Logic and the payroll tax

Minoosh

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jul 15, 2011
Messages
12,906
It seems to me like GOP opposition to extending the payroll tax reduction is rationally indefensible. If people have more money they'll buy more and the "job creators" may start creating jobs. General fiscal prudence is a principle I readily accept, but ideologically, when this issue goes head-to-head with Republicans' absolute intransigence on taxing the rich, I'm completely baffled. They want the rich to keep more of their money but not the working class? How is that not class warfare? I'd like to hear rational arguments on this. General screeds against Republicans, not so much.

This could really bite them in the bum. I hope the Democrats spin the hell out of it. GOP timing could not be worse. Happy holiday shopping, and BTW you're going to make $700 less next year. What am I missing here?
 
Last edited:
What payroll tax are you talking about? There's a payroll tax holiday that's up for renewal (or not, as the case may be), that puts money in people's pockets by diverting it from the Social Security funding stream. Is that what you're talking about? If so, knowing where the money is coming from may be of interest to you.
 
It seems to me like GOP opposition to extending the payroll tax reduction is rationally indefensible. If people have more money they'll buy more and the "job creators" may start creating jobs.

This could really bite them in the bum. I hope the Democrats spin the hell out of it. GOP timing could not be worse. Happy holiday shopping, and BTW you're going to make $700 less next year. What am I missing here?

According to that logic why don't we just do away with payroll taxes completely , double Earned income credit etc all of these things will put more money into the hands of those who spend.

I do think the republicans are hurting themselves politically by refusing to even consider tax hikes on high earners.
 
What payroll tax are you talking about? There's a payroll tax holiday that's up for renewal (or not, as the case may be), that puts money in people's pockets by diverting it from the Social Security funding stream. Is that what you're talking about? If so, knowing where the money is coming from may be of interest to you.

You see, this could be a legitimate argument on its own; "by renewing tax break X, we will have less money for the use of Y." That's a basic argument that could be used to dispute any tax break whatsoever. That's an argument that can be, and is, used against the extension of parts of the Bush tax cuts.

But that doesn't really address the problems that the OP raises. If the payroll tax break that is under discussion only applied to people making a yearly salary of $500,000 or more, I am not sure people on the right would be as eager to argue that "we'll have less tax revenue!" At least, judging from their past positions on such issues.
 
Why not just extend the tax holiday another year and use the sunsetting of the Shrub-era tax cuts to put the money back?
 
What payroll tax are you talking about? There's a payroll tax holiday that's up for renewal (or not, as the case may be), that puts money in people's pockets by diverting it from the Social Security funding stream. Is that what you're talking about? If so, knowing where the money is coming from may be of interest to you.

As a factual matter, it does not. The current payroll tax holiday is paid for by the general fund and does not affect Social Security. And this is true for the proposed extension as well. Does this change your mind?

http://motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2011/12/no-payroll-tax-cut-doesnt-hurt-trust-fund
 
It seems to me like GOP opposition to extending the payroll tax reduction is rationally indefensible. If people have more money they'll buy more and the "job creators" may start creating jobs. General fiscal prudence is a principle I readily accept, but ideologically, when this issue goes head-to-head with Republicans' absolute intransigence on taxing the rich, I'm completely baffled. They want the rich to keep more of their money but not the working class? How is that not class warfare? I'd like to hear rational arguments on this. General screeds against Republicans, not so much.

This could really bite them in the bum. I hope the Democrats spin the hell out of it. GOP timing could not be worse. Happy holiday shopping, and BTW you're going to make $700 less next year. What am I missing here?



Except your premise is wrong, the GOP is *NOT* opposed to extending the payroll tax holiday; it's a question of ways and means and, as always in politics, mixing a gallon of ice cream with a gallon of dog crap, doesn't make a bill half good.

The question of raising tax rates in a "Great Recession" is a completely different issue. :rolleyes:
 
The question of raising tax rates in a "Great Recession" is a completely different issue.
I have heard this but it doesn't make much sense. Bush lowered taxes in 2001 and lowered them further in 2003. We've not seen much growth. But business are doing well. I don't think there is any shortage of cash. What exactly is supposed to happen if we raise taxes to cause such fear? And why have such low taxes not done much since 2001? Some people suggest we raise taxes and offer credits to direct business investments.
 
I have heard this but it doesn't make much sense. Bush lowered taxes in 2001 and lowered them further in 2003. We've not seen much growth. But business are doing well. I don't think there is any shortage of cash. What exactly is supposed to happen if we raise taxes to cause such fear? And why have such low taxes not done much since 2001? Some people suggest we raise taxes and offer credits to direct business investments.

That was the Paul Tsongas plan in a nutshell. Pass a law that says if you do the right thing (hire more people, clean up your pollution, etc) you get a tax break. If you don't, you get a tax increase. Then you let shareholders push the company to save on taxes and do the right thing. That seemed very sensible to me. At least under those tax cuts, society can get something in return instead of just trusting businesses to use their windfalls in a way that offsets the lost revenue to the government.
 
I have heard this but it doesn't make much sense. Bush lowered taxes in 2001 and lowered them further in 2003. We've not seen much growth. But business are doing well. I don't think there is any shortage of cash. What exactly is supposed to happen if we raise taxes to cause such fear? And why have such low taxes not done much since 2001? Some people suggest we raise taxes and offer credits to direct business investments.


Does anyone think that removing more money from the private sector will make it grow faster? :confused:

And, just for fun, considering total fed, state, local, city, etc. taxes, what percentage of a person's income should be paid in taxes? To make it easier, just consider a person making $1,000,000.00 per year.
 
Does anyone think that removing more money from the private sector will make it grow faster?
YES! Absolutely if the money diverted back into the economy and if tax credits are provided to incentiveize corporations to invest money back into the economy. Damn straight I do.

I'm sorry but you are simply out of gas. Businesses are flush with cash. Having money doesn't mean companies will hire people. There must first be demand to justify hiring people. SUPPLY SIDE DOESN'T WORK.
 
Last edited:
YES! Absolutely if the money diverted back into the economy and if tax credits are provided to incentiveize corporations to invest money back into the economy. Damn straight I do.

I'm sorry but you are simply out of gas. Businesses are flush with cash. Having money doesn't mean companies will hire people. There must first be demand to justify hiring people. SUPPLY SIDE DOESN'T WORK.

Well said!
 
YES! Absolutely if the money diverted back into the economy and if tax credits are provided to incentiveize corporations to invest money back into the economy. Damn straight I do.

I'm sorry but you are simply out of gas. Businesses are flush with cash. Having money doesn't mean companies will hire people. There must first be demand to justify hiring people. SUPPLY SIDE DOESN'T WORK.


It seems you think that government bureaucrats are better at running businesses than anyone in the private sector, no? And tax credits for innovative expansion has been done in the past (and, guess what, they work - too bad the idiots in the White House aren't interested in that!) but that has nothing to do with personal tax rates.

GDP went up for 5 years even while a silly amount of money was wasted in Iraq and on the Medicare-D program. But I am not sure what no-tax-decrease outcome you might be comparing that to in your crystal ball.

Momentum as far as I can tell.

And if we went back to the per capita government spending (at fed, state, local and city-levels) of those eras, I have little doubt our economy would be a great deal better. Your opinion may differ.

Businesses are flush with cash? Multi-national corporations may be cash rich with overseas holding but small businesses are still in big trouble and facing a very uncertain future.

People without jobs or with uncertain futures don't stimulate demand. And sticking it those people and corporations who tend to create jobs isn't going to help the situation.

I note that you ignored my simple question. I'm happy to give you another chance ... ;)
 
It seems you think that government bureaucrats are better at running businesses than anyone in the private sector, no?
Yes, and?

And tax credits for innovative expansion has been done in the past (and, guess what, they work - too bad the idiots in the White House aren't interested in that!) but that has nothing to do with personal tax rates.
It could if we offered incentives to individuals based on investing.

GDP went up for 5 years
Adjusting for inflation it was pathetic. I have the numbers. I have the charts. I'm happy to debate that.

...even while a silly amount of money was wasted in Iraq and on the Medicare-D program. But I am not sure what no-tax-decrease outcome you might be comparing that to in your crystal ball.
I'm only stating facts.

Businesses are flush with cash? Multi-national corporations may be cash rich with overseas holding but small businesses are still in big trouble and facing a very uncertain future.
Hey, give them tax credits the way they were given during the Eisenhower and Nixon era. No one is arguing to simply raise taxes. I've already stated that plainly.

People without jobs or with uncertain futures don't stimulate demand.
Yep, they need money.

And sticking it those people and corporations who tend to create jobs isn't going to help the situation.
It's not sticking it to them. It's reasonably taxing them and it's not just my idea. David Stockman, Reagan's budget director, is making that argument.

I note that you ignored my simple question. I'm happy to give you another chance ...
I apologize. It's been argued that we should go back to Clinton's tax rates for the higher tiers and keep the middle tax rates the same. I think that is a good idea.
 
Last edited:
"The Economy" being merely money going in circles, I just don't see which pockets the money goes through having any effect on "The Economy".

The OP was about taking the money out of the private sector's pockets and putting it into the Government's pockets, from which it will be spent/doled/given back to the private sector- corporations, civil servants, military personnel pay, etc. "The Government" is just one more stop for the money to make as it transits the circle.

I can see that taking the money by force (taxes) is one way to speed it on it's way on the cycle. How is that bad? Versus leaving it in peoples pockets, where it will be either spent or saved. Spending = good for the economy. Saving = stuck in an investment= good for the economy. Banked= loaned out to somebody else to invest= good for the economy.

Seems to be true, what I've always heard- nothing the government ever did actually had an effect on the economy.

So then, the term 'sluggish economy' is the crux. It's a matter of how fast the money makes it's trip around the cycle from employer to employee/consumer to marketer to producer to miner to government, back to the people via the same cycle. Speed is the key, not which pockets.

But what do we measure anyhow? Let me start the cycle by spending my money on a $10 widget at the hardware store. I pay the store, which spends all $10 for paying the wholesaler, clerk, overhead, and profit. The wholesaler pays the producer (plus labor, overhead) the producer buys the raw material and pays labor, the material supplier buys the ore from the mining company. My $10 has made six steps, each worth $10, that is $60 to the economy. This is called "The Gross Domestic Product", or GDP. $10 = $60. Sounds like the old Hokus-Pocus, Smoke & Mirrors, Figure don't lie but Liars figure. Yet I still eat regularly, buy gas, scrimp on luxuries...

I guess the only real measure of an economy is the very basics of life- food. Are the people well fed, the economy is in great shape. All other metrics are baloney.
 
"The Economy" being merely money going in circles, I just don't see which pockets the money goes through having any effect on "The Economy".

The OP was about taking the money out of the private sector's pockets and putting it into the Government's pockets, from which it will be spent/doled/given back to the private sector- corporations, civil servants, military personnel pay, etc. "The Government" is just one more stop for the money to make as it transits the circle.

I can see that taking the money by force (taxes) is one way to speed it on it's way on the cycle. How is that bad? Versus leaving it in peoples pockets, where it will be either spent or saved. Spending = good for the economy. Saving = stuck in an investment= good for the economy. Banked= loaned out to somebody else to invest= good for the economy.

Seems to be true, what I've always heard- nothing the government ever did actually had an effect on the economy.

So then, the term 'sluggish economy' is the crux. It's a matter of how fast the money makes it's trip around the cycle from employer to employee/consumer to marketer to producer to miner to government, back to the people via the same cycle. Speed is the key, not which pockets.

But what do we measure anyhow? Let me start the cycle by spending my money on a $10 widget at the hardware store. I pay the store, which spends all $10 for paying the wholesaler, clerk, overhead, and profit. The wholesaler pays the producer (plus labor, overhead) the producer buys the raw material and pays labor, the material supplier buys the ore from the mining company. My $10 has made six steps, each worth $10, that is $60 to the economy. This is called "The Gross Domestic Product", or GDP. $10 = $60. Sounds like the old Hokus-Pocus, Smoke & Mirrors, Figure don't lie but Liars figure. Yet I still eat regularly, buy gas, scrimp on luxuries...

I guess the only real measure of an economy is the very basics of life- food. Are the people well fed, the economy is in great shape. All other metrics are baloney.
It sucks to be homeless and unable to get health care. That aside, I actually agree that food is a significant and important metric as to the strength of the economy. So, I'm going to agree with you 33%. :) I have a few issues but overall I think it is a good post.
 
"The Economy" being merely money going in circles, I just don't see which pockets the money goes through having any effect on "The Economy".

But of course, that's not what the economy is at all. If it were, well, just print more money and problem solved!

No, the economy is about a hell of a lot more than just cash. It's also about goods, services, and capital. And how well it runs depends not only on money circulating somewhere, but also on how efficiently allocated resources are. That's what money is supposed to do, by the way. Money isn't the economy, rather, money is how we transmit information in order to decide how to allocate resources. And which pockets money goes through has a very obvious impact on how resources get allocated. In particular, they get allocated according to the decisions of the people whose pocket it goes through. And how resources get allocated matters. It matters a lot. Some purposes really are better than others. Some purposes have large positive impact, some purposes have no impact or even negative impact.

The OP was about taking the money out of the private sector's pockets and putting it into the Government's pockets, from which it will be spent/doled/given back to the private sector- corporations, civil servants, military personnel pay, etc. "The Government" is just one more stop for the money to make as it transits the circle.

At every single stop, the person holding the dollars gets a hand in deciding how resources get allocated because of that money. Now, if you think government is an efficient allocator of economic resources, then you wouldn't see a problem with this. But if you think that maybe government isn't that great at allocating resources, well... then there is a potential problem with more money passing through government's pocket.

So then, the term 'sluggish economy' is the crux. It's a matter of how fast the money makes it's trip around the cycle from employer to employee/consumer to marketer to producer to miner to government, back to the people via the same cycle. Speed is the key, not which pockets.

No. You and I could trade dollars back and forth all day, buying each other's naval lint, and it wouldn't help one bit. What money gets spent on really does matter.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom