Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

I mentioned this earlier and it got passed over:

Under UHC would Doctors still maintain liability for malpractice? ...
Yes, and there would be a tendency toward single doctors vanishing, and small groups growing larger, etc, as happens in every industry where regulatory costs increase.
 
Obama the law professor has apparently forgotten little things like Marbury v. Madison:

Overturning the law would be “an unprecedented, extraordinary step” since it was passed by a majority of members in the House and Senate,” he said.

What, the Supreme Court can only overturn laws that were passed by a minority of members of the House and Senate?:D
 
Obama the law professor has apparently forgotten little things like Marbury v. Madison:



What, the Supreme Court can only overturn laws that were passed by a minority of members of the House and Senate?:D
What, you don't believe in spreading the wealth of constitutional interpretations around?

Some people have more than they need, and some people are constitutionally poor. We need a single player system. That way, we can take from those that have constitutions, and give to those that don't. To each according to his needs, and from each accordin to our takins'.

Think about those doctors who for a simple tonsil problem whack off a foot. Now you can't trust them. But you can trust attorneys, and guys like me, the Bamster. I'm on your slide. And let me point this out clearly - the Republicans would throw your granny under the bus, and we can't have that. There's no room under the bus. And who said they could move out of the back of the bus? Get some cops after them, and not those white cops. You can't trust them, you know.
 
Last edited:
Obama the law professor has apparently forgotten little things like Marbury v. Madison


The quotation marks in the article are weird, but if he actually said that, his law professor credentials should be revoked.

Another quote from the article that seemed heavy on politics and weak on legal theory:

"We are confident that this will be upheld because it should be upheld ..."


In other words, "I want it, so it's constitutional."
 
As much as I support the AHA and believe it to be constitutional...

I'm disappointed in Pres Obama's address. He should have just left it alone. Or maybe a "look, we tried to devise a law to extend healthcare to all while decreasing costs in a manner that is constitutional. If the SCOTUS decides that we have failed in that endeavor, then we'll readdress the issue. Hopefully with less acrimony."

He could have taken a few digs at the Republicans who stonewalled any attempts at a bipartisan compromise on UHC, etc...but...what he did... that's a big fail :(
 
As much as I support the AHA and believe it to be constitutional...

I'm disappointed in Pres Obama's address. He should have just left it alone. Or maybe a "look, we tried to devise a law to extend healthcare to all while decreasing costs in a manner that is constitutional. If the SCOTUS decides that we have failed in that endeavor, then we'll readdress the issue. Hopefully with less acrimony."

He could have taken a few digs at the Republicans who stonewalled any attempts at a bipartisan compromise on UHC, etc...but...what he did... that's a big fail :(
Agreed, it would have been nice if he had gotten in a few digs by pointing out that he had adopted a conservative plan promoted by the GOP.

Now we will have to resort to promoting the CT that this was a GOP plan to sink the Obama administration. Shrewd, really, really shrewd.
 
No, that does not work. This can best be expressed mathematically but let me try to put it in words. There is high individual variance in symptoms displayed and similar variance in actual illness based on those symptoms displayed. Therefore, the entire concept of a "general rule" does not work, excepting insofar as the general rule allows the physician to do what he thinks is best. This is a danger to the welfare of the patient whether it is a third party payer or some slugs in washington. But it would be far worse with the slugs, than the average insurance company.

Are then suggesting we throw out diagnostic codes altogether? Once a doctor has made a diagnosis, there are already best practices in place. One example would be formularies instituted in hospitals and by insurance carriers. The system isn't rigid and is based on a diagnosis.

I believe doctors helped write these things.

I would advocate a model where doctors are mainly diagnosticians and increase the roles of other practitioners.

But we are right back where we started. Customization costs more. My question is whether the results are worth the price and whether there is any ceiling to the price.
 
Agreed, it would have been nice if he had gotten in a few digs by pointing out that he had adopted a conservative plan promoted by the GOP.

Now we will have to resort to promoting the CT that this was a GOP plan to sink the Obama administration. Shrewd, really, really shrewd.

He's just practicing for the campaign; the SC had an informal vote on Friday and while it's supposed to be kept secret, it's pretty obvious that word leaked out that Obamacare is on life support, awaiting the final decision of the "death panel".
 
He's just practicing for the campaign; the SC had an informal vote on Friday and while it's supposed to be kept secret, it's pretty obvious that word leaked out that Obamacare is on life support, awaiting the final decision of the "death panel".
Thank you ever so much for that. Not sure what that has to do with my post but, well, thanks.
 
Thank you ever so much for that. Not sure what that has to do with my post but, well, thanks.

Just letting you know what it was all about. I could have quoted Bob the Donkey or posted it solo. Still, now you know.
 
He's just practicing for the campaign; the SC had an informal vote on Friday and while it's supposed to be kept secret, it's pretty obvious that word leaked out that Obamacare is on life support, awaiting the final decision of the "death panel".

Oh, no doubt. I just think the smart play would be to hedge the bets. As it is...he's held a gun to the SCOTUS head. Let's say that prior to that statement the SCOTUS was 5-4 in favor of constitutionality...the SCOTUS now has to weigh what extra message that vote could mean.
 
Obama the law professor has apparently forgotten little things like Marbury v. Madison:



What, the Supreme Court can only overturn laws that were passed by a minority of members of the House and Senate?:D

The entire left wing of legal academia seems to have acquired a newfound appreciation of the virtues of majoritarian democracy in this ACA debate. Not too long ago anyone suggesting that Alexander Bickel might have had a point when he referred to the "countermajoritarian difficulty" of the unelected Supreme Court nullifying democratically-enacted legislation would have been quickly called a closet bigot trying to create an intellectually respectable smokescreen for the maintenance of regressive racial policies. Of course that accusation would have often been true-- the conservatives' appreciation for judicial restraint from the 1930s to today was just as self-serving as the liberals' is now. Felix Frankfurter may have been the only truly principled advocate of restraint in the last century.
 
Last edited:
He's just practicing for the campaign; the SC had an informal vote on Friday and while it's supposed to be kept secret, it's pretty obvious that word leaked out that Obamacare is on life support, awaiting the final decision of the "death panel".

Marvelous.

THE DEATH PANEL OF OBAMACARE:

Supreme Court.

How fitting.

Obama the law professor ...
You mean the part time lecturer?
 
Last edited:
Are then suggesting we throw out diagnostic codes altogether? Once a doctor has made a diagnosis, there are already best practices in place. One example would be formularies instituted in hospitals and by insurance carriers. The system isn't rigid and is based on a diagnosis.

I believe doctors helped write these things.

I would advocate a model where doctors are mainly diagnosticians and increase the roles of other practitioners.

But we are right back where we started. Customization costs more. My question is whether the results are worth the price and whether there is any ceiling to the price.
Diagnostic codes are a fact of life, although one problem is that as insurance companies changed their rules about what was paid for with various codes, the various codes submitted seemed to change subtly. Thus using the actual codes for statistics is now likely impossible, as is trying to derive useful generalizations from them. But as I noted, the high variance makes the entire idea of generalizations or "general rule making" not advisable.

You err in my opinion, in starting thinking that an overall scheme would improve things, and thence in asking about prices and results. One time tested and well proven scheme is actually "decentralization". However, nonwithstanding that, some improvements are starkly obvious.

  • Make insurance available across state lines.
  • Increase availability of medical savings accounts.
  • Limit malpractice lawsuit awards strictly.
  • Regulate insurance companies to protect the insured against coverage being dropped or refused (high risk state pools would easily do this)

Personally I don't think this is complicated, but one reason for that is that some very complicated questions, I am happy to let the free market decide. For example some of your questions about cost benefits drop out when the market decides. Analogue:

Would everyone be better and happier if everyone had a Ferrari? But that'd be expensive. But people would like it.... (ad nauseum...)

...As it is...he's held a gun to the SCOTUS head. Let's say that prior to that statement the SCOTUS was 5-4 in favor of constitutionality...the SCOTUS now has to weigh what extra message that vote could mean.

Translated:

Can we become a banana republic?

Yes We Can! Yes We Can! Yes We Can!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2fZHou18Cdk&feature=results_main&playnext=1&list=PLE35C307C9776D8C0
 
Last edited:
The entire left wing of legal academia seems to have acquired a newfound appreciation of the virtues of majoritarian democracy in this ACA debate. Not too long ago anyone suggesting that Alexander Bickel might have had a point when he referred to the "countermajoritarian difficulty" of the unelected Supreme Court nullifying democratically-enacted legislation would have been quickly called a closet bigot trying to create an intellectually respectable smokescreen for the maintenance of regressive racial policies. Of course that accusation would have often been true-- the conservatives' appreciation for judicial restraint from the 1930s to today was just as self-serving as the liberals' is now. Felix Frankfurter may have been the only truly principled advocate of restraint in the last century.
I'm going to happily agree with this post. Thank you.
 
To get back to the Constitutional discussion, a lot of the problems the Justices on the rigth are having is not the fact that the phrase "interstate commerce" is unclear. It is unclear, but 180 years of jurisprudence has elucidated it quite well), but that the ubiquity of interstate commerce has quite outstripped whatever limit was intended.

Let's take Scalia's hypothetical broccoli farmer. In the 1780's (and let's ignore for the moment that broccoli wasn't introduced to America until the late 1800's), this broccoli farmer would grow broccoli, travel to his local market, sell it to other residents of his State, and then return to his farm. It was easy in the 1880's for the government to discern that this broccoli farmer was not engaged in interstate commerce, and was thus beyond the reach of the federal government's commerce clause.

Today, however, broccoli is big business. Broccoli is sold through national wholesalers. The US government invests in broccoli research and farming. The USDA carefully monitors broccoli growth and sales, and off-handed remarks by Presidents can affect the product's sales.

I think the commercial growing of broccoli is big business and Congress can regulate it. And in that vein, so is healthcare.

Kennedy asked the central question: "Can Congress force someone to engage in interstate commerce". But, to me, this should not have anything to do with whether Congress has the authority under the Commerce Clause. Clearly, compelling interstate commerce is a regulation of interstate commerce.

To me, the proper question is what limits are there on the government's ability to compel someone to act? The Commerce Clause is the wrong clause. Rather, this requires an analysis of whether you can deprive someone's liberty without due process, and, since we're discussing the government's ability to compel people to spend money, an examination of the taxing powers of the federal government.

But that's a legal analysis that the right is likely to lose. So they are trying to redefine the scope of the interstate commerce clause. I think it's wrongheaded, and I hope sufficient justices see through the problem.
 
To get back to the Constitutional discussion, a lot of the problems the Justices on the rigth are having is not the fact that the phrase "interstate commerce" is unclear. It is unclear, but 180 years of jurisprudence has elucidated it quite well), but that the ubiquity of interstate commerce has quite outstripped whatever limit was intended.

Let's take Scalia's hypothetical broccoli farmer. In the 1780's (and let's ignore for the moment that broccoli wasn't introduced to America until the late 1800's), this broccoli farmer would grow broccoli, travel to his local market, sell it to other residents of his State, and then return to his farm. It was easy in the 1880's for the government to discern that this broccoli farmer was not engaged in interstate commerce, and was thus beyond the reach of the federal government's commerce clause.

Today, however, broccoli is big business. Broccoli is sold through national wholesalers. The US government invests in broccoli research and farming. The USDA carefully monitors broccoli growth and sales, and off-handed remarks by Presidents can affect the product's sales.

I think the commercial growing of broccoli is big business and Congress can regulate it. And in that vein, so is healthcare.

Kennedy asked the central question: "Can Congress force someone to engage in interstate commerce". But, to me, this should not have anything to do with whether Congress has the authority under the Commerce Clause. Clearly, compelling interstate commerce is a regulation of interstate commerce.

To me, the proper question is what limits are there on the government's ability to compel someone to act? The Commerce Clause is the wrong clause. Rather, this requires an analysis of whether you can deprive someone's liberty without due process, and, since we're discussing the government's ability to compel people to spend money, an examination of the taxing powers of the federal government.

But that's a legal analysis that the right is likely to lose. So they are trying to redefine the scope of the interstate commerce clause. I think it's wrongheaded, and I hope sufficient justices see through the problem.
Great post. I'm really enjoying this thread. :)
 
.....the proper question is what limits are there on the government's ability to compel someone to act? The Commerce Clause is the wrong clause. Rather, this requires an analysis of whether you can deprive someone's liberty without due process, and, since we're discussing the government's ability to compel people to spend money, an examination of the taxing powers of the federal government.

But that's a legal analysis that the right is likely to lose. So they are trying to redefine the scope of the interstate commerce clause. I think it's wrongheaded, and I hope sufficient justices see through the problem.
I doubt it, because you are trying to redefine taxation as requiring people to give money to a private company. And that simply isn't taxation.

And it isn't exactly "the right" that focused on the interstate commerce clause, that's exactly the clause under which the Bamster and cronies thought they do these forcings. "The right" has simply responded to this reality.
 
I doubt it, because you are trying to redefine taxation as requiring people to give money to a private company. And that simply isn't taxation.

And it isn't exactly "the right" that focused on the interstate commerce clause, that's exactly the clause under which the Bamster and cronies thought they do these forcings. "The right" has simply responded to this reality.
I dunno. To me, "tax" means any State-mandated surrender of resources. It does not matter if the surrender takes the form of a check to the IRS, a State-mandated employer-funded benefit program, or a blue law (no liquor sales on Sunday). Some taxes make sense and some do not. That's the real argument, not whether to call a mandate or a fine a "tax".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom