BTMO
Overlord of the Underthings
- Joined
- May 1, 2009
- Messages
- 2,521
I had asked earlier, so thanks...though 'about the 6 minute mark' is a curiously unspecific reference to an image of the cops encircled. Aha, I see. 'About the 6 minute mark' is where we see the caption saying the police were encircled, and then a claim that someone claimed they were claiming the claim that police were encircled. Maybe they were encircled. Who knows? Maybe they were. If I wanted out of a circle, I'd head for the weakest link, not the strong point, but perhaps the commanding officer reasoned that a show of force was required. We all know who liked a show of force, don't we
Pepper spray is a violent action. It is, you're right, less violent than shooting. I appreciate that the US has developed admirably since Kent State. In this instance, however, the police chose to pepper spray seated protestors presenting no threat. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.
It is safer, too, than dropping a refridgerator on them from a crane. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.
Seriously? 'Safely'? 'No threat' . Seated protestors presenting no threat to armed & armoured officers and you're concerned for their safety? Their safety had no bearing on this one. Nor does the packaging of the spray - guns are perfectly designed for shooting people, they'd work for shooting unarmed seated protestors protesting no threat. Fridges aren't principally designed for crowd control, but dropping a **** off big chest freezer on the unarmed, seated protestors would have allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely too.
Yes, there were more unarmed, peacefulprotestorscitizens than there were public servants. 'Outnumbered' is an unnecessarily martial term, don't you think?
Can you reference the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently'? Failing that, the time at which the caption saying they did appears?
So when the citizenry express their common opinion, it's the job of the police to supress that? Is that because the voters can't be trusted to run their own affairs? Do you have a dog in this race? Are you a politician?
They wanted not to be swayed from their goal. Your language is that of the oppressor - they 'deserved what they got', they were 'asking for it'. Fancy, the audacity of the common populace to say 'no!' to the agents of power!
The video that has been linked to only 'clearly' shows the flag flying over the trench you and the caption writer share.
A chinese burn (noogie? fill in whatever the bullies in your school did) doesn't kill anyone. Some people are bullies, some people support bullies so they don't get bullied. Some people get pepper sprayed while sitting down and presenting no threat.
Is this in the video? To be fair, in my experience young adults from under-privileged families are too busy trying to survive, leaving little time for protest, but perhaps you could list your fanciful ideas of what activities are permissible to one depending on family income or social status. People got pepper-sprayed (that's violence, remember) for sitting down and presenting no threat. Defend that.
IF the video is to be believed, police officers with prisoners were prevented from doing their job. They were blocked, when they attempted to go around, the people blocking them ran to block them again.
Personally, I'd have used dogs. People are less likely to argue with dogs than cops...
Yes, pepper spray is "violence" - but it is a particularly safe form. Hell, when I was in the navy they trained us on chemical weapons by *spraying us* with teargas.
Why? Because it is uncomfortable, but is ultimately harmless. Just like pepper spray.