Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
No moving of goal posts. Pepper spray isn't to be used on people who are sitting and are no threat.
So say you. Experts say it is an appropriate way to deal with chained protesters resisting arrest.

Looks, this isn't difficult. Use the pepper spray against those who are threatening you. People seated on the ground aren't threatening.
It is also acceptable to use with people resisting arrest, chained together..

I would be interested in reading your source.
Multiple cites have been given in this thread when the incident first happened. You are bringing up an issue that has already been extensively discussed. Go back and and catch up and read the citations.



Let's back up, pepper spray was invented to be non lethal force. To take the place of lethal force. Are you saying that had they not had pepper spray they would have started shooting people? Are you saying that was their only option?
No, the one other alternative is to try to start yanking on arms to try to break them up. Much more risk in causing injury than pepper spray. AGAIN already discussed and explained in the thread. Do try to pay attention.

The AG and Sheriffs department of Yolo county and others have said they are concerned that the pepper spray represented excessive force. I'm not an expert. I don't know what the tactics are. I'm only relaying what other experts are saying.
Engineering boy is your "expert"? If you'd stay up to date on the thread, you'd know what the real experts are saying.
 
Remember Nathan Brown, the assistant professor of English, who organized the protest at UC-Davis and described himself in a poorly-written letter as an asset to the college community (while insisting the chancellor wasn't)?

Here's his webpage, where he describes his specialty as:

Nathan Brown's research and teaching focus on 20th and 21st century poetry and poetics, continental philosophy, and science/technology studies.

An upcoming course (Winter 2012) sounds interesting:

The Real Movement of History —
 Left Communism and the Communization Current

This course will be devoted not to 'the idea of communism but rather to understanding communism as 'the real movement of history.'
:rolleyes:

It also sounds like a course that should be taught either by a political science or history professor. Not that either of those would be likely to endorse the idea of communism being the movement of history.
 
Last edited:
Remember Nathan Brown, the assistant professor of English, who organized the protest at UC-Davis and described himself in a poorly-written letter as an asset to the college community (while insisting the chancellor wasn't)?

Here's his webpage, where he describes his specialty as:



An upcoming course (Winter 2012) sounds interesting:

:rolleyes:

It also sounds like a course that should be taught either by a political science or history professor. Not that either of those would be likely to endorse the idea of communism being the movement of history.
I love that someone, bikerdruid, IIRC, claimed he was an impartial observer, despite the fact that his claims students had their mouths forced open has not been corroborated, and is actually contradicted by the videos of Occupy itself.

I'm not sure if Communism counts as conservative or liberal, but he's not unbiased.

I'm also suspicious that students who were coughing blood would be allowed to stick around for 45 minutes instead of being bundled off to a hospital or clinic and out of public view as soon as possible. Very incompetent, these merciless jackbooted thugs. Odd that no one got a picture or video of the blood-coughing individual.
 
Last edited:
They are an authority. They enforce the law. You keep dodging the point.
WHAT POINT? Stop it or I will put you on ignore.

Do you know what the plausible alternatives are?
No.

Because if not, you're a parrot.
BS


  • I know that the police were able to do their jobs before pepper spray.
  • I know that the police are able to do do their jobs now without pepper spray.

No. They wouldn't have. They would've resorted to wrestling the "protestors" apart. Which would've likely resulted in a dislocated arm or two.
Oh BS. Protests are nothing new. I've seen the police arrest protestors like during operation rescue many, many times. NO pepper spray needed. You are being absurd.
 
've ever acknowledged the officers may be in the legal right. (For the record: I think it is possible that the cops could be wrong, but do not believe that to be the case, in light of the evidence I have gathered.) You've claimed it was brutality, and in the same breath hid behind "experts". You've been shuckin' and jivin' this entire time. You can't even admit you don't know of any alternatives, weasel-wording it as you never claimed you know any alternatives, which is about two qualifiers away from a concrete statement. In fact, it's a politician's answer.
I find you very dishonest. This is all BS. I didn't hide behind anything anymore than you have. This is rhetorical ad hominem.

Look, ask most people. I'm one of the few who will step up to the plate and admit when I'm wrong. I do it often. I don't have to justify myself to you and I don't have to put up with your silly fallacy.

Stop it. Have an honest conversation with me or I'm putting you on ignore.
 
So say you. Experts say it is an appropriate way to deal with chained protesters resisting arrest.
I'm still wating for your sources.

It is also acceptable to use with people resisting arrest, chained together.
Still waiting for those sources.

Multiple cites have been given in this thread when the incident first happened. You are bringing up an issue that has already been extensively discussed. Go back and and catch up and read the citations.
Oh, the ever elusive, I lost my homework.

No, the one other alternative is to try to start yanking on arms to try to break them up. Much more risk in causing injury than pepper spray. AGAIN already discussed and explained in the thread. Do try to pay attention.
Protests like operation rescue and MANY others have been dealt with, without injury. This has been explained to you. PLEASE DO TRY TO PAY ATTENTION.

Engineering boy is your "expert"? If you'd stay up to date on the thread, you'd know what the real experts are saying.
Straw man. The appeals court, DA and Sheriff of Yolo county.
 
WHAT POINT? Stop it or I will put you on ignore.
The point that they are themselves an authority. They not only represent authority, they are also authority themselves.

Then stop parroting the opinions of "experts" and educate yourself.

BS

  • I know that the police were able to do their jobs before pepper spray.
  • I know that the police are able to do do their jobs now without pepper spray.
I always like this bit, where my posts are quote-mined down to nearly nothing because the person I'm talking to can't respond to them straight-up.

The police had pepper spray. I and other assert, and continue to assert that the only other feasable alternatives to pepper spray would have been inefficient (Taser) or been likely to cause more harm than pepper spray (physically struggling to disengage them from each other).

I further assert that you feel remarkably free to offer your opinion on matters you evidently know little about, and yet you will hastily declare you are not an expert when challenged.

Oh BS. Protests are nothing new. I've seen the police arrest protestors like during operation rescue many, many times. NO pepper spray needed. You are being absurd.
Straw Man. The assertion is that wrestling people apart in the specific linked-arm configuration used by the UC Davis protestors (who were, again, actively obstructing the police in the execution of their duty) is likely to cause injury. Present an "expert" with a contrary opinion or be silent.

Also, start responding to all of my posts, you intellectually dishonest sophist, or not at all.
 
Last edited:
Pepper Spray Update: More Fatalities, More Questions

The ACLU report concludes that:
1) There is clear evidence that pepper spray is unlikely to work on people who are high on drugs and in psychiatric crisis and there is clear evidence pepper spray poses serious risks if it is used on people with respiratory disease, especially asthma.

2) There is a strong statistical association between use of pepper spray in combination with police restraint techniques, like the controversial hog-tie, and death.

3) Cal-EPA scientists have warned the California Department of Justice and Attorney. General. Dan Lungren of their reservations about pepper spray and concerns about its possible role in causing fatalities for more than two years, but no action has been taken in response. In fact, the Department of Justice permitted civilian use of pepper spray despite many of these fears by scientists.

4) No federal agency has taken regulatory responsibility for pepper spray and California’s state agency that oversees law enforcement training has failed to caution police that pepper spray should not be used in excess of a single one-second burst.
 
The point that they are themselves an authority. They not only represent authority, they are also authority themselves.
DUH! Seriously. What the hell is your problem? I never said they were not authorities. In fact I SAID THEY ARE. I said they are iconic of authority. That does not obviate them as authority. Jesus H. Christ.

Then stop parroting the opinions of "experts" and educate yourself.
Stop it. Good bye.
 
I'm still wating for your sources.

Still waiting for those sources.

Oh, the ever elusive, I lost my homework.
Did you even go look? I think not.

Protests like operation rescue and MANY others have been dealt with, without injury. This has been explained to you. PLEASE DO TRY TO PAY ATTENTION.
Unless Operation Rescue involved people sitting down in a linked-arm configuration functionally identical to that used by the UC Davis protestors being broken up by police wrestling with them, you're comparing apples and oranges.

This also does nothing to rebut the assertion that tussling with people in such a configuration is more likely to cause injury than pepper spray.

Straw man. The appeals court, DA and Sheriff of Yolo county.
This is an excellent example of your doublespeak. You will claim that they couldn't be politically butt-covering because the events happen outside their bailiwick, but claim their opinions on the matter as those of experts.
 
Folks, we can have a discussion. But it isn't going to work if we are are only talking past each other. I will commit to toning it down a bit but I ask you to also. Can we have a rational discussion without recriminations?
 
The ACLU is hardly unbiased. For example, their statistics for deaths in police custody from pepper spray include any person who died in police custody after being pepper sprayed. It also does not say how many people, overall, are pepper-sprayed each year. It is also 16 years old. There are people able to drive and have sex in large portions of the US who were not born when that report was made. The situation has changes since.

I would also like to point out that there have been less deaths and injuries connected to police actions against Occupy than there have been connected to Occupy camps themselves.

DUH! Seriously. What the hell is your problem? I never said they were not authorities. In fact I SAID THEY ARE. I said they are iconic of authority. That does not obviate them as authority. Jesus H. Christ.
I said they were authorities, and you said you were talking about the people who gave them the authority and suchlike.

Stop it. Good bye.
Hey guys, this is what happens when I tell RandFan to actually learn for himself what he's talking about.

EDIT: By all means, Rand, continue to shoot without aiming. You're already on my ignore. Must be some kind of record.
 
Last edited:
Given that there are serious potential health risks associated with pepper spray I find it difficult to buy into the argument that pepper spray is used to ensure the safety of protestors. I don't think that is warranted and as of yet no one, as far as I know, has posted any data showing pepper spray to be less harmful than other means.

So, I ask, given the scientific data presented that it is potentially harmful, is there scientific data to the contrary? Yes? no? If so would you please provide it?
 
No, my problem is that you were throwing around claims without sufficient information, and piling more and more intellectual dishonesty on top of it to defend it.

I'm guessing, of course, since you're still on Ignore. I wonder how accurate I am?
 
Given that there are serious potential health risks associated with pepper spray I find it difficult to buy into the argument that pepper spray is used to ensure the safety of protestors.

Unless the chain is broken up by fluffy kitty tickle parties I don't think you'll find any sort of tactic that ensures no one will get injured. The conversation is regarding what is considered 'excessive' force, and you continue to maintain that there are better alternatives to using pepper spray. Will you be supporting that by listing the alternatives?

I don't think that is warranted and as of yet no one, as far as I know, has posted any data showing pepper spray to be less harmful than other means.

You are the one who is positing that using pepper spray is "excessive force". You're job, then, is to give an example of minimal force that could be used to break apart a chain that refuses to break, while causing equal or less damage than pepper spray. Please support this with facts.

So, I ask, given the scientific data presented that it is potentially harmful, is there scientific data to the contrary? Yes? no? If so would you please provide it?

Has anyone said it isn't harmful?
 
Unless the chain is broken up by fluffy kitty tickle parties I don't think you'll find any sort of tactic that ensures no one will get injured.
No such thing exists. The question is what is the safest tactic. Do you have evidence that pepper spray is safer for the protestors than pepper spray? ACLU prepared a report that says no.

You are the one who is positing that using pepper spray is "excessive force". You're job, then, is to give an example of minimal force that could be used to break apart a chain that refuses to break
Been there done that. They are called bolt cutters and there is documented evidence that they work.

So, about that evidence to counter the ACLU report?
 
Unless the chain is broken up by fluffy kitty tickle parties I don't think you'll find any sort of tactic that ensures no one will get injured. The conversation is regarding what is considered 'excessive' force, and you continue to maintain that there are better alternatives to using pepper spray. Will you be supporting that by listing the alternatives?
He doesn't have any. He said so.

You are the one who is positing that using pepper spray is "excessive force". You're job, then, is to give an example of minimal force that could be used to break apart a chain that refuses to break, while causing equal or less damage than pepper spray. Please support this with facts.
He's not an expert. Quoting "experts" is the same as a fact. It's not his opinion it's excessive force, it's the experts. He's just presenting their opinion without looking for info about the matter himself, which is totally not the same as parroting something you don't understand.

Has anyone said it isn't harmful?
It wouldn't be very useful if it didn't cause some discomfort (and thus, harm). Even tugging on an arm causes discomfort. Police have been sued--with mixed success--for "intimidation", which means that the cops allegedly made someone feel emotionally uncomfortable.

There is no feasible alternative to pepper spray in that particular situation that was less of a risk of damage. If there is, Rand does not know what it is. He has admitted it, yet refuses to listen to people who actually know what they're talking about, or to educate himself on the use of force continuum. I'd really like to see the source of his claims about the police departments offering their opinion, but I can't, because I have him on ignore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom