What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

^
Chunky or smooth?

Natural or with fats added.
Personal choice in you are a Unitarian Universalist. Other churches have dogma such as the Skippians and their war with the Panites. Then there are those of the Almond Butter persuasion and even the Soy Butter faction (universally despised).
 
But I like us all to think about the origins of the concept of God as creator of the universe, that concept has a long development until at the time when Genesis 1:1 was written, it has already arrived at the formulation that God is the creator of the universe, the heaven and the earth.

And in that connection to delve on what were the grounds for the ancient thinkers to come to such a formulation of God, namely, as creator of heaven and earth, or what I would say to be their totality of the universe.
Yrreg
Who are you calling "the ancient thinkers"?
When Genesis says "the heaven and the earth", it means literally, the earth, as in, the dirt you are standing on, and the heaven is what you are constantly taking into your lungs and then expelling.
That was done as described in the book, by persuading the ocean to split and half of it to form the firmament, which contains the atmosphere, while that removal of water from the ocean exposes the land that was already there, but had previously been under the surface.
The Bible does not claim God as having created the universe, or anything else for that matter, but the manipulation of things around Him to be more the way He likes.
As for "the ancient thinkers", they do not believe God created the universe, but something else did. The Ancient Greeks believed it was Anankē, a pre-creation consciousness.
 
Last edited:
Since you don't know as to choose a point to start, I will not deal with you.

Yrreg

But, isn't the admission of ignorance the first step towards knowledge?

Ok, let's start with humans then. I may be uncomfortable with that but we can work that out later. Maybe my concerns are unfounded.

Where do we go from there?
 
Where do we go from here? Start searching for answers.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Since you don't know as to choose a point to start, I will not deal with you.

Yrreg
​


But, isn't the admission of ignorance the first step towards knowledge?

Ok, let's start with humans then. I may be uncomfortable with that but we can work that out later. Maybe my concerns are unfounded.

Where do we go from there?


Where do we go from here? Start searching for answers.

Now, one question with people curious is who put the nose in our face.

Do you want to ask that question or you think that question is beneath your capability to think about, or beneath your whatever for example dignity to think about?

Now, you might want to go into what is our capability and our dignity that we should think about the question who puts the nose in our face?

Or that I am making assumptions in asking myself who puts the nose in our face because I am already assuming that there is someone who does put nose in people's face?


Suppose you just go and think about the answer to the question who puts the nose in our face, okay?

Or you just go away and keep uttering to yourself that you are not going to be kept wasting your time and thinking power on who put the nose in people's face.




Yrreg
 
Rougarou has not reacted to my post addressed to him, so I will return tomorrow morning and see whether he has reacted by then.



Yrreg
 
Where do we go from here? Start searching for answers.

Now, one question with people curious is who put the nose in our face.

Do you want to ask that question or you think that question is beneath your capability to think about, or beneath your whatever for example dignity to think about?

Now, you might want to go into what is our capability and our dignity that we should think about the question who puts the nose in our face?

Or that I am making assumptions in asking myself who puts the nose in our face because I am already assuming that there is someone who does put nose in people's face?

Suppose you just go and think about the answer to the question who puts the nose in our face, okay?

Or you just go away and keep uttering to yourself that you are not going to be kept wasting your time and thinking power on who put the nose in people's face.

Yrreg


Your entire argument is a logical fallacy in a dishonest framework. You're lying about the atheist position. Lying. And just because you don't understand something doesn't mean it happened by magic. How does it feel to fail every single time you write a post?
 
Rougarou has not reacted to my post addressed to him, so I will return tomorrow morning and see whether he has reacted by then.


Wow. You either have no sense of self-awarness, or are extremely hypocritical.





<snip>

Now, one question with people curious is who put the nose in our face.

<snip>



We've been down this road before Yrreg, remember?
I find it odd you would complain about Rougarou not reacting to your post on your time-table, given how you run from the following vivisection of your "argument":




So, let me see your concepts of the universe, and we will work out a concurring definition of the universe.


You meant to type "So, let me see your concepts of the universe so I can reject them as not fitting with my pre-determined conclusion and insult you for daring to disagree with me", correct?



What is the purpose of this exercise?

In order to resolve the God debate.



We've been through this dance before. Many times.


You remember...


For those who are always repeatedly abusing me that I have not presented my argument for the thesis that the universe is the evidence for God's existence, here it is:

Thank you.



1. First we agree on the concepts of God and the universe as:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​


I have mentioned before that your definition of god is so vague as to be useless, but for the sake of argument I agreed to let it stand. This was before your inserted the added detail of it being the Christian god. I will still honour my agreement and accept your definitions for the purpose of looking at your proof of god. But I reject the a-priori Christian assumption as unnecessary. Your argument will work for any god equally well. Once you've proven the existence of a god, you may freely argue that Christianity, specifically, is true. But that's best saved for another thread.

Thus,
Definition 1: God is the pre-existing maker of the universe.
Definition 2: The Universe is everything that exists, be the things known or unknown to us.



2. Then we present
the fact of the nose existing in the universe so it is a part and parcel of the universe.​


I see no reason to quibble over this; the statement is fundamentally correct based on your definition of the Universe, which I have accepted for the sake of argument.

Thus,
Premise 1: The nose exists and thus is part of the universe.



3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.​


I will state that I had some reservations about this one. "Beginning" and "ending", in reference to the nose, is vague. Are we counting left-to-right, top-to-bottom, bottom-to-top? Or are you referring to a start of formation (fetal development) and end of formation (death and decay)? The wording here is vague enough to allow equivocation. This is why I specified, in my post accepting the point for argument purposes, the bridge of the nose as the beginning and the tip of the nose as the end. If you wish to argue on a time-base definition o beginning and end, I suggest changeing your object of reference from the nose (a physical, geometric object) to a temporal one like life.

Thus,
Premise 2: The nose has a physical, geometric beginning and an end point (the bridge and tip, respectfully).



4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.​


Stop. This is a non-sequiturWP. The non-sequitur fallacy ("non sequitur" means "does not follow") is an argument in which the premise does not support the conclusion. Here, your premise, which I have accepted with noted reservations, is that the nose has a beginning and end (see Premise 2. Your conclusion, that everything in the universe has a beginning and ending, is not in any way supported by the premise. I suggest you find a way to prove that everything in the universe has a beginning and end, and not try to broadcast the features on one object onto the whole universe.
Further, you are still playing fast and lose with the definition of "beginning" and "ending". You never clarified if you we speak on a time-basis or shape-basis. This is equivocation, another fallacy, but I have a feeling we'll get to that later. It's unimportant right now, as this is a non-sequitur using either basis. But I suggest you clarify what you mean, be defining beginning and end clearly (make them Definition 3 and Definition 4).

Thus,
Conclusion 1 (NS & UT): From Premise 2, everything in the universe has a beginning and ending.
INVALID: NON-SEQUITUR.
INVALID: UNDEFINED TERMS.



5. Wherefore
everything in the universe has need of an agent to bring them to the beginning of their existence.​


Stop. This is an equivocationWP. The equivocation fallacy (in this case arising from your ambiguous use of the terms "beginning" and "end") is an argument in which a term having more than one meaning is used misleadingly. It can be both formal and informal. In this case, it is a formal fallacy. I suggest, as before, that you clarify your terms (in this case, clarifying whether you are referring to "beginning" and "end" as shape-based properties or time-based properties.

Stop. This is a non-sequiturWP. Here, your premise, Conclusion 1, which is in turn flawed, is that everything in the universe has a beginning and end. Your conclusion, that everything in the universe requires an agent to make them begin, is not in any way supported by the premise. I suggest you find a way to prove that everything that "begins" requires an agent to begin it.

Stop. This is an argument implicitly based on a premise (Conclusion 1) shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a second time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Conclusion 1.

Stop. This is an argument implicitly based on a premise (Premise 3) shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a third time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Premise 3.

Thus,
Premise 3 (implied) (NS & UD): Everything that begins has a cause
INVALID: NON-SEQUITUR.
INVALID: UNDEFINED TERMS.

Conclusion 2 (EQUIV & FP): From Conclusion 1 (NS & UT) and Premise 3 (NS & UT), the universe has need of an agent to cause it to begin.
INVALID: EQUIVOCATION.
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (CONCLUSION 1: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (PREMISE 3: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).



6. And this fact that everything in the universe has a need of an agent to bring them to existence and the fact that they do exist,
that double fact is the evidence that:​
7. There is an agent which I call
God, who is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


Stop. This is a non-sequiturWP. Your conclusion that there exists a god who created the universe (based on Definition 1) is based on a flawed premise (Conclusion 2)


Stop. This is an argument based on a premise (Conclusion 2) shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a second time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Conclusion 2.

Stop. This is an argument based on a premise (Conclusion 2) whose premise (Conclusion 1) is shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise, which in turn uses another fallacious argument as its premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a third time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Conclusion 1.

Stop. This is an argument based on a premise (Conclusion 2) whose premise (Premise 3) is shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise, which in turn uses another fallacious argument as its premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a fourth time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Premise 3.

Thus,
Conclusion 3 (NS & FP & FP): From Conclusion 2 (EQUIV & FP), there is an agent called "god" who caused the universe to exist.
INVALID: NON-SEQUITUR
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (CONCLUSION 2: EQUIVOCATION & FALLACIOUS PREMISE & FALLACIOUS PREMISE).
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (CONCLUSION 1: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (PREMISE 3: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).


Thus, from the realm of concepts we arrive at the realm of real actualities in
the existence of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
​


Your argument fails, yrreg. Even accepting your uselessly vague definition of god for the sake of argument, it fails. It has logical fallacies piled on top of logical fallacies, undefined terms and misleading examples of those terms. Above, I have shown where it fails, and provided you with suggestions on where to fix it. In addition to the noted suggestions, I also suggest you improve your definition of god so that it is not as amorphously worded. I have spent well over an hour writing this post, and I think it stands as evidence that I have given your proof of god due consideration, and avoided mockery, evasion, blind-thinking, and whatever other buzzwords you've latched onto.

Ball's in your court.


ETA: This argument is nothing new, yrreg. It's called the "Cosmological Argument"WP, or "First Cause Argument". It dates back to Plato and Aristotle, and has always been flawed.




There's more, from other posts, here
 
Rougarou has not reacted to my post addressed to him, so I will return tomorrow morning and see whether he has reacted by then.



Yrreg

Once again, the word you're looking for is 'replied', not 'reacted'. Don't worry, you'll learn this language one day.
 
Sometimes I think half of the noise in yrreg threads stems from his lack of english comprehension skills.

Like:

I will not anymore entertain any other question except this one on what is the origin of the universe if you don't want to admit God as the uncreated creator of the universe.

Eeeek. We must admit God as the uncreated creator of the universe. Tall order for a bunch of atheists, given no evidence. However, perhaps Gerry actually means:

It is pointless to continue with this until you are happy to accept for the sake of argument that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

So, were we to accept that for the sake of argument, Gerry could then happily walk us through his logic. Perhaps (and I highly doubt it, but perhaps) his entire belief system in fact logically follows if you accept this premise up front - of course, all his work is still to be done providing evidence for this premise.

Seems like a completely pointless exercise, and Im convinced that we will fall at the first hurdle, but:

Sure Gerry, I am willing to accept your premise that God is the uncreated creator of the universe for the sake of argument
 
... and even the Soy Butter faction (universally despised).
And rightly so.
Still, it's as plain as the nose on your face that sesame butter is the choice of right minded people. After all, it's a vital ingredient of hummous.
Didn't Jesus eat hummous? And Moses?

Back to yrreG's nasal enquiries.
...Or that I am making assumptions in asking myself who puts the nose in our face because I am already assuming that there is someone who does put nose in people's face?...
Suppose you just go and think about the answer to the question who puts the nose in our face, okay?


Thanks, dlorde.
 
We've been down this road before Yrreg, remember?
I find it odd you would complain about Rougarou not reacting to your post on your time-table, given how you run from the following vivisection of your "argument":


I disagree that it was a vivisection. That would require his argument to have been alive in the first place.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom