Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reading the challenge to skeptics to replicate the image and the challenge's list of requirements reminds me of a long-ago discussion here about a psychic who allegedly found the body of a missing child. At the pro-psychic's request I produced examples of non-psychics performing similar feats under analogous circumstances. I predicted objections by anticipating he would complain that the psychic wore a blue shirt instead of the green one worn by the non-psychic in my example and the replication was therefore not a replication after all. Lo and behold, my opponent did almost precisely that, though instead clothing he talked about (iirc) the weather not being the same.

If someone were to produce an image indistinguishable from the SoT, believers would discount it because they can't find an invisible patch on the duplicate.

Can I just turn this around: Can we challenge any shroud supporter to replicate the image by using a dead body? Heck, use a live body for all I care.

I have heard claims that it results from some quantum projection process or something, but that's not replication. It certainly will not result from wrapping a sheet around a body.
 
Can I just turn this around: Can we challenge any shroud supporter to replicate the image by using a dead body? Heck, use a live body for all I care.

I have heard claims that it results from some quantum projection process or something, but that's not replication. It certainly will not result from wrapping a sheet around a body.
I understand the sentiment, but it won't work. From the believer point of view, the inability to replicate -- even with a real live dead body -- is evidence of the miraculousness of the image.

All of which ignores, of course, the actual replications and the very relevant point raised in this thread that no one (not even the believers) knows what needs to be replicated because no one knows what it looked like in the 14th century.
 
I understand the sentiment, but it won't work. From the believer point of view, the inability to replicate -- even with a real live dead body -- is evidence of the miraculousness of the image.

But as I've pointed out, that's a dead end. As soon as they say, "It's miracle" then the entire discussion is out the window. It becomes solely a matter of faith and there is no basis for rational discussion.

14C dates? Irrelevant.
Blood? Irrelevant.

If one side can invoke miracles, nothing else matters, because everything can be written off as a miracle.
 
But as I've pointed out, that's a dead end. As soon as they say, "It's miracle" then the entire discussion is out the window. It becomes solely a matter of faith and there is no basis for rational discussion.14C dates? Irrelevant.
Blood? Irrelevant.

If one side can invoke miracles, nothing else matters, because everything can be written off as a miracle.
The bit I highlighted is key. The fact of there being no basis for rational discussion is not the same as them not claiming to have the basis for rational discussion.

ETA: I think my answer is incomplete and possibly off the mark. For the most part (not entirely), proponents of the shroud's authenticity are not trying to prove it rationally possible; such demonstrations are more for ark proponents. Instead, shroud proponents are trying to show that it isn't rationally possible; that's the point. No rational explanation, therefore miracle. Hence, the desperate attempts to disprove rational explanations. This is precisely the opposite of the ark proponents who put forth "kinds" and other nonsensical ideas precisely to be able to rationally explain it.
 
Last edited:
Reading the challenge to skeptics to replicate the image and the challenge's list of requirements reminds me of a long-ago discussion here about a psychic who allegedly found the body of a missing child. ...
If someone were to produce an image indistinguishable from the SoT, believers would discount it because they can't find an invisible patch on the duplicate.

Yes, i expect you're right.
What I found most interesting about that challenge was that the pro authenticity folk manage to ignore the elephant in the room - the C14 dating.
 
Jabba said:
- Select a "gatekeeper," rather than a spokesperson,
This is telling us how to discuss the topic--it's you trying to control the conversation. No. You need to address ALL of the points we've raised in order to be right.
 
But as I've pointed out, that's a dead end. As soon as they say, "It's miracle" then the entire discussion is out the window. It becomes solely a matter of faith and there is no basis for rational discussion.

14C dates? Irrelevant.
Blood? Irrelevant.

If one side can invoke miracles, nothing else matters, because everything can be written off as a miracle.



Well I agree with that, and I think you and I have both independently pointed that out a while back.

If this comes down only to Jabba (or any shroud believers) claiming the shroud image is a miracle, then that's the end of all rational discussion.

Because on that basis, no matter what anyone ever says and no matter what science ever shows to be right or wrong, those who believe in unexplained miracles from an inexplicable unknown god can just claim ...


... black is really white ... because it's a miracle

... up is actually down ... it's a miracle

... 2 + 2 = 49 .... it's a miracle

... any claim at all ... it's a miracle.


There can be no rational discussion with anyone like that.

In fact, some pages back, I did ask Jabba if he could explain how the image of Jesus ever got onto the shroud in the first place. But of course he never replied to that question.

Perhaps the onus here (“burden of proof") should be for Jabba and other shroud believers to answer that question before anything else - how did a detailed image like that ever get on to the shroud in the first place? .... is it supposed to be a miracle? Really, a “miracle“? OK, end of all rational discussion.
 
Last edited:
- Well anyway, I think that I have a way you can prove that I'm avoiding the evidence -- if I really am.

- Select a "gatekeeper," rather than a spokesperson, to tell me which specific Q, C or A to try to answer next. Everyone can raise whatever questions and objections they wish -- but, instead of me deciding what to try to answer next, the gatekeeper will decide for me.
- I agree that there are numerous Q/C/A's that have been repeated numerous times -- but again, these are, themselves, numerous. Just tell me which of these to address next...
- I claim that if you go ahead and do that, I'll be slow, but you'll see that I do not try to avoid the evidence. That's exactly what I was trying to show with Dave's list re reweaving -- but then, people kept wanting me to move on to other issues. And if you noticed, in addressing Dave's list, I was admitting that my answers weren't that good... I wasn't giving up, as my task is to present the best Shroud authenticity case I can muster -- and, I do still think that the Shroud probably is authentic.

- Perhaps, instead of electing a gatekeeper, you guys could just talk amongst yourselves and decide "in committee" what you would most like me to address next. Maybe, you could develop a private distribution list for anyone who's interested in helping to direct the conversation. Maybe, someone could just offer him or her self to designate what I should answer next. Maybe, you could take turns in alphabetical order...

- I will still want equal time to direct the conversation myself.

--- Jabba

Continued evasion noted
 
Well I agree with that, and I think you and I have both independently pointed that out a while back.

If this comes down only to Jabba (or any shroud believers) claiming the shroud image is a miracle, then that's the end of all rational discussion.

Because on that basis, no matter what anyone ever says and no matter what science ever shows to be right or wrong, those who believe in unexplained miracles from an inexplicable unknown god can just claim ...


... black is really white ... because it's a miracle

... up is actually down ... it's a miracle

... 2 + 2 = 49 .... it's a miracle

... any claim at all ... it's a miracle.


There can be no rational discussion with anyone like that.

In fact, some pages back, I did ask Jabba if he could explain how the image of Jesus ever got onto the shroud in the first place. But of course he never replied to that question.

Perhaps the onus here (“burden of proof") should be for Jabba and other shroud believers to answer that question before anything else - how did a detailed image like that ever get on to the shroud in the first place? .... is it supposed to be a miracle? Really, a “miracle“? OK, end of all rational discussion.

Exactly. That's why I have said, the sooner we can get him to resort to a miracle, the sooner we can call this conversation dead.

So far, what I saw was that he invoked "some sort of science that we don't yet understand." It's funny, he could just as well say that for the 14C dating, too.
 
What Next?

Jabba, #3005: What Next?
- I’ll try again.

- Over the past 6 months there must have been (in combination) at least 100 “responses” (questions, comments and attacks) (not counting repeats) that I have not "answered" (not responded to)…
- But then, I probably spend about 4 hours a day trying to answer your responses. That’s all the time that I can reasonably spend on this project – and, other than my family, this project is my primary investment these days.
- If you look back over my 491 posts so far, you’ll see that the vast majority (at least) are responding directly to at least one of your responses (looking quickly, I think that ALL of my posts are responding – at least indirectly -- to at least one of them).
- And then, you fuss at me for what I have left unanswered…
- Which is a problem for me.
- And, you'll probably fuss at me for this, my answer, to your fussing.

- And again, when I try to answer one response, I usually provoke at least a few more. And so, by trying to answer one response, I generally accumulate multiple new ones, and rather than gradually reduce the number of unanswered responses on my table -- by trying to answer them -- I quickly increase them instead...
- And finally, it seems to me that I have given my answers to as many of your responses as 4 hrs a day will allow...

- Where do you disagree with what I’ve just said?

- Do you want me to spend more time on this? Do you want me to do a better job of selecting what to answer next?

- If you guys don’t have a sincere solution, I’ll offer mine.

- Well anyway, I think that I have a way you can prove that I'm avoiding the evidence -- if I really am.

- Select a "gatekeeper," rather than a spokesperson, to tell me which specific Q, C or A to try to answer next. Everyone can raise whatever questions and objections they wish -- but, instead of me deciding what to try to answer next, the gatekeeper will decide for me.
- I agree that there are numerous Q/C/A's that have been repeated numerous times -- but again, these are, themselves, numerous. Just tell me which of these to address next...
- I claim that if you go ahead and do that, I'll be slow, but you'll see that I do not try to avoid the evidence. That's exactly what I was trying to show with Dave's list re reweaving -- but then, people kept wanting me to move on to other issues. And if you noticed, in addressing Dave's list, I was admitting that my answers weren't that good... I wasn't giving up, as my task is to present the best Shroud authenticity case I can muster -- and, I do still think that the Shroud probably is authentic.

- Perhaps, instead of electing a gatekeeper, you guys could just talk amongst yourselves and decide "in committee" what you would most like me to address next. Maybe, you could develop a private distribution list for anyone who's interested in helping to direct the conversation. Maybe, someone could just offer him or her self to designate what I should answer next. Maybe, you could take turns in alphabetical order...

- I will still want equal time to direct the conversation myself.

--- Jabba

Dave,
`What do you think?
--- Jabba
 
Dave,
`What do you think?
--- Jabba

What does re-posting two posts have to do with anything?

- I will still want equal time to direct the conversation myself.
That says it all, doesn't it? You don't want to address the facts: you want to dictate the conversation.
 
Jabba, #3005: What Next?
- I’ll try again.

- Over the past 6 months there must have been (in combination) at least 100 “responses” (questions, comments and attacks) (not counting repeats) that I have not "answered" (not responded to)…
- But then, I probably spend about 4 hours a day trying to answer your responses. That’s all the time that I can reasonably spend on this project – and, other than my family, this project is my primary investment these days.
- If you look back over my 491 posts so far, you’ll see that the vast majority (at least) are responding directly to at least one of your responses (looking quickly, I think that ALL of my posts are responding – at least indirectly -- to at least one of them).
- And then, you fuss at me for what I have left unanswered…
- Which is a problem for me.
- And, you'll probably fuss at me for this, my answer, to your fussing.

- And again, when I try to answer one response, I usually provoke at least a few more. And so, by trying to answer one response, I generally accumulate multiple new ones, and rather than gradually reduce the number of unanswered responses on my table -- by trying to answer them -- I quickly increase them instead...
- And finally, it seems to me that I have given my answers to as many of your responses as 4 hrs a day will allow...

- Where do you disagree with what I’ve just said?

- Do you want me to spend more time on this? Do you want me to do a better job of selecting what to answer next?

- If you guys don’t have a sincere solution, I’ll offer mine.



Dave,
`What do you think?
--- Jabba

Just curious: do you count this repost, and the original 2 posts, among your "responses?" because they've already been addressed and they don't respond to anything!

If you feel this thread is taking up hours of your time each day, then avoid this type of meaningless effort and just answer one question: on what scientific evidence do you reject the 14C dating that invalidates the shroud as the burial cloth of Jesus? Remember: invisible patches don't work: they are neither invisible nor change the 14C date.
 
Dave,
`What do you think?
--- Jabba
I think you are evading the issue at hand.

I think you are glomming on to an individual, in a vain attempt to control the discussion.

I think you are furiously paddling your fail canoe away from the inevitable waterfall of the C14 dating.

I think you have nothing left in the intellectual locker, except to try and personalise the argument.

And yes, I am Dave. Not the same Dave you are attempting to control, but a different Dave. You failed to specify which Dave. Per Dr. Seuss, there are too many Daves. (Cue the Spartacus jokes)
 
- Well anyway, I think that I have a way you can prove that I'm avoiding the evidence -- if I really am.

- Select a "gatekeeper," rather than a spokesperson, to tell me which specific Q, C or A to try to answer next. Everyone can raise whatever questions and objections they wish -- but, instead of me deciding what to try to answer next, the gatekeeper will decide for me.
- I agree that there are numerous Q/C/A's that have been repeated numerous times -- but again, these are, themselves, numerous. Just tell me which of these to address next...
- I claim that if you go ahead and do that, I'll be slow, but you'll see that I do not try to avoid the evidence. That's exactly what I was trying to show with Dave's list re reweaving -- but then, people kept wanting me to move on to other issues. And if you noticed, in addressing Dave's list, I was admitting that my answers weren't that good... I wasn't giving up, as my task is to present the best Shroud authenticity case I can muster -- and, I do still think that the Shroud probably is authentic.

- Perhaps, instead of electing a gatekeeper, you guys could just talk amongst yourselves and decide "in committee" what you would most like me to address next. Maybe, you could develop a private distribution list for anyone who's interested in helping to direct the conversation. Maybe, someone could just offer him or her self to designate what I should answer next. Maybe, you could take turns in alphabetical order...

- I will still want equal time to direct the conversation myself.

--- Jabba

Jabba,
I've just learned by inspired revelation that I have been appointed Gatekeeper for the next 30 minutes. Your request has come true!

The first question everyone wants me to ask you is:
The 14C dating proves that the Shroud of Turin cannot be the burial cloth of Jesus. What scientific evidence do you have that invalidates the 14C dating? Please remember that invisible patches and bacterial contamination have been shown to not affect the dating.

Others will take over the job of Gatekeeper when you answer this question, or when I rotate off this position in 30 minutes. They may wish to ask the same question again if you don't answer it.
 
- If you look back over my 491 posts so far, you’ll see that the vast majority (at least) are responding directly to at least one of your responses (looking quickly, I think that ALL of my posts are responding – at least indirectly -- to at least one of them).
As I see it, and I haven't gone back to count, a vast majority of your posts have been numbered and bulleted attempts to define what you should answer, what the subject should be, and who should be the one true voice to tell you what questions to respond to.

All I can compare it to is North Korean, South Korean, US, Chinese, and UN delegates to peace talks arguing about what chairs should be used at the table, then pretending incredible progress was made when the decision made was to continue chair negotiations during the next session.
 
And yes, I am Dave. Not the same Dave you are attempting to control, but a different Dave. You failed to specify which Dave.


As you're probably aware, I'm Dave too. It's kind of amusing, the way he keep asking us questions and then pretending we don't even exist when we answer him.


Per Dr. Seuss, there are too many Daves. (Cue the Spartacus jokes)


There can never be too many Daves.
 
As you're probably aware, I'm Dave too.
No, you are the Pharaoh.

It's kind of amusing, the way he keep asking us questions and then pretending we don't even exist when we answer him.
How many here has he attempted to elect as spokesperson, or the latest, gatekeeper? I am a little surprised that davefoc is even entertaining that malarkey.
I should do it. After all, I am the gatekeeper of the Abyss.

There can never be too many Daves.
Bet?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom