Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am not a physicist, and I don't know what the plasma physicists mean when they talk about reconnection rates.
The reconnection rate is the ratio of the inflowing plasma velocity to the out flowing plasma velocity. It tells you things like the characteristic time over which the reconnection happens.

The Sweet-Parker model has a reconnection rate of
The dimensionless reconnection rate can then be written as
9567473f430340803975053589c8908e.png

where the dimensionless Lundquist number
5dbc98dcc983a70728bd082d1a47546e.png
is given by
c4bca0477871854bef9cbd717c20999f.png

​
 
When people start to define things such as the wavelength of the filed lines, and then try to tie down the reconnection rate to physically experimentally testable processes, they are left with an issue.

I have never heard a talk or read a paper where there was a "wavelength of the field lines." Also looking on ADS or just googling finds no results of this claim, so you might want to explain yourself better.

Reconnection rate is basically the inflow velocity of the plasma to the X-point/line, however it is most often defined as a representative electric field: E = v x B, but there are slightly varying definitions in the literature. Basically it is the efficiency in which the inflow velocity is transformed to the outflow velocity after MRx has happened.

A quick search found the following (older) experiments on reconnection rate:
M. Yamada, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 721 (1990).
M. Yamada, et al., Phys. Fluids B 3, 2379 (1991).
Y. Ono, et al., Phys. Fluids B 5, 3691 (1993).

However, Yamada wrote two papers lately on MRx:
Yamada, Reviews of Modern Physics, 82, 604, (2010)
Yamada, Space Science Review, 160, 25 (2012)
In both of which he discussed reconnetion rate and laboratory experiments.

The wavelength is chosen by us. Like contour lines on a map. You could model the magnetic field with say 100 lines in a certain area, or you could use less lines to represent the exactly same vector field, say five. They both represent the same field. So a reconnection rate is surely more dependant on a totally subjective human artefact, a choice made by the person modelling the field. The field lines represent a continuum, not a quantized set of events/lines you can attribute such things as a reconnection rate to, which need a physical basis.

This whole discussion shows that you have no idea what reconnection rate is. It is not dependent on how many field lines you draw in your picture, only the idea is already ridiculous.

I'm still waiting for someone to show experimental evidence for magnetic reconnection where the wavelength and reconnection rate of the field lines is defined, an then this is matched to experimental data for verification.

What wavelength, man? What on Earthspace are you talking about?

There are numerous laboratory experiments on reconnection, there are numerous Cluster observations of reconnection in the Earth's magnetotail, etc. etc.

You clearly have no idea what is happening in modern day (space)plasma physics.
 
I am not a physicist, and I don't know what the plasma physicists mean when they talk about reconnection rates.

Wow!


RC said:
The reconnection rate is the ratio of the inflowing plasma velocity to the out flowing plasma velocity.

Ding, ding, DING!

t said:
I have never heard a talk or read a paper where there was a "wavelength of the field lines."

Then you have no business even trying to defend Clinger's nonsense in the first place.

This conversation is almost surreal at this point. Let me try to help you out Clinger.

The PROCESS called "reconnection" is a PROCESS by which magnetic field energy is CONVERTED into PARTICLE KINETIC ENERGY. It's an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in plasma as defined by Peratt. It is the PROCESS by which STORED magnetic field energy is TRANSFERRED into another state of energy, specifically particle kinetic energy. That is also why plasma is NOT OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process.

What your website describes is the "magnetic flux" inside that chamber, nothing more. Whatever "flux happens", there are no plasma particles to accelerate, and therefore there is no way to generate particle kinetic energy, or convert magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

Your vacuum contraption was doomed to be a bust the moment you tried to remove the PHYSICAL PARTICLES from the TRANSFER PROCESS. You can't remove the mass from the process, or there can be no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, and no "rate of reconnection" could ever be measured.

The primary difference between the two different MODELS of reconnection in PLASMA PHYSICS are the RATES at which that TRANSFER of magnetic field energy can be converted into particle kinetic energy. The fastest one is the likely winner.

You simply CANNOT remove the PARTICLES from the PROCESS Clinger. It's not possible to describe the "rate of reconnection" in your contraption because there are no "velocities" to discuss, no ways to convert magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. You can't remove MASS in the form of PLASMA from the reconnection PROCESS and call it "reconnection".

I'm stunned that RC and t will sit there and admit that the rate of reconnection is measured in MASS FLOW CHANGES/TIME and still claim "reconnection" occurs in a vacuum. How did you intend to describe the 'rate of reconnection' without particle velocities?
 
Last edited:
When people start to define things such as the wavelength of the filed lines, and then try to tie down the reconnection rate to physically experimentally testable processes, they are left with an issue.
I have never heard a talk or read a paper where there was a "wavelength of the field lines."
Then you have no business even trying to defend Clinger's nonsense in the first place.

Oh please, Michael, explain what the wavelength of a magnetic field line is, we could all use the laugh.
 
Last edited:
FYI Clinger,

The reason Somov is able to describe "reconnection" and reconnection rates in his VACUUM is because he ADDED CURRENT (particle mass) to his 'vacuum'. At that point it becomes possible to discuss and describe the particle velocities of that current. That CURRENT is NOT OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process. It's a VITAL part of the PROCESS. The introduction of the CURRENT to his vacuum is what allows Somov to then describe PARTICLE VELOCITIES. Do you understand that?
 
You missed the point. There is no such thing, which is why "reconnection" cannot occur in the absence of particles of mass.

So you said he has no business discussing it, because he never heard of something that doesn't exist? Do you think before you type?
 
I'd also love to hear an explanation for how lack of wavelength of field lines prevents reconnection in a vacuum.
 
So you said he has no business discussing it, because he never heard of something that doesn't exist? Do you think before you type?

Then you have no business even trying to defend Clinger's nonsense in the first place.

I didn't say he couldn't our shouldn't discuss it. I said he had no business defending the notion of 'reconnection' without PLASMA!

These WAVELENGTHS described in MHD theory relate to PLASMA PARTICLES and the MOVEMENTS OF PLASMA. In fact EVERYTHING in MHD theory relates to PLASMA PHYSICS. It's therefore impossible to simply remove the physics and claim it's "equal'. Talk about equivocation fallacies of *EPIC* proportions! Clinger doesn't even have a way of describing "reconnection rates" without VELOCITIES related to PHYSICAL PARTICLES! t should have been all over him. Instead some amateur in cyberspace has to not only point out the obvious problem (no way to convert magnetic field energy to particle kinetic energy), but also defend t's nonsense at the same time! WOW! Those WAVELENGTH are plasma related features, not features related to the magnetic fields.
 
You missed the point. There is no such thing, which is why "reconnection" cannot occur in the absence of particles of mass.

what kind of idiotic answer is that?
Zeuzzzz makes one of his uninformed comments.
I ask him to explain.
you comment on it making it sound that I am an idiot that I don´t know it and thus should shut up, from which we may conclude that you know what this wavelength thingy is.
And then you sy it does not exist, aaaaa classical mozina madness.
 
what kind of idiotic answer is that?
Zeuzzzz makes one of his uninformed comments.
I ask him to explain.
you comment on it making it sound that I am an idiot that I don´t know it and thus should shut up, from which we may conclude that you know what this wavelength thingy is.
And then you sy it does not exist, aaaaa classical mozina madness.

Wow. You point out to Clinger that the "rate of reconnection' is directly related to PARTICLE VELOCITY CHANGES/TIME and *STILL* defend the claim that "reconnection" occurs *WITHOUT* particles of mass? :eek: :eye-poppi :jaw-dropp
 
nope I am in mozina madness mode, i don´t read anything I just comment, just like you.

and no Somov did not put in plasma in his VACUUM.

Yes he did. He specifically adds CHARGED PARTICLES OF MASS to his vacuum and describes their velocity changes. His VACUUM includes charged particles which is what enables him to discuss *VELOCITY* in the first place!
 
Wow. You point out to Clinger that the "rate of reconnection' is directly related to PARTICLE VELOCITY CHANGES/TIME and *STILL* defend the claim that "reconnection" occurs *WITHOUT* particles of mass? :eek: :eye-poppi :jaw-dropp


yes sweetypie, but this is too difficult for you to understand, you will just be confused, just remember that your own source Somov writes in his published book:

Vacuum reconnection is a real process.
 
yes sweetypie, but this is too difficult for you to understand, you will just be confused, just remember that your own source Somov writes in his published book:

Vacuum reconnection is a real process.

Ya, the moment he ADDED CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENT (AKA CURRENT) to his VACUUM, "vacuum reconnection" is possible. WITHOUT those CHARGED PARTICLES OF MASS, it's never going to happen. There's no physical way to transfer magnetic field energy to particle kinetic energy without charged particles. There's no way to even discuss "reconnection rates" without charged particle movement.
 
Yes he did. He specifically adds CHARGED PARTICLES OF MASS to his vacuum and describes their velocity changes. His VACUUM includes charged particles which is what enables him to discuss *VELOCITY* in the first place!

No, he says, see my copy of his work one page back, that the induced electric field would accelerate a charged particle. However that section is about a VACUUM, and I am sure Somov knows the difference between vacuum and plasma, specially because the next section is called reconnection in plasma.......
 
No, he says, see my copy of his work one page back, that the induced electric field would accelerate a charged particle. However that section is about a VACUUM, and I am sure Somov knows the difference between vacuum and plasma, specially because the next section is called reconnection in plasma.......

The only difference between the two examples in Somov's book is that in the 'vacuum' example there are just two currents already flowing in the vacuum, and nothing surrounding the two currents. The existence of the CURRENTS exists in BOTH examples t. Talk about BLATANT denial. How did you intend to discuss RECONNECTION RATES without PHYSICAL CHARGED PARTICLES and changes in the velocities of those particles?
 
I didn't say he couldn't our shouldn't discuss it. I said he had no business defending the notion of 'reconnection' without PLASMA!

These WAVELENGTHS described in MHD theory relate to PLASMA PARTICLES and the MOVEMENTS OF PLASMA. In fact EVERYTHING in MHD theory relates to PLASMA PHYSICS. It's therefore impossible to simply remove the physics and claim it's "equal'. Talk about equivocation fallacies of *EPIC* proportions! Clinger doesn't even have a way of describing "reconnection rates" without VELOCITIES related to PHYSICAL PARTICLES! t should have been all over him. Instead some amateur in cyberspace has to not only point out the obvious problem (no way to convert magnetic field energy to particle kinetic energy), but also defend t's nonsense at the same time! WOW! Those WAVELENGTH are plasma related features, not features related to the magnetic fields.

No. Go back and read the quotes again. He specifically said "wavelength of the filed lines", and was called out on it rightfully, and now you're defending him by talking about OTHER uses of the word wavelength that have nothing to do with what he said. Just stop, you're sounding even more desperate to avoid concession than usual.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom