Terrible news from Afghanistan

Thank goodness that's cleared up. I mean I and others asked her once what she felt about the Bali Nightclub bombings, and she never responded.

Yeah, well she probably thinks it was Western Imperialism that did it.
 
JihadJane must be a big Ken Livingstone fan:

He is a foremost example of that weird current stereotype, the hard-core Leftist who promotes with apparent sincerity an Islam hostile to everything he claims to believe. Communists in the past were like that. The likes of Anthony Blunt and Kim Philby worked to build a Soviet society that they either shunned or sometimes had to live in unhappily. Leftists take up the Muslim cause but couldn’t possibly live with the beliefs and values that go with it. Here’s a real mystery. Explanations, please.

They seem to suffer the same disease.
 
Last edited:
Serving in Afghanistan enhances your perspective by providing a basis of knowledge and experience to avoid being taken in by false narratives, whether express or implied. The concept that either Afghan culture is monolithic or that the Afghans view the Americans as a monolithic force is wrong. Afghans interact at the village level with platoons and companies, no higher. They are also well accustomed to the US and NATO rotations, and the changing relationships that come with each rotation. Consequently, the repercussions from this incident are highly localized - villagers in say Nangarhar, Kunar, or Ghazni are unaffected and unconcerned, and I would wager that even Maiwand and Spin B residents are more concerned about their relationship with the platoon leader/platoon sergeant or company commander/first sergeant in their districts than what a lone soldier in a different unit in a different district did.
Further, if you are using the phrase "hearts and minds" and talking about Vietnam, you either have not been paying attention or you are trying to frame a current counterinsurgency operation in the context of a historically remote one. The latest buzzwords are sufficiency and sustainability ("Afghan good enough" and "Afghan sustainable"). In the larger context, this is about the legitimacy of the Afghan government (local to national level) and the confidence the Afghan population has in the ANA and ANP. One soldier shooting local civilians, while tragic and certainly making life difficult for that unit on the ground in that particular district, neither undermines the legitimacy of the local Afghan government nor diminishes confidence in the ANA or ANP.
 
One soldier shooting local civilians, while tragic and certainly making life difficult for that unit on the ground in that particular district, neither undermines the legitimacy of the local Afghan government nor diminishes confidence in the ANA or ANP.


The "local civilians":

Nine of the 16 victims were children.

'No One Asked Their Names'

Photograph of distressed adult with small, dead children:
263894f692dbd630ba.jpg

The dead:

Mohamed Dawood son of Abdullah
Khudaydad son of Mohamed Juma
Nazar Mohamed
Payendo
Robeena
Shatarina daughter of Sultan Mohamed
Zahra daughter of Abdul Hamid
Nazia daughter of Dost Mohamed
Masooma daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Farida daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Palwasha daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Nabia daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Esmatullah daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Faizullah son of Mohamed Wazir
Essa Mohamed son of Mohamed Hussain
Akhtar Mohamed son of Murrad Ali

The wounded:

Haji Mohamed Naim son of Haji Sakhawat
Mohamed Sediq son of Mohamed Naim
Parween
Rafiullah
Zardana
Zulheja
 
Last edited:
What are the names of the 15 Pakistanis killed by the Taliban the day after?

http://abcnews.go.com/International...s-10-northwest-pakistan-15896038#.T2lF445rrTV



Anybody care? Jihad?

...I assume he's not posting the names of those Pakistani's because this thread is about the alleged murders of 16 civilians at the hands of a US citizen and soldier. That seems pretty obvious.

Why aren't you starting a new thread to discuss the 15 dead Pakistanis's over in Non-US Politics? Then you can show how people how much you really care about those 15 dead Pakistanis's and leave those who want to discuss the incident that provoked this thread to talk about it without the constant hijacks.
 
...I assume he's not posting the names of those Pakistani's because this thread is about the alleged murders of 16 civilians at the hands of a US citizen and soldier. That seems pretty obvious.

Why aren't you starting a new thread to discuss the 15 dead Pakistanis's over in Non-US Politics? Then you can show how people how much you really care about those 15 dead Pakistanis's and leave those who want to discuss the incident that provoked this thread to talk about it without the constant hijacks.

Because there is such an attack every two days. There was one in Iraq just yesterday that killed almost three times as many people. Will someone try to remember their names?

It seems Jihad cares about innocent victims only when US soldiers are involved. Her concern for civilian casualties is a feigned one.
 
Last edited:
It's worth noting that MAJ Hasan, who killed 13 in November 2009, won't go to trial until June of this year. Similarly, we can expect the SSG Bales case not to go to trial until late 2014 - the same time that we are withdrawing combat forces. Based on his lawyer's comments concerning "two years" until trial, I anticipate that he will be active in attempts to keep the trial on that schedule, and not sooner.
 
...I assume he's not posting the names of those Pakistani's because this thread is about the alleged murders of 16 civilians at the hands of a US citizen and soldier. That seems pretty obvious.

Perhaps in response to the claim that the Taliban is better at maintaining security, JihadJane will speak to the list of atrocities perpetrated on the Afghan population by the Taliban? Pardalis compiled a nice little list.
 
Because there is such an attack every two days. There was one in Iraq just yesterday that killed almost three times as many people. Will someone try to remember their names?

It seems Jihad cares about innocent victims only when US soldiers are involved. Her concern for civilian casualties is a feigned one.

...there are people that die on the roads daily: does Jihad have a responsibility to talk about those victims?

Should this thread become about the hundreds of thousands that died as a result of the invasion of Iraq? The hundreds that died at American Roadblocks in both Iraq and Afghanistan that were "done in the accordance with the rules of engagement?" Shall we make the thread about the Badr Brothers, and Murat Kurnaz and many of the other Guantanamo detainees: is that what you want to make this thread about?

The thread is about and American who allegedly murdered 16 innocent people: an incident that your absolute best to avoid talking about the whole thread. This thread isn't about all those other victims caused by the Taliban: and it isn't about the thousands that died at the hands of the Americans. Why are you doing your best to avoid talking about this incident?

Perhaps in response to the claim that the Taliban is better at maintaining security, JihadJane will speak to the list of atrocities perpetrated on the Afghan population by the Taliban? Pardalis compiled a nice little list.

You know: providing a "laundry list" of incidents using google does not prove JihadJane's proposition incorrect. Were there more terrorist attacks on the citizens of Afghanistan before or after before or after the US invasion? There are many many other questions that you would have to ask before you could even come close to proving JihadJane wrong. The Taliban are not in power now: do you think providing a list of terror attacks that occured when the Taliban are not in power proves that the Taliaban aren't better at providing security? There is a certain logic failure there.
 
Council on Foreign Relations report (October 6, 2011):

'The Taliban in Afghanistan'

""" Public reaction to the Taliban's rule was not wholly negative. While the rigid social standards fostered resentment, the Taliban cracked down on the corruption that had run rampant through the government for years. The new leaders also brought stability to Afghanistan, greatly reducing the infighting between warlords that had devastated the civilian population.

Ten years after being ousted, the Taliban continues to enjoy political and psychological support in the south, experts say, largely because the international community has not coupled its military gains with equally robust efforts in development or governance."The impact of the conflict, coupled with chronic poverty, unemployment, and corruption," has made it easy for the Taliban to manipulate the population, notes a May 2011 survey from ICOS (PDF). Almost 42 percent of survey respondents in the south said working with the Taliban is right. The ICG report (PDF) says the "Taliban propaganda has convinced a segment of Afghan public opinion that foreign troops and the Afghan government are the main threat to their physical security." """


~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~




'Afghan villagers told they would pay for bomb days ahead of massacre of 16'

EXTRACT:

"After the incident, they took the wreckage of their destroyed tank and their wounded people from the area," Mr Rasool said. "After that, they came back to the village nearby the explosion site.

"The soldiers called all the people to come out of their houses and from the mosque," he said.

"The Americans told the villagers 'A bomb exploded on our vehicle. ... We will get revenge for this incident by killing at least 20 of your people,"' Mr Rasool said. "These are the reasons why we say they took their revenge by killing women and children in the villages."

...

The US soldiers arrived in the village with their Afghan army counterparts and made many of the male villagers stand against a wall, Mr Khan said.

"It looked like they were going to shoot us, and I was very afraid," said Mr Khan. "Then a NATO soldier said through his translator that even our children will pay for this. Now they have done it and taken their revenge."

Several Afghan officials, including Kandahar lawmaker Abdul Rahim Ayubi, said people in the two villages that were attacked told them the same story.
 
Last edited:
Why are you doing your best to avoid talking about this incident?

I am talking about it, I just see Jihad's use the names of the victims as some kind of appeal to emotion as using this tragedy to advance her ideology.

If she really cared about civilian casualties, she wouldn't endorse the Taliban the say she does. If she cared about Afghan civilians, she would be against the Taliban, but here she is again apologizing for them.

If innocent people are all equal, then she should care as much about the deaths committed by the Taliban than this one soldier. But I guess Afghans who get killed by a lone white guy are more important than Afghans killed by brown people.

I've posted two links showing how many victims the Taliban cause, and she continues to ignore them.

Were there more terrorist attacks on the citizens of Afghanistan before or after before or after the US invasion?[...] The Taliban are not in power now: do you think providing a list of terror attacks that occured when the Taliban are not in power proves that the Taliaban aren't better at providing security?
That is not the topic of this thread.

We are talking about now. Right now the Taliban are not protecting the lives of civilians, they are attacking them deliberately.

Right now they do not care for the security of the Afghans, they purposefully want to create chaos and destruction.

Right now the Taliban are actively trying to make the Afghans suffer.

Anyone who thinks the Taliban are on the Afghan's side is delusional.

The people who care about the Afghans and are making all they can to ensure they have a future are the Coalition, and the Afghan military and police.

And even if we were talking about the times when they were in power, even then they didn't care about Afghans either, they only cared about their extreme ideology being followed to the letter. They didn't care about education, about infrastructure, or harmony amongst religious minorities. Quite the contrary, they ruled with an iron fist, they suppressed minorities and women, and were ruthless.

But Jihad Jane loves brutal dictators. She loved Hussein, she loved Quaddafi, and she loves Assad. Her idea of stability and security is a ruthless autocracy, cronyism, and brutal suppression of basic rights.

North Korea isn't a secure place, and Saddam's Iraq wasn't either. It was for the friends of the party, but it wasn't for the rest of the population, it wans't if you were of the wrong religious denomination or ethnic group, who lived in constant fear. Go tell a Kurd how wonderfully safe life was under Saddam Hussein, he'll punch you in the face.

That is not security.

The ICG report (PDF) says the "Taliban propaganda has convinced a segment of Afghan public opinion that foreign troops and the Afghan government are the main threat to their physical security." """

Look who's been fooled by the Taliban propaganda...:rolleyes:

Again, the Taliban are responsible for 77% of the civilian deaths in 2011

Here is a year by year account:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2010/aug/10/afghanistan-civilian-casualties-statistics

The Taliban are evidently the main threat to Afghans' physical security.
 
Last edited:
The main reason why things are getting worse is because of the insecurity caused by the Taliban attacks, not the other way around.

If the Taliban and the insurgency weren't there to create chaos, the work of the Coalition would be easier, and the Afghan state would be much more secure and democratic. All our resources and the resources of the Afghan government are diverted towards the fight against terrorism, that's why there's nothing left to fight poverty and other pressing needs.

It's not the Coalition's fault for this, it's the Taliban. They're the ones hindering progress, they're the ones making it difficult for NGOs to work, they're the ones making it hard for Afghans to make their country whole and working again.

The Taliban are fueling sectarian hatred, not the Coalition. The Taliban want the country to go badly because they want a shot at taking control of it again. They don't want things to improve for Afghans, because that would prove that the invasion was a good thing. They don't want the Afghans to be free and democratic, because they want to be in power again, their want they brand of Islam to dominate public and private life again. They don't want women to be educated and liberated, they want to continue to subjugate them.

The Taliban don't have the Afghans' best interest at heart, they only have their own interest in mind.
 
Last edited:
I am talking about it, I just see Jihad's use the names of the victims as some kind of appeal to emotion as using this tragedy to advance her ideology.

If she really cared about civilian casualties, she wouldn't endorse the Taliban the say she does. If she cared about Afghan civilians, she would be against the Taliban, but here she is again apologizing for them.

If innocent people are all equal, then she should care as much about the deaths committed by the Taliban than this one soldier. But I guess Afghans who get killed by a lone white guy are more important than Afghans killed by brown people.

I've posted two links showing how many victims the Taliban cause, and she continues to ignore them.

That is not the topic of this thread.

We are talking about now. Right now the Taliban are not protecting the lives of civilians, they are attacking them deliberately.

Right now they do not care for the security of the Afghans, they purposefully want to create chaos and destruction.

Right now the Taliban are actively trying to make the Afghans suffer.

Anyone who thinks the Taliban are on the Afghan's side is delusional.

The people who care about the Afghans and are making all they can to ensure they have a future are the Coalition, and the Afghan military and police.

And even if we were talking about the times when they were in power, even then they didn't care about Afghans either, they only cared about their extreme ideology being followed to the letter. They didn't care about education, about infrastructure, or harmony amongst religious minorities. Quite the contrary, they ruled with an iron fist, they suppressed minorities and women, and were ruthless.

But Jihad Jane loves brutal dictators. She loved Hussein, she loved Quaddafi, and she loves Assad. Her idea of stability and security is a ruthless autocracy, cronyism, and brutal suppression of basic rights.

North Korea isn't a secure place, and Saddam's Iraq wasn't either. It was for the friends of the party, but it wasn't for the rest of the population, it wans't if you were of the wrong religious denomination or ethnic group, who lived in constant fear. Go tell a Kurd how wonderfully safe life was under Saddam Hussein, he'll punch you in the face.

That is not security.



Look who's been fooled by the Taliban propaganda...:rolleyes:

Again, the Taliban are responsible for 77% of the civilian deaths in 2011

Here is a year by year account:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2010/aug/10/afghanistan-civilian-casualties-statistics

The Taliban are evidently the main threat to Afghans' physical security.

...so you really really really are avoiding the topic of this thread.

You know what, writing lots of words doesn't change the fact that you are doing the best to avoid the topic of this thread. You haven't even made the effort to say what this US soldier has done has been a bad thing. This thread isn't about the Taliban but you've done your absolute best to deflect the topic to something that you can rant and rave about.

You've done everything but talk about this incident and you've done it again. How hard is if for you to say that this incident is a tragedy that never should have happened? Your first post in this thread was a rant about the "heroic actions of the coalition." You accuse other people of "not caring" but you can't even be bothered to say anything at all about the victims of this atrocity.
 
.
You know what, writing lots of words doesn't change the fact that you are doing the best to avoid the topic of this thread. You haven't even made the effort to say what this US soldier has done has been a bad thing.

Do you really think that NEEDS TO BE SAID? it's not, you know, PATENTLY OBVIOUS?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom