Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo IV

Do a search on books.google.com on "vacuum reconnection" and you will find a paper by Priest, a paper by Priest and Schrijver (here section 5 even has software to do your own vacuum reconnection) and there is a paper by Pritchett, where he specifically lets the density go to zero in his modelling. I think that were the first three links (did this yesterday evening) and there I stopped.

The simple fact that Somov's currents are just two wires carrying an electric current (otherwise you cannot maintain a vacuum) seems to be lost on MM.

And no, vacuum reconnection does not mean that the vacuum itself is reconnecting!


Is there a PARTICULAR ONE that tickles your fancy that I can take a look at?


Yes, this paper: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 190(1/2): 1-24, December 1999.
Abstract: In this review paper we discuss several aspects of magnetic reconnection theory, focusing on the field-line motions that are associated with reconnection. A new exact solution of the nonlinear MHD equations for reconnective annihilation is presented which represents a two-fold generalization of the previous solutions. Magnetic reconnection at null points by several mechanisms is summarized, including spine reconnection, fan reconnection and separator reconnection, where it is pointed out that two common features of separator reconnection are the rapid flipping of magnetic field lines and the collapse of the separator to a current sheet. In addition, a formula for the rate of reconnection between two flux tubes is derived. The magnetic field of the corona is highly complex, since the magnetic carpet consists of a multitude of sources in the photosphere. Progress in understanding this complexity may, however, be made by constructing the skeleton of the field and developing a theory for the local and global bifurcations between the different topologies. The eruption of flux from the Sun may even sometimes be due to a change of topology caused by emerging flux break-out. A CD-ROM attached to this paper presents the results of a toy model of vacuum reconnection, which suggests that rapid flipping of field lines in fan and separator reconnection is an essential ingredient also in real non-vacuum conditions. In addition, it gives an example of binary reconnection between a pair of unbalanced sources as they move around, which may contribute significantly to coronal heating. Finally, we present examples in TRACE movies of geometrical changes of the coronal magnetic field that are a likely result of large-scale magnetic reconnection.

You can download the PDF from the Solar Physics website without logging in (it worked for me). See section 5, "Toy Model for Vacuum Reconnection" (pages 17-19).

Also recall the abstract already referenced by Reality Check: Magnetic reconnection on the sun by E.R. Priest, from the book "Basic Plasma Processes on the Sun", Kluwer 1990, pages 271-288 (abstract truncated on ADS webpage - see paper for full abstract). Here we find the beginning of the 2nd paragraph of the introduction: In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivial process, but, in a plasma atmosphere such as the Sun's, normally the plasma is attached very effectively to the magnetic field. It is only where the magnetic gradients are, say, a million times stronger than normal that the magnetic field can slip through the plasma and reconnect (Figure 1). There are three important effects of such a process. Firstly, the global topology of the magnetic field may be changed since the connectivity of the field lines may be altered. For example, initially in Figure 1 the point A is joined to point B and finally it is connected to point C. This may affect heat and the flow of particles which tend to travel along field lines. Secondly, inflowing stored magnetic energy is converted into heat, bulk kinetic energy and fast particle energy. Thirdly, reconnection creates large electric currents, electric fields, shock waves, filamentation, each of which may be involved in the acceleration of charged particles."

In light of Priest's hilighted comment, remember my own comments in October:

See my post Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo where I outline the clear evidence that magnetic field lines, and not field aligned currents, topologically reconnect to change the energy state of the Magnetic field. To reinforce my demonstration, I now also suggest Magnets in Motion, where you can access animated gif images of the magnetic field lines reconnecting as magnets move. The magnetic fields are derived from solutions of Maxwell's equations. The author of the page, Rick Hoadley, has a Master's Degree in Electrical Engineering from Cornell University, so it is fair to assert that he is an authority on electricity and magnetism.

There is no arguing with the physics, that this definitely represents the breaking & reconnecting of magnetic field lines, no current of any kind involved. This is not found in textbooks & published papers for the simple reason that is is both obvious & trivial. Contrary to the ill-informed opinion of some, it is actually not true that literally everything is found within the covers of a book or on the pages of a scholarly paper. These are the same people who think that every question has an answer in the "solutions manual", if you can find it; thinking not required, just look it all up. It is just one more example of appeal too authority rather than an independent examination of the actual physics involved.


There simply is no justification for the claim that the reconnection of magnetic field lines cannot happen in a vacuum.
 
Wow.

Not even Clinger agreed to have his own work peer reviewed. Why am I not surprised?
Wow. You persist in your ignorance of science and are so not surprised!

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is an interesting exercise in undergraduate physics. It is not new scientific research. MR in vaccum is a trival exercise, see e.g.
 
That's two more than Clinger has. :)
Lucky that you added the :) because otherwise we would think that this is a new delusion to add to your existing ones (see below).

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has 1, 4 and 5 electrical currents in his posts. None of them are in actual plasma (the 5 current case is a first approximation to the current sheet in a plasma), thus disproving your assertion that MR can only happen in plasma.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V
 
Here: You guys really need a refresher on magnetic fields. Pay attention to the part about "magnetic pressure", and what happens when magnets REPULSE.

http://www.brightstorm.com/science/physics/magnetism/magnetic-fields/

Unlike electric fields, magnetic fields always make closed loops and are never created nor destroyed. Though magnetic field lines go out of north poles and end at south poles, within the magnet they form a closed loop. The closer together the field lines are, the stronger the field. When opposite ends of two magnets interact, their field lines connect the north pole of one with the south pole of another, and the two attract. When the same ends of two magnets interact, they repel because the lines cannot cross and are compressed by each other.
 
Last edited:
Yes. It's a NULL. You can call it a "neutral point" if you like (it's technically correct), but without any plasma it's never going to form a fully developed "neutral" in the sense that Dungey is using the term. He's using the term 'neutral' more like an electrical term since he has current running up the Z axis.

Clinger has more of a NULL than a "neutral".
That is really incoherent and misses what a a null or neutral point is:
A null of neutral point is where the magnetic field is zero.
​
Opposing magnetic fields generally create null points. W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection uses currents through rods.

Neutral Points in a Magnetic Field
 
Yes, this paper: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 190(1/2): 1-24, December 1999.

Priest and Schrijver the PLAMSA guys?

I love how you go for a Priest paper again, but you utterly *IGNORED* equations 16&17 *ENTIRELY* from the LAST paper you asked me to read. Wow. I guess I'll have to read this paper too and find out where the "magic" happens. I love how you folk grasp at a single word "vacuum" and ignore the fact he's applying MHD theory to the process.

Got a copy of his computer code by any chance? That's likely to be the EASIEST way to falsify the concept.
 
You're right Tim, I could download the paper for free. Unfortunately, only the CD must contain the "toy reconnection" code that they are talking about. It's also extremely difficult to know exactly what they mean by the term "vacuum", or a "Toy Model" for that matter. The "toy model" in the paper includes nothing more than a couple of diagrams.

5. Toy Model for Vacuum Reconnection
We have constructed a simple toy model for vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric sources and have presented the results in the accompanying CD-ROM.

:confused: As far as I can tell, they are still talking about PLASMA physics, in this case a LOW DENSITY plasma like the corona. :confused:

I guess I need to see the code and the CD.
 
Last edited:
That is idiotic. Just because people publish about MR in plasma does not mean that they do not know out the trivial case of MR in vacuum:

Somov's "vacuum" included CURRENTS/plasma. As far as I can tell Priest's use of the term "vacuum" also includes PLASMAS, but I can't tell for SURE without looking at the source code. He's definitely talking about PHOTOSPHERE processes.
 
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II

You keep ignoring the fact that those papers describe PLASMA processes so they do NOT apply to Clinger's example.
You are ignoring that my post (and your post that I replied to) did not refer to W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

But they do apply since the presence of plasma or not does not matter. MR is B lines breaking and reconnecting in both vacuum and plasma. Read Somov's book where the section on reconnection in vacuum is followed by the section on reconnection in plasma.

MM: 1000's of references (many of which are REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES) for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting
debunks your obsession with the undergraduate EM links that simplify things ("B lines do not end" is a lie to children).

MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II
debunks your obsession with the undergraduate EM links that simplify things ("B lines do not end" is a lie to children).

You are relying on undergraduate EM course notes and web pages which simplified for the level of the reader and so do not mention the exception to the "field lines do not end" rule - field lines crossing null points.

There are also REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES to MR in vacuum (where field lines also break and reconnect):
P.S. MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
This is basically either put up or shut up. If you cannot show that you understand his derivation and thus show where he made his errors, then you are just arguing from a stance of ignorance.
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI

Somov's "vacuum" included CURRENTS/plasma.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V
Wow - you are really making yourself seem deluded with this continued instance that a section about reconnection in vacuum has plasma in it.

As I pointed out before this is stupid:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V

Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing WIRES to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing ELECTRON BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing PROTON BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducingIONIZED SILVER BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.

Can you see that my satirical comments is as stupid as your serious assertion about PLASMA?

Somov has no plasma.
Somov has no wires.
Somov has no beams of any kind of charged particle.

He has 2 parallel electrical currents that just exist.
and:
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing CHARGED PINK UNICORNS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.

Worthy of noting in the ever longer list of your delusions about Somov's book.
 
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 II

I love how you go for a Priest paper again, but you utterly *IGNORED* equations 16&17 *ENTIRELY* from the LAST paper you asked me to read.


Did I really?? :jaw-dropp

Here I am "utterly ignoring" equations 16 & 17 ...

Reference Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992

(emphasizing that the current is a consequence of the field)
It's then *CONVERTED* to "magnetic charge* in equation 17, ...


No it is not. Look at the sentence immediately prior to equation 16. It read as follows, with my added emphasis:
"Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:"

The authors then go on to show the current in equation 16 and the magnetic charges in equation 17. This is not a conversion of current into charges, it is a listing of both currents and magnetic charges that are together simultaneously.

... meaning that *WITHOUT CURRENT* through the Z axis, you have no magnetic charge, and no "reconnection"! Its a 'requirement' for "reconnection". Plasma and CURRENT aren't optional.


Everything you have said here is dead wrong. You do not understand the paper at all, and certainly do not understand the role of equations 16 & 17 in that paper. According to you the authors are "converting current to magnetic charge". Well, no, that's not what they are doing, as I have shown above. Furthermore, neither equation 16 nor equation 17 has a thing to do with magnetic reconnection.

The title of the paper is "The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force-free field". Did you see the words "magnetic reconnection" in that title?

Here is the abstract:
"In a highly conducting plasma, the magnetic field topology determines where, for example, current sheets can form, which is of great importance as a potential coronal heating source. With the classical extrapolation of a continuous weak photospheric field, the determination of topology is in general a difficult challenge. Because of the concentration of the photospheric field at intense flux tubes in supergranulation boundaries a more realistic field representation may be a description in terms of magnetic singularities located just below the photosphere. In this paper we analyze in detail the generalization to linear force-free fields of the standard multipole expansion for singular potential fields. Solutions are presented in spherical coordinates with the constraint that all singularities are located in the half-space z is less than 0 below the solar photospheric plane (z = 0). A great variety of solutions is shown to exist depending on two continuous and one discrete parameter. The properties of monopole and dipole solutions in particular are discussed and it is shown that isolated magnetic charges exist only in the potential limit and not in a linear force-free field."

Do you see the words "magnetic reconnection" anywhere in that abstract? Did you read the highlighted sentence, which explains the point of the paper?

Look at the section headings:

1 Introduction
2 Multipole expansion of a linear force-free field
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Solutions with a Toroidal/Poloidal representation
2.3 Direct solution in the case with cylindrical symmetry
2.4 General properties
3 Study of the particular case l = 0
3.1 Singularity along the negative z-Axis
3.2 Field lines
3.3 Is a single magnetic charge possible in a linear force-free field?
4 Conclusion
5 Appendix: The Chiu and Hilton Green's function

Do you see "magnetic reconnection" on that list? Which of those section titles suggests that magnetic reconnection occurs in that section?
Indeed, can you even find magnetic reconnection anywhere in the paper?

Yes, and here they all are:

Page 535 (Introduction, lower right):
"Reconnection therefore allows a general force-free field to relax to a constant-alpha field (Taylor, 1986; Berger, 1984)"

Page 536 (Introduction, middle left):
"Observations show that flares occur sometimes in bipolar regions which have S-shaped polarity inversion lines. Because these regions are bipolar, the classical picture of current sheet formation, with reconnection taking place at separatrix surfaces, cannot be used because the field topology is that of a simple arcade.

Page 536 (Introduction, lower left):
"On a smaller spatial scale, magnetic fields are observed to be concentrated at supergranular boundaries in small knots of magnetic field. To study the process of reconnection observed there (Martin 1990), it may be very useful to have a simple representation of the magnetic field which retains its main features"

Page 540 (Conclusion, middle right):
"The study of three-dimensional field topology with observed photospheric boundary conditions was initiated by Gorbachev & Somov (1988), who model the observed field as a potential field created by four charges placed below the photosphere. The model supposes the reconnection is taking place at the separator. The location of chromospheric flare ribbons computed from this model compares well with observations, giving support for this kind of modelling."

That's a complete list of all instances of the word "reconnection" in the paper. The infamous equations 16 & 17 are on page 539, right at the beginning of section 3. So where is the connection between equations 16 & 17 & magnetic reconnection? There isn't one.

Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina. This trick of using magnetic charges appears in only a few papers, and they are all early in the process of describing the physics of magnetic reconnection. Its sole purpose is to play a role in multipole expansions of the magnetic field. But superior methods soon arrived and this methodology of using magnetic charges, which was even then esoteric & obscure, disappeared altogether, never to be seen again. It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics, field modeling, or magnetic reconnection that I have seen. That's why I said I didn't want to talk about this, because it is irrelevant. irrelevant. The current state of the physics of magnetic field modeling and magnetic reconnection does not involve any of this at all.


I must say, I really impress myself with my superior ignoring skills. I ignored those two equations so utterly that I never even noticed that I had said all of this. I am cool. :D
 
Did I really?? :jaw-dropp

Here I am "utterly ignoring" equations 16 & 17 ...




I must say, I really impress myself with my superior ignoring skills. I ignored those two equations so utterly that I never even noticed that I had said all of this. I am cool. :D

I don't suppose you have a link to the CD with the "toy" code by any chance?

I love how you provide a related source/sink paper, and I spend the time to go through it, and then you ignore the implications entirely, claiming the paper *YOU* provided isn't relevant. :) Lovely. You're not going to do that again with the new paper are you?
 
A "vacuum" appears to be the corona as far as I can tell:

These simple experiments demonstrate a fundamental property of magnetic fields in association with magnetic reconnection: for reconnection that occurs on scales comparable to or larger than the characteristic separation of the magnetic poles (i.e., excluding the reconnection associated with small-scale footpoint motion resulting in what is generally described as field-line braiding), there are motions of pairs of field lines towards and later away from the reconnection site. In the simple simulations shown in Movie I on the CD-ROM, vacuum reconnection occurs through null points as field lines move through separators (the intersections of separatrix surfaces) whenever two pairs of field-line segments exchange connectivity at the reconnection location. The simulations suggest that most of the time field lines move through the coronal volume in response to source motions with speeds comparable in magnitude to that of the footpoints themselves. Just prior to reconnection, however, field lines approach the separator and slide past it often with a substantially increased speed.

They are consistently talking about movements in the photosphere, and movement of the lines through the CORONA. I guess I'll have to take a look at the actual "toy code" to get a handle on what they actually mean.
 
The way in which the field lines reconnect by changing from being open to closed and back to open can be seen clearly.

Um, it would appear (without having reviewed the actual software and code yet) that in the "toy model" that they are talking about, the "way it works" is by breaking the laws of physics. :) There are no "open" magnetic lines. They may close at infinity, but they always form closed loops.
 
I give up for now. Without seeing the Movie and without reviewing the code that appears to violate the laws of physic, I really have no idea how their "magic" works. All I can see so far is that they are INTENT on claiming that B field lines SWITCH from being closed, to "open". AFAIK, that's bogus nonsense. Unless they have a monopole up their sleeve, or some "magic monopole code" in that "toy" software, it's never going to happen. All magnetic lines form as closed directional loops.
 
Last edited:
Um, it would appear (without having reviewed the actual software and code yet) that in the "toy model" that they are talking about, the "way it works" is by breaking the laws of physics. :) There are no "open" magnetic lines. They may close at infinity, but they always form closed loops.
Please do not project your state of ignorance/delusion on other people who have studied plasma physics such as Priest, etc.

It is evident that this is you being fooled by that lie to children taught to undergraduate students (that B lines never end).

Anyone who can read and understand the laws of physics can see that MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II .

People who can read can read can see MR happens in a vacuum:
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov

People who can understand undergraduate science can see that MR happens (even in a vacuum): by reading W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

People who have knowledge of science have no problen with B lines ending: MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II
 
One other part of their presentation that is rather "telling" IMO is the fact that all their drawings show "sources and sinks" in terms of magnetic lines rather than showing the FULL LOOPS. No lines are shown UNDER the photosphere/surface in their drawings a-d. IMO the monopole magic must be in one of the lines of code. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom