158 papers written by me personally wouldn't convince an EU hater of anything.
Unless and until you actually do write such papers, there's no way to tell, is there?
I mean, I'm just using your logic re fission as the predominant source of the Sun's energy ...
Alfven wrote HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops.
Perhaps he did.
However, a) you are not Alfvén, and b) you have not written a single paper "
on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to Alfvén's "
HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops".
This crew doesn't care one iota about the maths in the final analysis. Did the paper by Mann and Onel convince anyone here of the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity?
Maybe it did, maybe it didn't.
However, that's hardly relevant, is it?
After all, a) you are not Mann or Onel, and b) you have not written a single paper on "
the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to anything Mann and Onel wrote on "
the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity".
How many of you accept that "electrical discharges happen" in plasmas/conductors yet?
Maybe some do, maybe all do, maybe no one does.
However, that's hardly relevant, is it?
After all, your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to "
electrical discharges happen[ing]" in plasmas/conductors".
Dungey linked flares to electrical discharges DECADES ago and yet this crew REMAINS in hard core denial to this very day.
Maybe he did, maybe he didn't.
However, that's hardly relevant, is it?
After all, a) you are not Dungey, and b) you have not written a single paper linking "
flares to electrical discharges". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to anything Dungey wrote linking "
flares to electrical discharges".
<more of the same skipped>
One thing that this thread has taught me is that no amount of maths really matter to a hater.
As I am not "a hater" (whatever this is), I cannot say.
However, in terms of the amount of math that would be convincing to me, well, I've already provided an extensive list of exactly what I would regard as a good start, in several posts this month alone.
As far as I know, you did not respond to any of those questions/suggestions in any way that could be called positive; specifically, you did not provide anything quantitative that links your published electric Sun idea - as it relates to coronal activity (the subject of this thread) - with any published experimental results, observational results, simulations, theory, ...
I'd be delighted to be proven wrong.
<rant skipped>
I do honestly believe that fusion is the primary source of energy from the sun.
With these few words, you have just declared yourself to be no longer a member of the EU community. How does it feel?
I assume it has the "standard' solar mass, the standard solar output in terms of energy production, and undergoes STANDARD atmospheric behaviors from about 4800K under the photosphere outward, including convection, coronal loops, etc. If and when I see any real opportunity to DEVIATE in some way from STANDARD theory in a way that produces TESTABLE differences between them, I'll sit down and write a paper about it.
Good. I, for one, look forward to reading just such a paper.
At the moment I can't even think of anything to write about that might convince a hater of anything.
Why should that be a motivation, or even a consideration, regarding your research and/or writing?
If you're doing science, your results will stand or fall on their own two feet (so to speak). As long, of course, as it's objective, and independently verifiable ...
SDO does in fact present a new frontier in terms of coronal loop activity, and I do have some projects I'm working on that I believe are worth the effort. It's done in my "spare time". To do it "properly" will require the accumulation of information over YEARS, not weeks, or even months. If and when I feel it's PUBLISHABLE and I see how the data works out, you'll be the first to know.
Good. Thanks.
Despite the OVERWHELMING evidence to demonstrate the scientific legitimacy of evolutionary theory, there are steadfast creationists. Likewise, despite the OVERWHELMING scientific evidence to demonstrate that electrical discharges occur in solar flares, and circuit theory in general, there will always be 'EU haters'.
That may be so. Or not.
However, that's hardly relevant, is it?
(You can fill in the rest of what I want to say, can't you?)
IMO this crew is *SO* emotionally invested in their position, nothing I personally publish will EVER be 'enough' anymore than anything BIRKELAND published was ever enough to convince the mainstream in his lifetime, or Alfven convinced this crew.
How does it go, "They laughed at Galileo, they laughed at Einstein, ..."?
It's all about BASHING PEOPLE with creationists and EU haters. It's all about protecting their current belief systems. Truth is irrelevant.
Nice rant.
Now, about those quantitative results, linking your published electric Sun ideas with ....