A coherent definition of God

You are already quite enlightened..... I cite everything you said in your post. :)

But also remember that Ferdinand II was Holy Roman Emperor and King of Holland for a while.... so obviously Papal influence was not far off.

I also remember reading (a million years ago) that Descartes was also tried for some sort of Heresy and had to leave Holland.... I may be wrong though...my memory has never been any good and now it is even worse.... I am not able to find anything on the internet.


http://library.thinkquest.org/18775/descartes/biod.htm
Descartes' philosophy became famous during the last decade of his life. Descartes was later accused of heresy at the University of Leyden and wrote a letter of self-defense to its trustees in 1647. He feared that he might be arrested and killed, like Galileo, but that never happened.

Also mentions heresy in claims he was poisoned by a catholic priest....
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/feb/14/rene-descartes-poisoned-catholic-priest
 
http://library.thinkquest.org/18775/descartes/biod.htm

Descartes' philosophy became famous during the last decade of his life. Descartes was later accused of heresy at the University of Leyden and wrote a letter of self-defense to its trustees in 1647. He feared that he might be arrested and killed, like Galileo, but that never happened.


Also mentions heresy in claims he was poisoned by a catholic priest....
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/feb/14/rene-descartes-poisoned-catholic-priest



Aha...I am not as senile as I thought..... THANKS a lot Joolz.... those links are good.

ETA: The link has a slight error. Galileo was never killed but Bruno was.
 
Last edited:
You are already quite enlightened..... I cite everything you said in your post. :)
:)

But also remember that Ferdinand II was Holy Roman Emperor and King of Holland for a while.... so obviously Papal influence was not far off.
[nitpick mode on]Lord of the Netherlands, which is shorthand for "Count of Holland, Count of Zeeland, Count of Flanders, Duke of Brabant, etc. etc.". However, that title passed from Emperor Charles V on his abdication to the Spanish Habsburgs, Philips II and his successors. The Emperors had no effective say here.
[/nitpick]
And well, the Spanish Habsburgs, we threw them out because their main hobbies were to burn Calvinists and to import Spanish civil servants who'd replace/overrule the home-grown nobility and, most of all, the city regents, and trample on our liberties. And as we were at war with them, we certainly didn't want them to influence our politics.

I also remember reading (a million years ago) that Descartes was also tried for some sort of Heresy and had to leave Holland.... I may be wrong though...my memory has never been any good and now it is even worse.... I am not able to find anything on the internet.
That was new to me, I always thought Descartes left because he got an offer he couldn't refuse from an attractive Swedish queen. :D On top of Joolz' evidence, here's a page with some more specifics:
Descartes’ relations with the Dutch began to sour when his follower, and Professor of Medicine and Botany at the University of Utrecht, Henricus Regius, held a public disputation in 1641 in which he defended the controversial thesis that the human mind and human body formed an accidental not a substantial union. In his book Descartes and the Dutch, Theo Verbeek reports that, probably in an effort to protect Descartes from legal charges by the conservative Calvinist rector of the university, Gijsbert Voetius, Regius claimed to take his thesis from the deceased Dutch atomist philosopher, David Gorlaeus rather than from Descartes. Unfortunately, this only served to fan the flames of Voetius’ wrath as Gorlaeus had been an Arminian sympathizer when the more liberal Arminians clashed with orthodox Calvinists during Voetius’ days as a theology student in Leiden.
The debate between Arminians and orthodox Calvinists had, 20 years earlier, not only been a theological debate but also fanned out to politics.
 
Aha...I am not as senile as I thought..... THANKS a lot Joolz.... those links are good.

ETA: The link has a slight error. Galileo was never killed but Bruno was.


Religion has so much to answer for. Still does, as I see from your link that they reaffirmed their decision to prosecute Bruno on the 400th anniv of his death. That'd be 2000, just as the planet, apart from the church, moved into the 21st century.
 
Religion has so much to answer for. Still does, as I see from your link that they reaffirmed their decision to prosecute Bruno on the 400th anniv of his death. That'd be 2000, just as the planet, apart from the church, moved into the 21st century.


They officially apologized about Galileo but since Bruno is not very well known they were never PRESSURED to apologize about SNUFFING his life and the resulting loss to humanity, not to mention the loss of his GENES that may have benefited humanity along the last 400+ years.

The egregious harm that religion causes is not just of a direct effect to its victims....rather it is an all pervasive chronic retardation of humanity due to direct suppression of knowledge and even more importantly due to the LOSS of opportunities that may have evolved the human condition a long time ago.

For examples of this consider the RETARDATION and VITIATION with which Christianity eventually plagued the human race.

Among the very deeply pensive and poignant short stories in the marvelous book Galileo's Children: Tales of Science Vs. Superstition , the one by Keith Roberts called The will Of God expresses most exquisitely the effects of Christianity on the world.

Roberts' short story explores the possibility of an inventive mind that creates the phonograph during the Inquisition era and is burnt on the stake as a witch along with his demon-summoning contraption, his scribblings, as well as the only witness to the facts, his maid that snitched on him to the Grand Inquisitor after being terrified out of her mind by the demon voices coming out of the device.

This fictional account is quite illustrative of what Christianity managed to do across the board to all SCIENCE and KNOWLEDGE in REALITY, not just in a fictional ponderings. Giordano Bruno being one example among many.

A REAL historical parallel to the above story is the MURDER of Hypatia by Christians.

Hypatia was an amazing mind. Who knows what more she could have accomplished had not "the mob of Christian monks flayed her body with ostraca (pot shards), and then burned her remains". All because of Christian Love and Tolerance.


Also see this illuminating albeit tragic information. Not to mention the persecution of women throughout the Christian ages (also see this).
 
Last edited:
:)
[nitpick mode on]Lord of the Netherlands, which is shorthand for "Count of Holland, Count of Zeeland, Count of Flanders, Duke of Brabant, etc. etc.". However, that title passed from Emperor Charles V on his abdication to the Spanish Habsburgs, Philips II and his successors. The Emperors had no effective say here.
[/nitpick]
And well, the Spanish Habsburgs, we threw them out because their main hobbies were to burn Calvinists and to import Spanish civil servants who'd replace/overrule the home-grown nobility and, most of all, the city regents, and trample on our liberties. And as we were at war with them, we certainly didn't want them to influence our politics.


I surmise you are Dutch and thus should know infinitely more about Holland's history than I could.



That was new to me, I always thought Descartes left because he got an offer he couldn't refuse from an attractive Swedish queen. :D On top of Joolz' evidence, here's a page with some more specifics:

The debate between Arminians and orthodox Calvinists had, 20 years earlier, not only been a theological debate but also fanned out to politics.



It must be something the Dutch don't want to remember ... I don't blame you.
:D

It was tragic how he died soon after going to live in Sweden.... the Catholic priest poisoning is an interesting and plausible theory. But it is not beyond the imagination that Sweden's weather killed him... :D
 
:D

It was tragic how he died soon after going to live in Sweden.... the Catholic priest poisoning is an interesting and plausible theory. But it is not beyond the imagination that Sweden's weather killed him... :D

In 1649 Queen Christina of Sweden persuaded Descartes to go to Stockholm. However the Queen wanted to draw tangents at 5 a.m. and Descartes broke the habit of his lifetime of getting up at 11 o'clock. After only a few months in the cold northern climate, walking to the palace for 5 o'clock every morning, he died of pneumonia.
 
In 1649 Queen Christina of Sweden persuaded Descartes to go to Stockholm. However the Queen wanted to draw tangents at 5 a.m. and Descartes broke the habit of his lifetime of getting up at 11 o'clock. After only a few months in the cold northern climate, walking to the palace for 5 o'clock every morning, he died of pneumonia.

Nonsense! A cold climate does not contribute to getting a cold, etc.

Notice the people who winter over in Antarctica. After a few weeks, no more colds for the rest of winter.


Colds come from other people and not from the weather!

This myth has been dis-proven many times.
 
Religion has so much to answer for. Still does, as I see from your link that they reaffirmed their decision to prosecute Bruno on the 400th anniv of his death. That'd be 2000, just as the planet, apart from the church, moved into the 21st century.

What. The. ****?! I'm completely dumbfounded. :jaw-dropp
 
Nonsense! A cold climate does not contribute to getting a cold, etc.

Notice the people who winter over in Antarctica. After a few weeks, no more colds for the rest of winter.


Colds come from other people and not from the weather!

This myth has been dis-proven many times.

Pneumonia is not a cold.
 
They officially apologized about Galileo <snip>

Thanks for the interesting links, and making me look up 'vitiation' in the dictionary :D The list on the truthbeknown link is something I've been hoping to find for for a while.

The phonograph point is interesting. Got me thinking about how 'christians' would treat a messiah arriving nowadays. He's prob get beaten up, or shot. They certainly wouldn't believe him as they think they know better than everyone else.

There's an old Star Trek episode where there was a modern earth type place that got such a visitation, I remember fighting in it, but not much else. Saw it years ago. Maybe a Trekkie would remember what happened.
 
I used to believe in an alien god. But a voice told me that is was just a dream I had. His main characteristic was that he did not speak to me. Thus I don't know if he is there or not. I have climbed the mountain but not because anybody asked me to.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the interesting links, and making me look up 'vitiation' in the dictionary :D The list on the truthbeknown link is something I've been hoping to find for for a while.


You are welcome.... I am told that one should make sure to do two things every day
  • Laugh at least once
  • Learn at least one thing new


Sorry about the laugh part... :D


Now I am going to make you angry...:o

Don't think that the religious persecution of scientists was confined to before the enlightenment. As this link shows even in the 20th century theists were persecuting scientists whenever they could.

Bertrand Russell found that Christian persecution exists even in the 20th century. One of the greatest of modern philosophers, Russell angered many Christians with his essay, Why I am not a Christian. And they exacted their revenge in 1940, when Russell accepted an appointment at the College of the City of New York. The Christian community launched a furious and protracted campaign to prevent the appointment, printing slanderous accusations of homosexuality, child molestation, public nudity and lechery. (This, for his mildly liberal views on sex, which would be considered tame by today's standards.) Even New York's highest political officials joined the assault, calling him a "dog" who should be "tarred and feathered and driven out of the country." Christians sued in court to prevent Russell's appointment, and in a trial filled with legal howlers, Russell was barred from teaching in New York State -- in a word, censored.



There's an old Star Trek episode where there was a modern earth type place that got such a visitation, I remember fighting in it, but not much else. Saw it years ago. Maybe a Trekkie would remember what happened.


Sorry Captain it can’t be done... :D….. I like Star Trek in all of its versions but I am not much of a Trekky to remember the episodes.
 
Pneumonia is not a cold.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pneumonia

Cause

Pneumonia is due primarily to infections, with less common causes including irritants and the unknown. Although more than one hundred strains of microorganisms can cause pneumonia, only a few are responsible for most cases. The most common types of infectious are viruses and bacteria, with its being less commonly due to fungi or parasites. Mixed infections with both viruses and bacterial may occur in up to 45% of infections in children and 15% of infections in adults.[15] A causative agent is not isolated in approximately half of cases despite careful testing.[16] The term pneumonia is sometimes more broadly applied to inflammation of the lung (for example caused by autoimmune disease, chemical burns or drug reactions), however this is more accurately referred to as pneumonitis.[17][18]

Cold weather is not a cause of pneumonia.
 
There's an old Star Trek episode where there was a modern earth type place that got such a visitation, I remember fighting in it, but not much else. Saw it years ago. Maybe a Trekkie would remember what happened.

Would help if you knew which series of Star Trek there were 5 or 6 of them, plus 11 movies.

Speaking of which, this whole 'God' thing reminds me of "Return of the Archons", creepy episode and good indication of what I believe that the religious would like to use technology for.
 
You are welcome.... I am told that one should make sure to do two things every day
  • Laugh at least once
  • Learn at least one thing new .
Good advice that I try and follow too, although JREF has given me an overdose on #2 recently :D

Sorry about the laugh part... :D .

Never apologise for enlightening people! :)


Now I am going to make you angry...:o

Don't think that the religious persecution of scientists was confined to before the enlightenment. As this link shows even in the 20th century theists were persecuting scientists whenever they could.

Not so much angry as sad at a world that still persecutes people who work for knowledge :( It seems to go on even today, albeit in a (sometimes) more subtle way. The denigration of scientists who believe in evolution is a prime example. That Bachmann woman claiming they were talking rubbish and the movement to promote ID in schools shows the contempt some idiots have for science.

The way that some 'Merkans are gun happy and the foul and despicable threats made by the christian right in the link I posted recently are reasons I won't discount a scientist being murdered for his/her research even today. :(:(:(


Sorry Captain it can’t be done... :D….. I like Star Trek in all of its versions but I am not much of a Trekky to remember the episodes.

Just posted the link. Kirk thought they were 'sun' worshippers but turned out of was 'son' (of god) worshippers. Weirdos either way ;)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom