, you'll have to learn something about the partial derivatives of B4. When you're ready for us to grade your math homework, please let us know.
 
That's really great! When you do decide to comment on that paper, since it is supported with many mathematical equations describing the processes involved, I assume your comments will include a good deal of mathematics.

Why would I bother? It's a fantastic paper! Unfortunately for you, I see nothing in the paper that claims that magnetic B lines reconnect. Perhaps I missed it and you would be so kind as to point out where in the paper they actually made such a claim?
 
For what?

I'm waiting for the electrical discharge and mathematical proof that your B lines actually "reconnect", rather than INDUCE E fields and generate current. I want mathematical proof that B lines begin and end at that X in a vacuum. I don't want hints, I want your math. Got it? Yes or no?
 
Last edited:
If you're asking about the large current density at the neutral point, then yes: I will explain the main result of Dungey's 1958 paper, which is in his second section on Lenz's Law.

Too bad you don't have a charged particle to your name to work with then, eh? It literally sucks that you claimed that you could do this in a vacuum. :)
 
Still waiting. That electrical discharge from your calculations will be included, right?
Oh dear - your delusions abut the experiment persist!
Originally Posted by Reality Check
It is idiocy to think that a large current density (Dungey's 'electrical discharge' term that is no longer used) in plasma in an experiment that has no plasma (is in vacuum) :jaw-dropp!

W.D. Clinger may get to magnetic reconnection in plasma. But then he will not be able to include any 'electrical discharge' because electrical discharges are impossible in plasma.
He may cite the relevent textbooks (which you will ignore yet again) where there are equations for current densities in MR.
 
I'm waiting for the electrical discharge
I'll discuss that in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

and mathematical proof that your B lines actually "reconnect",
I'll give a very simple topological proof of that in part 4 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

rather than INDUCE E fields and generate current.
I have already explained that, for any given upper limit on the E field, we can change the B field so slowly that the magnitude of the E field never exceeds that upper limit. For a proof of that, I suggest you understand Faraday's law of induction.

I want mathematical proof that B lines begin and end at that X in a vacuum. I don't want hints, I want your math. Got it? Yes or no?
Yes, I have math.

Too bad you don't.
 

You know Clinger, Belz actually nailed your BIGGEST PROBLEM on the VERY FIRST question. It's a pity he directed the right question at the wrong individual. I think your whole show would have fallen apart in about 4 or 5 posts. I guess Belz, part 5 will be the "switcheroo" installment of his presentation, where he finally trades in his "vacuum" for "plasma". :)

Honestly Belz, it's a pity you didn't ask Clinger that question as your first question to him. I think his house of cards would have fallen in a day and you would have accomplished MIRACLES. You really do have the right instinct in terms of the right questions. Are you sure you don't want to join my side for awhile? You can always switch back and forth if you like. I'm not attached. :)
 
Last edited:
Yes, I have math.

Too bad you don't.

Ya, but I've got physics, plasma particles to work with, and textbooks on plasma physics. Too bad you don't. :)

Besides, whatever math you have that answers any of my fundamental questions still remains a mystery to the rest of us. Please show us your math.
 
Last edited:
Gekelman, Collette & Vincena: Magnetic Reconnection

Micheal, I'm wondering if you have read this paper from UCLA. http://plasma.physics.ucla.edu/papers/POP-colliding-plasmas.pdf

From the summary and conclusions;
"two magnetic “bubbles” collide. The collision produces turbulent local magnetic fields...
FYI, it's going to take me awhile to get through this paper, mostly because it's an EXCELLENT paper and I want to enjoy it. From what I've read so far they described CURRENT and INDUCTION based processes. I haven't been through the whole paper yet, but I'm definitely enjoying it. It's a bit busy at work so bear with me a bit. I will get back to you, but I do want to finish the whole paper. As far as I can tell so far, they are using the term "reconnection" consistently with the way that Somov uses the term. Specifically it's an induced field generation process caused by 'magnetic flux' and particle movements. Cool paper. Thanks again for the reference.
That's really great! When you do decide to comment on that paper, since it is supported with many mathematical equations describing the processes involved, I assume your comments will include a good deal of mathematics.
Why would I bother? It's a fantastic paper! Unfortunately for you, I see nothing in the paper that claims that magnetic B lines reconnect. Perhaps I missed it and you would be so kind as to point out where in the paper they actually made such a claim?


The paper is Three-dimensional current systems generated by plasmas colliding in a background magnetoplasma by Gekelman, Collette & Vincena; Physics of Plasmas 14(6): 062109, June 2007. The claim is found in the final section, summary and conclusions: "In the first microsecond of the process, it seems that the initial electron current is driven by magnetic field-line reconnection." There is a similar later comment, but I am not sure whether the authors are referring to their own experiment, or another that they are also talking about: In this experiment, magnetic field line reconnection sites pepper the plasma volume and are identified with the Alfven wave structures."
That other paper, the 1958 Dungey paper, also explicitly identifies the reconnection of magnetic field lines as the initial source of energy for his "electric discharge". Not, mind you, the reconnection of "field aligned currents", but rather the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field.
 
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection

I'm fine with Dungey's electrical discharge and solar flare paper.


Okee-Dokee ... Dated 7 Dec 2010 ...

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​


So, you're fine, I take it, with Dungey pegging the reconnection of the magnetic field lines of force as the source of the energy for his "electric discharge"?
 
Yes, I have math.

Too bad you don't.

Ya, but I've got physics, plasma particles to work with, and textbooks on plasma physics. Too bad you don't. :)

Besides, whatever math you have that answers any of my fundamental questions still remains a mystery to the rest of us. Please show us your math.
I already have, but it doesn't appear to have done you any good.

To repeat:

[latex]
\[
\begin{align*}
\hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} &= \hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} (x, y, z, t) = \hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} (t) (x, y, z) \\
&= \frac{\mu_0}{2 \pi} \frac{I^{(p)}(t)}{(x-x_0)^2+(y-y_0)^2}
\left( - (y-y_0) \, \hbox{{\bf e}}_x + (x-x_0) \, \hbox{{\bf e}}_y \right)
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]​
where ex and ey are the unit vectors in the x and y directions.


[size=+1]Magnetic fields around multiple rods[/size]

Applying that equation to our four rods, we define

[latex]
\[

\begin{align*}
p_E &= \langle 1, 0 \rangle \\
p_W &= \langle -1, 0 \rangle \\
p_N &= \langle 0, 1 \rangle \\
p_S &= \langle 0, -1 \rangle \\
I_E(t) &= I^{p_E}(t) = \hbox{{1000 amperes}} \\
I_W(t) &= I^{p_W}(t) = I_E(t) \\
I_N(t) &= I_S(t) = - I_E(t) = - I_W(t) \\
\hbox{{B}}_E &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_E)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_W &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_W)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_N &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_N)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_S &= \hbox{{B}}^{(p_S)} \\
\hbox{{B}}_2 &= \hbox{{B}}_E + \hbox{{B}}_W \\
\hbox{{B}}_4 &= \hbox{{B}}_E + \hbox{{B}}_W + \hbox{{B}}_N + \hbox{{B}}_S
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]​
Since that was too hard for you, let's simplify it. Letting B=B4 and I=1000 amperes, we have

[latex]
\[
\begin{align*}
B_x &= \frac{\mu_0 I}{2 \pi}
\left(
\frac{-y}{x^2 - 2x + 1 + y^2} +
\frac{-y}{x^2 + 2x + 1 + y^2} -
\frac{-y+1}{x^2 + y^2 - 2y + 1} -
\frac{-y-1}{x^2 + y^2 + 2y + 1}
\right) \\
B_y &= \frac{\mu_0 I}{2 \pi}
\left(
\frac{x-1}{x^2 - 2x + 1 + y^2} +
\frac{x+1}{x^2 + 2x + 1 + y^2} -
\frac{x}{x^2 + y^2 - 2y + 1} -
\frac{x}{x^2 + y^2 + 2y + 1}
\right)
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]

When I compute those components at the origin, I get zero for both of them. That means there is no magnetic field line that goes through the origin. Are you with us so far, or am I going too fast for you?
 
Could you start by explaining to me why it's impossible for one electron or charged particle from one field aligned current to physically jump current streams and "reconnect" with the other one? IMO from your last response, this is our basic area of disagreement. I'd rather we focus on one issue at a time.

I have not got the foggiest what you are trying to say here.

"impossible for one electron ... to physically jump"

There is no "jumping of current streams" (whatever current streams are), the electrons (and ions) just flow as they should and no "jumping" is required. That is you limited view in circuit theory probably.

In the simplest case of reconnection (petchek, sweet-parker) there are no field aligned currents of any importance (there are some though along the separatrices). Unless you understand the simplest model of reconnection it is useless to try and discuss more complicated stuff.
 
Anyone can parrot the term "reconnection" RC. The term is technically "magnetic reconnection", not "magnetic B LINE reconnection". Nobody disputes the fact that magnetic field FLUX can INDUCE (not reconnect) E fields which result in electrical discharges in plasma RC (except you). Nobody has shown any math to demonstrate that B field lines "reconnect".

Well, as you are only parrotting yourself ... ah never mind.

Nobody has shown any math? Really? How about the following books:

Somov, Plasma Astrophysics: Part II reconnection and flares
Biskamp, Magnetic reconnection in plasmas
Priest & Forbes, magnetic reconnection: MHD theory and applications
Parker: Conversations on electric and magnetic fields in the cosmos (which also has an excellent discussion about circuit theory)

These books have more math on MRx than you can ever hope to understand.
 
Hmmm. Well, let's start by saying that I am not trying to suggest that there is now, or ever was 100% agreement on any position. Alfven totally REJECTED the idea of B field line reconnection for instance. He called the whole MR theory "pseudoscience" and replaced the idea with a double layer transaction involving current sheet acceleration with NO magnetic line reconnection. He utterly rejected the idea in CURRENT CARRYING, or light plasma and he viewed the entire universe as a current carrying environment.

I'm not sure who even counts today as an "authority" on plasma physics, or how many of them there might be. To my knowledge there has NEVER been full agreement on any position related to MR theory. About the BEST I could do for you is start with the folks that CREATED the magnetic reconnection theory (Giovanelli and Dungey) and go from there. Peratt is one of Alfven's first generation students. I'm sure that he believes it's an electrical discharge. I know that Dungey and Giovanelli used the term "electrical discharge" when describing the whole "process" of energy exchange. I can name "some" MR proponents that agree. I can't say all would necessarily agree, in fact I know for a fact that tusenfem DISAGREES with me and I would agree he's somewhat of an "authority" since he at least HAS read the relevant work and is professionally employed in the area. That pretty much eliminates any possibility of 100% agreement.

FYI, while I can appreciate the value of studying Dungey's early work and Giovanelli's work on this topic, and the work of others as well, I'm not convinced that anything much is gained by citing MORE references. Furthermore, we risk bordering on an appeal to authority fallacy if that is ALL we try to use as a means to judge the validity of some position or another. In theory the science should speak for itself, and authorities aren't relevant.

So if you admit that there is no agreement amongst experts, why do you then assume there should be 100% agreement here, with you ?
 
So if you admit that there is no agreement amongst experts, why do you then assume there should be 100% agreement here, with you ?

I don't really expect 100 percent agreement. I just expect logical, scientifically based "disagreements" and arguments. Humanzee's latest approach of providing a relevant (excellent) published paper to review and comment on is a very logical and reasonable way to debate scientific points. I'm STILL finishing up that paper in fact. It's worth making an effort to work through these kinds of resources.

PS's handwave about a random image that he found on a website however is just bizarre. It's the kind of argument that a creationist would engage in. When I had a hard time understanding the point PS was trying to make (because he misread the website), I got called a "fraud" and worse for my efforts. That's the kind of BS that has no place in a real scientific debate. Ditto on Clingers so called handwavy "experiment". I mean the guy doesn't have a single electron or plasma particle to his name to work with, so he is never going to get an "electrical discharge" from that contraption. He doesn't even have CURRENT to generate any B fields at his X point. You caught that problem in the VERY FIRST QUESTION. Clinger has never read a book on plasma physics and he's STILL trying to "reconnect" B lines in a vacuum while berating me personally every day for not reading his mind evidently.

Published works are a logical way to argue science. The haters of this thread however seem to get by without reading or responding much to the materials, without providing any published materials to support their own claims. Instead they typically just handwave away and engage themselves in daily personal attacks. Haters don't even debate logically or rationally.

FYI, I have an extremely busy day ahead of me. I'm not sure how much time I'll have today to respond to this board.
 
Last edited:
Are you going to ask *THEIR SIDE* any questions Belz? Honestly, I'd *LOVE* to hear you ask Clinger how he intends to get an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption, or how he expects a B field to form at the X without a single plasma particle to work with, and no possibility of current flow at that location. That would not be a comfortable conversation for Clinger, in fact I suspect he'd run like hell from it.
 
Honestly, I'd *LOVE* to hear you ask Clinger how he intends to get an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption, or how he expects a B field to form at the X without a single plasma particle to work with, and no possibility of current flow at that location.

Again, you have not understood a thing, have you?
The X lines forms in the, as you so often call is, continuum that is the B field, between oppositely directed magnetic field lines that are pressed together.
The X line is not creating the magnetic field, as you seem to imply here, cf. "a B field to form at the X".
Bringing fields together does that automatically, there need not be a plasma. However, without a plasma you will not get interesting effects, like e.g. the creation of aurorae.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom