Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You have serious issues. A need for attention, for sure, amongst other things.

Do you say that to EVERYONE that starts a thread on some topic in cyberspace? What is YOUR emotional motive for fixating on *INDIVIDUALS* rather than the topic of this thread?
 
Last edited:
That is only because in the presence of a plasm (like in the Earth's magnetotail) more interesting stuff in happening. MRx in vacuum is rather boring,

I'll say. :)

it's only field lines making new connections as the move through the X point (null-point) for the rest nothing happens.

What NEW connections? All the lines are CREATED BY the currents running through the various poles and every line forms as a full full loop, without a beginning and without an end.

If there is plasma, then you get the nice stuff going on like plasma acceleration of plasma perpendicular to the direction of the magnetic field,through the relaxation of the tension of the magnetic field, and we arrive e.g. at the nothern and southern lights.

And in the absence of plasma, only FLUX CHANGE occurs in a vacuum and that's it. Origin the Null never grows up to become an adult NEUTRAL so no ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES occur.
 
Last edited:
What NEW connections? All the lines are CREATED BY the currents running through the various poles and every line forms as a full full loop, without a beginning and without an end.

Can you really be so dense? Even Somov discusses this in his "vacuum reconnection" in e.g. Section 1.1.2 of his "plasma astrophysics part 2" book, where it actually says at the end of that section that:

Somov said:
Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as

the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charged particle or particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.

In this sense, a collisionless reconnection – the physical process in a hightemperature rarefied plasma such as the solar corona, geomagnetic tail,
fusion plasmas, and so on – is simpler for understanding than reconnection in a highly-conducting collisional space plasma.

The charged particle here is just a test particle that you may put there, however, it need not be there. And really, look at the pictures that Somov draws in that section, see how the connections of the field lines have to be changed when he moves the two currents (which are just electric wires carrying a current) apart, which is basically the same a Clinger changing the current. This all is a direct consequence of Maxwell's equations and the definition of a vector field

And in the absence of plasma, only FLUX CHANGE occurs in a vacuum and that's it. Origin the Null never grows up to become an adult NEUTRAL so no ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES occur.

What is "flux change" give it a correct description please, alone with your Mozinawordphysics it is impossible to work with.

What ever does "origin the Null" mean? You are so stuck with holding on to your first impression of something you read but do not understand that we now have the "origin the Null" even though the origin (of the frakking GRAPH) can be anywhere you like, it is just for calculations easier if it is in the middle of the two or four currents, for obvious reasons.

And what is a frakkin "adult NEUTRAL"???

Keep on inventing more new terms and you will be all alone in the Moziverse.

There is no real scientific discussion possible with you, because you are stuck in your misinterpretations. I bet you feel like you are a modern day Galileo.
 
Can you really be so dense?

Can you *CHEAT* at debate any more than you do? Can you be so DENSE as to actually believe that attacking the individual is going to work in my case? How many YEARS have I been at this now?

Even Somov discusses this in his "vacuum reconnection" in e.g. Section 1.1.2 of his "plasma astrophysics part 2" book, where it actually says at the end of that section that:

It says that *PLAMSA* is involved!

The charged particle here is just a test particle that you may put there, however, it need not be there. And really, look at the pictures that Somov draws in that section, see how the connections of the field lines have to be changed when he moves the two currents (which are just electric wires carrying a current) apart, which is basically the same a Clinger changing the current. This all is a direct consequence of Maxwell's equations and the definition of a vector field

As long as you have *PLASMA*, I'm sure you will get "reconnection" and particle acceleration. Without it, I'm sure you won't!

What is "flux change" give it a correct description please, alone with your Mozinawordphysics it is impossible to work with.

Go look it up for yourself! I'm not your physics mommy. Flux changes occur when you change the flow of current in one or more of the poles.

What ever does "origin the Null" mean?

According to Clinger, that's the beginning of every B line in the B line universe.

You are so stuck with holding on to your first impression of something you read but do not understand that we now have the "origin the Null" even though the origin (of the frakking GRAPH) can be anywhere you like, it is just for calculations easier if it is in the middle of the two or four currents, for obvious reasons.

It's just a frigging NULL. That's it! It's not the "beginning" of any magnetic line. It's not the ENDING of any magnetic line. It's just a simple, boring, non-interesting *NULL*. NOTHING begins there. NOTHING ends there. NOTHING does anything there. FLUX CHANGE happens *EVERYWHERE*, not just in the NULL.

And what is a frakkin "adult NEUTRAL"???

Keep on inventing more new terms and you will be all alone in the Moziverse.

There is no real scientific discussion possible with you, because you are stuck in your misinterpretations. I bet you feel like you are a modern day Galileo.

That's just pure BS. A NEUTRAL forms when the CURRENT flows through the Z axis. A NULL has no plasmas, whereas a NEUTRAL is composed *OF* plasma. Without a plasma. Origin the NULL is a boring NOTHING. It's the 'beginning' of NOTHING. It's the end of NOTHING. IT'S NOTHING!
 
Last edited:
B *LINES* are incapable of having a beginning or an end, a source or a sink. The only thing that 'reconnects' inside of plasma are CURRENTS charged particles. There's no monopole, so there's no "magnetic charge". Get over it already.

This is incorrect. At a null point, B lines may begin or end, because there is an infinitesimal place where they don't exist at all.

ETA: "B lines don't have a source or sink" is in fact correct, as stated above.
 
Last edited:
This is incorrect. At a null point, B lines may begin or end, because there is an infinitesimal place where they don't exist at all.

You have that backwards. The *WHOLE* field simply DOES NOT EXIST THERE at all. It's just a NULL. NOTHING begins there. NOTHING ends there. NOTHING physically exists there. It's simply a NULL.

All *FIELDS* form as a complete and full CONTINUUM. They aren't simplified discrete lines as you imagine them to be in your "simplified" view of a magnetic FIELD. The only way a B line could begin or end at an POINT (even a NULL) is *IF* monopoles existed. The NULL isn't special. A MONOPOLE would be special, and capable of allowing lines to 'begin' or 'end' as some point. A NULL is just a NULL. Nothing begins there.
 
Can you *CHEAT* at debate any more than you do? Can you be so DENSE as to actually believe that attacking the individual is going to work in my case? How many YEARS have I been at this now?


How has the state and body of knowledge of solar and plasma physics advanced because of all those years of alleged involvement?

As long as you have *PLASMA*, I'm sure you will get "reconnection" and particle acceleration. Without it, I'm sure you won't!


That has been repeatedly demonstrated to be incorrect to the satisfaction of the other participants in this discussion.

What ever does "origin the Null" mean?
According to Clinger, that's the beginning of every B line in the B line universe.


It does not appear that W.D.Clinger has ever used the term "Origin the Null", so whatever it might mean, it's not "according to Clinger".

It's just a frigging NULL. That's it! It's not the "beginning" of any magnetic line. It's not the ENDING of any magnetic line. It's just a simple, boring, non-interesting *NULL*. NOTHING begins there. NOTHING ends there. NOTHING does anything there. FLUX CHANGE happens *EVERYWHERE*, not just in the NULL.

[...]

That's just pure BS. A NEUTRAL forms when the CURRENT flows through the Z axis. A NULL has no plasmas, whereas a NEUTRAL is composed *OF* plasma. Without a plasma. Origin the NULL is a boring NOTHING. It's the 'beginning' of NOTHING. It's the end of NOTHING. IT'S NOTHING!


Whatever all that is supposed to mean, if it's supposed to mean anything at all, as it stands it is definitively gibberish.
 
How has the state and body of knowledge of solar and plasma physics advanced because of all those years of alleged involvement?

The operative word in your question is PLASMA PHYSICS. Clinger doesn't have plasma. That's where his problems begin and end.

That has been repeatedly demonstrated to be incorrect to the satisfaction of the other participants in this discussion.

I've heard creationists make similar statements based on pure handwaves such as Clinger's never to be published handwave of a presentation. Origin the Null religion has to be THE most pathetic religion on the planet. ;) Having faith in a God as a creator is one thing. Having faith that a simple NULL is a "beginning" of a B line is just weird.

It does not appear that W.D.Clinger has ever used the term "Origin the Null", so whatever it might mean, it's not "according to Clinger".

According to Clinger, B lines "begin" at some point. According to those dozen or so published references I provided, that's just BS.

Whatever all that is supposed to mean, if it's supposed to mean anything at all, as it stands it is definitively gibberish.

The only thing that is "gibberish" is pretty much everything that comes out of your mouth in this thread.
 
Last edited:
The one thing that's been someone unusual about this cycle IMO is that the southern hemisphere hasn't been as active yet as the northern hemisphere, or at least there are few "interacting" active regions that interact over the equator.

During the last cycle there were more active regions on both sides of the equator and they interacted quite a bit. I imagine as this solar cycle continues to progress toward full activity that we'll see more of that cross hemisphere activity, but thus far the active regions has been concentrated in one hemisphere or the other, but not both hemispheres at the same time.
 
The only way a B line could begin or end at an POINT (even a NULL) is *IF* monopoles existed. The NULL isn't special. A MONOPOLE would be special, and capable of allowing lines to 'begin' or 'end' as some point. A NULL is just a NULL. Nothing begins there.

A place that has 0 B field has no field line, because there is no field there. As stated by others, it's not a sink or a source since the same number of lines approach the null point. They of course can reach the null point, but they approach it.

I don't know why I bother. You're not listening.
 
A reminder in case anybody missed it the first time around:




The claim that magnetic field lines do not ever end at a null point, in light of a formal proof that they do, is stupid. Just plain stupid. The incessant repetition of that which is stupid will not suddenly make it un-stupid after a sufficient number of times. It just makes it stupid more often that it would otherwise have been.

All of the rapid fire examples provided by Mozina, without any exception, adhere to my previous statement.
It's kinda amazing, shocking, saddening (and so on), all at the same time.

I mean, you'd think an inability to understand the relevant math would produce a little humility and a desire to learn. Yet here we have MM, in a really deep hole, continuing to dig with all his might. :jaw-dropp
 
Michael Mozina's dishonesty, part 1

Michael Mozina routinely uses quotes to pretend others have been using the silly phrases he invented. That's dishonest.

What ever does "origin the Null" mean?

According to Clinger, that's the beginning of every B line in the B line universe.
No. Michael Mozina is lying. The phrase in quotes is Michael Mozina's, not mine.

As I have noted elsewhere:
Mozina likes to invent absurd phrases so he can pretend they were spoken by his opponents. He may then ridicule the phrase he invented for days, weeks, months, or years.
​

As for the rest of Michael Mozina's claim quoted above, that too appears to be a lie. He's been lying about this since at least 11 November:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7751177#post7751177
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7751270#post7751270

As I have noted elsewhere, however:
...it's hard to know whether Mozina is lying or just doesn't understand the difference between existential and universal quantification.
​

That's just pure BS. A NEUTRAL forms when the CURRENT flows through the Z axis. A NULL has no plasmas, whereas a NEUTRAL is composed *OF* plasma. Without a plasma. Origin the NULL is a boring NOTHING. It's the 'beginning' of NOTHING. It's the end of NOTHING. IT'S NOTHING!
What Michael Mozina said there is pure BS. The above definition of "NEUTRAL" is Michael Mozina's own invention. His claim that a "NULL has no plasmas, whereas a NEUTRAL is composed *OF* plasma" is Michael Mozina's own invention. "Origin the NULL" is a silly phrase that Michael Mozina invented so he could put it in quotes and ridicule it.

Michael Mozina excels at ridiculing straw men he invents. That's dishonest.

All *FIELDS* form as a complete and full CONTINUUM. They aren't simplified discrete lines as you imagine them to be in your "simplified" view of a magnetic FIELD.
It would be hard to underestimate Michael Mozina's understanding of vector fields, and no other participant in this thread has demonstrated so much confusion about the relationships between vector fields and field lines.

In the context of this thread, a magnetic field is a vector field: a mapping from 3-dimensional Euclidean space to its 3-dimensional tangent bundle. Magnetic field lines are 1-parameter curves that run parallel to the magnetic field, which means that, at every point p on the curve, the magnetic field at p is a vector tangent to the curve at p with magnitude determined by the derivative of the curve with respect to its parameter. In short, the magnetic field lines of a magnetic field B are the 1-parameter curves c(λ) that satisfy the following differential equation:
dc/dλ = B​

Yes, a stationary magnetic field consists of a 3-dimensional continuum of 3-vectors, and a time-varying magnetic field consists of a 4-dimensional continuum of 3-vectors. In most magnetic fields, there will also be an uncountable (continuum) number of field lines. That's why, when we draw magnetic fields or field lines, we draw only a finite number of representative vectors or field lines.

Michael Mozina pretends the finiteness of our display technology counts as evidence we don't understand the continuum nature of magnetic fields or field lines. That's just another straw man of his own invention. It's dishonest.

The only way a B line could begin or end at an POINT (even a NULL) is *IF* monopoles existed.
False.
  • From the mathematically correct definition of magnetic field lines (above), it's obvious that no B field line can go through a point p at which B(p)=0. (Such points are said to be "null" or "neutral" points. In this context, those two words are interchangeable.)
  • It's also obvious that the magnetic field B4 (defined in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection) is zero/null/neutral at the center of the four rods that generate that field. It was mathematically and computationally convenient to place that zero/null/neutral point at the origin of the xy plane.
  • So none of B4's field lines go through the zero/null/neutral point at the origin.
  • It's easy to prove that
    • four of B4's field lines lie along the diagonals of the xy plane,
    • two of those field lines are directed away from the origin,
    • the other two are directed toward the origin,
    • and all four lines come infinitesimally close to the origin. (That means they intersect every open neighborhood of the origin, no matter how small.)
  • As a matter of standard mathematical terminology, that means the two field lines that are directed away from the origin begin at the origin, and the two field lines that are directed toward the origin end at the origin.

The NULL isn't special.
Zero/null/neutral points are special because they're the only points at which magnetic field lines can begin or end.

Zero/null/neutral points are so rare and so special that freshmen are often told that magnetic field lines never begin or end, but that's an over-simplification. It's a white lie that professors have gotten into the habit of telling because it helps mathematically unsophisticated freshmen to understand an approximation to the truth.

A MONOPOLE would be special, and capable of allowing lines to 'begin' or 'end' as some point.
Monopoles would violate Gauss's law for magnetism. It is easy to prove that B4 does not violate Gauss's law for magnetism, and I have done so several times using three distinct methods of proof.

Thanks to those proofs, we know that magnetic field lines can begin or end without monopoles. Without monopoles, however, magnetic field lines can begin or end only at zero/null/neutral points of the magnetic field. That's an exception to the general rule that's taught to freshmen. That exception is part of what makes zero/null/neutral points interesting.

Another part of what makes zero/null/neutral points interesting is that the magnetic field lines of time-varying magnetic fields can change their topology at those zero/null/neutral points. Scientists refer to that changing topology as magnetic reconnection.

Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he understands very little of what I've explained above.

There's no shame in that. It's impossible to understand everything I've said above without basic knowledge of vector calculus, freshman-level electromagnetism, and differential equations. Sophomores majoring in physics should have that basic knowledge, but most people don't.

On the other hand, most people who lack sophomoric knowledge of physics understand full well that they aren't qualified to dispute the above math and physics or to dispute the hundreds of papers on magnetic reconnection that depend on that math and physics.

Michael Mozina doesn't understand that. Like the zero/null/neutral points, Michael Mozina is special.

I've heard creationists make similar statements based on pure handwaves such as Clinger's never to be published handwave of a presentation. Origin the Null religion has to be THE most pathetic religion on the planet. ;) Having faith in a God as a creator is one thing. Having faith that a simple NULL is a "beginning" of a B line is just weird.
Mathematics is not handwaving. The religions that Michael Mozina invented are indeed pathetic. Inventing religions and silly phrases just so he can ridicule them is lame and dishonest, but that's what Michael Mozina does.
 
Last edited:
It says that *PLAMSA* is involved!

How can it say *PLASMA* is involved when it is specfically discussing reconnection in vacuum.

As long as you have *PLASMA*, I'm sure you will get "reconnection" and particle acceleration. Without it, I'm sure you won't!

Well, I guess Somov is delusional too for discussing a whole section about reconnection in vacuum.

Go look it up for yourself! I'm not your physics mommy. Flux changes occur when you change the flow of current in one or more of the poles.

The problem is that you just throw in terms here and there that you heard or read, without even taking the littlest effort to actually explain what you mean. That is understandable, because you don't understand electrodynamics nor plasma physics.

According to Clinger, that's the beginning of every B line in the B line universe.

You read wrong, but who is surprised by that.
Did you understand my explanation about the separatrices, the crossing of field lines and the consequences that has? I think not.

It's just a frigging NULL. That's it! It's not the "beginning" of any magnetic line. It's not the ENDING of any magnetic line. It's just a simple, boring, non-interesting *NULL*. NOTHING begins there. NOTHING ends there. NOTHING does anything there. FLUX CHANGE happens *EVERYWHERE*, not just in the NULL.

Where the field has no magnitude and no direction, however the field lines that are the separatrices still go there, what are they to do, the cannot cross, because field lines cannot cross. But the field is zero in that point, so there is nowhere for the field line to go. So two field lines in the Xpoint end there and two field lines in the Xpoint start there. Nothing wrong there, because Gauss's law is still fulfilled without your beloved monopoles.


That's just pure BS. A NEUTRAL forms when the CURRENT flows through the Z axis. A NULL has no plasmas, whereas a NEUTRAL is composed *OF* plasma. Without a plasma. Origin the NULL is a boring NOTHING. It's the 'beginning' of NOTHING. It's the end of NOTHING. IT'S NOTHING!
[/quote]

"A NEUTRAL" is what exactly? Can you please express yourself a little more precise?
There are only currents in the wires in Somov's vacuum reconnection, which may flow along the z-axis, because that is usually the definition in these kind of models. However, there is no current flowing at the Xpoint, because it is a vacuum.

A NULL has no plasma whereas a NEUTRAL is composed of plasma? Well interesting, it does not mean anything, but interesting.

What the frak is "origin the NULL" it is a nice expression, but is shows clearly that you have not understood a single word of what Clinger, I, Somov, Tim Thompson, etc. etc. have written.

Well, "it's nothing" is correct only when applied to your misconceptions.
 
It's a busy day at work today, so let's cut to the chase:

*WHEN* can I expect Clinger to submit his NONSENSE for publication and to which publication will he submit it to? *WHEN* can I expect you folks to provide REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES that claim that a NULL in a vacuum is a "beginning" of a B line?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom