Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have not knowingly lied about what you have said.
MM: I have called you a liar becuase you have lied as documented in this post
Those lies include your quote mining of Peratt.
I have not lied about Somov.

All of these statements are false. Knowingly or unknowingly you've consistently lied about my position, Peratt's position and now Somov's statements. You're consistently batting 1000% in terms of pure denial or pure misrepresentation of scientific documents, including Dungey's use of the term *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in relationship to solar flares and plasma. It's one big denial-lie-hate-go-round around here.
 
I am not telling you that this is the *BEST* source - it is*A* source.

It's not *A* source! Somov's example *INCLUDES* currents/plasmas!

I am telling you that you are deluded about Somov's example including plasma.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III

I'm telling you that you've never read *ANY* of Somov's books and I'm telling you that CURRENT is a *PLASMA*. I'm telling you like it is. Deal with it.
 
What exactly about parallel electric currents are you having trouble comprehending?
Somov is stating that parallel electric currents exist. Duh :jaw-dropp!
Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of 2 parallel electric currents of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 4.17.
What exactly about in a vacuum are you having trouble comprehending?
What exactly about no mention of plasma until after the example has been finished being discussed are you having trouble comprehending?

Can you see why an fantasy that his example contains plasma seems delusional?
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III
 
I've seen creationists present *MUCH* better arguments and shoot themselves in the foot less often than EU haters. This conversation is just SAD. Not only do you *NOT* have legitimate published references to support your case, you've set YOURSELVES up as *THE* authority on all things related to 'magnetic reconnection'. Nevermind the fact that the vast majority of the hater core hasn't ever read a book on plasma physics, and nevermind the fact that we have to believe that physicists all over the planet published "bad information", not your beloved CLINGER! What a sad little hater cult.
 
Last edited:
As ELECTRONS (or protons) traverse that "vacuum" they are a form of PLASMA! OMG. I've seen hard core denial before but this is absolutely pathetic!
OMG. I've seen hard core ignorance before but this is absolutely pathetic!
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III

One more time (and the last time):
Somov has theoretical currents in a vaccuum. His example just has the currents and a vacuuum. There is no assumption about the cause of the currents. They are just there.

Somov goes onto MR in a plasma after this section. It is there that he inroduces currents and current sheets in a plasma.
 
One more time (and the last time):
Somov has theoretical currents in a vaccuum. His example just has the currents and a vacuuum. There is no assumption about the cause of the currents. They are just there.

One more time (and I'll repeat myself as long as necessary):

Somov introduced *PLASMA* in the form of CURRENT. You can't ignore his introduction of plasma particles in the form of current and current sheets. I won't let you. Those currents are plasma.
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7798491&postcount=5527

There you go. Deny those facts all you like but CURRENT is PLASMA.
You are persisting with the fantasy that Somov's example contains plasma.

Here is Somov's example: "Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of 2 parallel electric currents of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 4.17. ".
No plasma. Just theoretical currents and vacuum.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III
 
You are persisting with the fantasy that Somov's example contains plasma.

Here is Somov's example: "Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of 2 parallel electric currents of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 4.17. ".
No plasma. Just theoretical currents and vacuum.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III

It is you that suffer from the serious delusion that CURRENT in a vacuum is NOT PLASMA. What exactly do you figure that current is made of *OTHER THAN* electrons and/or protons?
 
Michael Mozina demonstrates his incompetence, part 2

Anybody but Clinger eh? The *easier*, *simpler* and more *LOGICAL* option is that only one Phd made a mistake, namely CLINGER!
The simpler and more logical option is that Michael Mozina continues to make mistakes.

As far as I can tell only *ONE* Phd has it wrong, specifically CLINGER.
Michael Mozina's denials of magnetic reconnection come down to Michael Mozina's insistence upon his own personal definitions and interpretations of the math, based on nothing more than Michael Mozina's own personal authority and math skills, against the definition and math provided by hundreds of research papers in plasma physics.

Yes, it's Michael Mozina against the scientific world, and Michael Mozina appeals to majority opinion.

That may not be one of his better arguments.

So what? Clinger said he didn't NEED plasma in the first place and he claimed this was a FRESHMAN experiment Tim. He needs to show lines beginning and ending *WITHOUT* plasmas, not with them.
Done, more than a week ago:
http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/

Magnetic field lines form and, as they move,
Combine: nor can thy shouts of "NULL!" remove
The math that says they reconnect sans
Plasma, in a vacuum, though you disapprove:
​

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr100.gif[/qimg]

Get a grip! Currents ARE plasma! Duh!
Currents that run through conducting rods are plasma?

Michael Mozina said it, and he's read five books on plasma physics, so who are we to argue?

Currents in a vacuum is also known as "plasma" in a vacuum!

BS. A "current" in a "vacuum" is a "plasma"!

I'm telling you that you've never read *ANY* of Somov's books and I'm telling you that CURRENT is a *PLASMA*. I'm telling you like it is. Deal with it.

There you go. Deny those facts all you like but in a vacuum, CURRENT is PLASMA.

It is you that suffer from the serious delusion that CURRENT in a vacuum is NOT PLASMA. What exactly do you figure that current is made of *OTHER THAN* electrons and/or protons?
ETA: Highlighting is Michael Mozina's.
 
Last edited:
In its entire history, including all of the threads in all ten of its areas, the Thunderbolts forum has barely ten times the number of posts as this one thread in the JREF Forum.

Among the deniers of magnetic reconnection who are active at the Thunderbolts site, I can think of only two who understand electromagnetism better than Michael Mozina: Wal Thornhill and Donald E Scott. (There must be more, because that's an extremely low bar, but those are the only two I can think of.) Thornhill's and Scott's arguments aren't any better than Michael Mozina's. In fact, their arguments are virtually identical to Michael Mozina's, probably because Michael Mozina is basically parroting their arguments.

If you set the bar that low, there are - very likely - at least a half dozen others, possibly more (not counting the physicists (etc) who have - for various reasons - posted there, briefly, before being permabanned). Anyone want names?

IIRC, there's one (regular, non-banned) member who clearly understands this topic far better than MM, and whose objections (if that's the right word) to magnetic reconnection seem to reflect a more realistic understanding of the relevant physics. It's a pity MM has (apparently) never read posts by this person; many hundred posts in this thread would not need to have been written if he (MM) had. Well, assuming MM actually understood what is written in that forum ...

Oh, and at least Scott seems conversant with some of the relevant math (Thornhill has not, ever, to the best of my knowledge, demonstrated an understanding any deeper than MM's).
 
MM: Where are the magnetic monopoles in a plasma

A little question for Michael Mozina:
Magnetic reconnection is the breaking and reconnection of magnetic field lines.
You insist that this cannot happen without magnetic monopoles and back this up by citing undergraduate level (i.e. where plasma physics is not covered) web pages and Wikipedia.
But you also allow that magnetic reconnection can happen in a plasma.

Michael Mozina
Where are the magnetic monopoles in a plasma?
Why can we not detect them?
 
Get a grip! Currents ARE plasma! Duh!
Currents that run through conducting rods are plasma?

Michael Mozina said it, and he's read five books on plasma physics, so who are we to argue?

Currents in a vacuum is also known as "plasma" in a vacuum!

BS. A "current" in a "vacuum" is a "plasma"!

I'm telling you that you've never read *ANY* of Somov's books and I'm telling you that CURRENT is a *PLASMA*. I'm telling you like it is. Deal with it.

There you go. Deny those facts all you like but in a vacuum, CURRENT is PLASMA.

It is you that suffer from the serious delusion that CURRENT in a vacuum is NOT PLASMA. What exactly do you figure that current is made of *OTHER THAN* electrons and/or protons?

ETA: Highlighting is Michael Mozina's.


That seems to be pretty much the staple argument in the electric Sun advocates' toolkit. It's reminiscent of this assertion which was supported by nothing more than belligerent insistence...

For the record, I said that a solar flare *IS* an electrical discharge.


That was almost a year ago, and no objective support has been offered for that nonsense either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom