To get back to the Constitutional discussion, a lot of the problems the Justices on the rigth are having is not the fact that the phrase "interstate commerce" is unclear. It is unclear, but 180 years of jurisprudence has elucidated it quite well), but that the ubiquity of interstate commerce has quite outstripped whatever limit was intended.
Let's take Scalia's hypothetical broccoli farmer. In the 1780's (and let's ignore for the moment that broccoli wasn't introduced to America until the late 1800's), this broccoli farmer would grow broccoli, travel to his local market, sell it to other residents of his State, and then return to his farm. It was easy in the 1880's for the government to discern that this broccoli farmer was not engaged in interstate commerce, and was thus beyond the reach of the federal government's commerce clause.
Today, however,
broccoli is big business. Broccoli is sold through national wholesalers. The US government invests in broccoli research and farming. The
USDA carefully monitors broccoli growth and sales, and
off-handed remarks by Presidents can affect the product's sales.
I think the commercial growing of broccoli is big business and Congress can regulate it. And in that vein, so is healthcare.
Kennedy asked the central question: "Can Congress force someone to engage in interstate commerce". But, to me, this should not have anything to do with whether Congress has the authority under the Commerce Clause. Clearly, compelling interstate commerce is a regulation of interstate commerce.
To me, the proper question is what limits are there on the government's ability to compel someone to act? The Commerce Clause is the wrong clause. Rather, this requires an analysis of whether you can deprive someone's liberty without due process, and, since we're discussing the government's ability to compel people to spend money, an examination of the taxing powers of the federal government.
But that's a legal analysis that the right is likely to lose. So they are trying to redefine the scope of the interstate commerce clause. I think it's wrongheaded, and I hope sufficient justices see through the problem.