How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mainly because you don't have any facts.
* You don't know what was discussed when the founders first mooted bitcoin.
* You don't know how many bitcoins are still held by the founders
* You don't know how many bitcoins are still held by the early adopters
* You don't know if they are still holding on to them or if they sold them off too early.
* You don't even know if the founders/early adopters number among the top 1% of bitcoin holders.

The possibility of cartel action might be a concern but even if the worst case scenario that you presented was true, the history of the founders/early adopters has nothing to do with whether the price of bitcoin will rise or fall tomorrow.

Not knowing the exact numbers does not prevent a reliable conclusion that the market is severely lopsided, and that early adopters and founders very likely have a complete corner on the market. This is very relevant to the future price of bitcoin.
 
Mainly because you don't have any facts.


This is a blatant lie. I have presented numerous facts in this thread, along with citations to back them up.


* You don't know what was discussed when the founders first mooted bitcoin.


Totally irrelevant. We can look at how the system operates and draw reliable conclusions from that.


* You don't know how many bitcoins are still held by the founders
* You don't know how many bitcoins are still held by the early adopters
* You don't know if they are still holding on to them or if they sold them off too early.


I know that over 50% of all bitcoins in existence are controlled by less than 1% of the holders. While I don't know exactly who those people are (the "founders" are likewise totally anonymous), I know that is an extremely suspicious and dangerous circumstance for any economy.


The possibility of cartel action might be a concern


Given all that we know about Bitcoin, I'd say it's definitely an extremely grave "concern."

If you choose to ignore that and participate in this sham economy, that's your own business. But one has to wonder why anyone would proselytize so vehemently on behalf of something that is so obviously fraudulent.


but even if the worst case scenario that you presented was true, the history of the founders/early adopters has nothing to do with whether the price of bitcoin will rise or fall tomorrow.


SO you're actually arguing that it doesn't matter that it's a scam, so long as you might be able to make some money off of it?

That's a shockingly cynical, amoral stance. Now we see what caliber of people we're dealing with in this Bitcoin thing. I guess a guy like Bruce Wagner is not quite the exception that proves the rule.

Is that why you keep alleging that the only reason people might oppose this scam is because they're "jealous" of somebody getting rich off another person's hardship? Because greed and jealousy are the only human emotions you're able to identify with? Have you no ethics? Is this what "libertarian free-market capitalism" has come to?

Even if you cut the morality factors totally out of the equation, you still have to realize that Bitcoin is an extremely foolish investment by any standard. It's obviously a gamed system, and there are no laws, no recourse if you get screwed. Plus the returns are not that great, unless you're one of the early adopters with a huge pile of Bitcoins by which you can leverage the swindling of investors.

Unless you're one of them, you don't know who the early adopters are any better than I do, nor do you know the identity of the top 1% of Bitcoin holders who effectively wield total control over the market. What reason can you possibly have to trust that those people are motivated to act in the best interest of the market, and aren't just gaming the system for their own benefit?

Why would you assume that level of trust, of a group of people who have set up this system that favors themselves at the expense of others, and who've chosen to remain completely anonymous? Why would you trust their system, given the obviously scammy way it's been designed to operate? Given the astonishing number of high-level scams and thefts perpetrated therein in the short span of 3 years, with no accountability at all of the people in charge of maintaining the system?


It's blatantly obvious that this is a plan to amass monetary wealth from many small investors and concentrate it into the hands of a few people who paid nothing to enter into the economy. It's the exact kind of situation that the conspiracist goldbugs proclaim is wrong with the Federal Reserve System and the US dollar—except the wealth disparity is several orders of magnitude worse—yet here they are hailing it as "The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man!"

I have to wonder why anyone would willingly place their money into a system like this, unless they're totally ignorant of the economics behind it and have honestly been duped by the hype, or else they're amoral swindlers or criminals seeking to cash in on it. Or, maybe a little of both.

I guess it's not surprising, given that willful ignorance and blind ambition often go together.
 
Last edited:
For many scams, the money is the hook as much as it is the fish. A quack's most vehement supporters are the patients that were swindled. We are psychologically wired not to walk away from sunk costs, and that manifests as defending the mistake.
 
Last edited:
SO you're actually arguing that it doesn't matter that it's a scam, so long as you might be able to make some money off of it?

That's a shockingly cynical, amoral stance. Now we see what caliber of people we're dealing with in this Bitcoin thing.
I have never heard of a "scam" where the victims can make a profit. By its very definition, being "scammed" means that you have lost your money. In a typical scam or Confidence Trick, the scammer is usually long gone before the "mark" smells a rat.

The fact that you would choose such an inappropriate word together with the lengthy post about how "amoral" I am shows that for you this is just a moral issue. You have no interest in whether a potential investor can weigh up the pros and cons of bitcoin. You just want it outlawed because the originators might have made too much money.
 
I have never heard of a "scam" where the victims can make a profit. By its very definition, being "scammed" means that you have lost your money. In a typical scam or Confidence Trick, the scammer is usually long gone before the "mark" smells a rat.

The fact that you would choose such an inappropriate word together with the lengthy post about how "amoral" I am shows that for you this is just a moral issue. You have no interest in whether a potential investor can weigh up the pros and cons of bitcoin. You just want it outlawed because the originators might have made too much money.

Actually in scams like chain letters and pyramid schemes early adaptors CAN make some money. As long as they manage to get others to follow their lead. However its based on rapidly dimisihing returns the later you step in and to dispropotionally reward the early investors/starter.
And yes, from where I sit bitcoin does seem to follow that pattern as well.
 
Actually in scams like chain letters and pyramid schemes early adaptors CAN make some money. As long as they manage to get others to follow their lead.
In such schemes, it is the latecomers rather than the "early adaptors" who lose money (but I think you knew that ;)). Since a scam is a fraud that can't make money for any of its participants, there would be no "early adaptors" (although the organizers of a scam may employ "shills" to gain the confidence of the "mark").

Ponzi and pyramid schemes can make money for those who get in and get out of the scheme early enough (although I would suggest they are not scams unless the nature of the scheme is concealed). I have already shown that bitcoin does not share common characteristics of either a ponzi or pyramid scheme. Early adopters have to hold on to their bitcoins rather than get out of the "scheme" to realize their profits.

However its based on rapidly dimisihing returns the later you step in and to dispropotionally reward the early investors/starter.
This would be true only if the price of bitcoins rose constantly and never fell. Then the later you buy in or the earlier you sell out, the less profit you make. However, a commodity that never lost value would be a gilt edged investment. :D

Since bitcoin has already been in one bubble (and is likely in a second one), there is no guarantee that early participants have done better than the later ones.

And yes, from where I sit bitcoin does seem to follow that pattern as well.
Your earlier assessment of bitcoin was much more credible. Attempts to link bitcoin to the worst frauds in history reek of desperation.
 
I have never heard of a "scam" where the victims can make a profit.

A lot of scams work by either providing small amounts of profits early in the scam or by providing large amounts of profits to some subset of the victims. That's how they establish credence. Ponzi schemes basically work by using the money from late entrants to pay out profits to the early entrants in order to draw in even more entrants.

That said, I personally don't see any reason to believe that Bitcoins are a deliberate scam rather than a well-meaning but deeply flawed effort by someone smart but rather naive about how currencies and money work. Creating a workable (in the technical rather than monetary aspects) crypto-currency is a lot of work just to pull off a scam.

The end result is the same, though: you end up with a "currency" that is incredible vulnerable. Any one of the (anonymous and uncontrollable) early adopters can crash the currency at the drop of a hat and there's nothing anyone can do to prevent it.
 
In such schemes, it is the latecomers rather than the "early adaptors" who lose money (but I think you knew that ;)). Since a scam is a fraud that can't make money for any of its participants, there would be no "early adaptors" (although the organizers of a scam may employ "shills" to gain the confidence of the "mark").

Ponzi and pyramid schemes can make money for those who get in and get out of the scheme early enough (although I would suggest they are not scams unless the nature of the scheme is concealed). I have already shown that bitcoin does not share common characteristics of either a ponzi or pyramid scheme. Early adopters have to hold on to their bitcoins rather than get out of the "scheme" to realize their profits.

This would be true only if the price of bitcoins rose constantly and never fell. Then the later you buy in or the earlier you sell out, the less profit you make. However, a commodity that never lost value would be a gilt edged investment. :D

Since bitcoin has already been in one bubble (and is likely in a second one), there is no guarantee that early participants have done better than the later ones.

Your earlier assessment of bitcoin was much more credible. Attempts to link bitcoin to the worst frauds in history reek of desperation.

Desperation is a big word, I don't care if other people want to stick their money in some inherently unsafe bubble commodity.

A simple question. There are a number of people in the bitcoin community that for littel to no effort managed to get the vast majority of bitcoins.
There is also the mysterious inventor who can at will make as many as he/she wants.
Is there anything inherent in the system that will prevent these people from, at will, crashing the entire bitcoin market by selling everything they have?
Thus making vast profit for themselves and dooming all the other investors?
If there is, I will withdraw my statement, but if there isn't, to me this seems like a form of pyramid scheme. With the added bonus of ADVERTISING it's one, and still getting people to invest in it.
I only whish I'd thought of it, so I could be the one fleecing people :)
 
I have never heard of a "scam" where the victims can make a profit.

Then you've never heard of Ponzi schemes ?

The idea of the scam is that the scammer makes a profit. He doesn't care whether the victim makes a tiny profit also.

Ponzi and pyramid schemes can make money for those who get in and get out of the scheme early enough

If and when the early ones in Bitcoin withdraw from the market, everybody else will have a worthless stash of it. I'd say their profits will evaporate specifically because they didn't get out early enough.
 
Ponzi and pyramid schemes can make money for those who get in and get out of the scheme early enough (although I would suggest they are not scams unless the nature of the scheme is concealed). I have already shown that bitcoin does not share common characteristics of either a ponzi or pyramid scheme. Early adopters have to hold on to their bitcoins rather than get out of the "scheme" to realize their profits.

Bad logic here... If Bitcoin does not share property A with a Ponzi/Pyramid scheme, that doesn't mean it can't share property B with them.
 
Ponzi and pyramid schemes can make money for those who get in and get out of the scheme early enough (although I would suggest they are not scams unless the nature of the scheme is concealed).

This surprises me. Mathematically, Ponzi schemes are scams.

The Quora article linked was interesting. Plus his retraction of the word "scam" from it.
 
I think psionl0 is ahead here and tho' JAlbert makes many valid points he sounds a bit shrill and negative and overly reliant on unevidenced assumptions about the bitcoin-founders being evil-doers. 50% of coin in the hands of 1% of users says nothing unless we understand the distribution and uses. Are there 1k regular users and 100k tried-it-once types ? I don't know and don''t greatly care.

There are a lot of good reasons to avoid bitcoin,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin#Related_controversies_and_hacks

More fundamental - bitcoin has a mechanism to increase the computational difficulty to mine bitcoin. WHOEVER controls this 'level of difficulty' feature is effectively the central banker and can manipulate currency value, further than can leverage the 'monetary policy' info against the interests of bitcoin holders. That's a fundamental flaw.

We want currency amounts to increase with GDP/productivity or some OBJECTIVE proxy. It seems possible to do this by measuring both currency velocity (rate of bitcoin transfers) and also total volume and therefore to adjust currency for constant velocity.
 
Is there anything inherent in the system that will prevent these people from, at will, crashing the entire bitcoin market by selling everything they have?
Thus making vast profit for themselves and dooming all the other investors?
Dump enough of any commodity and you will ruin the other investors but you won't get anything worth a cracker for your sale. Bitcoin is not different in this regard.

That is not to say that a majority bitcoin holder can't manipulate the price or won't hold a fire sale. That is the problem you get when a small number of investors corner a commodity market.
 
Bad logic here... If Bitcoin does not share property A with a Ponzi/Pyramid scheme, that doesn't mean it can't share property B with them.
I have no idea what this "property B" is that you refer to.

Pyramid/ponzi schemes rely on new entrants to make the promised payments to the existing entrants. These schemes fail when you can't find any more new entrants.

You don't need new entrants in the market to drive up the price of a commodity.
 
This surprises me. Mathematically, Ponzi schemes are scams.
Ponzis almost certainly but not necessarily pyramids.

I once bought into a pyramid for $60. However, it was marketed as a pyramid and the instructions left no doubt about how it worked. I managed to recover my $60 investment but I never got the thousands that the scheme promised. Was I scammed? No! I took a calculated risk and ended up even.

The Airplane Game was a popular pyramid game before it was outlawed.
 
Last edited:
More fundamental - bitcoin has a mechanism to increase the computational difficulty to mine bitcoin. WHOEVER controls this 'level of difficulty' feature is effectively the central banker and can manipulate currency value, further than can leverage the 'monetary policy' info against the interests of bitcoin holders. That's a fundamental flaw.
The mining difficulty is not controlled by anybody. It increases in response to the number of computers doing the mining.

The fact that it rewards those with the most computing power is probably the reason that the ownership of bitcoins is so concentrated.
 
The fact that it rewards those with the most computing power is probably the reason that the ownership of bitcoins is so concentrated.


Wait--I thought the main reason ownership of bitcoins is so concentrated is because it was a lot easier to mine early on, giving the creators and early adopters a huge advantage in building relatively huge stockpiles.

Is that not the case?
 
It might be (assuming that these early miners held on to their bitcoins) but I don't think that you are fundamentally disagreeing with me here.

ETA When I first heard of bitcoin a couple of years ago, I tried mining for them myself. Even then my puny PC was no match for the mainframes that were being used.
 
Last edited:
It might be (assuming that these early miners held on to their bitcoins) but I don't think that you are fundamentally disagreeing with me here.

ETA When I first heard of bitcoin a couple of years ago, I tried mining for them myself. Even then my puny PC was no match for the mainframes that were being used.


Obviously, at any given point in time, greater computing power means greater ability to mine bitcoins.

My understanding was--given that at the very early stages it was relatively easy (in terms of computing power) to mine bitcoins, and, since relatively few people were mining, the creator(s) and early adopters were able to build huge stockpiles with a lot less effort than later adopters required. In other words, it was the fact that they were one of the few in early--not necessarily their computing power--that allowed them to get bitcoin-rich. Isn't that the case?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom