Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
And I'm not going to go back through the thread and hand feed them to you.

Already cited. Don't expect to arrive late then demand everyone else get you up to speed.

Not at all. It's there. I'm not redoing it because of your laziness.


What part of "investigating" do you not understand? "investigating" does not equal "they did not follow the correct protocol". It means they are looking at what happened to make sure procedures were followed. The appeals court was not based on what happened in Davis, it was a separate different situation. I provided testimony from current police experts who viewed the video of the Davis incident. You have provided nothing.

Sure, but it's hard to do when you demand to discuss an incident that was already discussed and won't take the time to read the previous discussion and demand that everyone repeat and dig up everything that was already posted.

It doesn't matter whether you buy into it or not. It is the best choice as determined by standard police procedures.

That's because you don't really want to know. It's already been cited. You are too lazy to go back through the thread and read it.

Rest assured, he doesn't. His lack of initiative and honesty is tempting me to put him on ignore as well.
Thanks Nova, I missed this.

Nova put it rather succinctly. I'll leave it at that.
 
Wow! It always amazes me when someone passes up an opportunity to post evidence which they think supports their claim.

Agreed, but sometimes it's best to read a thread before posting in it. Skimming is always good, no?
 
Let's parse that, "we will be in trouble for using less harmful means so let's use more harmful means."

You have to know that police DO arrest protestors in similar situations without pepper spray, right?


"We will be in trouble for not removing these people, so we have to use the only means left"

I'm sure there have been instances where similar situations resulted in both more severe use of force, and less severe use of force.
 
Why was it so important that they break down the Occupy camp?
Because it was both breaking the school's rules and obstructing other students.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7804067#post7804067

I'm not sure why you expect me to link you to every single person who has expressed a desire for Kelly's bodily harm.

None of the examples you have offered are saying Kelly should be pepper sprayed for, as you claim, exercising Free Speech:
If OWS is sprayed for "exercising Free Speech", regardless of other considerations, then wanting to spray Kelly because she said something one didn't like is also wanting to spray her for "exercising Free Speech".

She did not claim it was a food product in the sense commonly interpreted. Context makes it clear she was referring to it in a scientific manner, and she is clearly against its use on the protestors, regardless of the legality. Ignoring that is intellectually dishonest. It's something Fox News would do.


No, he put you on ignore for being dishonest:
He put me on ignore because I kept asking him to prove his points and find evidence for himself rather than regurgitating the opinions of "experts". Please note he only started hiding behind such opinions after he was asked to back his claims up. In fact, he had started quote-mining my posts down to only the bits he wanted to respond to.

It's very simple. For RandFan to be able to claim that the pepper spray was excessive, he must have an idea of what is "reasonable force", in order to know what limits are being exceeded. When asked to say what reasonable force would be, he has refused, dodged, and said that he's not an expert. When I asked him if his experts said what reasonable force would be (among other things), he started threatening an ignore.
 
tant to post your evidence is. But in the past I've noticed a strong correlation people making excuses for not posting evidence they claim to have and the evidence turning out to be non-existent or exceedingly weak.
See, here's the thing; we've asked Rand to provide evidence to support his position. All he had is some experts saying they're concerned and/or investigating. Far from conclusive. So he won't provide substantiative evidence even after over a half-dozen requests from various people, even putting two of them on ignore, then demands evidence from others. That's just hypocrisy. The fact that he considers not being an expert an excuse for not being informed further damns him.

Even his current Holy Writ, the ACLU paper, is biased, selective, and over ten years old.
 
Yes. But that would have shown contempt.

We need to understand something important here. We need to discuss the elephant in the room.

  • Protests are used because they can be effective.
  • The people the protests are aimed at don't want the protests.
  • The protestors are violating the law.
  • The people who don't want the protests can use the law to stop the protests.
  • This is a war between the powers that be and the protestors.
  • Protestors use public anger and they desire confrontation.
  • It's STUPID TO PLAY INTO THEIR HANDS. But that's just my opinion.
To some degree the police are pawns of the powers that be and the protestors.
I disagree. Whether the police give in or not, protestors win. The police are the Knights. The general public, manipulated by the selective and biased coverage of the event, are the pawns. The objective was to make the cops look bad in the eyes of the world.
 
Irrelevant.



How is this relevant?

(Which "guys" are you addressing?)

Why was it deemed necessary to "break down" the camp? It could simply have been left where it was.

The police could also have chosen not to arrest the seated protestors.
They could've chosen to do handstands wearing clown noses.

Either the cops do nothing and look weak, or they use force and look tyrannical. The only winning move was not to play.
 
Unless there is a compelling reason why protestors need to be carted off immediately, the simplest way to deal with demonstrators who link hands or chain themselves to heavy objects is to wait.

Most people have physical needs which will eventually cause them to want to unlink themselves. When those needs arise, they can be arrested -- one by one, if need be -- with relatively little fuss. Depending on how urgent their need is, they may even be grateful to be hauled away to somewhere they can relieve themselves with a little more dignity than doing so while linked together would permit.

On rare occasions protestors planning to sit-in and to be hard to remove have worn adult diapers. But that calls for advance preparation, as well as for unusually dedicated protestors.

Using pepper spray or other types of force on protestors who are not posing a physical thread to the police makes the police look bad in the eyes of anyone who is inclined to be sympathetic to the protestors (and even to a good number of people who were on the fence or mildly opposed). It's generally not a good idea to make martyrs out of people if it can be avoided -- and in this case it can. There is no compelling reason why the protestors need to be arrested by any specific time. It's not like a nuclear bomb is ticking and will go off if they aren't in jail by 4 pm.

Waiting patiently may be disappointing to people who hate the protestors and want to see them beaten -- but to more reasonable people, seeing police exhibiting extreme patience and consideration makes the police look good. As a side benefit of this approach, the demonstrators are likely to come off looking immature in contrast.
 
Yes. But that would have shown contempt.

Why would it have shown contempt? The UC Davis authorities could have backed the camp and used college facilities to encourage, develop and explore freedom of speech.


We need to understand something important here. We need to discuss the elephant in the room.

  • Protests are used because they can be effective.
  • The people the protests are aimed at don't want the protests.
  • The protestors are violating the law.
  • The people who don't want the protests can use the law to stop the protests.
  • This is a war between the powers that be and the protestors.
  • Protestors use public anger and they desire confrontation.

I'm not so sure about that they desire confrontation. The main function of the camps appears to be as a venue for creating community and for education.

  • It's STUPID TO PLAY INTO THEIR HANDS. But that's just my opinion.
To some degree the police are pawns of the powers that be and the protestors.

I feel a little patronized that you think I need it pointed out to me that the police are pawns. The police, however, work in a hierarchical organization. The actions of lower ranks are controlled and led by higher ranks.


~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~


They could've chosen to do handstands wearing clown noses.

Infantile.

Either the cops do nothing and look weak, or they use force and look tyrannical. The only winning move was not to play.

Why didn't they choose the winning option, then?

The police can do nothing and look (and be) strong. Patience is a virtue, after all, especially for community oriented policing.


I disagree. Whether the police give in or not, protestors win. The police are the Knights. The general public, manipulated by the selective and biased coverage of the event, are the pawns. The objective was to make the cops look bad in the eyes of the world.

The "cops" didn't have to pepper spray the students.
 
Last edited:
...
Why was it deemed necessary to "break down" the camp? It could simply have been left where it was.
...
To uphold the democratic will of the people. Here in Portland, there was substantial political pressure on Mayor Sam Adams to remove the camp because the vast majority of the people wanted them removed and the city ordinance of no overnight camping in the park to be enforced. The campers were removed. This is what democracy looks like.
 
To uphold the democratic will of the people. Here in Portland, there was substantial political pressure on Mayor Sam Adams to remove the camp because the vast majority of the people wanted them removed and the city ordinance of no overnight camping in the park to be enforced. The campers were removed. This is what democracy looks like.

UC isn't Portland and, even if it were, if the context of the movement's actions is taken into account (massive fraud and theft by a financial sector that has blackmailed, corrupted and usurped the organs of democracy, creamed off the nations wealth and brought the world's economy to its knees) it is not what democracy looks like.
 
Unless there is a compelling reason why protestors need to be carted off immediately, the simplest way to deal with demonstrators who link hands or chain themselves to heavy objects is to wait.
They were actively and deliberately impeding the police.

Most people have physical needs which will eventually cause them to want to unlink themselves. When those needs arise, they can be arrested -- one by one, if need be -- with relatively little fuss. Depending on how urgent their need is, they may even be grateful to be hauled away to somewhere they can relieve themselves with a little more dignity than doing so while linked together would permit.

On rare occasions protestors planning to sit-in and to be hard to remove have worn adult diapers. But that calls for advance preparation, as well as for unusually dedicated protestors.
That requires money and time, which people would complain about being used to guard "peaceful" protestors.

Using pepper spray or other types of force on protestors who are not posing a physical thread to the police makes the police look bad in the eyes of anyone who is inclined to be sympathetic to the protestors (and even to a good number of people who were on the fence or mildly opposed). It's generally not a good idea to make martyrs out of people if it can be avoided -- and in this case it can. There is no compelling reason why the protestors need to be arrested by any specific time. It's not like a nuclear bomb is ticking and will go off if they aren't in jail by 4 pm.
They needed to be arrested and removed so the police could do their jobs. To do that, they needed to be disengaged. To do that, they could try asking them (failed), trying to remove them the easy way (tug, tug, failed), then pepper spray or wrasslin'. The former causes an hour or so of discomfort, and is unlikely to cause serious harm. The latter has a very good chance of leading to a dislocated limb.

Waiting patiently may be disappointing to people who hate the protestors and want to see them beaten --
I simply think people obstructing the police should be removed in an expedient manner.

but to more reasonable people,
Here we go.

seeing police exhibiting extreme patience and consideration makes the police look good.
It also means the police/UC Davis look weak to some people and/or implies the protestors are worthy of that patience and consideration. This was a no-win situation for the cops.

As a side benefit of this approach, the demonstrators are likely to come off looking immature in contrast.
They'd look immature if the videos showed the bits with them yelling "**** the police!" They'd look immature if it was widely known they were there specifically to keep the police from doing their jobs. Funny how that sort of thing is omitted.

You seem to be placing the entire onus on the Campus Security officers.
 
UC isn't Portland and, even if it were, if the context of the movement's actions is taken into account (massive fraud and theft by a financial sector that has blackmailed, corrupted and usurped the organs of democracy, creamed off the nations wealth and brought the world's economy to its knees) it is not what democracy looks like.
Empty rhetoric. The Occupy UC Davis protests seemed to be about tuition rises. The protestors who were pepper sprayed were there to keep the police from removing other protestors. #OUCD was the subject of numerous complaints from faculty and students, most of which did not want to protest.

So, you have a minority saying they should get to dictate the actions of the majority because of some inherent rightness.

Incidentally, the number of protestors and people there, compared to the UC Davis total population? About 1%.
 
Last edited:
Why would it have shown contempt? The UC Davis authorities could have backed the camp and used college facilities to encourage, develop and explore freedom of speech.
Why should they do that? The students, as far as I can tell, were violating the Uni's rules on protests.

I'm not so sure about that they desire confrontation. The main function of the camps appears to be as a venue for creating community and for education.
These protestors were. They plopped themselves right in the way of the police, and made themselves hard to remove. Then they chanted "Cops off campus!" and "**** the Police!" They were not being merely confrontational, they were actively confronting the police.

I feel a little patronized that you think I need it pointed out to me that the police are pawns. The police, however, work in a hierarchical organization. The actions of lower ranks are controlled and led by higher ranks.
Not necessarily, no.



Infantile.
Yes, that's the idea. They "could've chosen" to do a lot of things.

Why didn't they choose the winning option, then?
They didn't have a choice. The protestors put themselves in the cops' way. If they prevent the cops from breaking down the camps, they win. If the police use force, they win.

The police can do nothing and look (and be) strong. Patience is a virtue, after all, especially for community oriented policing.
Patience which would cost UC Davis money. The students were asked to move, and given plenty of time to do so.

The "cops" didn't have to pepper spray the students.
And they didn't have to refrain from doing so either. Not did the students have to obstruct the cops. If all you can drum up is "They didn't have to--", then you're not going to get very far.
 
Police do not use pepper spray, or any other non-lethal method, as a substitute for lethal force. Police don't use pepper spray when someone pulls a gun on you, or a knife, or other lethal object. Lethal force is met with lethal force.

Pepper spray is used instead of the baton, as a less injurous use of force.
I completely missed that. The not-expert strikes again.

I don't know why he keeps making force binary.
 
Why was it deemed necessary to "break down" the camp? It could simply have been left where it was.

The police could also have chosen not to arrest the seated protestors.
Why is it necessary to have laws against camping in urban public parks, or the white house lawn, or in any other public space?

Now as for me, I'm delighted to re-post evidence as often as people need to see it. If I've got strong evidence for the point I'm making, I'd be happy to post it and re-post it and re-post it, on every page of a thread, to make sure people who hadn't seen it could see it.
Great, Mr. Helpful, go back in this thread and find the links I posted. Randfan is waiting for those links and I'm anxiously waiting to see you put your money where your mouth is.

I don't know what your reason for being reluctant to post your evidence is.
Then you have a reading comprehension problem as I explained it multiple times.

Thanks Nova, I missed this.
Yeah, you've missed a lot of things. That happens when you come in at the end of a thread and demand everyone repeat stuff that has already been discussed.

Unless there is a compelling reason why protestors need to be carted off immediately, the simplest way to deal with demonstrators who link hands or chain themselves to heavy objects is to wait.
Well sorry, the police don't have the time and money to just wait to see if people will cease breaking the law and play a game of wait and see if they will quit resisting arrest.


UC isn't Portland and, even if it were, if the context of the movement's actions is taken into account (massive fraud and theft by a financial sector that has blackmailed, corrupted and usurped the organs of democracy, creamed off the nations wealth and brought the world's economy to its knees) it is not what democracy looks like.
Um, the police aren't about to weigh the pros and cons of people breaking the law to decide if they actually should enforce the laws that they are paid to do.
 
Police have, for years, dealt with protestors without the use of pepper spray.

Yes, they did. You can see examples of pepper spray-free dealing with protesters starting about 30 seconds into this video:



Pick your poison RandFan.
 
Yeah, you.

  • You refuse to accept the data I provide.
  • You refuse to lift a finger to find anything out so you can contribute.
That's not just ignorant, it's willful ignorance.
The data you provide is meaningless in the absence of an alternative to compare it to. The same tactic anti-vaxers use. OMG, the polio vaccine has caused 540 deaths!

Bob: Is there a better method?
Tim: I don't know.
Bob: Let's vaccinate them!

Were you vaccinnated for polio RandFan?

But mainly because your data is meaningless unless weighed against alternatives. You can claim ignorance, but it is your responsibility to identify a better alternative if you're going to declare that pepper spray is the wrong choice. You have to identify the right choice.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom