Tim Thompson
Muse
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2008
- Messages
- 969
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo IV
Yes, this paper: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 190(1/2): 1-24, December 1999.
Abstract: In this review paper we discuss several aspects of magnetic reconnection theory, focusing on the field-line motions that are associated with reconnection. A new exact solution of the nonlinear MHD equations for reconnective annihilation is presented which represents a two-fold generalization of the previous solutions. Magnetic reconnection at null points by several mechanisms is summarized, including spine reconnection, fan reconnection and separator reconnection, where it is pointed out that two common features of separator reconnection are the rapid flipping of magnetic field lines and the collapse of the separator to a current sheet. In addition, a formula for the rate of reconnection between two flux tubes is derived. The magnetic field of the corona is highly complex, since the magnetic carpet consists of a multitude of sources in the photosphere. Progress in understanding this complexity may, however, be made by constructing the skeleton of the field and developing a theory for the local and global bifurcations between the different topologies. The eruption of flux from the Sun may even sometimes be due to a change of topology caused by emerging flux break-out. A CD-ROM attached to this paper presents the results of a toy model of vacuum reconnection, which suggests that rapid flipping of field lines in fan and separator reconnection is an essential ingredient also in real non-vacuum conditions. In addition, it gives an example of binary reconnection between a pair of unbalanced sources as they move around, which may contribute significantly to coronal heating. Finally, we present examples in TRACE movies of geometrical changes of the coronal magnetic field that are a likely result of large-scale magnetic reconnection.
You can download the PDF from the Solar Physics website without logging in (it worked for me). See section 5, "Toy Model for Vacuum Reconnection" (pages 17-19).
Also recall the abstract already referenced by Reality Check: Magnetic reconnection on the sun by E.R. Priest, from the book "Basic Plasma Processes on the Sun", Kluwer 1990, pages 271-288 (abstract truncated on ADS webpage - see paper for full abstract). Here we find the beginning of the 2nd paragraph of the introduction: In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivial process, but, in a plasma atmosphere such as the Sun's, normally the plasma is attached very effectively to the magnetic field. It is only where the magnetic gradients are, say, a million times stronger than normal that the magnetic field can slip through the plasma and reconnect (Figure 1). There are three important effects of such a process. Firstly, the global topology of the magnetic field may be changed since the connectivity of the field lines may be altered. For example, initially in Figure 1 the point A is joined to point B and finally it is connected to point C. This may affect heat and the flow of particles which tend to travel along field lines. Secondly, inflowing stored magnetic energy is converted into heat, bulk kinetic energy and fast particle energy. Thirdly, reconnection creates large electric currents, electric fields, shock waves, filamentation, each of which may be involved in the acceleration of charged particles."
In light of Priest's hilighted comment, remember my own comments in October:
There simply is no justification for the claim that the reconnection of magnetic field lines cannot happen in a vacuum.
Do a search on books.google.com on "vacuum reconnection" and you will find a paper by Priest, a paper by Priest and Schrijver (here section 5 even has software to do your own vacuum reconnection) and there is a paper by Pritchett, where he specifically lets the density go to zero in his modelling. I think that were the first three links (did this yesterday evening) and there I stopped.
The simple fact that Somov's currents are just two wires carrying an electric current (otherwise you cannot maintain a vacuum) seems to be lost on MM.
And no, vacuum reconnection does not mean that the vacuum itself is reconnecting!
Is there a PARTICULAR ONE that tickles your fancy that I can take a look at?
Yes, this paper: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 190(1/2): 1-24, December 1999.
Abstract: In this review paper we discuss several aspects of magnetic reconnection theory, focusing on the field-line motions that are associated with reconnection. A new exact solution of the nonlinear MHD equations for reconnective annihilation is presented which represents a two-fold generalization of the previous solutions. Magnetic reconnection at null points by several mechanisms is summarized, including spine reconnection, fan reconnection and separator reconnection, where it is pointed out that two common features of separator reconnection are the rapid flipping of magnetic field lines and the collapse of the separator to a current sheet. In addition, a formula for the rate of reconnection between two flux tubes is derived. The magnetic field of the corona is highly complex, since the magnetic carpet consists of a multitude of sources in the photosphere. Progress in understanding this complexity may, however, be made by constructing the skeleton of the field and developing a theory for the local and global bifurcations between the different topologies. The eruption of flux from the Sun may even sometimes be due to a change of topology caused by emerging flux break-out. A CD-ROM attached to this paper presents the results of a toy model of vacuum reconnection, which suggests that rapid flipping of field lines in fan and separator reconnection is an essential ingredient also in real non-vacuum conditions. In addition, it gives an example of binary reconnection between a pair of unbalanced sources as they move around, which may contribute significantly to coronal heating. Finally, we present examples in TRACE movies of geometrical changes of the coronal magnetic field that are a likely result of large-scale magnetic reconnection.
You can download the PDF from the Solar Physics website without logging in (it worked for me). See section 5, "Toy Model for Vacuum Reconnection" (pages 17-19).
Also recall the abstract already referenced by Reality Check: Magnetic reconnection on the sun by E.R. Priest, from the book "Basic Plasma Processes on the Sun", Kluwer 1990, pages 271-288 (abstract truncated on ADS webpage - see paper for full abstract). Here we find the beginning of the 2nd paragraph of the introduction: In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivial process, but, in a plasma atmosphere such as the Sun's, normally the plasma is attached very effectively to the magnetic field. It is only where the magnetic gradients are, say, a million times stronger than normal that the magnetic field can slip through the plasma and reconnect (Figure 1). There are three important effects of such a process. Firstly, the global topology of the magnetic field may be changed since the connectivity of the field lines may be altered. For example, initially in Figure 1 the point A is joined to point B and finally it is connected to point C. This may affect heat and the flow of particles which tend to travel along field lines. Secondly, inflowing stored magnetic energy is converted into heat, bulk kinetic energy and fast particle energy. Thirdly, reconnection creates large electric currents, electric fields, shock waves, filamentation, each of which may be involved in the acceleration of charged particles."
In light of Priest's hilighted comment, remember my own comments in October:
See my post Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo where I outline the clear evidence that magnetic field lines, and not field aligned currents, topologically reconnect to change the energy state of the Magnetic field. To reinforce my demonstration, I now also suggest Magnets in Motion, where you can access animated gif images of the magnetic field lines reconnecting as magnets move. The magnetic fields are derived from solutions of Maxwell's equations. The author of the page, Rick Hoadley, has a Master's Degree in Electrical Engineering from Cornell University, so it is fair to assert that he is an authority on electricity and magnetism.
There is no arguing with the physics, that this definitely represents the breaking & reconnecting of magnetic field lines, no current of any kind involved. This is not found in textbooks & published papers for the simple reason that is is both obvious & trivial. Contrary to the ill-informed opinion of some, it is actually not true that literally everything is found within the covers of a book or on the pages of a scholarly paper. These are the same people who think that every question has an answer in the "solutions manual", if you can find it; thinking not required, just look it all up. It is just one more example of appeal too authority rather than an independent examination of the actual physics involved.
There simply is no justification for the claim that the reconnection of magnetic field lines cannot happen in a vacuum.
