Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Fair enough. 31 is many many times. I have beachnut on ignore, so I had no idea. Counting may well make your point 'stand', but it collapses again when we suggest that counting the times a single poster said something may not be the best measure. One. That's the count you want. One poster. But one isn't as helpful to you as 'many many'. Try that for size. "One poster says" vs "Many many times". Your point stands only if your point is that someone isn't right, therefore all opposition to you is wrong.

Well I am certainly prepared to accept this correction. I am not in the habit of always checking every post in a long thread to see who wrote it. As I read the thread I became aware of the word "kids" being used many times. Upon review following your request for numbers I noticed that the posts were predominantly, if not completely, made by Beachnut and I stated this in my response to you. My opinion of why he used that word so many times stands. My opinion that he is wrong to use that word in this context also stands. I will gladly change my opening sentence in the post you have questioned to read "Many many times in this thread one poster defending the students actions has referred to them as kids". Any more nits that need picking?
 
"Officer, you have no warrant, but I have nothing to hide. I will let you search my home. Hey, what?! Don't pepper spray me, dude!"

Gosh, isn't life simple when you don't allow for complications. Of course, you'll argue that the two 'let's are different, but that's the nub of the argument anyway.

Oh yes, life is incredibly simple if we just let cops come into our homes and pepper spray us! I'm sure there are some on this forum who do that as a hobby!

..and they get a boner from it!
 
Entirely irrelevant. The police were encircled in a rather small part of the quad. The quad can be enormous, but if an event happens in a small section of it, why is it relevant to talk about the size?
Totally relevant for me. If I was a policeman in charge an confined to a small space with limited exit, my tactics would change. As a student at the event, or an onlooker, I would feel safe with large infinite directions for exit if someone goes nuts, like the police did for a few seconds of stupid acts.

One variable I thought would be a factor...
I approached understanding this event by looking at the impact of the student protest on the campus function. When I saw the size of the quad, and the number of protesters, I found the protest had little impact on campus function. The protest was zero threat to other people, or the activities of the school. No need to remove the sitting students, no need to do more than take the time to remove tents.

To only view video of the event, one or two videos, offers zero chance to make an informed decision. The size of the event, and the stage, are very important for many reasons. Wish I could explain better, but I am poor at expressing my ideas. Wish I could do better, I offer nearly 60 years of observing the world I live in, and can't get it out. My limitation. I think more facts are good, and size of the quad, and where it is are very important to me, along with countless other facts.

The deeper I study this event, the more I see. If you have some great insight why it is wise to pepper spray students sitting in the face, enlighten me; please. I am not for the students, I am not against the police. I think the police made a mistake.

Large open area, many ways to leave. If you pick a direction to leave, you continue to gain more space to maneuver, you are not cornered, you can leave and have places to go. I can image areas where you could be limited with space to leave, not at the UC Davis quad.
[imgw=777]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111RaidersLeadPoliceRetreat3.jpg[/imgw]
Above, after the police pepper spray people, they are "forced" to retreat. They seem to be figuring out they made a big mistake. I see a person step up and be a leader; do you see her?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIewW8WNN5c

The size of the quad and the quad location is very important for me. Proves the police can not be surrounded unless they choose to. Video shows the sitting student did not make a barrier, the policeman who started the insanity stepped over the surrounding students so he could pepper them in the face. The size of the quad makes it clear there was plenty of room for the protest without impacting the school. I don't drop out factors to make a decision, I add them, weigh them, use them to form my ideas. I am not trying to defend my opinion, I am seeking knowledge and facts to make an opinion.
http://publiclaboratory.org/sites/default/files/IMG_7757.JPG
A small part of the quad from the rally on the 21st. The size and location are important looking at the event - I was "forced" to study military science and pass to fly jets and become a pilot, the battle field is important.

I am not for students, I am not against police. I am looking at an event.

Before I made a comment on the pepper spray I wanted to know why it was necessary to do it. Why was it required to remove the students? Were they in the way, like the crazy guy preaching at San Jose State, right in the sidewalk preaching end of time, you can't avoid him by more than 20 feet? At UC Davis, if you wish, you could walk past with a buffer of 200 to 300 feet. The protesters were not a clear and present danger! That end of times guy is, the riot police could go get him off the street, pepper spray him, he is predicting the end, they could make it happen.
 
Last edited:
I haven't read all 12 pages. Is it too much to ask?

[Rule 10 deleted], this thread seems to push all my wrong buttons. I'm actually a nice guy, honest.

That particular issue has been brought up a couple of times though.. The police and the protesters both said it was true, which has been shown a couple of times.
 
[Rule 10 deleted], this thread seems to push all my wrong buttons. I'm actually a nice guy, honest.
Cool, and I'm sure it carries over from the other thread also. I know that a number of people felt that I had been obtuse in that thread. I left it because of that. So, yea, I get it.

That particular issue has been brought up a couple of times though.. The police and the protesters both said it was true, which has been shown a couple of times.
Thanks.
 
Oh yes, life is incredibly simple if we just let cops come into our homes and pepper spray us! I'm sure there are some on this forum who do that as a hobby!

..and they get a boner from it!

Well that may be some kind of crazy humour, or it may be the sort of unexamined kneejerk opposition to the 'side' that opposes police brutality towards seated unarmed students without bothering to relate any remark to its context. Who knows?
 
Cool, and I'm sure it carries over from the other thread also. I know that a number of people felt that I had been obtuse in that thread. I left it because of that. So, yea, I get it.

Thanks.

Here is one of the protesters saying they surrounded them, sat down and linked arms.

From the mouth of one of the pepper spray recipients:

"We had encircled them and they were trying to leave and they were trying to clear a path and so we sat down, linked arms and said that if they wanted to clear the path they would have to go through us..."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8yHfLDIeBs
 
Here is one of the protesters saying they surrounded them, sat down and linked arms.

Oh please. While the video does not support the notion that the cops were encircled (whether or not they were), it certainly disproves the contention that they were surrounded by seated unarmed protestors. Just as your quote suggests, the seated, arm-linked protestors blocked the path. The cops apparantly weren't smart enough to move round them.
 
Yeah, you meant 'the seated unarmed students deserved to be pepper sprayed, the long-hair pinko liberals. Who do they think they are? Citizens? The police represent the politicians, not the people. The people should do as they're told. They don't know what's good for them. Pepper spray is a food product! They should be thanking us for the free lunch!"

Right?

I figure I'm free to invent whatever the hell I like for 'what you meant', since apparantly 'what you said' isn't 'what you meant' at all.

Right. :cool:
 
Oh please. While the video does not support the notion that the cops were encircled (whether or not they were), it certainly disproves the contention that they were surrounded by seated unarmed protestors. Just as your quote suggests, the seated, arm-linked protestors blocked the path. The cops apparantly weren't smart enough to move round them.

There was a photo about 3 posts above this that PROVED they were surrounded. OPEN YOUR EYES

At some point you people are going to move from willful ignorance to blatant dishonesty. It's not too far off.
 
Last edited:
There was a photo about 3 posts above this that PROVED they were surrounded. OPEN YOUR EYES

At some point you people are going to move from willful ignorance to blatant dishonesty. It's not too far off.

Yes! And the post immediately above the post of the photo shows what honesty and willful brilliance can bring to the table, eh??

Ah yes, SEVENTH GRADE ROCKS!
 
There was a photo about 3 posts above this that PROVED they were surrounded. OPEN YOUR EYES.
Without respect to anything anyone else said, the photo doesn't show the students seated and arms interlocked, right? I'm not trying to be difficult. It's just that there seems (note I said "seems") conflicting information about why the police could not pass. So, the interlocking isn't a relevant point as it relates to this photo, right?

Again, not trying to defend anything. I'm not trying to prove something. I'm more interested in understanding claims made.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom