Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

I had asked earlier, so thanks...though 'about the 6 minute mark' is a curiously unspecific reference to an image of the cops encircled. Aha, I see. 'About the 6 minute mark' is where we see the caption saying the police were encircled, and then a claim that someone claimed they were claiming the claim that police were encircled. Maybe they were encircled. Who knows? Maybe they were. If I wanted out of a circle, I'd head for the weakest link, not the strong point, but perhaps the commanding officer reasoned that a show of force was required. We all know who liked a show of force, don't we ;)




Pepper spray is a violent action. It is, you're right, less violent than shooting. I appreciate that the US has developed admirably since Kent State. In this instance, however, the police chose to pepper spray seated protestors presenting no threat. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.



It is safer, too, than dropping a refridgerator on them from a crane. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.



Seriously? 'Safely'? 'No threat' . Seated protestors presenting no threat to armed & armoured officers and you're concerned for their safety? Their safety had no bearing on this one. Nor does the packaging of the spray - guns are perfectly designed for shooting people, they'd work for shooting unarmed seated protestors protesting no threat. Fridges aren't principally designed for crowd control, but dropping a **** off big chest freezer on the unarmed, seated protestors would have allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely too.



Yes, there were more unarmed, peaceful protestors citizens than there were public servants. 'Outnumbered' is an unnecessarily martial term, don't you think?



Can you reference the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently'? Failing that, the time at which the caption saying they did appears?



So when the citizenry express their common opinion, it's the job of the police to supress that? Is that because the voters can't be trusted to run their own affairs? Do you have a dog in this race? Are you a politician?



They wanted not to be swayed from their goal. Your language is that of the oppressor - they 'deserved what they got', they were 'asking for it'. Fancy, the audacity of the common populace to say 'no!' to the agents of power!



The video that has been linked to only 'clearly' shows the flag flying over the trench you and the caption writer share.



A chinese burn (noogie? fill in whatever the bullies in your school did) doesn't kill anyone. Some people are bullies, some people support bullies so they don't get bullied. Some people get pepper sprayed while sitting down and presenting no threat.



Is this in the video? To be fair, in my experience young adults from under-privileged families are too busy trying to survive, leaving little time for protest, but perhaps you could list your fanciful ideas of what activities are permissible to one depending on family income or social status. People got pepper-sprayed (that's violence, remember) for sitting down and presenting no threat. Defend that.

IF the video is to be believed, police officers with prisoners were prevented from doing their job. They were blocked, when they attempted to go around, the people blocking them ran to block them again.

Personally, I'd have used dogs. People are less likely to argue with dogs than cops...

Yes, pepper spray is "violence" - but it is a particularly safe form. Hell, when I was in the navy they trained us on chemical weapons by *spraying us* with teargas.

Why? Because it is uncomfortable, but is ultimately harmless. Just like pepper spray.
 
Hell, the kids that got sprayed with pepper sprary were *interviewed* by reporters afterwards. They weren't hurt. They weren't even arrested (and that in itself surprised me).

Nathan Brown, an English professor at UC Davis, wrote an open letter to Katehi calling for her resignation. He witnessed the attack, and described it, writing:

"Police used batons to try to push the students apart. Those they could separate, they arrested, kneeling on their bodies and pushing their heads into the ground. Those they could not separate, they pepper-​sprayed directly in the face, holding these students as they did so. When students covered their eyes with their clothing, police forced open their mouths and pepper-​sprayed down their throats. Several of these students were hospitalized. Others are seriously injured. One of them, forty-​five minutes after being pepper-​sprayed down his throat, was still coughing up blood." [Cleveland Leader]
 
Nathan Brown, an English professor at UC Davis, wrote an open letter to Katehi calling for her resignation. He witnessed the attack, and described it, writing:

"Police used batons to try to push the students apart. Those they could separate, they arrested, kneeling on their bodies and pushing their heads into the ground. Those they could not separate, they pepper-​sprayed directly in the face, holding these students as they did so. When students covered their eyes with their clothing, police forced open their mouths and pepper-​sprayed down their throats. Several of these students were hospitalized. Others are seriously injured. One of them, forty-​five minutes after being pepper-​sprayed down his throat, was still coughing up blood." [Cleveland Leader]

Can you show me that bit in the video?
 
IF the video is to be believed, police officers with prisoners were prevented from doing their job. They were blocked, when they attempted to go around, the people blocking them ran to block them again.

Personally, I'd have used dogs. People are less likely to argue with dogs than cops...

Yes, pepper spray is "violence" - but it is a particularly safe form. Hell, when I was in the navy they trained us on chemical weapons by *spraying us* with teargas.

Why? Because it is uncomfortable, but is ultimately harmless. Just like pepper spray.

There's very little point quoting everything I said if you're not actually going to respond to any of the points. Why, some people might even think it looks deceitful.

At least we have reached agreement. The police were violent towards peaceful protestors. Thank you for your honesty on that point.

You're remarkably honest that you'd use dogs to enforce your will too. For dogs to work, the protestors would have to be reasonably sure you'd release the dogs. So I'm taking the reasonable position that you would choose to set ferocious dogs (you didn't mean poodles, right?) on protestors. Do you have a long leather coat that you wear around the home, admiring yourself in the mirror and thinking "Ven I rule ze vorld zer vill be NO MORE DISSENT!"?

Yes, the police must be able to do their jobs. That's a necessary part of a civilised lawful society. But another crucial part is that citizens must be able to peacefully protest, even to protest the actions of the police. Even the real police, let alone the campus cops.

The police don't decide the law. A court will address the events of the day, and they will not be deciding the matter based on the opinions of people who weren't there but think students should shut the **** up and learn their place or take whatever is meted out to them.
 
Can you show me that bit in the video?

Oh, I love a bit of comedy banter. You expressed an opinion, while discussing the video, about what the protestors were 'clearly' thinking and feeling during the recording. That's when I asked you 'can you show me that bit in the video?'

I posted a quote from (and a link to) an article about the aftermath of the videod events. No, of course I can't show you in the video the bits that happened after the video ended. Are you disputing the account, or merely dodging the question in a manner that is neither as clever or amusing as you 'clearly appear' to think it is?
 
There's very little point quoting everything I said if you're not actually going to respond to any of the points. Why, some people might even think it looks deceitful.

At least we have reached agreement. The police were violent towards peaceful protestors. Thank you for your honesty on that point.

You're remarkably honest that you'd use dogs to enforce your will too. For dogs to work, the protestors would have to be reasonably sure you'd release the dogs. So I'm taking the reasonable position that you would choose to set ferocious dogs (you didn't mean poodles, right?) on protestors. Do you have a long leather coat that you wear around the home, admiring yourself in the mirror and thinking "Ven I rule ze vorld zer vill be NO MORE DISSENT!"?

Yes, the police must be able to do their jobs. That's a necessary part of a civilised lawful society. But another crucial part is that citizens must be able to peacefully protest, even to protest the actions of the police. Even the real police, let alone the campus cops.

The police don't decide the law. A court will address the events of the day, and they will not be deciding the matter based on the opinions of people who weren't there but think students should shut the **** up and learn their place or take whatever is meted out to them.

Yeah. I started responding point by point, then lost interest.

Because I realised there was no way to change your mind. It was a waste of my time, so I stopped. I will address one point from above though - you are dead right in saying the police don't decide the law. But they do enFORCE it. That word (sometimes) has a quite specific meaning. Force is sometimes necessary to prevent people from breaking the law.

Crowds have a funny way of reacting when they feel they are getting their way. Police know this. History has taught them this. Therefore, they (police) behave in a certain way when faced with crowds (ie, they are grossly outnumbered). They ask them to comply. They outline what the consequences of non-compliance is. They then *deliver* those consequences if the crowd continues to non-comply.

That, in the video posted, appears to be exactly what happened.
 
Oh, I love a bit of comedy banter. You expressed an opinion, while discussing the video, about what the protestors were 'clearly' thinking and feeling during the recording. That's when I asked you 'can you show me that bit in the video?'

I posted a quote from (and a link to) an article about the aftermath of the videod events. No, of course I can't show you in the video the bits that happened after the video ended. Are you disputing the account, or merely dodging the question in a manner that is neither as clever or amusing as you 'clearly appear' to think it is?

I have absolutely no idea if the account is accurate. I have, however, heard of people lying - yes lying (! good heavens !) to make a point. And of course, newspapers like controversy. It sells more advertising space.

Now, please go back to speaking in the funny voice. It was very amusing!
 
I had asked earlier, so thanks...though 'about the 6 minute mark' is a curiously unspecific reference to an image of the cops encircled. Aha, I see. 'About the 6 minute mark' is where we see the caption saying the police were encircled, and then a claim that someone claimed they were claiming the claim that police were encircled. Maybe they were encircled. Who knows? Maybe they were.
Are you disagreeing that they were? Are you saying you're not sure?

If I wanted out of a circle, I'd head for the weakest link, not the strong point, but perhaps the commanding officer reasoned that a show of force was required. We all know who liked a show of force, don't we ;)
Baseless speculation. The cops didn't do much of anything but stand in defensive positions around the prisoners until backup arrived in a car and dispersed the outer perimeter. The seated students remained between the car and the cops with prisoners. At that point, that was the weakest link.


Pepper spray is a violent action. It is, you're right, less violent than shooting. I appreciate that the US has developed admirably since Kent State. In this instance, however, the police chose to pepper spray seated protestors presenting no threat. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.
no one has to. It's a straw man.

The crowd encircling, obstructing, and actively threatening officers. If you are threatening to stop "protesting peacefully", that means you're violent. The seated students were sprayed so they could be disengaged with the minimum use of force necessary, in order for them to be arrested for obstruction.

It is safer, too, than dropping a refridgerator on them from a crane. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.
Straw man.

Seriously? 'Safely'? 'No threat' . Seated protestors presenting no threat to armed & armoured officers and you're concerned for their safety?
This may come as a shock to you, but cops prefer to leave suspects alive. It's a lot less fuss and paperwork. Most officers never fire their weapon in combat..


Their safety had no bearing on this one. Nor does the packaging of the spray - guns are perfectly designed for shooting people, they'd work for shooting unarmed seated protestors protesting no threat.
The standards for using pepper spray are quite different from employing deadly force.

Fridges aren't principally designed for crowd control, but dropping a **** off big chest freezer on the unarmed, seated protestors would have allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely too.
Okay, I'm starting to suspect, for some reason, you have some sort of bias against cops.

Yes, there were more unarmed, peaceful protestors citizens than there were public servants. 'Outnumbered' is an unnecessarily martial term, don't you think?
"If you let them go, we will continue to protest peacefully!" This was a hostile crowd that was threatening to riot. Even armed operators can be and have been overwhelmed by human waves.

Can you reference the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently'? Failing that, the time at which the caption saying they did appears?
I note that you're not actually disputing the claim.

So when the citizenry express their common opinion, it's the job of the police to supress that? Is that because the voters can't be trusted to run their own affairs? Do you have a dog in this race? Are you a politician?
Straw man, personal attack. "Their opinion" was that they wanted the cops to release the prisoners under threat of continued obstruction and possibly violence. Fire in a crowded theatre, etc.

They wanted not to be swayed from their goal. Your language is that of the oppressor - they 'deserved what they got', they were 'asking for it'. Fancy, the audacity of the common populace to say 'no!' to the agents of power!
Just so I'm clear, are you saying that the populace has a right to defy and obstruct authority at any time? Or only in specific situations? If so, what are these situations?

The video that has been linked to only 'clearly' shows the flag flying over the trench you and the caption writer share.
More personal attacks, denial.

A chinese burn (noogie? fill in whatever the bullies in your school did) doesn't kill anyone. Some people are bullies, some people support bullies so they don't get bullied. Some people get pepper sprayed while sitting down and presenting no threat.
I love how you're carefully phrasing around the fact that they were obstructing the cops and subject to the same arrest as everyone else.

Is this in the video? To be fair, in my experience young adults from under-privileged families are too busy trying to survive, leaving little time for protest, but perhaps you could list your fanciful ideas of what activities are permissible to one depending on family income or social status. People got pepper-sprayed (that's violence, remember) for sitting down and presenting no threat. Defend that.
Cops got surrounded and threatened for arresting only the protestors that directly interfered with their tent removal and leaving the others alone, whereupon the others decided to obstruct them. They started the fight and bought violence into the equation defend that.
 
The students were in the Campus Quad. They were not blocking access to anything, protesting, sitting. The Campus Police might qualifiy as idiots.
There is a perfectly good video you need to watch. The students were deliberately surrounding and threatening police who were trying to leave peacefully.

"Shame on you". Amazing they did not attack those yelling Shame on you.
Almost as if they were trying to use as little force as possible.

The Campus Quad is over 500 feet wide in all directions. Police must of needed to use up expiring pepper spray. Lucky they did not have shotguns.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIewW8WNN5c&feature=related
I think they were armed with handguns, IIRC. At least one.

Why can't the police give the students a permit to protest. Here sign this... and leave them alone? The quad is for students, not pepper spray practice of people sitting.
Actually, the police were only there to remove some tents, after ample notice, and left most of the protesters alone. They only arrested the people who directly interfered, then tried to leave peacefully. Then the crowd tried to stop them.

It is funny the protest is for fees...

If you feel threated by a crowd, you leave and get the real police.
UCPD is the "real police". Same training and standards as regular cops.

You don't waste your pepper spray on the students sitting, you keep it as back up to leave in-case you get attacked by students who scare you by talking mean to you.
I'd think someone who was/is(?) in the Air Force would know about the dangers of human wave attacks of overwhelming force. The crowd and seated students were actively preventing the cops from leaving with their prisoners. They said as much. After backup arrived and got the bulk of the crowd out of the way, that left the kids sitting down, who were legally obstructing the police.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qrx6DDgTH_w&feature=endscreen&NR=1
The students were sitting in the Quad, not blocking FOX news. How can you block access to anything from sitting in the Quad at UC Davis?
 
I don't agree. Maybe if they weren't so liberal with the trigger, I'd be more understanding.
Ken, your knowledge of the varying types of use of force has been shown to be sadly lacking. I think you can forgive us if we don't take your opinion on the matter as Gospel.

I wouldn't have arrested the few kids in the first place. Somehow, I don't think peaceful protest merits jail time.
Obstructing the police, however, does.


...
Even if the police make an unjustified arrest, you can't just surround them and demand that they let the people go. That's ridiculous.
According to California law, there are certain circumstances when you can legally obstruct the police, such as when they are acting illegally. Problem is, that justification is determined post facto, by a court, and all but the nuttiest know that what the protestors were doing was illegal.
 
That's 'belligerence'? Warlike activity? No. It's protest, peaceful, non-violent protest.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/belligerence
a warlike or aggressively hostile nature, condition, or attitude.
http://mw1.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/belligerence
an aggressive or truculent attitude, atmosphere, or disposition

Oh, was what they did illegal? Or did you accidentally use the word 'legal' about some other imaginary actions you haven't specified, without meaning to imply that their untried action was illegal.
Untried and legal are not the same thing. UCD dropped the charges because of bad PR. What the students were doing was obstruction of police, even if you don't accept that they were threatening.

Oh we're all for the rule of law round here. The thread is about the students using the law to seek redress for the violent (and probably illegal) response of the police to the student's peaceful lawful protest.
Telling the police to release lawful prisoners and blocking them until they do is not a "lawful protest". It is obstruction.
 
Nathan Brown, an English professor at UC Davis, wrote an open letter to Katehi calling for her resignation. He witnessed the attack, and described it, writing:

"Police used batons to try to push the students apart. Those they could separate, they arrested, kneeling on their bodies and pushing their heads into the ground. Those they could not separate, they pepper-​sprayed directly in the face, holding these students as they did so. When students covered their eyes with their clothing, police forced open their mouths and pepper-​sprayed down their throats. Several of these students were hospitalized. Others are seriously injured. One of them, forty-​five minutes after being pepper-​sprayed down his throat, was still coughing up blood." [Cleveland Leader]
Here's the thing; Brown never actually says he witnessed the attack, and there is no evidence other than his claim that students were coughing blood. Not a photo, not a video, I've not even seen any other "witness" claim it, yet they were supposedly there for the better part of an hour (because the jackbooted thugs with liability want people who are seriously and visibly injured to just sit around in public for extended periods), and we know for a fact there were several cameras rolling. Moreover, coughing blood is not one of the standard effects of pepper spray, and there is, again, no evidence of students' mouths being forced open other than his claim.

The videos, you will recall, were supposedly recording this happening, so your excuse that it happened offscreen doesn't wash. In fact, the most common version of the video, which starts with Pike stepping over the line, directly contradicts Brown's timeline.

Nor do I find any evidence of police using batons to push the students apart before deploying pepper spray. The letter reads exactly like an eyewitness in a confused and chaotic situation recounting the story to someone later as best as they can remember, but still incorrectly. Anybody with legal or police experience will tell you that witnesses often get things wrong; you can take ten witnesses who saw the exact same thing, and they will give different testimonies, several of which will actively contradict more objective evidence like a security camera video.

Brown is wrong. Not even a little wrong. Absolutely wrong.

He heard the story, put it in his open letter, and everyone assumed a)he was right, and b)he was there.

I wonder why your link did not include the primary source.
 
Last edited:
My apologies. When you said...




... I thought that by "real world legal aspects" you meant something similar to my own "interesting questions":




I hope you will forgive me if my assumption is incorrect. I hope you will also understand how, having made this assumption, I would be surprised to see you involved in an argument about specific techniques used, let alone so excited about winning it.

Also, looking back over the thread, I think you are confusing the claim that a particular suit doesn't have merit, with the claim that a particular suit can't be brought. So you may actually be using evidence that the suit can be brought to try refute claims that the suit doesn't have merit. But I'm not sure about this. When you said...




... Was there a specific post or list of posts you had in mind, in which these assurances were given? The only person who mentions "immunity" up to that point in the thread is you. Interestingly enough, you seem to use in a context that I would characterize as "armchair quarterbacking the specific techniques used".
That's charming, except for the part where you completely make up stuff.

Post #3 names my point, I've explicated it several times, no one has provided a shred of rational evidence against it, and your straw man that I was arguing about 'specific techinques' is just that... a strawman, every bit as fake as your claim that I said I wasn't interested in the legal aspects.
Which is why you couldn't provide a quote where I actually said those things, so you simply resorted to the tired old trick of claiming that what I did say meant something it did not.
 
Yeah. I started responding point by point, then lost interest.

Because I realised there was no way to change your mind. It was a waste of my time, so I stopped.

No, it's easy to change my mind. You present compelling evidence that setting dogs on students is the way to go. I don't think it is, but if your aim is to change my mind you'll have to put some work in.

I will address one point from above though - you are dead right in saying the police don't decide the law. But they do enFORCE it. That word (sometimes) has a quite specific meaning. Force is sometimes necessary to prevent people from breaking the law.

Yup. Now show that it was necessary to pepper spray seated unarmed students offering no threat. For bonus points, justify your wish to turn dogs on them.

Crowds have a funny way of reacting when they feel they are getting their way. Police know this. History has taught them this. Therefore, they (police) behave in a certain way when faced with crowds (ie, they are grossly outnumbered). They ask them to comply. They outline what the consequences of non-compliance is. They then *deliver* those consequences if the crowd continues to non-comply.

Good stuff. But if the officers outline the consequences as 'being taken back to the nick and getting pushed down a stairwell to be beaten at the bottom by duty sergeant's baseball bat", *delivering* those consequences would be unlawful. We're going to find out how lawful the use of pepper spray was in this instance when the courts decide. Meanwhile, you could try addressing the specific case in question and justifying the use of pepper spray on seated unarmed students presenting no threat.

That, in the video posted, appears to be exactly what happened.

We all know what happened in the video. You think it's acceptable, and advocate the use of dogs as well. We disagree. If you do really want to change my mind, have a look in yours and show me the process that you use to justify pepper spraying seated unarmed students offering no threat. I may have missed something. You might be right...

I have absolutely no idea if the account is accurate. I have, however, heard of people lying - yes lying (! good heavens !) to make a point. And of course, newspapers like controversy. It sells more advertising space.

Was your account accurate? If you have no idea whether there were students coughing up blood hours after the incident, then you have no idea whether your earlier claim (that nobody was hurt) is accurate. You just...well, we can say newspapers did what you did without breaking any rules. Let's call your claim 'a wild assed guess that helpfully supported your position'.

Now, please go back to speaking in the funny voice. It was very amusing!

Certainly more amusing than your desire to set dogs on peaceful unarmed seated students.
 
Let's try a different tack.

JQ, Ken, imagine the situation was the same in every way, except for the parts where it becomes justifiable in your eyes for the police to have pepper sprayed the seated protestors.

What would have to be different?

Would the crowd have to be actively assaulting the officers? Would an explicit and unequivocal threat of violence have to be made? What if the prisoners being transported, for whatever reason, were convicted felons instead of alleged suspects? What if they and the crowd were, IDK, white supremacists, members of Westboro Baptist, or Republicans? Can you imagine the situation and describe it, please?
 
No, it's easy to change my mind. You present compelling evidence that setting dogs on students is the way to go. I don't think it is, but if your aim is to change my mind you'll have to put some work in.
You clearly think that removing the students, by any means, was wrong. Arguing about whether particular methods would've been justified is a false track, since you don't think the ends used to accomplish it are justifed.

Yup. Now show that it was necessary to pepper spray seated unarmed students offering no threat. For bonus points, justify your wish to turn dogs on them.
They sprayed non-compliant suspects who had immobilized themselves, as is standard police procedure.

Good stuff. But if the officers outline the consequences as 'being taken back to the nick and getting pushed down a stairwell to be beaten at the bottom by duty sergeant's baseball bat", *delivering* those consequences would be unlawful.
Straw man.

We're going to find out how lawful the use of pepper spray was in this instance when the courts decide. Meanwhile, you could try addressing the specific case in question and justifying the use of pepper spray on seated unarmed students presenting no threat.
I did already.

We all know what happened in the video. You think it's acceptable, and advocate the use of dogs as well. We disagree. If you do really want to change my mind, have a look in yours and show me the process that you use to justify pepper spraying seated unarmed students offering no threat. I may have missed something. You might be right...
Considering all the straw men you've been setting up, no, you will not. I speak from experience, such as the time you somehow managed to interpret my "the police are not militarized in any sufficient amount to justify use of the term in any sense whatsoever" as misunderstanding what you kept claiming was a metaphorical use. You also, during the course of that thread, implied I was an American misunderstanding an article written for British sensibilities, then did not apologize when I informed you I live in England and my passport says "British" on the front. If you can't really admit you were wrong on something as simple as that...

Was your account accurate?
Attempting to shift the burden of proof.

If you have no idea whether there were students coughing up blood hours after the incident,
Brown's claim was that they were "still" coughing up blood at 45 minutes. Which means they spent 45 minutes coughing up blood, starting from the time they were pepper sprayed. There is no corroboration of his claims, and his timeline actively contradicts that of the video. I do not believe students were coughing up blood as a result of pepper spray. Let's chat.

then you have no idea whether your earlier claim (that nobody was hurt) is accurate. You just...well, we can say newspapers did what you did without breaking any rules. Let's call your claim 'a wild assed guess that helpfully supported your position'.
Said the person using an uncorroborated account that directly contradicts other evidence.

Certainly more amusing than your desire to set dogs on peaceful unarmed seated students.
Are you done attempting to poison the well?
 
Last edited:
Here's a post of mine from the last thread.
...
I don't doubt that OWS is breaking the law. But the law is wrong. We have the right to peaceably assemble.
It is nice that private citizens can determine whether or not to comply with the law whenever they want. I'm sure "but I didn't want to follow the rules!" is going to hold up in court.

That was sarcasm.

Look up Cox vs. New Hampshire. Cities have the right to restrict the circumstances of the delivery of free speech for public safety...And I'd like to point out, again, the hypocrisy of wanting to create rules which are supposed to be egalitarian, even while demanding special rules for oneself.

The law may not be right, but it is always the duty of the police to uphold the law until it is changed by the government, even a law that they may think is wrong. Can you imagine what would happen if police officers didn't have to uphold laws they felt were unjust?

Furthermore, just breaking the law that you believe to be unjust isn't brave. Breaking the law AND ACCEPTING THAT YOU MAY BE THROWN IN JAIL FOR A WHILE is. I can't cite it, but I know King made that very, very clear in his speeches that just breaking a law you think is bad doesn't mean anything. Heck, thinking it would would validate those Freeman on the Land cranks, among other bad things.
 
Are you disagreeing that they were? Are you saying you're not sure?

Do try to keep up. I'm repeating what I said from the off: the video does not show the cops encircled. Nobody has been able to show where the video shows that, because it doesn't? Are you disagreeing? Are you sure?

Baseless speculation. The cops didn't do much of anything but stand in defensive positions around the prisoners until backup arrived in a car and dispersed the outer perimeter. The seated students remained between the car and the cops with prisoners. At that point, that was the weakest link.

It is 'baseless speculation' that the officer commanding thought a show of force was necessary just before a show of force was deployed? I'd call it an 'educated guess', myself, if not a 'foregone conclusion'. You appear to be saying, by the way, that the outer perimeter was dispersed and then the only point of blockage was pepper sprayed, rather than circumvented. Are you sure that's what you meant?

no one has to. It's a straw man.

No one has to defend 'no threat' being met with violence? Because it's a straw man?? We see it happening. If you're going to keep insisting there was threat, although the perimeter had been dispersed and the students were seated and peaceful, you'll have to be much more explicit about the nature of the threat you perceive.

The crowd encircling, obstructing, and actively threatening officers. If you are threatening to stop "protesting peacefully", that means you're violent. The seated students were sprayed so they could be disengaged with the minimum use of force necessary, in order for them to be arrested for obstruction

Oh, you are claiming the officers are threatened. You're just not explicit. Your second sentence here could use some work, I think I might see what you're trying to convince yourself of but I can't be sure. I see no violence on the part of the protestors - can you reference it in the video?

I understand the purpose of the spraying, we're questioning the wisdom and validity of the action, not its purpose.

Straw man.

My fanciful analogy involving domestic appliances is not what you're being asked to defend, and it's disingenuous to pretend otherwise. 'No threat' was met with violence. That's not a strawman. Defend that.

This may come as a shock to you, but cops prefer to leave suspects alive. It's a lot less fuss and paperwork. Most officers never fire their weapon in combat...

That paragraph has no relationship to the points it appeared to be addressing. It comes as no shock to me, by the way.

The standards for using pepper spray are quite different from employing deadly force.

Probably so. Defend the use of violence against seated unarmed peaceful protestors.

Okay, I'm starting to suspect, for some reason, you have some sort of bias against cops.

That's possibly because, as with most polarised arguments, it's easier for you to lump together everyone who disagrees with you and suppose they all share common arguments that you have imagined for them and which you can cleverly refute. What do they call that? Oh yes, a straw man. You misused the term twice earlier.

In fact, I work hand in hand with the police, have considerable contact with a great many officers through the course of my work and have seen on several occasions exemplary behaviour which has only increased my respect for them. But these cops, in this incident, pepper sprayed seated unarmed protestors who were offering no threat. I'm beginning to suspect you have some sort of bias against imaginary long-haired pinko intellectuals.

"If you let them go, we will continue to protest peacefully!" This was a hostile crowd that was threatening to riot. Even armed operators can be and have been overwhelmed by human waves.

Ah, of course. Attack is the best form of defence, and surprise is the best form of attack, so attack the rioters before they start rioting. Hell, why stop there, we should beat students up on a random basis, that'll put a stop to all this talk of rights and democracy and a just society for all.

I note that you're not actually disputing the claim.

My request for a reference to the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently' was the disputation. I note you don't actually provide any evidence, just an attempt to make a putative audience believe that I might have seen some belligerence. So once again, I dispute your claim and suggest you present some evidence.

Straw man, personal attack. "Their opinion" was that they wanted the cops to release the prisoners under threat of continued obstruction and possibly violence. Fire in a crowded theatre, etc.

A personal attack? To ask if you're a politician? I guess that depends how you feel about politicians. Hypocrisy is a prime requisite, I think, so you could run if you don't already.

Just so I'm clear, are you saying that the populace has a right to defy and obstruct authority at any time? Or only in specific situations? If so, what are these situations?

At any time. They have the right to accept the consequences too. And then a wider society has the right to decide (by court of law, not by sophomoric debate on the intertubes) whether they were criminal scum who deserve dogs set on them, or brave members of the continuing brother(and sister!)hood of protesting citizens who bring about laudable changes in society.

In what situations do you believe it is acceptable for citizens to protest peacefully? Were the Egyptians right to defy and obstruct authority? The Syrians etc?

More personal attacks, denial.

I said his position was entrenched. It is. The 'denial' (you say like it's a dirty word...) was indeed denial. I deny that the video shows several things that have been claimed for it here and are claimed for it in the captions. You can dismiss that with "denial" if you like, but the smart kids use actual evidence.

I love how you're carefully phrasing around the fact that they were obstructing the cops and subject to the same arrest as everyone else.

That's irrelevant. The question was, and remains, whether it was acceptable to pepper spray them as we saw happening. I love how you use the 'personal attacks' you deride in others to wriggle round addressing the actual point.

Cops got surrounded and threatened for arresting only the protestors that directly interfered with their tent removal and leaving the others alone, whereupon the others decided to obstruct them. They started the fight and bought violence into the equation defend that.

Easy. They were non-violent. You can easily refute that by pointing to their violence in the video, but you don't. You keep claiming it's there, that seated unarmed protestors are a 'threat', but you have no evidence because there isn't any. It's a post hoc rationalisation for your inate support for the pepper spraying of uppitty book-loving punk kids.
 
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/belligerence
​
http://mw1.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/belligerence
​

Untried and legal are not the same thing. UCD dropped the charges because of bad PR. What the students were doing was obstruction of police, even if you don't accept that they were threatening.

Telling the police to release lawful prisoners and blocking them until they do is not a "lawful protest". It is obstruction.

You highlighted 'aggressively hostile' in the dictionary definition you linked to. Now highlight 'aggressive hostility' in the video of peaceful seated unarmed students being pepper sprayed.

Telling the police to release prisoners is not an offence. Were they lawful prisoners? One minute 'lawful' must wait for a court, when it suits you, the next it is decided by the police, when it suits you.

Obstruction of the police can be an offence. It is in the nature of lawful protest to obstruct the police. Was their obstruction lawful? Let's see, what would suit you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom