Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not a fact, and you are "full of prunes", as my dear old grandmother used to say. Monopoles are gloriously irrelevant.

No, they are not. The only way that "B *LINE* reconnection* would be possible is *IF* monopoles existed. No *OTHER* option is possible. There is no such thing as B LINE reconnection Tim. It's just that simple. It is HIGHLY relevant that monopoles do not exist.
 
Actually.....

Upon closer examination, there were actually TWO dark filament eruptions at about the same time on the 22nd. The second filament eruption occurs at approximately the center of the disk. That one COULD be directed our way. I'll have to keep an eye out on that one in STEREO.
 
Well drat....

There's a very inconvenient time skip in the SDO data just as the central dark filament "disappears/erupts". It's not clear if that particular filament near the center of the disk erupted outward yet. I don't see much mass flow from that filament in the center of the disk in any of the STEREO views. I think the central filament erupted downward, into the photosphere, not outward.
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section
Somov's vacuum is a vacuum :jaw-dropp.
Is this is another delusion of yours?
That a section on MR in vacuum that ends with mentioning the effect of the induced E field on chraged particles is not about MR in vacuum?

So lets add even more of the text that you are ignoring:

Basically what Clinger has been showing in his posts, albeit with changing the current density instead of moving the currents apart.
 
I do comprehend what he wrote. He said the example contains parallel currents. It's not a "pure vacuum" anymore. It's more akin to the "vacuum" of space.

The currents can easily be two copper wires in a vacuum, but I guess you would not understand that, sheesh! The stupidity, it hurts!
 
could MM's act be a deliberate parody of scientific crackpots?


FYI, that would be ANOTHER excellent example of your endless stream of lies and personal attacks.
I guess it's conceivable that, contrary to all appearances, Michael Mozina is a nice young man who likes to solve differential equations as he eats his corn flakes, and conducts experiments in his basement that he designed with an eye toward falsifying his hypotheses, even as he ignores all the math that's been posted here or in the hundreds of research papers on magnetic reconnection, runs away from the experiment I've been suggesting to him for most of the past year, denies the empirical reality of astronomical observations because they weren't performed inside a laboratory, ignores the empirical reality of controlled laboratory experiments that reproduce magnetic reconnection without plasma, blathers about sources, sinks, and monopoles in magnetic fields that quite obviously obey Gauss's law for magnetism, repeats a popular myth as though repetition of that falsehood could overcome the rigorous mathematical refutations of that myth that several of us have presented within this thread, says magnetic flux is a euphemism for field-aligned currents, tries to derail serious discussion of scientific issues by inventing spurious phrases such as "current reconnection" or "reconnections per unit length" and insisting they be discussed instead, tries to derail serious discussion of scientific issues by dragging in irrelevancies such as "electrical discharge" and "equation 17" and insisting they be discussed instead, invents ridiculous mistakes (such as redefining "inductance" to "reconnection") so he can accuse serious discussants of having made those mistakes, compares legitimate scientists to creationists, accuses anyone who uses mathematics to support a scientific point of saying "God did it", routinely describes rigorous mathematical arguments as "PURE HANDWAVING", dismisses animations constructed directly from the laws of physics as mere "cartoons", informs all and sundry that he has read Cosmic Plasma as if that could compensate for his abject ignorance of freshman-level calculus and physics, asks all and sundry whether they have read Cosmic Plasma as though that question could discredit the legitimate math and science they have been presenting, accuses all and sundry of "pure blind ignorance", "arrogance", "OUTRAGEOUS claims", "pure hatred", "BLIND FAITH", of refusing "to educate themselves", of "the very WORST type of denial based "creationist" beliefs", of loving "to attack the individual just like a creationists", describes sound arguments as "IRRATIONAL and based on PURE IGNORANCE and irrational hatred", "boloney" [sic], "TOTALLY FUBAR", "CHILDISH", tells scientists who earned their academic degrees with highest honors that they have "just earned a GIANT *F*", tells those scientists they "don't know the difference between magnetic flux density changes and "magnetic reconnection" and "don't even understand BASIC theory", believes he has the power to prevent others from presenting the next part of a tutorial whose outline has already been given, misrepresents others' posts, doesn't understand that a choice of Cartesian coordinate systems is arbitrary and has no effect on the physics, routinely gets confused about the distinctions between charge, current, and electric fields, doesn't know what the magnetic field of a current-carrying wire looks like, doesn't know that magnetic fields can exist within a vacuum, doesn't know that magnetic fields can change within a vacuum, cannot state Gauss's law for magnetism correctly, regards himself as this thread's foremost authority on magnetic fields, finally admits "his graph is fine, his math is fine" but says "his understanding of that math and WHAT that graph actually means stinks to high heaven", and finally admits that "magnetic flux densities will shift along with magnetic field topologies" (which is exactly what we mean by magnetic reconnection) even as he continues to deny magnetic reconnection.

Yes, it's conceivable that Michael Mozina has just been putting us on, and that his 2000+ posts in this thread and 8000+ posts in this forum have all been some kind of performance art designed to make fun of EU pseudoscientists and physics crackpots in general.

If so, then he fooled me completely. I thought he was serious.
 
I guess it's conceivable that, contrary to all appearances, Michael Mozina is a nice young man who.....

Yawn. You're still attacking individuals rather than presenting scientific arguments. How sad. "Earth to Clinger, come in Clinger." I'm 51 (almost 52) years old now. Young? I wish.

Back in December of 2010, you made a series of "handwavy" statements and claims related to a "freshman physics experiment" that you personally claimed would produce "magnetic reconnection" *WITHOUT* a plasma.

To that point in time I had read at least 5 textbooks on plasma physics, all of which describe the electrical discharge process in *PLASMA* known as "magnetic reconnection". In addition, I had read probably a hundred or more papers by Alfven describing the E orientation to plasma physics as it applies to events in space. I'd also read probably three dozen or more papers on 'magnetic reconnection' by a variety of different authors. In that *ENTIRE VOLUME OF LITERATURE*, I personally had never seen anyone claim that 'magnetic reconnection', as described by Dungey, would occur *WITHOUT* plasma. Never. I told you early on that you were in 'uncharted territory'.

I'll admit that I did not understand what you meant. I had no idea how you expected to be able to get "magnetic reconnection", a physical process in plasma, *WITHOUT* plasma. I was clueless and I admitted it. I'd never seen such a thing suggested in any *PUBLISHED* work to that point in my reading career.

The way a scientific debate is *SUPPOSED* to work, is one side is SUPPOSED to *PRESENT *PUBLISHED* EVIDENCE* to support their claim. You didn't do that. Instead of handing me a nicely put together presentation to support your case at the start, you spent the next 10 month attacking me as an individual, never producing even 'part 1' of your presentation. During those many months, you claimed that my lack of math skills was the whole problem, even though I pointed out to you that Alfven himself called the idea of B line reconnection "pseudoscience" his entire career. You accused me of misrepresenting Alfven on this topic, but again you provided no SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE to support your claim that "magnetic reconnection" could occur without a plasma or that I misrepresented Alfven's position on this issue.

You did however attack me personally, repeatedly, weekly if not daily for more than 10 months while *NOT* presenting your evidence.

I think the fact that Belz recently got interested in this discussion and topic is what *FINALLY* got you to actually do anything and present anything to support your handwavy claim that Dungey's reconnection would occur *WITHOUT* a plasma.

After making a *SERIES* of basic mistakes related to BASIC EM theory, including but not limited to confusing a NULL point in a vacuum, with a 'beginning and ending, a source and sink of B field lines, you then pulled the *ULTIMATE* form of fraud. You cheated. You used plasma. That was a HUGE form of fraud. No wonder I personally could not understand how you expected to get magnetic reconnection without a plasma. You can't. :(

Rather than admit *ANY* of the *MANY* mistakes that you have made in this thread, including your BLATANT form of bait and switch fraud, you're continuing to attack the individual. How predicable and how sad.

Hater behaviors are all alike. The topics change, but the personal attack behaviors are *IDENTICAL*.
 
Last edited:
Boo. You keep using that emotionally charged word. You are not interested in debate.

Keep in mind that Tim was flailing away at EU theory before I personally even became involved in the topic. Tim was slugging it out publicly with Donald Scott before I'd even heard of the idea, even going to all the trouble to put up a website about his criticisms. IMO I simply became a "target" in Tim's mind the moment I started to publicly support Alfven's work.

In case you're keeping score, without a monopole they are all up a metaphysical creek without a physical paddle in terms of B field *LINE* reconnection. Without a monopole, "FOREGETABOUTIT"! B lines cannot be broken into segments. They have no sources or sinks. They have no beginnings or endings. They do have NULLS sometimes. :)

This whole thing has evidently been a sham from the start. Clinger never produced magnetic reconnection without plasma. He simply added plasma and then blamed me for *HIS* mistake in *HIS* original claim. Wow.
 
Last edited:
I guess it's conceivable that, contrary to all appearances, Michael Mozina is a nice young man who likes to solve differential equations as he eats his corn flakes, and conducts experiments in his basement that he designed with an eye toward falsifying his hypotheses, even as he ignores all the math that's been posted here or in the hundreds of research papers on magnetic reconnection, runs away from the experiment I've been suggesting to him for most of the past year, denies the empirical reality of astronomical observations because they weren't performed inside a laboratory, ignores the empirical reality of controlled laboratory experiments that reproduce magnetic reconnection without plasma, blathers about sources, sinks, and monopoles in magnetic fields that quite obviously obey Gauss's law for magnetism, repeats a popular myth as though repetition of that falsehood could overcome the rigorous mathematical refutations of that myth that several of us have presented within this thread, says magnetic flux is a euphemism for field-aligned currents, tries to derail serious discussion of scientific issues by inventing spurious phrases such as "current reconnection" or "reconnections per unit length" and insisting they be discussed instead, tries to derail serious discussion of scientific issues by dragging in irrelevancies such as "electrical discharge" and "equation 17" and insisting they be discussed instead, invents ridiculous mistakes (such as redefining "inductance" to "reconnection") so he can accuse serious discussants of having made those mistakes, compares legitimate scientists to creationists, accuses anyone who uses mathematics to support a scientific point of saying "God did it", routinely describes rigorous mathematical arguments as "PURE HANDWAVING", dismisses animations constructed directly from the laws of physics as mere "cartoons", informs all and sundry that he has read Cosmic Plasma as if that could compensate for his abject ignorance of freshman-level calculus and physics, asks all and sundry whether they have read Cosmic Plasma as though that question could discredit the legitimate math and science they have been presenting, accuses all and sundry of "pure blind ignorance", "arrogance", "OUTRAGEOUS claims", "pure hatred", "BLIND FAITH", of refusing "to educate themselves", of "the very WORST type of denial based "creationist" beliefs", of loving "to attack the individual just like a creationists", describes sound arguments as "IRRATIONAL and based on PURE IGNORANCE and irrational hatred", "boloney" [sic], "TOTALLY FUBAR", "CHILDISH", tells scientists who earned their academic degrees with highest honors that they have "just earned a GIANT *F*", tells those scientists they "don't know the difference between magnetic flux density changes and "magnetic reconnection" and "don't even understand BASIC theory", believes he has the power to prevent others from presenting the next part of a tutorial whose outline has already been given, misrepresents others' posts, doesn't understand that a choice of Cartesian coordinate systems is arbitrary and has no effect on the physics, routinely gets confused about the distinctions between charge, current, and electric fields, doesn't know what the magnetic field of a current-carrying wire looks like, doesn't know that magnetic fields can exist within a vacuum, doesn't know that magnetic fields can change within a vacuum, cannot state Gauss's law for magnetism correctly, regards himself as this thread's foremost authority on magnetic fields, finally admits "his graph is fine, his math is fine" but says "his understanding of that math and WHAT that graph actually means stinks to high heaven", and finally admits that "magnetic flux densities will shift along with magnetic field topologies" (which is exactly what we mean by magnetic reconnection) even as he continues to deny magnetic reconnection.

Yes, it's conceivable that Michael Mozina has just been putting us on, and that his 2000+ posts in this thread and 8000+ posts in this forum have all been some kind of performance art designed to make fun of EU pseudoscientists and physics crackpots in general.

If so, then he fooled me completely. I thought he was serious.

It just does not seem possible that anyone who has any real interest in these topics could be so dense. So ..., it had occurred to me many months ago on another thread (dark matter, dark energy, negative pressure, electric universe?) that this could be a spoof. Lacking any real knowledge of physics and having no skills in mathematics, this is just the way some unemployed character stuck in his home with no social life or family entertains himself.
 
It just does not seem possible that anyone who has any real interest in these topics could be so dense. So ..., it had occurred to me many months ago on another thread (dark matter, dark energy, negative pressure, electric universe?) that this could be a spoof. Lacking any real knowledge of physics and having no skills in mathematics, this is just the way some unemployed character stuck in his home with no social life or family entertains himself.

FYI, I've been happily married now for over 20 years, with two teenage daughters. I have also been self employed for over 18 years and currently serve over 9000 clients, including the US Airforce, school districts and many corporate organizations. My online time is more of a "hobby", an 'escape' from THAT teenage daughter social life. :) Actually however, most of my online time occurs at work between technical support calls.

I guess since Haters are all hell bent on NEVER educating themselves, involving the reading of actual related textbooks, in this case on the topic of plasma physics, the only thing they can actually do is spew hatred at individuals. How sad. Why don't you two consider splitting the cost of buying a real textbook on plasma physics? It would do you two a world of good, I assure you. Education is a good thing.
 
Last edited:
Let's put it this way: If I drop a charged particle, positive or negative, at the X in the NULL, it's not necessarily going to accelerate in any particular direction with respect to X or Y as long as all the pole strengths remain constant. On the other hand, I can drop that test particle anywhere else and watch it accelerate in some direction. That movement and acceleration of a charged particle is a form of "current". That current coming up through the X in Priest's source/sink paper is turned into "magnetic charge" at equation 17. Without current up the Z axis at X, no 'reconnection' process is possible.

Technically a charged particle has to be moving through the magnetic field or the magnetic field needs to be changing over time in order for that charged particle to experience an induced Electromotive Force from that magnetic field, which is why a small magnetic particle is the test particle for magnetic fields (it will align to a static field). In either case if you are claiming that a moving charged particle will experience no EMF or a magnetic particle will have no field to align to at the null point, then you are claiming no magnetic field (and thus no field line(s)) at that point (you could have just admitted it instead of pretending like you weren’t). That you try to talk about locations other than the specific null point (and that "Priest's source/sink paper") merely exacerbates your obvious pretence.

Hmmm. No, that's not quite what I meant.

Really so what exactly would be the difference between your “magnet reconnection” and magnetic reconnection then?



When the magnets are apart, they simply "attract", or "repulse", or create "magnetic flux changes over time" due to movement over time. There was a point in PS's animation where the magnetic are rotating and creating a magnetic flux change as a result. Any of those kinds of processes will INDUCE CURRENT in plasma.

What plasma between or around the refrigerator magnets are you referring to? When you get those refrigerator magnets to switch from "attract" to "repulse" and even back again, you have reconnected their magnetic fields.

At the level of 'physical things' the magnets themselves can physically "reconnect" and the H lines *INSIDE* the magnets will reconnect accordingly. Likewise, in plasma, the particles themselves can 'reconnect' and the "currents' can "reconnect", but the magnetic lines themselves cannot "reconnect" because no monopoles exist in nature.

Yet you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets that never contact each other. So clearly whatever “level of 'physical things'” your referring to doesn’t include physical things that exist in many peoples kitchens.

Is that any better of any explanation of my position?

No it simply explains your position as being as untenable as it was already demonstrated to be before, so no better.


You really might want to checkout that magnetic reconnection source/sink paper by Priest and checkout equations 16 and 17. At that point, Priest simply "converts" current running through the Z axis into "magnetic charge" that attaches itself to "lines" along the X,Y axis. What's really going on at the level of physics is that currents are being INDUCED into various X,Y lines, and currents are being "redirected" from the Z axis into different directions. They start coming OUT of the Z axis and flowing into the X,Y axis.

The real 'source' of kinetic energy is the E field, not the NULL. The NULL simply becomes the focal point of current running up through the Z axis. That CURRENT can get redirected into the X,Y axis. Changes in the flow of current might also create magnetic flux changes that induce CURRENT in the various lines flowing from the NULL. What CANNOT happen is any sort of B LINE reconnection without a monopole.

You really might want to check out just a couple of refrigerator magnets.







No, I'm trying to make a very specific and highly important point. "Reconnection" is not a "plasma optional" process Tim.


No, Tim has just consistently avoided meeting me in the middle and accepting the fact that the process isn't "plasma/current optional" as demonstrated in Priests equation 16&17.


Were you only half wrong, then perhaps someone could meet you “in the middle”. Get some refrigerator magnets then let us know when you’ve found the plasma in the process or the “currents” that ‘reconnect’ as you require.


Yes, I know he has charged particles in his "vacuum" RC, otherwise "reconnection" and charged particle acceleration doesn't happen. Equation 17 is zero without some charged particles. Unlike you, I've also read AN ENTIRE BOOK by Somov, including chapter 16 where he relates it all back to Alfven's views. But you wouldn't know anything about that, since your knowledge is limited to a nifty quote mine here and there and devoid of any actual (plasma) physics.


“"reconnection" and charged particle acceleration doesn't happen.”? So reconnection without “charged particle acceleration” can, see that wasn’t so hard.
 
Last edited:
IMO The Man, you are confusing magnetic flux changes over time, and the reconnection of solid *OBJECTS* (like magnets or plasma particles), with B field *LINE* reconnection. In plasma (or the vacuum) it's not the monopole that does the work in terms of the kinetic energy transfer, and the making and breaking of B lines. It's the CURRENT through the Z axis that get's "redirected" and INDUCED current in the plasma that does all the actual work in terms of kinetic energy. It's the E field that provides the source and sink for charged particle kinetic energy.
 
Last edited:
Mozina vs Physics

IMO, it's highly disappointing you chose "hate" over science Tim. :(
Boo. You keep using that emotionally charged word. You are not interested in debate.
IMO I simply became a "target" in Tim's mind the moment I started to publicly support Alfven's work.


I choose physics. I always choose physics. I am actually pretty good at it, though far from flawless. After receiving my BS degree I thought I knew physics pretty well. But as a graduate student and working physicist I discovered this was a delusion and became impressed by how much I did not know. I have been a student of physics ever since, every once in a while I learn something. One of the reasons I take part in discussions like this one is that there are people here who know things I don't know and I have no problem learning from them. I particularly like learning from 5 year-olds who ask naive questions. I give them adequate answers for a 5 year-old and then go home and spend the rest of the day trying to figure out what the real answer might be. Mozina teaches me the way the 5 year-old does, the main difference being that his questions are a bit more complicated, but the 5 year-old is willing to believe that "adults" know more than they do (a wise point of view), while Mozina will not suffer the terrible embarrassment of knowing less than any other living human being. The extreme arrogance does bring out the combative spirit I admit, as it does with other pseudo-science crackpots I have dealt with over the years. Even as a student I had a reputation for dealing with the fringes, and the physics department faculty would always transfer the "Einstein was stupid" folks to me.

I choose physics. I always choose physics. I spend hours, often I spend days preparing my answers to Mozina's claims, trying to make sure that my intuition is not leading me astray. Usually when I make some kind of careless mistake it's because I respond too quickly (I can't do anything quickly & right, which is one reason why I play chess but rarely play speed chess - I am just too slow). Mozina did not simply become a "target", and certainly not because of Alfven; why would anyone with half a brain automatically dismiss anything about physics from a Nobel Prize winner in that field? No, I first encountered Mozina by virtue of his iron-sun claims, which are about as crackpotty and pseudo-scientific as it is possible to get (which may be granting the idea far more intellectual credit than it deserves).

I don't know what Mozina chooses; his own ego perhaps, from all appearances, but I always choose physics, and there are no doubts in my mind at all about the extremely unreliable nature of Mozina's arguments & claims. In this case there can be no question, and there is no question, that his claims about magnetic reconnection are pure crackpot, pure pseudoscience, absolutely and unquestionably wrong. His claims deeply violate the laws of physics, when they don't simply ignore them altogether, and are so obviously wrong that I cannot imagine that he has ever cracked open a book on any topic related to science in his entire life. I suppose it is possible (the laws of physics do not prohibit it), but the empirical evidence is highly limited to say the least.

In case you're keeping score, without a monopole they are all up a metaphysical creek without a physical paddle in terms of B field *LINE* reconnection. Without a monopole, "FOREGETABOUTIT"! B lines cannot be broken into segments. They have no sources or sinks. They have no beginnings or endings. They do have NULLS sometimes. :)


Crackpot. Pseudoscience. Nonsense. Stupid. Hopeless. Wrong. It is absolutely not at all true that monopoles are necessary for magnetic field line reconnection. This is not just an idle claim, it is something which can be, and has been, formally & logically proven. Mozina can neither understand nor deal with this proof, so he makes up some cheap argument about "origin", or some cheap argument about "equation 17" and runs and hides from the physics he will never in his life understand. Fear of learning can evidently be a powerful thing. Magnetic field lines can & do terminate at null points. This is something else which is not just an idle claim, something that can be, and has been, formally & logically proven. Mozina's arguments are scientifically & intellectually brain-dead wrong. Physics proves it conclusively. The argument is over except for the death-rattles of Mozina's arguments, that continue to echo through the pages of JREF.

This whole thing has evidently been a sham from the start. Clinger never produced magnetic reconnection without plasma. He simply added plasma and then blamed me for *HIS* mistake in *HIS* original claim. Wow.


Crackpot. Pseudoscience. Nonsense. Stupid. Hopeless. Wrong. Clinger, and I, have produced magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. If Mozina knew as much as he claims to know about physics, he could do the math, do the physics, make the computer simulation himself. But he can't, and wouldn't even if he could. I already know in advance what his complaint here will be ...

The way a scientific debate is *SUPPOSED* to work, is one side is SUPPOSED to *PRESENT *PUBLISHED* EVIDENCE* to support their claim. ... but again you provided no SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE to support your claim that "magnetic reconnection" could occur without a plasma


No doubt providing published evidence is a legitimate tactic in a scientific debate. However, in a debate between scientists, we can also present original work. That's what Clinger did. The idea that magnetic reconnection in vacuo cannot be accepted unless there is a publication trail for it is weak at best, but pure crackpot when it goes along with ignoring an explicit original proof. So, are there any books or papers that describe magnetic reconnection in vacuo? I doubt it. Why would anyone ever bother to put such a thing in a paper or a book? Aside from being painfully obvious (quite regardless of Mozina's complaints to the contrary), truth be told, it's boring. I mean really boring. Not much happens in a vacuum. Now, start magnetically reconnecting in a plasma, where there are charged particles to push around, and things can get really exciting really fast. Suddenly we have plenty of book & paper fodder enough for everyone! Curiously, perhaps, it is simply not the case that literally everything appears between the covers of a book or in the pages of a journal. That's the big reason why we go to school & learn, so we can deal with all the stuff not found in books & papers.

Rather than admit *ANY* of the *MANY* mistakes that you have made in this thread, including your BLATANT form of bait and switch fraud, you're continuing to attack the individual. How predicable and how sad. Hater behaviors are all alike. The topics change, but the personal attack behaviors are *IDENTICAL*.


Mozina provides us with a powerful self-portrait. There is only one "hater" in this thread, and Mozina is it, pure & simple. Mozina love to trade insults and personal barbs, and will readily engage anyone who provokes him or whom he can provoke, and will favor personal attacks over substantive arguments most of the time. This is not surprising; the more time we spend distracted by irrelevancies, red-herrings or personal attacks, the less time there is to dwell on Mozina's numerous and substantial mistakes.

After all these years I have learned that it is hopeless and I long ago gave up on the notion the Mozina, or those like him, might ever learn something real. I could be wrong, and it would surely be nice if I were, but realistically, it's unlikely that I am wrong. I don't do this for Mozina, I do it for a combination of myself and the legendary "lurker". As I said before, I can learn from the effort of preparing my own responses, or by reading those from others. I am also heavily involved in public education; I do a fair amount of writing and even more public speaking, usually for astronomy clubs, but also for school groups or anyone else willing to listen. I want the "lurker" to see the difference between the content & style of real science, versus the content & style of pseudoscience. Most people, when they see Mozina interact with real science & real scientists, or just interact with normally intelligent people, will quickly recognize that his is the pseudoscience and thereby learn something. If they learn something from me, so much the better, but even if all that happens is to spot the crackpot, that's reason enough to be here doing this, when time allows.

I see no reason to alter the opinions I have expressed in the past, for example ...

From 26 August 2010:
Mozina is completely wrong about dark matter, completely wrong about dark energy, completely wrong about magnetic reconnection, completely wrong about any iron surface on the sun, completely wrong about what constitutes empirical science, just plain completely wrong about everything. And I suspect that the vast majority of all you "lurkers" out there have figured that out for yourself. In any case, I stand by what I have posted, and I note that Mozina has never been able to muster an objective argument against any of it.


From 13 September 2010:
It is important to realize how deep Mozina's self-deception runs. He has set himself up as a maverick opposed to literally every branch of modern science. His ideas don't just fail the test of standard thermodynamics but also fail the test of plasma physics and electromagnetism, in which areas he falsely claims his ideas are superior to standard physics. The most efficient way to learn from discussions with Mozina is to assume that literally everything he says is not possible and have confidence that the opposite of what he says is the real truth. That might occasionally lead you astray, but not much.
 
I choose physics. I always choose physics. I am actually pretty good at it, though far from flawless.

Don't you think that was true of Alfven too? Didn't he write about these very same topics in terms of "circuits" and "double layers", rather than "magnetic reconnection", a concept that he personally labelled "pseudoscience"?

After receiving my BS degree I thought I knew physics pretty well. But as a graduate student and working physicist I discovered this was a delusion and became impressed by how much I did not know. I have been a student of physics ever since, every once in a while I learn something. One of the reasons I take part in discussions like this one is that there are people here who know things I don't know and I have no problem learning from them.

Me too Tim. As I said before, I've personally very much enjoyed the many things that you've taught me over the years. It would be my great pleasure to *EVENTUALLY* teach you just ONE thing about plasma. That's sort of my secret goal you know. :)

I particularly like learning from 5 year-olds

What I've never understood about you is why you feel the need to attack individuals rather than to stick to the topic. Unless one of you is hiding a monopole up your sleeve, abandon all hope of B field *LINE* reconnection Tim. It's never going to happen.

If and when you get around to personally admitting that Clinger's claim about Dungey's "magnetic reconnection" happening *WITHOUT* plasma is utterly *BOGUS* and FALSE, let me know. Until then your actions in terms of personal attacks are beneath your skills as a "scientist" IMO.

Got a monopole, yes or no?
 
Last edited:
It's certainly possible, if it were The Blob who had the interest in these topics. :D

Note: This joke is not meant as an insult to anyone.

Sure, skirt the edges and play in the gray areas, and then throw in a disclaimer at the end no less. :) That's funny. :) I can't help but enjoy your sense of humor.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom