Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

There was a photo about 3 posts above this that PROVED they were surrounded. OPEN YOUR EYES

At some point you people are going to move from willful ignorance to blatant dishonesty. It's not too far off.
You mean like saying you admit when you are wrong, then ignoring the post where someone shows you, in an earlier thread, ignoring the fact you are wrong?

Or declaring your own evidence "irrelevant" when it is proven false?

Or seeing testimony from one of the people involved in a situation which directly contradicts the claims you've been making of them, then questioning someone about whether it's true, then claiming you don't actually care about the answer and changing the subject and ignoring questions about why you asked a question you don't actually care about the answer to?

Or saying two screenshots from two videos are representative of an entire time period?

Or repeatedly looking at the posts of someone you have on ignore and implying they force you to respond by doing so, when you have seen fit to not respond to some of their posts?

Or claiming cops "get a boner" from pepper spraying people?

Or criticizing the cops actions while refusing to consider alternatives, and declaring that you are under no obligation to?

Or taking one guy in your opposition saying he, personally would've used dogs, and repeatedly saying several or all of your opponents hold the same opinion despite being directly denied by them?

Or taking a guy saying in exactly what sense he used the word "opponent" and directly contradicting him?

Would those count as dishonesty?
 
Last edited:
Without respect to anything anyone else said, the photo doesn't show the students seated and arms interlocked, right?


It shows them being surrounded. Just like the students themselves said they did.

I'm not trying to be difficult. It's just that there seems (note I said "seems") conflicting information about why the police could not pass. So, the interlocking isn't a relevant point as it relates to this photo, right?

I don't see the conflicting information, sorry. I see police claiming they were being surrounded. I see students claiming they were surrounding police. I see photo and video backing this up.
 
Basically, the only people in this debate who yet argue the students weren't obstructing at any point have claimed that they weren't, and now need to ignore every bit of evidence that they were, even from the students themselves. One person even said they were going to stop discussing the obstruction part entirely.

Fair enough. 31 is many many times. I have beachnut on ignore, so I had no idea. Counting may well make your point 'stand', but it collapses again when we suggest that counting the times a single poster said something may not be the best measure. One. That's the count you want. One poster. But one isn't as helpful to you as 'many many'. Try that for size. "One poster says" vs "Many many times". Your point stands only if your point is that someone isn't right, therefore all opposition to you is wrong.
Nope. The two aren't mutually exclusive.

Yeah, you meant 'the seated unarmed students deserved to be pepper sprayed, the long-hair pinko liberals. Who do they think they are? Citizens?
Citizens are often pepper sprayed for refusing to comply with the police, much less actively blocking them.

The police represent the politicians, not the people. The people should do as they're told. They don't know what's good for them. Pepper spray is a food product! They should be thanking us for the free lunch!"

Right?
Are you done with the straw men? You've swung from "the protestors" to "the people", which, as I recall, includes "the police".

Even Megyn Kelly, in context, clearly meant that pepper spray was a product of food, not that it was a tasty treat. Her very next sentence says that it doesn't matter what it was made of if it was hurting the students. She is clearly against the use of the "caustic and abrasive" substance.

I'm betting you didn't actually watch the segment in question and, ironically, are relying on what someone else told you it said.

I figure I'm free to invent whatever the hell I like for 'what you meant', since apparantly 'what you said' isn't 'what you meant' at all.
So you are now admitting to actively making up stuff about your opponents positions because you think they use imprecise language.

Okay.
 
How many many? I would have thought, round here, that you'd have actually counted the incidences, if not calculated some ratios. Your red-herring looks more like a strawman. Who has called the students 'kids'? I've consistently referred to them as students. Seated, unarmed students....
Sure about that?

...
'Whiny brats' is not 'protesting students'. 'Whiny' is a way of denying a voice to a group you wish to silence, 'brats' is a dismissive term diminishing the students and their opinions. The police brutally pepper sprayed seated unarmed protestors. Some people support that (and support the use of dogs). They are supporters of police brutality. That's nothing to do with emotion....

Tiresome. Over and over, supporters of police brutality claim that there are occasions when force is warranted and necessary. We've done that, you have no argument there. We agree.

The pepper-spraying of peaceful seated unarmed student protestors was not warranted nor was it necessary.

It wasn't necessary to describe the protestors as 'whiny brats', either. That the supporters of police brutality can't express their support without making their biases and deficiencies clear is informative.

...By the by, there is no comparison between describing the protestors as 'whiny brats' and describing those here who support the brutal use of pepper spray on seated, peaceful, unarmed students as 'supporters of police brutality'. ...

...You're remarkably honest that you'd use dogs to enforce your will too. For dogs to work, the protestors would have to be reasonably sure you'd release the dogs. So I'm taking the reasonable position that you would choose to set ferocious dogs (you didn't mean poodles, right?) on protestors. Do you have a long leather coat that you wear around the home, admiring yourself in the mirror and thinking "Ven I rule ze vorld zer vill be NO MORE DISSENT!"?

Yes, the police must be able to do their jobs. That's a necessary part of a civilised lawful society. But another crucial part is that citizens must be able to peacefully protest, even to protest the actions of the police. Even the real police, let alone the campus cops....

Oh, I love a bit of comedy banter. You expressed an opinion, while discussing the video, about what the protestors were 'clearly' thinking and feeling during the recording. That's when I asked you 'can you show me that bit in the video?'
...

...
Oh, you are claiming the officers are threatened. You're just not explicit. Your second sentence here could use some work, I think I might see what you're trying to convince yourself of but I can't be sure. I see no violence on the part of the protestors - can you reference it in the video?
...
Probably so. Defend the use of violence against seated unarmed peaceful protestors.

...
Easy. They were non-violent. You can easily refute that by pointing to their violence in the video, but you don't. You keep claiming it's there, that seated unarmed protestors are a 'threat', but you have no evidence because there isn't any. It's a post hoc rationalisation for your inate support for the pepper spraying of uppitty book-loving punk kids.

If you like, I can list the occassions where you quote-mined, starting with this one. I don't think, at any point, you've responded to a post stating that or admitted that one does not need to be violently resisting the police to be subject to justified use of pepper spray, or to be actively committing violence or about to commit violence to be a "threat".
 
Totally relevant for me. If I was a policeman in charge an confined to a small space with limited exit, my tactics would change.

Their tactics did change based on that exact situation. You can see it evolve.

I approached understanding this event by looking at the impact of the student protest on the campus function.

The protests impact on the function of the campus is entirely irrelevant. The students protesting were doing so against campus rules and regulations by setting up camps in the middle of the quad. The order to remove the camps in no way violated their right to protest, and in no way interfered with it. Had the camps been taken down without incident, the students would most likely still be protesting there today.

When I saw the size of the quad, and the number of protesters, I found the protest had little impact on campus function. The protest was zero threat to other people, or the activities of the school.

Irrelevant. The camps were illegally set up.

No need to remove the sitting students

The sitting students were removed from the path to allow the cruiser in to remove the students who were arrested for obstructing police from removing the illegally erected camps. (:boggled:)

no need to do more than take the time to remove tents.

This was done, and arrests were made on people who obstructed the police from removing the tents. The pepper spraying incident came after, when other protesters physically blocked the police from removing those they arrested earlier.

If you have some great insight why it is wise to pepper spray students sitting in the face, enlighten me; please. I am not for the students, I am not against the police. I think the police made a mistake.

RandFan can tell you all about how pepper spray is less dangerous than physically moving those who do not want to move - he has sources that document studies that support it.

The purpose of the pepper spray is to gain control over a person without use of physical force. The students who were pepper sprayed were physically blocking the cops from bringing in a cruiser to remove previously arrested students who had prevented the cops from removing the illegally set up camps. People here posit that the cops should have just lifted the arrested students over the sitting students, but that idea stands on its own - no need to refute that silliness. Pepper spray was the best option, unless you think police should physically break apart a human chain?

Proves the police can not be surrounded unless they choose to

:D

Does this apply to all forces in history who have ever been surrounded by an opposing force? Sometimes a force can be outmaneuvered and become surrounded. Sometimes they blunder and essentially allow it to happen. It doesn't change the fact that the police were indeed surrounded.

Military science? Indeed.
 
Last edited:
Totally relevant for me. If I was a policeman in charge an confined to a small space with limited exit, my tactics would change. ...
Change...to what? I asked you this before.

To only view video of the event, one or two videos, offers zero chance to make an informed decision.
The "What Really Happened" video is stitched together from several videos, not just one.

Above, after the police pepper spray people, they are "forced" to retreat.
They pepper-sprayed the students so they could leave, as my side has been saying for the duration of the thread! Are any of these posts getting through to you? And if the police weren't surrounded, why did you just post a picture that shows them surrounded in every direction? Why does the video show them surrounded except for the direction that's just been cleared by their backup, as we've been claiming?
 
I don't see the conflicting information, sorry.
As I remember a lot of attention has been given to the fact that the students who were pepper sprayed were seated and had their arms interlocked. Is that correct? Look, I understand you are frustrated that some of us have not kept up. I don't blame you for that frustration. But my question is sincere. If you are too frustrated to answer it then just ignore me.

Was a big deal made of dislocating shoulders because students has their arms interlocked? I'm not assuming anything about the answer. I apologize I asked. I apologize that I don't know. Though in a skeptics forum people ought to be able to ask questions. Right?
 
Last edited:
RandFan can tell you all about how pepper spray is less dangerous than physically moving those who do not want to move - he has sources that document studies that support it.
I honestly don't know that. I believed that proposition and I still do. I did attempt to support that proposition. That does not speak ill of me and hardly justifies your behavior toward me. And that raises two point.

  • What evidence is there that the physical force that would be necessary to move seated students is relatively a greater risk than pepper spray?
  • This.
I will concede that I don't know A.) that pepper spray is a relatively greater risk. B.) that I have any proof to demonstrate that.
 
Last edited:
As I remember a lot of attention has been given to the fact that the students who were pepper sprayed were seated and had their arms interlocked. Is that correct? Look, I understand you are frustrated that some of us have not kept up. I don't blame you for that frustration. But my question is sincere. If you are too frustrated to answer it then just ignore me.

Was a big deal made of dislocating shoulders because students has their arms interlocked? I'm not assuming anything about the answer. I apologize I asked. I apologize that I don't know. Though in a skeptics forum people ought to be able to ask questions. Right?
Actually, the defenders of the students seem unable to get past the "peaceful students" claims to address the question of what force would be appropriate assuming the police were justified in removing the students. Their claims seem to really be about removing them, period, rather than any specific method used. JQ has stated, in effect, that any removal of the students was unjustified. Why they continued to ask questions pertaining specifically to pepper spray I do not know.

I honestly don't know that. I believed that proposition and I still do. I did attempt to support that proposition. That does not speak ill of me and hardly justifies your behavior toward me. And that raises two point.

  • What evidence is there that the physical force that would be necessary to move seated students is relatively a greater risk than pepper spray?
  • This.
I will concede that I don't know A.) that pepper spray is a relatively greater risk. B.) that I have any proof to demonstrate that.
I believe one of your reports said that pepper spray was likely to cause an hour or so of intense discomfort that makes it nigh-impossible to remain resolute and decreases physical resistance. Have some studies.

http://www.nij.gov/journals/267/use-of-force.htm
Researchers coded 467 use-of-force reports from January 2005 to July 2006. The most frequent force level used by deputies (59 percent of incidents) was soft empty hand control (e.g., holding a suspect to restrain him), which increased the odds of officer injury by 160 percent.

Pepper spray decreased the odds of suspect injury by almost 70 percent,
...
Use of both soft hand tactics and hard hand tactics (e.g., using kicks or punches to restrain a suspect) by officers more than doubled the odds of officer injury. Hands-on tactics also increased the odds of injury to suspects, as did the use of canines.
...
The use of physical force by officers increased the odds of officer injury 258 percent. Not surprisingly, the odds of officer injury also increased when suspects resisted by using physical force or when suspects used or threatened to use a weapon.

http://www.nij.gov/journals/267/use-of-force-factors.htm
Physical force and hands-on control increased the risk of injury to officers and citizens. When controlling for the use of CEDs and pepper spray in the multiagency analysis, using force increased the odds of injury to officers by more than 300 percent, and by more than 50 percent to suspects.
...
Increasing levels of suspect resistance were associated with an increased risk of injury to officers and suspects. The increased injury risk was especially acute for officers.

http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/...ction=display&article_id=2216&issue_id=102010
Whereas CEDs and OC spray, which typically are deployed at a distance from resistive or combative suspects, were associated with injury reduction, the use of hands-on tactics that require officers to be in close physical proximity to suspects to effect arrests was associated with an increased risk of injury to both officers and suspects, although some variations on this finding existed among the three agencies.
...
The authors’ findings consistently show a significant reduction in the risk of injury to suspects when CEDs or OC spray is used.
...
If injury reduction is the primary goal, then agencies that authorize OC spray and/or CEDs to overcome defensive resistance are clearly at an advantage based upon the results from the current study. Both of these less-lethal weapons help prevent or minimize physical struggles that cause injury, albeit relatively minor ones, to officers and citizens.
Can someone quote this for Rand and remove my name from the quote? He has me on ignore, and asked that this be done in the last thread.
 
I honestly don't know that. I believed that proposition and I still do. I did attempt to support that proposition. That does not speak ill of me and hardly justifies your behavior toward me. And that raises two point.

  • What evidence is there that the physical force that would be necessary to move seated students is relatively a greater risk than pepper spray?
  • This.
I will concede that I don't know A.) that pepper spray is a relatively greater risk. B.) that I have any proof to demonstrate that.

You posted this study [PDF] that you thought supported your notion that pepper spray is dangerous.

You didn't read the study, because on chapter 6, page 71, it says,

Among the new technologies developed for controlling criminal suspects, pepper spray and stun guns have received considerable attention. These technologies often are promoted as alternatives to lethal force, although they have utility in their own right as tools for behavior control. Research by Kaminski and colleagues suggests that pepper spray is effective in controlling disorderly suspects and may reduce injuries to both officers and suspects.

The alternatives you are in favor of, over pepper spray, are,

Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car.

It just needs to be pointed out to you.
 
You didn't read the study, because on chapter 6, page 71, it says...
You are doing it again. We discussed these issues so obviously I read it.

...and may reduce injuries to both officers and suspects...
Please note the word "may".

Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car.
Please note the word "threaten".
 
Voldermort said:
Actually, the defenders of the students seem unable to get past the "peaceful students" claims to address the question of what force would be appropriate assuming the police were justified in removing the students. Their claims seem to really be about removing them, period, rather than any specific method used. JQ has stated, in effect, that any removal of the students was unjustified. Why they continued to ask questions pertaining specifically to pepper spray I do not know.

I believe one of your reports said that pepper spray was likely to cause an hour or so of intense discomfort that makes it nigh-impossible to remain resolute and decreases physical resistance. Have some studies.

http://www.nij.gov/journals/267/use-of-force.htm


http://www.nij.gov/journals/267/use-of-force-factors.htm


http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/...ction=display&article_id=2216&issue_id=102010
Can someone quote this for Rand and remove my name from the quote? He has me on ignore, and asked that this be done in the last thread.

On behalf of he who can't be named.
 
Quote:
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car.
Please note the word "threaten".

Some of those techniques could not be used, obviously. Well, obviously to me.

The one that they could use, "Threaten use of chemical agent" - was used.
 
Just curious.



Please look to @ 8:40. Having pepper sprayed and arrested some of the protestors the police leave, to chants of "you can go" and the rest of the protestors are still there. It's arguable that the road is no longer blocked but honestly, what did the police accomplish? Why was pepper spraying necessary if the grounds were not cleared of protestors? Did the action prevent the road from being reblocked?
The action was not to clear the road entirely, but to allow the police cruiser in to remove the protesters that were arrested earlier.

:mad: You are doing it again....

WHY WAS IT SO NECESSARY TO CLEAR THE PATH FOR THE POLICE? TO WHAT END WAS THE PATH CLEARED?

  • DID AN AMBULANCE NEED TO GET THROUGH?
  • WAS THERE SOME EMERGENCY FOR A SPECIFIC SQUAD CAR?
  • COULD THE POLICE HAVE WAITED?
Can you stop with the dancing and all the BS? PLEASE? Why must you assume the worse and refuse to take a deep breath and think about what it is I am asking?

This has been said thousands of times.
I had NOT seen that. I did not know. Jesus Christ why can't you people just act with even a modicum of decency?

Since it WAS a thousand times then you can point to those times, right?

BTW: You quote him again for the purposes of passing a message on to me and I'm putting you on ignore. In the future just answer my god damn question without all of the BS.

People were arrested.
k?
They needed to leave - to get to the police station because that's what happens to you when you get arrested.
k?
Protesters blocked that and needed to be moved because of THE LAW.
k?
From where I sit, and obviously many others including experts on the subject which neither of us are, the police acted according to whatever options they had left.

You - and many others - disagree with their tactics. That's your right. It was my right as well, until I educated myself by watching video's that were not a propoganda tool for the Occutard movement.


Can we PLEASE for the love of god and everybody's sanity move on from this idiocy? ALL of your questions, each and every one, has been answered numerous times by numerous people, those you have chosen to ingore, and those who are no doubt next.
There are literally no more unanswered questions.

I asked a question. It wasn't snarky. It was sincere. Don't give me that " for the love god" ****.

I'm happy to move on but I damn well won't be condescended to just for trying to get some information. Got it?

"All this has happened before..."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom