Gekelman, Collette & Vincena: Magnetic Reconnection II
It's a little surreal that some of you expect me to discuss Dungey's work on "magnetic reconnection" theory *WITHOUT* using the actual terms that he used. It's like trying to discuss GR theory but not use any of the terms or variables that Einstein used. Wow! Why complicate the process?
I agree that we should stick to the words the authors actually use. So consider this:
The paper is
Three-dimensional current systems generated by plasmas colliding in a background magnetoplasma by Gekelman, Collette & Vincena; Physics of Plasmas 14(6): 062109, June 2007. The claim is found in the final section,
summary and conclusions:
"In the first microsecond of the process, it seems that the initial electron current is driven by magnetic field-line reconnection." There is a similar later comment, but I am not sure whether the authors are referring to their own experiment, or another that they are also talking about:
In this experiment, magnetic field line reconnection sites pepper the plasma volume and are identified with the Alfven wave structures."
That other paper, the 1958 Dungey paper, also explicitly identifies the reconnection of magnetic field lines as the initial source of energy for his "electric discharge". Not, mind you, the reconnection of "field aligned currents", but rather the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field.
Actually Tim, you caught me. I haven't finished that entire paper yet, and I haven't gotten to the summary yet. It was a busy day yesterday and I took my time reading through the whole paper rather than just reading the abstract and conclusion. I've seen the concept of induced E field and field aligned currents used a TON of times. I'll have to wait to comment on those FEW instances where the used the term 'line'. It's not clear yet to me if he means the 'field aligned current line', or an actual magnetic line. I won't forget your question, but you'll need to be patient. I'm not done.
In terms of the inducement of an E field as Dungey and Somov describe it, that actually only requires "changing magnetic flux" (bending, twisting), not necessarily "reconnection". Therein lies the rub for me (and Alfven as well). How can any of you be POSITIVE that the MAGNETIC lines actually disconnect or reconnect rather than simply 'flux', particularly when were talking about FIELD ALIGNED CURRENTS, not just magnetic lines?
Does it really matter how many times the authors use the word "line"? If the point is to describe a physical process, or assign a physical process as an energy source, it seems to me that once and once only is quite a sufficient number of times to get the point across.
But see, when it comes to Dungey, you insist on the words "
electric discharge" because those are the words Dungey used. But those are clearly words that you like. On the other hand, from Gekelman, Collette & Vincena we find the words "
magnetic field line reconnection". Those are words that you don't like, and suddenly your own criterion is no longer such a good idea. You are no longer willing to settle for the words the authors use, their own words, but consider substituting your own words in their place. Is this not a double standard; when they give you what you want, only the authors own precise words will do, but when they fail to yield the desired conclusion, suddenly the authors' own words are to be abandoned for something you think is better?
Aside from the appearance of another double standard, what about our opinions about the general intelligence of the authors of this paper? Do you think they don't know the difference between "
magnetic field line" (their own words) and "
field aligned current" (your substitute words)? I submit that the two physical concepts are so radically different from each other that one can hardly imagine rising to the level of repeatedly funded, independent research scientists without being starkly aware of the difference between a magnetic field line and a field aligned current. How anyone could even suspect for a moment that the authors would say one, but actually mean the other, is quite mysterious to me.
Why not apply your own claimed standard and accept the words the authors use as if they were the words the authors intended to use (seems a reasonable assumption to me)? "
Magnetic field-line reconnection" looks like a pretty explicit and straight forward collection of words to me.
Regarding this paper, you have already said ...
FYI, it's going to take me awhile to get through this paper, mostly because it's an EXCELLENT paper and I want to enjoy it.
Can you continue to assess this paper as "excellent" if we allow ourselves the luxury of assuming that
all of the words actually used by the authors are the words they actually intended to use?