Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
If OWS had read actual politics books instead of watching Gurren Lagann and realised that yelling "ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWER!" until the cows come home does not effect change, maybe they could have made real progress.
 
It is? In what category?
The same category as America's 1%.

Support for the Tea Party I guess.

Gee, the Hannity forum is looking so much like a ray of light every day!
I don't live in America, and I didn't follow political news even when I was on the other side of the Atlantic.

And I think I've got the right to say they're a bunch of idiots made up from a minuscule segment of the radical left and assorted kooks and crazies. And as such have, and will achieve absolutely nothing.
I disagree. They've succeeded in being an absolute nuisance of themselves.

Let's take it one step further, Virus. What does smashing the window of a congressman's office have to do with anything you support?
What does that have to do with whether Occupy was justified in doing it?

Oh, wait, nothing.

If OWS had read actual politics books instead of watching Gurren Lagann and realised that yelling "ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWER!" until the cows come home does not effect change, maybe they could have made real progress.
Which is ironic, since the show makes the point that while Kamina was the charismatic leader, it was Simon who did most of the work. Kamina even says so himself.

Occupy wants to be a Kamina without a Simon.
 
If OWS had read actual politics books instead of watching Gurren Lagann and realised that yelling "ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWER!" until the cows come home does not effect change, maybe they could have made real progress.
OWS isn't a single person. It's a movement made up by a group of people. They are not monolithic and you are engaging in ad hominem.
 
I'm sure breaking windows is going to accomplish a lot and bring a lot of public sympathy to the cause.
I would advise them against doing it. But that's my opinion, though I have some background in sociology and psychology, it's impossible to predict what events will captivate public opinion and which will be perceived as good or bad.
 
They think they are entitled to redress and free speech. God forbid someone should exercise their rights and not shut up and sit down with the rest of the sheeple.

I think it's pretty disingenuous to claim that people are objecting to OWS because they're exercising their rights. This kind of argument is beneath you, RF.
 
I think it's pretty disingenuous to claim that people are objecting to OWS because they're exercising their rights. This kind of argument is beneath you, RF.
Straw man.

Just look at this drivel. They really think they're important don't they?
http://occupywallst.org/article/may-day-call-action/
What the protestors think about their relative importance is an irrelevant ad hominem. And I would add, being an American with the right to redress and free speech DOES make them important.

Please don't personalize the argument.
 
OWS isn't a single person. It's a movement made up by a group of people. They are not monolithic and you are engaging in ad hominem.
Yes, I see how saying a political movement ain't done squat to advance their alleged goals is a personal attack.

No, wait, it isn't.

I would advise them against doing it. But that's my opinion, though I have some background in sociology and psychology, it's impossible to predict what events will captivate public opinion and which will be perceived as good or bad.
Wow.

What a load of mealy-mouthed hand-waving moral-equivocation tripe.

I think it's pretty disingenuous to claim that people are objecting to OWS because they're exercising their rights. This kind of argument is beneath you, RF.

Clearly not.

Straw man.

What the protestors think about their relative importance is an irrelevant ad hominem. And I would add, being an American with the right to redress and free speech DOES make them important.

Please don't personalize the argument.
Virus was saying that they have an inflated sense of their own importance, after calling it "drivel". In other words, he was indirectly saying the entire movement is unimportant. That's not an ad hom.

Having Free Speech does not necessarily make what one says important, and people only have the right to ask the government for redress. I can use my free speech rights to ask the government for a pretty pony, but that doesn't mean I'm going to get one or that my request is important. By your own argument, criticism of OWS is also important because it's also free speech.

And I think I've got the right to say they're a bunch of idiots made up from a minuscule segment of the radical left and assorted kooks and crazies. And as such have, and will achieve absolutely nothing.
It took the kooks and crazies of the 60s many years to have any success. I don't know if this group has staying power but speaking up and speaking out is better than telling everyone else to sit down and shut up any day. "I like the noise of democracy." James Buchanan.

I think the idiots are those who think power doesn't corrupt. That people who control hundreds of billions if not trillions can't or won't try to bundle worthless derivatives, sell them and hedge them.

Nothing to see here folks. Go on being sheep and pretending that the powers that be are innocently looking out for your best interest.
BTW: My point since it sailed over your head is this, you don't have to think you are important to speak out. You only have to have something to say. It simply doesn't follow that speaking out makes you think you are important. You are engaging in fallacy. No one said you didn't have "the right" to attack people who are speaking up and exercising their rights. Of course you have the right to attack anyone you want.
...In case you still are not getting this, it was illegal when the patriots did it in 1773. It hurt capitalists who had done nothing more than investing in commerce. You support capitalism and the rule of law, right?

I say find those who break windows and lock 'em up. Had I been in a position of authority I damn sure would have been willing to lock up the patriots. That's the price of civil disobedience. The patriots thought it worth it.

I realize that moral consistency is a problem for some. Sentiment and time are sufficent to excuse the patriots actions for some. NOT me. You? Would you have locked up the patriots or are you going to fall back on moral inconsistency and ad hoc special pleading?

I find little backbone and morality in those who defend conformity and the status quo. Sheep.
I'm not an anarchist, I'm an unabashed capitalist. I think there is value to hard work, entrepreneurship, personal responsibility, thrift and investment. But I also have contempt for sheep that swallow the BS of the wealthy and powerful. At least the anarchists are willing to stand up to those in power and fight for justice and not tell others to sit down and accept the status quo.

You personalized the debate yourself, RF, and did so with repeated straw men.
 
Yeah. They actually seem to be so non-monolithic as to stifle achievement. Unless you count protesting as achievement, that is.
This kind of analysis truly baffles me. The civil rights movement took many years to achieve any success. There were years of reversals and little recognition or bad recognition. The protestors were assailed and derided.

The success or failure of protesting can't be measured in terms of a news cycle or even a year or two. If OWS folds up the tents and goes home this year and we hear no more about it for a year I would not call it a failure. Because to do so would be to retroactively declare much of the civil rights era a failure.

I'm not sure if this kind of micro analysis is indicative of ad hoc rationalization or simply a failure to understand what protesting is and wht it is not. It's not something that many if not most protestors naively believe will end in success within a few months.
 
This kind of analysis truly baffles me. The civil rights movement took many years to achieve any success. There were years of reversals and little recognition or bad recognition. The protestors were assailed and derided.

The success or failure of protesting can't be measured in terms of a news cycle or even a year or two. If OWS folds up the tents and goes home this year and we hear no more about it for a year I would not call it a failure. Because to do so would be to retroactively declare much of the civil rights era a failure.

I'm not sure if this kind of micro analysis is indicative of ad hoc rationalization or simply a failure to understand what protesting is and wht it is not. It's not something that many if not most protestors naively believe will end in success within a few months.
Under what criteria would you call it a failure, RF? As Tim points out, they haven't even managed to form a clear idea of what they want in six months.

I know what MLK fought for. There was a speech. All I can pin OWS down on is a few vague concepts like "economic inequality", which basically means "some people have more money than others".

 
Last edited:
They also had goals, which seems to be too monolithic for some movements.
Actually they were not unified then either. There were many conflicts over what to protest, how and why. Many simply wanted to raise awareness.

This for me is by far the most important goal. We were asleep at the wheel when the banking crises hit. There has been little resistance to the erosion of substantive regulations that protect us from such unnecessary nonsense. There is little doubt that history will judge American citizens as largely abrogating their responsibility to demand more of their leaders. Goals? Wake people the hell up. Power corrupts. As the gulf between poor and rich widens then the rich will have ever and ever more power to buy lobbyists and politicians. Hundreds of millions is without any sense of hyperbole, pocket change.

I honestly don't know if OWS is so poorly planned and executed that it is doomed to failure. But I'm damn well rooting that the movement will cause some percentage of the population to actually wake up and see that things are not going well. People need to understand that the lobbyists who write our laws don't write those laws with us in mind. They couldn't give a ****. The pendulum of erosion of protection and oversight is moving too far in the wrong direction for easy to understand reasons. Better to do something now than latter.

One can hope.
 
Last edited:
Understanding social and moral progress.

  • Social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic. (paraphrased) --Hegel
  • Social and moral progress is the equilibrium found in an adversarial system (paraphrased) --Michael Sandel.
  • Without deviation from the norm, Progress is not possible (paraphrased) --Frank Zappa.
Without discussion, without conflict, without people who stand out and threaten convention and the status quo, there simply is no progress. The folks in power want you to be obedient, be they ministers or politicians, they want you compliant and they want you to attack anyone who dares question their authority.
 
Last edited:
Here's another article, from some guy who got disillusioned with the movement. Notice the OWS-sympathetic commenters attacking him for doing so, decrying him for having no "patience" and insisting they're "just getting started". Getting started, by definition, requires one to be making some progress toward one's goals.
 
  • Social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic. (paraphrased) --Hegel
  • Social and moral progress is the equilibrium found in an adversarial system (paraphrased) --Michael Sandel.
  • Without deviation from the norm, Progress is not possible (paraphrased) --Frank Zappa.
Without discussion, without conflict, without people who stand out and threaten convention and the status quo, there simply is no progress. The folks in power want you to be obedient, be they ministers or politicians, they want you compliant and they want you to attack anyone who dares question their authority.
Once again, RF, you strawman "criticizing OWS for not making progress/having a coherent message or goals" with "supporting the status quo" and "telling people not to question authority", no matter how much you've been directly corrected and contradicted.
 
Last edited:
I think it's pretty disingenuous to claim that people are objecting to OWS because they're exercising their rights. This kind of argument is beneath you, RF.

Straw man.

I disagree:

They think they are entitled to redress and free speech. God forbid someone should exercise their rights and not shut up and sit down with the rest of the sheeple.

Here you're implying that critics of OWS believe OWS should not speak, and you're dismissing criticism of OWS as illegitimate because it is criticism of their right to speak.

If I've misinterpreted your argument in that post, please explain what you really meant.

As it stands, it's a poor argument and a strawman. Nobody is questioning OWS's right to speak, and nobody is criticizing that right to speak, and nobody is asking them not to exercise that right.

Instead, people are judging the quality of the ideas OWS is expressing, and--rightly or wrongly--finding the quality of their ideas to be poor. The right to express bad ideas does not delegitimize criticism of of bad ideas.

Bringing up the argument I quoted above, an argument nobody is actually making, is irrelevant. It's a strawman. And it's a dodge. In a discussion about the quality of the ideas, that's the only argument being made about the right to express those ideas. Why bring it up?
 
Instead, people are judging the quality of the ideas OWS is expressing, and--rightly or wrongly--finding the quality of their ideas to be poor. The right to express bad ideas does not delegitimize criticism of of bad ideas.
I'm sorry but this is really a very simple point.

  • I'm not arguing that anyone else is arguing against rights.
  • Virus is not judging the quality of anything but the people.
  • Attacking people and not their arguments is ad hominem.
Just look at this drivel. They really think they're important don't they?
Please to see my post in context. Given the post by virus (the one I'm addressing) what ideas exactly is he judging the quality of? BTW: How does labeling people "occutard" and attacking them personally judge the quality of their ideas?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom