Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It was a discussion about the first public relations color composite image from the SDO. The mis-alignment of the originals made a greenish stripe around the Sun in the image. The colors were simply mis-aligned, and several of us through objective analysis were able to determine that.

BZZZT!!!!!

The *green color* has *ABSOLUTELY NOTHING* to do with any "alignment problems". The COLOR is a direct results of assigning the various iron ion wavelengths a COLOR and then overlaying the various wavelengths and THEREBY BLENDING COLORS, in this case yellow and blue. In no way is the COLOR created by a misalignment of images. You haven't the FIRST CLUE how solar satellite images actually work.

All iron ion composite image generate that same effect:
http://sdowww.lmsal.com/sdomedia/SunInTime/2012/02/17/l_211_193_171.jpg

The color of the atmosphere around the sun changes when you change the color assignments that are assigned to the various iron ion wavelengths:
http://sdowww.lmsal.com/sdomedia/SunInTime/2012/02/17/l_094_335_193.jpg
 
Last edited:
158 papers written by me personally wouldn't convince an EU hater of anything.
Unless and until you actually do write such papers, there's no way to tell, is there?

I mean, I'm just using your logic re fission as the predominant source of the Sun's energy ...

Alfven wrote HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops.
Perhaps he did.

However, a) you are not Alfvén, and b) you have not written a single paper "on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to Alfvén's "HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops".

This crew doesn't care one iota about the maths in the final analysis. Did the paper by Mann and Onel convince anyone here of the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity?
Maybe it did, maybe it didn't.

However, that's hardly relevant, is it?

After all, a) you are not Mann or Onel, and b) you have not written a single paper on "the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to anything Mann and Onel wrote on "the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity".

How many of you accept that "electrical discharges happen" in plasmas/conductors yet?
Maybe some do, maybe all do, maybe no one does.

However, that's hardly relevant, is it?

After all, your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to "electrical discharges happen[ing]" in plasmas/conductors".

Dungey linked flares to electrical discharges DECADES ago and yet this crew REMAINS in hard core denial to this very day.
Maybe he did, maybe he didn't.

However, that's hardly relevant, is it?

After all, a) you are not Dungey, and b) you have not written a single paper linking "flares to electrical discharges". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to anything Dungey wrote linking "flares to electrical discharges".

<more of the same skipped>

One thing that this thread has taught me is that no amount of maths really matter to a hater.
As I am not "a hater" (whatever this is), I cannot say.

However, in terms of the amount of math that would be convincing to me, well, I've already provided an extensive list of exactly what I would regard as a good start, in several posts this month alone.

As far as I know, you did not respond to any of those questions/suggestions in any way that could be called positive; specifically, you did not provide anything quantitative that links your published electric Sun idea - as it relates to coronal activity (the subject of this thread) - with any published experimental results, observational results, simulations, theory, ...

I'd be delighted to be proven wrong.

<rant skipped>

I do honestly believe that fusion is the primary source of energy from the sun.
With these few words, you have just declared yourself to be no longer a member of the EU community. How does it feel?

I assume it has the "standard' solar mass, the standard solar output in terms of energy production, and undergoes STANDARD atmospheric behaviors from about 4800K under the photosphere outward, including convection, coronal loops, etc. If and when I see any real opportunity to DEVIATE in some way from STANDARD theory in a way that produces TESTABLE differences between them, I'll sit down and write a paper about it.
Good. I, for one, look forward to reading just such a paper.

At the moment I can't even think of anything to write about that might convince a hater of anything.
Why should that be a motivation, or even a consideration, regarding your research and/or writing?

If you're doing science, your results will stand or fall on their own two feet (so to speak). As long, of course, as it's objective, and independently verifiable ...

SDO does in fact present a new frontier in terms of coronal loop activity, and I do have some projects I'm working on that I believe are worth the effort. It's done in my "spare time". To do it "properly" will require the accumulation of information over YEARS, not weeks, or even months. If and when I feel it's PUBLISHABLE and I see how the data works out, you'll be the first to know.
Good. Thanks.

Despite the OVERWHELMING evidence to demonstrate the scientific legitimacy of evolutionary theory, there are steadfast creationists. Likewise, despite the OVERWHELMING scientific evidence to demonstrate that electrical discharges occur in solar flares, and circuit theory in general, there will always be 'EU haters'.
That may be so. Or not.

However, that's hardly relevant, is it?

(You can fill in the rest of what I want to say, can't you?)

IMO this crew is *SO* emotionally invested in their position, nothing I personally publish will EVER be 'enough' anymore than anything BIRKELAND published was ever enough to convince the mainstream in his lifetime, or Alfven convinced this crew.
How does it go, "They laughed at Galileo, they laughed at Einstein, ..."?

It's all about BASHING PEOPLE with creationists and EU haters. It's all about protecting their current belief systems. Truth is irrelevant.
Nice rant.

Now, about those quantitative results, linking your published electric Sun ideas with ....
 
Woah. I've created MANY RD images.


Many? Thirty five frames in a short video? Without even understanding how the images were made? The evidence does not seem to support much relevant experience or qualification.


I've now had a chance to re-examine the running difference video "rdquiz.wmv" that was provided somewhere around 2010-04-13. My objective analysis shows the running difference images themselves were likely created by NASA or one of its affiliated organizations, and that they were assembled into a video using the Windows Movie Maker program. It appears the claim, "I've created MANY RD images," may be false in its entirety.
 
The core simply releases the raw material, neutrons, which decay into ELECTRICAL CURRENT (AKA moving charged particles) that are necessarily moving OUTBOUND.

Neutrons decay into equal amounts of p+ and e-, which travel a short distances in random directions. This is not an electric current---it's a hot, neutral, isotropic plasma. If you inject so many neutrons that it makes this plasma flow outwards, obviously that flow includes both the + and the - components in exactly equal numbers---what else do you think happens? Were you picturing the p+ moving away from the core and the e- magically evaporating?

Nothing "comes back" to the spinning core. The EM field around the core spits out particles at close to the speed of light.

No it doesn't. You're in the middle of a blob of hydrogen at white-dwarf-like density. You're not in a vacuum or near-vacuum with long mean free paths. What makes you think they have high velocities?

Start by explaining to me WHY you think a RAW NEUTRON STAR is somehow going to experience "runaway fusion" just because it spits out protons and electrons around itself?

Because it's in the middle of the Sun, and the Sun has some hot matter in it---remember that stuff? The stuff that fills out the rest of the 4e7m sphere? Anyway, that stuff is gravitationally attracted to the neutron star, and (as any undergrad astronomer can tell you) this stuff gets compressed by this attraction. High-density matter has higher fusion rates than low-density matter (even a dimensional analysis can tell you that), but lower heat transfer rates, and this combination leads to extremely fast energy production. Whether that's "stable burning" or "detonation" is a question for detailed calculation, so I looked up such a calculation and used their numbers as a benchmark.

That's where I stand. Are you going to sit there and say "You shouldn't have done that calculation", or are you going to say "My coauthors and I calculated the structure more accurately than you did and got a different answer"?
 
I've now had a chance to re-examine the running difference video "rdquiz.wmv" that was provided somewhere around 2010-04-13. My objective analysis shows the running difference images themselves were likely created by NASA or one of its affiliated organizations, and that they were assembled into a video using the Windows Movie Maker program. It appears the claim, "I've created MANY RD images," may be false in its entirety.

Show me the original NASA images or retract your lies. I created those RD images myself and I explained *EXACTLY* which software I used to create them. You've demonstrated yet again that you lie and lie often and your so called video expertise is meaningless. Your "professional opinion" is dead wrong *AS USUAL*.
 
Last edited:
The *green color* has *ABSOLUTELY NOTHING* to do with any "alignment problems". The COLOR is a direct results of assigning the various iron ion wavelengths a COLOR and then overlaying the various wavelengths and THEREBY BLENDING COLORS, in this case yellow and blue. In no way is the COLOR created by a misalignment of images. You haven't the FIRST CLUE how solar satellite images actually work.


Leaving aside the incivility and personal attack, that comment is utter and complete nonsense. It demonstrates an absolute lack of understanding of satellite imagery, acquisition, processing, composition, and distribution.

All iron ion composite image generate that same effect:
http://sdowww.lmsal.com/sdomedia/SunInTime/2012/02/17/l_211_193_171.jpg

The color of the atmosphere around the sun changes when you change the color assignments that are assigned to the various iron ion wavelengths:
http://sdowww.lmsal.com/sdomedia/SunInTime/2012/02/17/l_094_335_193.jpg


That is an objectively wrong assessment which appears to come from a position of absolute lack of understanding computer graphics and satellite imagery. Although it appears to be an attempt to deceive, it may just be a gross mistake based on an elementary misunderstanding of some very simple concepts. Almost any idiot familiar with one of several pieces of free graphics software would objectively agree that it is total nonsense and completely wrong. Making those RGB composite images is child's play for anyone with simple background in graphics. I made these from nearly raw data sent back from the SDO less than two hours ago. It took me less than 15 minutes.

0943351930000.jpg


2111931710000.jpg
 
"Making them" and "understanding them" are two entirely different things. I'm sure you could MAKE the same RD video I made too, but you obviously don't understand that I CREATED THOSE RD IMAGES. You own prejudices influence your "opinion" in a very negative way. You are blinded by your own hatred to the point that your "professional expertize" is WRONG and BLATANTLY wrong.

Once again, you may understand VIDEO EDITING, but you know NOTHING about masonry just because we discuss an image of a brick wall, and you know nothing about solar physics or the RD image that *I CREATED*. You claimed that electrical discharges cannot occur in a conductor so you are COMPLETELY UNQUALIFIED to discuss solar satellite images in general! Dungey was correct. Flares involve "electrical discharges". Conductors can and do experience "electrical discharges". Like I said earlier. You may know something about video editing but your opinions in this thread are utterly WRONG!
 
Last edited:
You need to provide proof, not claims that the mainstream opinion is wrong.

I already did that MANY TIMES. I started with EMPIRICAL LABORATORY SUPPORT from Lee in the 70's that showed an EMPIRICAL connection between *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* and highly ionized iron like we might observe in an SDO image.

I threw in Alfven's work. I tossed in a NOBEL PRIZE WORTHY PAPER IMO with that Mann and Onel paper. None of you care.

MR theory scored a wimpy 1 of 7 on the high energy "proof" scale. NO empirical connection has been presented showing an empirical link between MR and SDO iron line images. NONE!

I'm not even claiming that the mainstream is "wrong" to embrace the B, I'm only claiming it's WRONG for not ALSO EMBRACING THE E!

What more can I personally do on that front anyway? If you won't accept that electrical discharges occur in flares, what *WILL* you accept? You folks claim to honor Dungey's work, and ALfven's work, but evidently only HALF of it.
 
Last edited:
Unless and until you actually do write such papers, there's no way to tell, is there?

Sure there is. All I have to do is use this thread to see that Lee's empirical lab work doesn't matter to you. I can see that Alfven's work on double layers doesn't matter to you. I can see that Dungey's work on electrical discharges in solar flares doesn't mean anything to an EU hater. I can see that even a paper of the caliber of that paper by Onel and Mann does not matter one IOTA to a hater. All that matters to a hater is continuing the battle/hate at all costs, science be damned. That's why there will always be creationists and there will always be EU haters. :(

You can't be interested in "truth" DRD and have been ignorant for the last 7 years that the model(s) I support is *INTERNALLY* powered. You just don't care. What difference will one or two papers make when you're ignored dozens already, including papers written by a Nobel Prize winning scientist?
 
Last edited:
DeiRenDopa said:
Unless and until you actually do write such papers, there's no way to tell, is there?
Sure there is. All I have to do is use this thread to see that Lee's empirical lab work doesn't matter to you.
Let's see now, this thread is - per your own post, IIRC - about the Sun's corona (well, photosphere to corona, or something like that).

And it's about the electric Sun idea that you, MM, have proposed.

That idea is presented, published one might almost say, on your website, as you have also reminded us, quite a few times, recently.

So the obvious question to ask would be this: does your website contain material which - quantitatively - links "Lee's empirical lab work" to your electric Sun ideas?

Hmm, well, I looked, but could not find any such material. Maybe I missed it; can you point us all to it please?

I can see that Alfven's work on double layers doesn't matter to you. I can see that Dungey's work on electrical discharges in solar flares doesn't mean anything to an EU hater. I can see that even a paper of the caliber of that paper by Onel and Mann does not matter one IOTA to a hater.
As this dog did not bark, I think it's safe to conclude that your published (as in, remember, on your website) works do not include anything which - quantitatively - links these guys' work to your electric Sun ideas.

Of course, it would be very easy to provide counter-evidence, if it exists ...

All that matters to a hater is continuing the battle/hate at all costs, science be damned. That's why there will always be creationists and there will always be EU haters. :(
Well, why should you care about "EU haters" (whatever they are)?

I mean, you are not a member of "the EU community", and neither is your co-author O. Manuel.

You can't be interested in "truth" DRD and have been ignorant for the last 7 years that the model(s) I support is *INTERNALLY* powered.
I have to say I was quite surprised to read that your electric Sun idea is fundamentally incompatible with the central dogma of the EU community (that central dogma is that the Sun is powered, predominantly, by external electric currents).

I certainly knew that you hedged your bets, a lot, but not that you'd 'come out' (so to speak). Ah well, I guess it won't be long now before you too will be called an "EU hater".

You just don't care. What difference will one or two papers make when you're ignored dozens already, including papers written by a Nobel Prize winning scientist?

OK, that's it. Back on Ignore you go.

Request to other JREF members reading this thread: if MM ever answers any of my recent questions - even by providing a definitive "no, such material does not yet exist" (or similar), would you mind quoting him, so that I can see it? Thanks.
 
What difference will one or two papers make when you're ignored dozens already, including papers written by a Nobel Prize winning scientist?

How about a paper whose actual content is "Here is a complete picture of the Mozina model, as written by Mozina, laying out the power source, the actual electromagnetic fields (explicitly shown to obey maxwell), the interior (explicitly shown to obey basic hydrostatics and heat transport), and the surface (explicitly shown to present a 6000K blackbody spectrum with limb darkening and absorption lines)"

Instead what we get are random papers, selected from the past 50 years of space plasma physics, which (apparently because they mention electric fields) accompanied by insinuations that they obviously confirm the still-unstated model, and that anyone who doesn't magically intuit this connection is a "hater".
 
Neutrons decay into equal amounts of p+ and e-, which travel a short distances in random directions. This is not an electric current---it's a hot, neutral, isotropic plasma. If you inject so many neutrons that it makes this plasma flow outwards, obviously that flow includes both the + and the - components in exactly equal numbers---what else do you think happens? Were you picturing the p+ moving away from the core and the e- magically evaporating?

Not to change a single thing about this, just to add something about the Pannekoek-Rossland field (some dude by the name of Nereid, on some weird forum - Starship Asterisk*, doh! explained this rather well). Because electrons have a much smaller mass than protons (and ions such as He-), their scale height is much greater than that of the protons (and ions; caveats, by the bucket-ful, apply). Charge separation, and an electric field, ensues.

Does this matter (pun intended)? And, more importantly, have "EU haters" (i.e. people who do astrophysics in a scientific way, which is to say, based on equations, numbers, etc) studied this, and incorporated it into their models?

First, though, who are these guys, Pannekoek and Rossland? And when did they write up their stuff (which is, pretty obviously, pure gold for the EU community)? Did high priest Alfvén endorse their work? or did he trash it? And what does the EU community - which used to include MM - think of this (seemingly radical) idea? Specifically, does MM refer to these EU pioneers on his website?

Well, let me quote from a Thunderdolts forum post (by that crazy, crazy dude, Nereid):
Nereid said:
As far as I've been able to determine, the effect Thornhill describes is called the Rossland field, or the Pannekoek-Rossland field, after a 1922 paper by Pannekoek, and a 1924 one by Rossland, and is described like this, by Alfven:
Alfven said:
In a plasma atmosphere consisting of electrons and ions with mass me and mi, the scale height

[equation]

is a compromise between the large-scale height of electrons and the small-scale height of ions.

I haven't yet studied the 1926 Eddington source (so I can't comment on Thornhill's characterisation), but I did find a paper which seems to examine exactly the concern Thornhill writes about, Bahcall and Loeb (1990). They show (in Section II), pace Thornhill, that this charge separation effect is tiny, in terms of counteracting gravitational compression (there are, it would seem, rather a lot of papers which examine the sorts of general question Thornhill writes about).

I did a quick check, on MM's website. I found, as you'd expect, Alfven mentioned several times.

Pannekoek? No.

Rossland? Um, let's see ... that's also a no.

Bahcall? Loeb? Ah, also a no.

Odd, don't you - dear reader - think? A rather important aspect of the behavior of plasmas in a gravitational field - of some relevance, perhaps, to modelling the Sun? a behavior that no less of a scientist than Alfven also wrote about - that MM seems ignorant of?
 
Your audio/visual expertise in no way makes you an "expert" on solar physics anymore than it makes you an "expert" on masonry when we happen to be discussing pictures of a brick wall.


Nobody here is talking about masonry, but my expertise in that area isn't half bad, either. My relevant expertise is in graphics, satellite imagery in particular. I have demonstrated that expertise. The only objections seem to be unsupported assertions from a demonstrably unqualified point of view.

No, you do not. You do not even have the VERY FIRST CLUE how the light itself is created because you personally remain in hard core denial that electrical discharges occur in solar flares. You could NOT begin to explain an iron ion solar image or a running difference image because you cannot even link iron ion emissions to solar activity in the lab using "magnetic reconnection"! MR scored a wimpy 1 of 7 and only because *I FELT SORRY FOR IT*! Lee however did provide us all with a link between "electrical discharges' through plasma and iron ion emissions in the 70's. Dungey linked electrical discharges to solar flares in the 50's!


Leaving aside the incivility and petulant complaining, I do have the very first clue, and many more. The results of my research and applied expertise in graphics and satellite imagery is in direct agreement with the professionals who do exactly that work for NASA and their affiliates. Again, the only objections are simple assertions from a position of no knowledge, experience, or understanding of the material. To claim my understanding is somehow lacking is to claim the experts at NASA also don't know what they're doing. And making that claim, as has been done here so often, without any quantitative objective support, is simply not a rational argument.

You're no expert on nuclear chemistry so your opinions about Manuel's work are IRRELEVANT.


My opinion on Oliver Manuel's attempt to defraud the scientific community when it comes to my area of expertise is completely relevant.

  • In the acknowledgements section of his "On the Cosmic Nuclear Cycle and the Similarity of Nuclei and Stars", he wrote, "NASA and Lockheed Martin’s TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere and the movie of a solar flare coming from that region." That is a lie. There are no images of any "rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere" in existence, and to fraudulently present such nonsense as if NASA endorsed it or was somehow responsible is despicable.

  • In his paper "The Sun Is A Plasma Diffuser That Sorts Atoms By Mass", he wrote "The top section is a 'running difference' image of the Sun's iron-rich sub-surface from the Trace satellite using a 171 Å filter sensitive to Fe (IX) and Fe (X) emissions," and he wrote, "The bottom section has a grid system to show rotation (left to right) of the Sun’s rigid, iron-rich structure over a 5-day period of 1-5 June 2005 in four images from the SOHO satellite using a 195 Å filter that is also sensitive to Fe (XII) emissions." All of that and accompanying commentary are more lies. Those images do not show any "iron-rich sub-surface" or "rigid, iron-rich structure". Oliver Manuel is using lies in an effort to deceive the scientific community that his crackpot notions have some validity.

  • In the above paper he also makes a fundamental error in this comment, "Images from the SOHO and Trace satellite programs reveal rigid, persistent structures in the transitional layer of the Sun, in addition to its dynamic, fluid photosphere." That is an idiotic statement. The transition region begins a couple thousand kilometers above the photosphere. That is so factually basic someone would probably fail a first level course in solar science if they didn't know it. There are no rigid persistent structures floating around in the plasma of the transition region. Even suggesting that is an irrational argument and demonstrates that Oliver Manuel doesn't have a clue about the solar atmosphere.

  • In his paper "Isotopes Tell Sun’s Origin and Operation", he wrote, "Here are images, over a 60-hour (2.5-day) period on 27-29 May 2005, of the rigid structure below the fluid photosphere," followed by several images which show no such thing. This statement follows the images, "Running difference images from SOHO using a 195 Å filter to enhance light Fe (IX) and Fe (X) emissions. Surface features in the iron-rich surface below the Sun’s fluid, hydrogen-rich photosphere are visible for days or weeks. From videos of these images, Mozina shows that this surface rotates uniformly, from pole to equator, every 27.3 days." Nothing in the images shows any "iron-rich surface below the Sun’s fluid, hydrogen-rich photosphere", or a surface that "rotates uniformly, from pole to equator", and the claim that it does is another attempted deception.
Those are just a few of the most obvious examples. Oliver Manuel is attempting to deceive legitimate scientists. It is fraud by definition, the epitome of unscientific.

You haven't the ability to attack the science in any meaningful way so you attack the man. Such pathetic behavior!


I am not attacking the individual. I am attacking the idiocy that the individual tries to foist off as science. I will, when it falls within my area of expertise or when it is otherwise obvious, point out those kinds of attempts at deception. Oliver Manuel's "work" is based on fiction, nonsense he made up, or maybe other people made it up and he was foolish enough to believe them. Either way, it's a sham.
 
Last edited:
How about a paper whose actual content is "Here is a complete picture of the Mozina model,

Um, you're starting with a conceptual misunderstanding of the fundamental nature of science and the HISTORICAL aspects of science. My ego was pretty much CRUSHED the moment I read Birkeland's book and realized that Birkeland had not only beaten me to the idea of an electrically active sun, he experimented with it in the lab, figured out the voltages that were likely involved. He figured out the energy source. He NAILED pretty much every electrical "discovery" I could hope to take personal credit for. From that moment on, my website became a tribute to his team's work and it's not about "Mozina" anymore. It's a historical look at the first real "electric sun" theory put forth, updated with satellite data. Period.

I also discovered on my journey of solar physics discovery that Sir William Herschel personally beat me to the idea of "solid surface" under the photosphere by 200 years!

It's not about me ben. It's about TRUTH.

IMO that paper by Mann and Onel is PRICELESS. It ties together the work of Lee (although I don't think they cite his work), Alfven (they do cite his work) and modern satellite imagery. It's a fundamentally GREAT paper in terms of using CIRCUIT theory to explain solar flares.

Until and unless one accepts BOTH sides of Maxwell's equations, it's impossible to see the FULL picture. I'd be willing to call the "process" circuit reconnection, or *ELECTROMAGNETIC RECONNECTION*. What I won't do is ignore the B side like Alfven, or the E side like the mainstream. I think it's just SILLY to dumb down a fundamentally ELECTROMAGNETIC process in plasma to ONE part or the other (E OR B).

Until you folks start embracing the E side of physics in space, solar physics is never going to make any sense to any of you. GM, the self professed "expert" among you on solar satellite imagery, still thinks that the color around the horizon of an iron line composite image is somehow related to an ALIGNMENT PROBLEM, and electrical discharges in conductors are IMPOSSIBLE! OMG. This crew knows NOTHING about solar satellite images. You really should read that paper by Mann and Onel and ACKNOWLEDGE it, and ACCEPT it.
 
Last edited:
Instead what we get are random papers, selected from the past 50 years of space plasma physics, which (apparently because they mention electric fields) accompanied by insinuations that they obviously confirm the still-unstated model, and that anyone who doesn't magically intuit this connection is a "hater".

No ben. You got collaborative papers from me that you can find on Arxiv and you got a website full of RELEVANT MATERIALS to peruse. A hater is someone that never takes the time to UNDERSTAND the model in the first place. DRD for instance claims that ONLY PUBLISHED WORKS MATTER, and she has debated me for YEARS on this topic, and yet she was somehow "surprised" to hear that the solar model(s) I champion are INTERNALLY powered! Holy COW!

A hater is someone who cannot and will not embrace the E. Electrical discharges have been associated with solar flares since Dungey and Lee in the 50's and 70's respectively. I suggest you folks embrace reality.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom