Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's my answer, which is entirely from reading the symbols in the equation:
The curl of the electric field is equal to opposite of the partial differential of the magnetic field with respect to time.
Well, I might prefer using the word "negative" instead of "opposite," but in any case I would be interested in Mozina's expert description of the physics being described by this equation and how it is that physicists "ignore the E side."
I suspect you mean E and B to be in bold since they are vector quantities. :)

Yes, but I don't know how to do that using LaTeX.

Addendum: ah yes, found it: \mathbf

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]
 
Last edited:
To begin with, this description of how neutrons avoid compression is not logically self consistent. After all, if you are going to argue that electrostatic repulsion of the negative outer layer is the explanation for neutron-neutron repulsion, then why don't you argue with equal force that the positive inner layer is electrostatically attracted to the negative core and negative outer layer, destroying the layered structure altogether?

I don't see how that's a logical argument frankly. I'm simply noting that neutrons have *INTERNAL STRUCTURE* that allows them to have a negative charge on the OUTSIDE, the side they present to protons, other neutrons and the world around them. It's evidently a VERY stable structure too as recent data would suggest:

http://www.astronomynow.com/news/n1010/28neutronstar/

I can't tell you exactly WHY it's "stable" internally Tim. I can only tell you that it is.

Or, ignoring that, just notice that while each negative shell sees another negative shell next door, they also each see a positive core a mere 10-13 centimeters away behind that other negative shell. Clearly the positive-negative attraction will do much to weaken the negative-negative repulsion, such that the net repulsive effect is quite weak, considering the small distances involved and the inverse square Coulomb repulsion/attraction forces.

It's simply a "what's on the outside of the shell" in terms of the MOST RELEVANT charge that it presents to the outside world, in this case a relatively NEGATIVE charge. This probably explains why it's attracted to protons, and why it's capable of repulsing other neutrons so efficiently under pressure.

If we pay attention to the language of the paper, rather than the language of the PR website, we can see what is the problem I previously alluded to. Mozina's model of neutron-neutron repulsion relies on a classical interpretation of electromagnetism, the low-energy limit where Maxwell's equations rule. Even in that context, it happens to be quite wrong, ignoring the part of the physics that would destroy the charge-layered structure instantly,

Er, no. It clearly DOESN'T destroy the structure 'instantly', in fact it is MORE stable than we FIRST REALIZED as that king sized neutron star demonstrates Tim. Whatever the INTERNAL structure might be, when compressed it is HIGHLY STABLE. It's only when they become FREE from PRESSURE and PROTONS that they begin to decay. They are UNSTABLE WITHOUT some sort of "partner/proton" or GRAVITATIONAL PRESSURE. In such cases they DECAY INTO CURRENT, aka moving charged particles composed of protons and electrons.

and ignoring the fact that the repulsion would be weak anyway on account of the presence of attractive positive charges only 10-13 centimeters away.

It doesn't matter Tim. Your entire post seems to be tilting at windmills of your own design, and you expect me to EXPLAIN the INNER STRUCTURE of the neutron to you before you'll accept that they are STABLE UNDER GRAVITATIONAL PRESSURE, even though the MEASUREMENTS we've made recently show that they ARE stable, even MORE STABLE that first imagined. Manuel's model PREDICTED heavy neutron stars and even HEAVIER neutron stars than we have found so far. Stay tuned.

Don't however expect me to EXPLAIN NEUTRON STRUCTURE to you Tim in order for you to accept that they are capable of withstanding PRESSURES that are higher than first imagined. We not only have evidence they are LAYERED with a NEGATIVE CHARGE on the OUTSIDE, we have evidence that neutron stars can grow MUCH LARGER than first PREDICTED under standard theories! Holy Cow Tim. What more 'evidence' will it take? Manuel's work PREDICTED that heavy neutron star Tim. I'm simply offering you a way to visually WHY they remain stable under PRESSURE.

Don't kill the messenger only because I can't explain it to your personal liking.
 
Last edited:
FYI, I'll tackle the "runaway fusion" issue as I get time today. Forget about blaming me however for the fact that the internal structure of the neutron is stable even WITH an INTERNAL arrangement of charges. If I had to guess I'd say a neutron has an extra electron at it's core, more positrons in the center, and more electrons in outer orbits. That's the best "guess" I could make based on particle physics collision data. All I can tell you is that the internal arrangement is ONLY STABLE UNDER PRESSURE or in close proximity to a proton.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cXsvy2tBJlU

In the EM fields of space, and in liquids and solids, gravity isn't the MOST IMPORTANT influence in ALL CASES. I think I'll start there in terms of discussing this 'runaway fusion' concept. If gravity were the 'be-all-end-all' of forces in space, that air bubble would have been crushed like a bug from the more dense 'water' in the shell. Fortunately for the air bubble inside the sphere, surface tension, inside pressure, and EM factors are MORE IMPORTANT than gravity.

The second key "issue" here is that the 'core' does not need to be a HUGE portion of the total mass, it can compose only a MINOR fraction of the total mass of the sun until it decays to the point that it FINALLY becomes unstable.
 
Last edited:
From that site:


:hit:



I have not seen any proof. Only :words:

I wonder what actually constitutes "proof" to you guys? There is empirical PROOF in Birkeland's work that solar wind acceleration occurs in cathode suns. There is empirical PROOF in his work that electrical discharges form in the atmospheres of cathode suns. There is EMPIRICAL PROOF that electrical discharges ionize iron to the states we see in SDO, SOHO, STEREO images, etc. There's is EMPIRICAL PROOF that "electrical discharges" pinch free neutrons from plasma and we observe neutron capture signatures in some flare events. There is MATHEMATICAL PROOF (if such a thing exists) that circuit theory does well to explain some types of flares. I really have no idea what kind of PROOF would do with this crew. It's like asking how much "proof/evidence" does it take to convince a creationist of evolutionary theory. :( Who knows?
 
Your entire post seems to be tilting at windmills of your own design, and you expect me to EXPLAIN the INNER STRUCTURE of the neutron to you before you'll accept that they are STABLE UNDER GRAVITATIONAL PRESSURE, even though the MEASUREMENTS we've made recently show that they ARE stable, even MORE STABLE that first imagined. Manuel's model PREDICTED heavy neutron stars and even HEAVIER neutron stars than we have found so far.

No it doesn't. Manuel's "model" explicitly states that neutrons stars are unstable---he states that they spontaneously decay by emitting neutrons from their surfaces. (Manuel's explanation for this is a piece of utter juvenalia, of course.)

I could explain this to anyone who understands energy conservation, energy landscapes, and/or F = dE/dx. I don't think I can explain it to you.
 
It's simply a "what's on the outside of the shell" in terms of the MOST RELEVANT charge that it presents to the outside world, in this case a relatively NEGATIVE charge. This probably explains why it's attracted to protons, and why it's capable of repulsing other neutrons so efficiently under pressure.

This is rather obviously wrong. We know from the shell theorem that outside the neutron, there is no electric field since there's no net charge. The uneven radial charge distribution will only create an electric field within the neutron, and it will point outwards towards the surface (from the positive core towards the negative outer shell). So the neutron will exert no electric force on the proton (or other neutrons) when they are separated, and will exert a repulsive force once they overlap. In contrast, this field will exert an attractive force on other neutrons once they start overlapping, since the negative shell of one will be attracted to the positive core of the other. The force won't turn repulsive until the positive core of one neutron is well within the negative shell of the other neutron.

But of course, not only are you ignoring nuclear interactions, you're also ignoring a little something called the Fermi degeneracy pressure. But that's quantum mechanics, and you can't even handle classical electrostatics correctly so there's no hope that you'll ever wrap your head around that.
 
I wonder what actually constitutes "proof" to you guys? There is empirical PROOF in Birkeland's work that solar wind acceleration occurs in cathode suns. There is empirical PROOF in his work that electrical discharges form in the atmospheres of cathode suns. There is EMPIRICAL PROOF that electrical discharges ionize iron to the states we see in SDO, SOHO, STEREO images, etc. There's is EMPIRICAL PROOF that "electrical discharges" pinch free neutrons from plasma and we observe neutron capture signatures in some flare events. There is MATHEMATICAL PROOF (if such a thing exists) that circuit theory does well to explain some types of flares. I really have no idea what kind of PROOF would do with this crew. It's like asking how much "proof/evidence" does it take to convince a creationist of evolutionary theory. :( Who knows?

 
I wonder what actually constitutes "proof" to you guys? There is empirical PROOF in Birkeland's work that solar wind acceleration occurs in cathode suns. There is empirical PROOF in his work that electrical discharges form in the atmospheres of cathode suns. There is EMPIRICAL PROOF that electrical discharges ionize iron to the states we see in SDO, SOHO, STEREO images, etc. There's is EMPIRICAL PROOF that "electrical discharges" pinch free neutrons from plasma and we observe neutron capture signatures in some flare events. There is MATHEMATICAL PROOF (if such a thing exists) that circuit theory does well to explain some types of flares. I really have no idea what kind of PROOF would do with this crew. It's like asking how much "proof/evidence" does it take to convince a creationist of evolutionary theory. :( Who knows?

You can provide #"*PROOF*"# of your expertise by describing the following and explaining how physicists "ignore the E side:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]
 
You can provide #"*PROOF*"# of your expertise by describing the following and explaining how physicists "ignore the E side:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]

Maxwell didn't ignore the relationship, just modern astronomers, and particularly EU haters. Everything in the media from astronomers, and in their papers is dumbed down to the B orientation. In fact, the mainstream's emotional attachment to the word "reconnection" and their irrational aversion to the term "electrical discharge" demonstrates this bias. Dungey himself made that connection himself when he coined the term 'reconnection', yet the haters can't handle the truth!

Anytime I hear a mainstream solar physics interview, its' "magnetic yada yada yada". Never do you I hear the term "ELECTROMAGNETIC*, nor any reference to the ELECTRIC CURRENTS that are present in those "coronal loops". It's always dumbed down to B and ONLY B. That's why that paper by Mann and Onel is so NOTEWORTHY. It's the EXCEPTION, not the rule.
 
Last edited:
Maxwell didn't ignore the relationship, just modern astronomers, and particularly EU haters. Everything in the media from astronomers, and in their papers is dumbed down to the B orientation. In fact, the mainstream's emotional attachment to the word "reconnection" and their irrational aversion to the term "electrical discharge" demonstrates this bias. Dungey himself made that connection himself when he coined the term 'reconnection', yet the haters can't handle the truth!

Anytime I hear a mainstream solar physics interview, its' "magnetic yada yada yada". Never do you I hear the term "ELECTROMAGNETIC*, nor any reference to the ELECTRIC CURRENTS that are present in those "coronal loops". It's always dumbed down to B and ONLY B. That's why that paper by Mann and Onel is so NOTEWORTHY. It's the EXCEPTION, not the rule.

Just as I (and everyone else here) thought. You have no clue* about the meaning of:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]

... so, all your pretensions to the contrary, you are totally unqualified to have any opinions about solar physics.

*Amazingly, even after Almo provided the meaning of the operators to make it easier for you.
 
Last edited:
Clinger's explanation of magnetic reconnection in this thread is an example of what we consider proof.

What you consider "proof" is a mathematical demonstration that 0+0=0! You utterly ignored the need for PHYSICAL PLASMA to get an "electrical discharge/reconnection" process, not just MATH! Holy cow!

Alfven's math is *INFINITELY* more impressive as was that math by Mann and Onel. Your concept of PROOF is highly SUBJECTIVE.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom