American 11 Heading Towards DC - Where Did This Come From?

Thanks BCR for the information. Yes that is the pdf I was referring to. And thanks again Cheap Shot for taking the time to help explain your position. It's apparent you were simply doing the best you could by passing on information which at that stage was considered accurate. I think 'fog of war' is about right. I'm going to look a little further through the DC side of this event, although I doubt it will turn up much more than has already been discussed here.

BCR, again a bit off topic, but what do you know about Giant Killer sending the F-16s to W386 instead of DC like NEADS asked for? Was he not supposed to get that hand off? Or did he simply misunderstand the instructions?
 
Last edited:
BCR, again a bit off topic, but what do you know about Giant Killer sending the F-16s to W386 instead of DC like NEADS asked for? Was he not supposed to get that hand off? Or did he simply misunderstand the instructions?

Let me start by saying that both Langley AFB and 'Giant Killer' (US Navy) failed to preserve their 9/11 records. I like to say they destroyed them, but essentially they recorded over everything 30 days post-event. This was SOP, although the FOIA officer at Langley found this just as incredulous as I did. The matter was escalated by me to the JAG, but no regulations were violated and the records simply no longer exist. What a tragedy.

With that said, there are enough FAA records from Norfolk to reconstruct what happened. The scramble order was clear and was to the north towards DC. In order to expedite the scramble, a standard flight plan (to W386) was entered into the system with the assumption that Norfolk controllers would turn the fighters north. According to statements, Norfolk controllers did plan to make the turn to the north to the scramble heading given to them by NEADS. Considering the circumstances, the FAA guys were going to let the fighters go anywhere they wanted to go and clear any traffic in their way.

According to the radar record, there was a clear shot to the north of Langley with no other traffic. The Norfolk audio record confirms that the controllers asked the QUIT pilot where he wanted to go just as soon as Langley handed them off to them. The PILOT requested to go to W386, he was not sent there. So it can only be assumed that 'Giant Killer' simply followed the flight plan in the system and was not requested to do otherwise by the pilot.

Reheat is more versed in this than I am, but I suggest listening to the Norfolk audios if you want the as-it-happened record. Why the pilot did not follow the scramble order is something only he can answer. Miles Kara has a more detailed break-down of all this posted.

At the critical decision point with Norfolk TRACON the flight leader was also waiting for his trail, the Supervisor of Flying, to join up. The flight lead and the Norfolk TRACON controller agreed that the flight plan, 090 for 60 was later information than the scramble order and so the fighters veered slightly right to a heading of 090 and proceeded out to sea. The flight leader was honest when he heard the TRACON tape. He said it was an opportunity missed. Ahead of the fighters was a military training area which brought an intervening, and unsuspecting, air traffic control facility into the equation—GIANTKILLER.
 
A quick question Cheap Shot, you said Joe Cooper had a direct line to NEADS. Were you there when Joe made the call to NEADS at 0837 about AA11? When did you come on the scene?
 
From the location in regards to the aircraft 6 miles southwest, according to Mark Gaffney this may have been VENUS77?,

Nah. VENUS77 was headed in the opposite direction. Mark just lets his imagination get the better of him sometimes :D

As you may recall, just about everything Mark knows about VENUS77 he learned from me. Boone870 made a nice little cartoon describing that aircraft. He did not even take off until after the Pentagon event (and your call).

 
Last edited:
Thanks BCR. In your honest opinion, if the scramble had gone as planned, would the F-16s have made it to DC in time to intercept and possible shoot down American 77? I cannot help but think this botched scramble didn't really change the outcome of anything.

Oh, and who was VENUS77?
 
Thanks BCR. In your honest opinion, if the scramble had gone as planned, would the F-16s have made it to DC in time to intercept and possible shoot down American 77? I cannot help but think this botched scramble didn't really change the outcome of anything.

Nope. Sure, they could have launched heat-seekers from a distance I reckon, but they did not have a shoot-down order as of yet.

Oh, and who was VENUS77?

The 9/11 Mystery Plane. I posted a video that Boone870 that describes it in greater detail in an edit to my last post.
 
Reheat is more versed in this than I am, but I suggest listening to the Norfolk audios if you want the as-it-happened record. Why the pilot did not follow the scramble order is something only he can answer. Miles Kara has a more detailed break-down of all this posted.

IIRC the flight leader did not ask to go to the W386 area, instead he was asked if he wanted to continue on his present heading, which only coincidentally was to the W386 area.

They all had the scramble order, but apparently did not realize the urgency of the situation. The one probable stopgap item that allowed this to happen, but could have prevented it was the SOF was flying in the third aircraft. If he had been in his normal position I believe he would have intervened and corrected this delay in turning North. Of course, as soon as NEADS realized what was happening they corrected the situation. Giant Killer was not the bad guy here. It was a combination of Norfolk Departure, the flight leader, and Giant Killer. They all three had the scramble order and should have executed it sooner. However,the primary responsibility rests with the flight leader as it always does...

It would have been clearer if the Langley and Giant Killer tapes had been preserved and that was inexcusable, however enough can be heard on the Norfolk Departure tapes that it's easy to piece it together. Ultimately, the flight leader "screwed-up", but any one of the agencies could have prevented the deviation if they had had the presence of mind to do so...

Keep in mind that in the end it didn't really matter anyway. The fighters launched to late to have any chance at all to intercept AA 77 even if they had flown direct toward the Pentagon. So, in essence it's all a moot point. As was said "it was simply an opportunity missed, but the final outcome would have been no different either way.
 
Last edited:
Thanks BCR. In your honest opinion, if the scramble had gone as planned, would the F-16s have made it to DC in time to intercept and possible shoot down American 77? I cannot help but think this botched scramble didn't really change the outcome of anything.

Oh, and who was VENUS77?

Again, I'll tell you it would have made no difference. The only possible way it could have succeeded was a Beyond Visual Range (BVR) shot in the face of AA 77 and in a thousand years that would never have been approved under any circumstances. BTW, no one, I repeat, NO ONE had shoot down authority at this point in the timeline anyway and a BVR shot in FAA Airspace against a Civilian Airliner would not have been and will never be approved by anyone in authority...
 
Nope. Sure, they could have launched heat-seekers from a distance I reckon, but they did not have a shoot-down order as of yet.

No, they would not have been close enough. Only an AMRAAM (AIM-120) in the face with a BVR shot might have worked, but no one would ever approve that...
 
A quick question Cheap Shot, you said Joe Cooper had a direct line to NEADS. Were you there when Joe made the call to NEADS at 0837 about AA11? When did you come on the scene?

I arrived about a minute after Joe had made the call.
 
Nah. VENUS77 was headed in the opposite direction. Mark just lets his imagination get the better of him sometimes :D

As you may recall, just about everything Mark knows about VENUS77 he learned from me. Boone870 made a nice little cartoon describing that aircraft. He did not even take off until after the Pentagon event (and your call).

So was I actually reporting the visual of AAL77? I know it is hard to believe, but no one has ever told me who I reported to NEADS, since I was only relaying what I heard on the telcon.
 
No, they would not have been close enough. Only an AMRAAM (AIM-120) in the face with a BVR shot might have worked, but no one would ever approve that...

Not to mention that the airspace above DC was packed full of aircraft. As I said, you would be the 'expert' in this area :)
 
No, they would not have been close enough. Only an AMRAAM (AIM-120) in the face with a BVR shot might have worked, but no one would ever approve that...

Not to mention that the airspace above DC was packed full of aircraft. As I said, you would be the 'expert' in this area :)

I'm not expert, but I do have a clue or two about this. Yes, that is the point. Too much possibility for a mistake with other aircraft in the area. It's not easy to even get approval for a BVR shot under actual combat conditions. That does require specific approval from the controlling authority, not the pilot or crew of the attacking aircraft...

Do you recall the UN helicopter in Iraq that was shot down by two F-15's early in that war? Although there was some controversy about it, that was approved by the controlling authority on the AWACS... That is the equivalent of a friendly fire incident or in military parlance a "short round". No one desires to live with that for the remainder of their lives...

In a crowded sky full of Civilian Aircraft it would be easy for the wires to get crossed enough for a mistake to happen... We aint' talking "hand to hand" combat here.. Even in a combat situation there are friendly aircraft in the area. Mistakes can and do happen...
 
Last edited:
With all that traffic in the vicinity I doubt the fighters would have been able to distinguish the correct target for a BVR anyway. Thanks again guys.

I needed this information to help with parts on my recent animation of AA77 (similar to the ones I did for AA11 and UA175 on my youtube page) to help myself get my head around it, and also enter the correct timeline entries for the video. I'll post it here when it's uploaded in a couple of days. I'll be referring people to this thread in the description of the video so they might be able to get a fuller idea of the situation rather than my simplified 'black and white' comments.
 
Last edited:
So was I actually reporting the visual of AAL77? I know it is hard to believe, but no one has ever told me who I reported to NEADS, since I was only relaying what I heard on the telcon.

I can't say that with 100% certainty, but from the evidence available ... very possible.
 
Just some clarification. Washinton ARTCC, Washington HQ, Washington Center. Are they separate? Or is Washington ARTCC and Washington HQ the same thing? Colin, you were getting your information from Washington ARTCC right?
 
Kind of like work no one ever tells me anything... Thanks for the info.

Of course you (more than anyone else posting here, including me) understand that Dulles/Washington would have had no idea at the time what they were tracking. All they would have known was that a fast-moving primary ('no tag') suddenly showed up on their screens to the southwest.



I should add that the first primary return associated with AAL77 is reported by the IAD ASR at 13:23:24. It would have taken a few returns before it was a noticeable track. That tends to correspond with the 'no tag' conversation heard on Local West a minute later. From that point on, all indications are that it was being reported up the food change via Eastern Region to FAA HQ and ultimately to the Secret Service.

You noted that you first heard the reference on the telecom as early as 9:18 (a good five-six minutes before). That is why I can't say with 100% certainty. However, there are indications that 'someone' was watching it before the IAD encounter. The airport manager at Yeager AP told me that their tower was evacuated due to a fast-moving primary target headed in their direction (AAL77 flew right over them) at some point between the WTC2 impact and the Pentagon event. That 'fly-over' was at 9:05. This evacuation did not impact air traffic since they were closed due to fog at this point anyways. So what happened between the Charleston encounter (if it was indeed AAL77) and IAD is anyone's guess.

Here is a JREF discussion on the Yeager incident. CheapShot, if you want more information on this, call Rick Atkinson at Yeager. He was the Airport manager on 9/11.
 
Last edited:
Just some clarification. Washinton ARTCC, Washington HQ, Washington Center. Are they separate? Or is Washington ARTCC and Washington HQ the same thing? Colin, you were getting your information from Washington ARTCC right?

Washington ARTCC and Washington Center are the same and located in Leesburg, VA, Washington FAA HQ is located on independence Ave., Washington DC. Then you have Reagan National (DCA), and Washington Dulles (IAD). I was getting telcon information from Washington HQ. I did speak with Washington ARTCC once maybe twice, never talked to Dulles or DCA.
 
Of course you (more than anyone else posting here, including me) understand that Dulles/Washington would have had no idea at the time what they were tracking. All they would have known was that a fast-moving primary ('no tag') suddenly showed up on their screens to the southwest.



I should add that the first primary return associated with AAL77 is reported by the IAD ASR at 13:23:24. It would have taken a few returns before it was a noticeable track. That tends to correspond with the 'no tag' conversation heard on Local West a minute later. From that point on, all indications are that it was being reported up the food change via Eastern Region to FAA HQ and ultimately to the Secret Service.

You noted that you first heard the reference on the telecom as early as 9:18 (a good five-six minutes before). That is why I can't say with 100% certainty. However, there are indications that 'someone' was watching it before the IAD encounter. The airport manager at Yeager AP told me that their tower was evacuated due to a fast-moving primary target headed in their direction (AAL77 flew right over them) at some point between the WTC2 impact and the Pentagon event. That 'fly-over' was at 9:05. This evacuation did not impact air traffic since they were closed due to fog at this point anyways. So what happened between the Charleston encounter (if it was indeed AAL77) and IAD is anyone's guess.

Here is a JREF discussion on the Yeager incident. CheapShot, if you want more information on this, call Rick Atkinson at Yeager. He was the Airport manager on 9/11.
I would imagine it took three to four hits to get the primary return, 4.8 seconds on their sweep I believe.

Do you have any idea of the altitude when AAL77 passed over, never heard that story, if their was fog that is interesting because the other 3 had visual contact ith the ground, flying without the visual contact would have mde it more difficult for the inexperienced pilot to fly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom