I'm not hung up on terminology; you're the one who keeps going back to that. I'm more interested in models, predictions, and observations.
IMO *IF* that were true, you'd be a lot more interested in Birkeland's original work. It "predicted" that electrical discharges occurred in flares. It "predicted" high speed plasma particles of BOTH types would come from the sun. It predicted that JETS would occur. It predicted that the sun would generate aurora around the Earth's poles too. That model PREDICTED a lot Das. It's not just empty math, or empty physics. He provided BOTH kinds of predictions based on simulated models and based on mathematical models. He did all this 100 years BEFORE satellites in space could confirm such things.
He'd stated that flares' luminous regions had to be about 1 meter thick. It's my understanding that they're now known to be a few (though not many) orders of magnitude thicker than that. Hopefully one of the others can jump in if I have that wrong, which is possible.
We're just talking about CURRENT SHEETS in such instance, not simply localized discharges. Some discharges probably are a meter or so in thickness, but they are spread out in long SHEETS.
I don't have a good concept of Dungey's life's work; I've read only two of his papers and know nothing else about the man. But if flares are substantially thicker than 1 meter, then I'm willing to write off his conclusions in that 1958 paper.
If you say so. So you reject the term 'magnetic reconnection' from that paper too?
. . . and that's where I lost interest searching. I dispute your use of the word "ignored."
I suppose your right. They simply won't come to grips with it. Nothing like ignoring the basic premise of the work itself (discharges happen in flares), use the work to create a "dumbed down model" devoid of plasma, and still be in denial that "discharges" occur in flares. Apparently the whole process has been dumbed down to the point that any sort of "flux change' becomes an example of "reconnection' and the NULL is sort of irrelevant other than the fact that it moves (like everything else).
1) how did aurora get into this discussion?
Well, for starters, its a "prediction" of Birkeland's "cathode/electric sun" model. That is the one I prefer. You claimed to be interested in proven "predictions", right?
2) I was unaware that Birkeland had associated terrestrial lightning with the "cathode sun," but if he did, I believe that he's completely wrong.
He associated flares with electrical discharges. He saw the whole thing as being interrelated to the fact that the sun acts as a cathode with respect to the heliosphere/space(his terminology).
3) Are you going to address either of my actual points? They were
a) the planet's magnetic field is not relevant to lightning, so why mention it?
I mentioned it because electrical discharges occur NATURALLY around a LOT of bodies in this solar system. It should be no surprise it occurs in the solar atmosphere. Birkeland PREDICTED that over 100 years ago.
b) the solar environment, being plasma, is fundamentally different from a non-conductive planetary atmosphere and therefore one cannot readily draw analogies between the two for electrical behavior.
One can and one has drawn analogies *AND WORKING MODELS*. Birkeland did it. Dungey did it. Bruce did it. Lot's of folks have done it. I'm certainly not the first person to make that connection.
A better analog would be Earth's oceans, which are conductive, but do not experience internal lightning.
Somewhere in this thread I posted an image of underwater welding.
My position is that "7 of 7" boils down to "really hot."
That's not a legitimate argument IMO. I've made 7 clear PUBLISHED and EMPIRICAL links between ordinary electrical discharges and solar flare events. Either you can do that with "really hot" stuff created in the lab a *DIFFERENT* way, or you can't. Can you? If not, it seems LOGICAL to at least see it as a FRONT RUNNER for the time being in terms of EMPIRICAL TESTED PHYSICS.
Neither solar plasma nor the sun's magnetic field occurs in terrestrial labs nor in the atmospheres of any other planet. For that matter, terrestrial lightning is nowhere near as hot as the corona, so it's not a compelling analogy for yet another reason.
If you checkout the Z-machine(s), you'll see that "electrical discharged" can produce temperature that EXCEED solar temperatures.
Actually, I thought that we didn't use magnetic reconnection to generate high temperatures in laboratories because it was inconvenient and tended to operate on much, much larger scales that a typical laboratory. But perhaps someone with more hands-on laboratory experience may correct me on that.
IMO that's one GIANT COP OUT. It should be pretty easy to demonstrate. It's been done with 'electrical discharges'. If you wish to rationalize like that about the importance of TESTING theory, I don't think we have a lot to discuss. If it can be done with electrical discharges at all sorts of scales in the lab, why do we need something "exotic" in the first place?
"Outperforms?" I agree that electrical discharges provide a more convenient way to create high temperatures in a lab.
And nature.
I'm disputing your extrapolation from "more convenient for humans in a lab" to "what's actually happening 140,000,000 km away on the fringes of a 2,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 kg ball of plasma"
But this isn't really something we "can't" create. You're just rationalizing it away as *IF* it can't be done. That's just sad IMO. It's a LIGHT plasma environment, with STANDARD EM influence. Why can't we experiment with "reconnection" at scales that are necessary to verify them?
But to my original point - your statement that I "cling to ONE physical piece of evidence" is bizarre. I don't even know which piece of physical evidence you're referring to.
I think Tim provided ONE LINK to one experiment that got a few ELECTRONS to reach high states of energy. I don't think it even generated PROTONS at such energy states, let alone ionized Iron as in Lee's experiments.
It's possible that the failure is partly mine and that I'm not communicating adequately. I shall try to be more clear.
What you really haven't been clear about is the "empirical alternative" and why you believe "reconnection' can't be "lab tested" in proper scales? If electrical discharges can be scaled up in Z-machines to produce plasmas at million degree temps, don't you think that SHOULD be done with 'reconnection" too?
First, I thought the refrigerator magnet example was pretty compelling.
IN the absence of plasma it's just "flux change/time". No currents will be induced as Sweet noted. Nothing happens but flux changes/time.
I've even ordered some iron filings and magnets to do my own little demos. But, as others have pointed out: Even if MR requires plasma, we're talking about the solar atmosphere, which is plasma.
A plasma ball from the store will demonstrate the basic forces in play in plasma.
I'll leave that to others, but that's a fundamental mischaracterization. Have you tried looking at it from a conservation-of-energy perspective?
I think you might be on to something with that. No induced current means no loss of stored magnetic energy. Hmm.
His prediction was successful only if you assume that it was correct.
Not at all. I didn't assume anything when I rounded up those 7 key high energy events associated with "electrical discharges" and solar flares. It requires no ASSUMPTION other than the assumption it MIGHT be right. Had the evidence not been there, then it requires ASSUMED CORRECTNESS. Since I assumed nothing of the sort from the start, and found what I was looking for empirically, the only assumption I actually made is that it was worth consideration. That seems to be where hater's fail to make the leap of faith.
FYI, I will try to stop by once or twice a week to keep the EU hater crew honest.
