Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

PH was really just a incident of really bad US naval maintenance and bad safety procedures
 
You all feel for it. There were less than thirty Japanese planes in Hawaii that day, and they were all flown by RAF pilots, who bailed out allowing the planes to be "shot down" with already dead IJN crewmen aboard. The RN sent in frogmen to plant limpet mines on USN warships to simulate torpedo hits. This allowed FDR to claim Japan had attacked us. The damage was so impressive that the IGHQ demanded that Tojo take the credit.

See? It's all very clear when you know the REAL STORY ®.
 
Care then to explain why MacArthur's air force was almost entirely caught on the ground by a Japanese air raid more than eight hours after the Pearl Harbor raid?

This is your answer to the fact that MacArthur's intel staff recognized the bomb plot messages as preparation for a bombing attack on Pearl Harbor?

Why MacArthur was caught off-guard the next day is a separate issue and question. It does not change the fact that his intel staff recognized the (obvious) implications of the bomb plot messages. A rookie analyst would have easily recognized that they indicated preparation for an air attack.

As for the various replies about Grogan's use of geographic terms, it comes down to a refusal by traditionalists to accept what Grogan plainly said he meant by them, and a refusal to admit that Jacobsen deliberately misrepresented Grogan's comments and suppressed the fact that Grogan made his intended meaning crystal clear.

I listened to a debate once where one of the participants kept using the term "mirror image" to mean the opposite of what it technically means. He kept using it to say that Reagan's economic plan was the opposite of FDR's economic plan. After several minutes, one of the members of the opposing debate team pointed out that "mirror image" meant exact duplicate, carbon copy, etc., and then asked, "But you're using it to mean the exact opposite, right?" "Yes," the guy replied.

Now, if I wanted to be dishonest about what the guy said, I could quote him using "mirror image," never mention what he said about how he was using the term, and then falsely claim that the guy said Reagan and FDR followed the same economic policies.

This is exactly what Jacobsen did with Grogan's geographic references regarding the signals and the location from which they were coming. He falsely portrayed Grogan's comments so he could falsely state that Grogan's best bearings were 18 and 44 degrees off.
 
Last edited:
This is your answer to the fact that MacArthur's intel staff recognized the bomb plot messages as preparation for a bombing attack on Pearl Harbor?
And warned Pearl, thus saving thousands of lives. Oh, wait.
Why MacArthur was caught off-guard the next day is a separate issue and question. It does not change the fact that his intel staff recognized the (obvious) implications of the bomb plot messages. A rookie analyst would have easily recognized that they indicated preparation for an air attack.
Yeah, the rookie analyst would, because of pure ignorance. As noted before, the "bomb plot" was just a shorthand way to save telegraphy charges. The information was NOT sent to the Kido Butai, except for the gross numbers of ship types in the harbor.
As for the various replies about Grogan's use of geographic terms, it comes down to a refusal by traditionalists to accept what Grogan plainly said he meant by them, and a refusal to admit that Jacobsen deliberately misrepresented Grogan's comments and suppressed the fact that Grogan made his intended meaning crystal clear.

I listened to a debate once where one of the participants kept using the term "mirror image" to mean the opposite of what it technically means. He kept using it to say that Reagan's economic plan was the opposite of FDR's economic plan. After several minutes, one of the members of the opposing debate team pointed out that "mirror image" meant exact duplicate, carbon copy, etc., and then asked, "But you're using it to mean the exact opposite, right?" "Yes," the guy replied.

Now, if I wanted to be dishonest about what the guy said, I could quote him using "mirror image," never mention what he said about how he was using the term, and then falsely claim that the guy said Reagan and FDR followed the same economic policies.

This is exactly what Jacobsen did with Grogan's geographic references regarding the signals and the location from which they were coming. He falsely portrayed Grogan's comments so he could falsely state that Grogan's best bearings were 18 and 44 degrees off.

Kido Butai did not transmit. So that section of your post is irrelevant.
 
So was the episode of JAGS that had a US Submarine transmitting a sighting of the Japanese Fleet on it's way to Pearl then being sunk and the report getting lost in the beurocracy before it go to the right people.

Only a story though.
 
Let's consider the serious, credible people who have come forward with disclosures regarding foreknowledge of the attack on the part of FDR and certain high officials in his administration:

* James Stahlman, a former Navy officer and a longtime close friend of Sec. of the Navy Frank Knox, who said Knox told him that FDR and other high officials knew positively by December 6 that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that they knew attack would occur the next day.

* Joseph Leib, a journalist who was friends with Sec. of State Cordell Hull, who said Hull told him that FDR and certain others in his administration knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and that FDR did not want this information passed to the Hawaiian commanders because he felt that only a surprise attack would galvanize the American people to support entering the war. Leib said that Hull added that FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover was aware of this information.

* Carlton Ketchum, a retired Army colonel, who said that J. Edgar Hoover told him in 1942 that by the fall of 1941 FDR knew from various sources that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked and that he had decided to allow the attack to occur.

* John Burns, a former head of the Honolulu Police Department's Espionage Bureau and later a governor of Hawaii, who disclosed shortly before he died that several days before the attack occurred the FBI Agent in Charge of the Honolulu FBI office told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked by the end of the week. Burns' account was confirmed by one of his subordinates.

* Helen Hamman, daughter of former senior Red Cross official Don Smith, who contacted the Kimmel family when she heard of efforts to clear Kimmel's name. Mrs. Hamman wrote that her father had told her that FDR had told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and ordered him to secretly arrange for additional medical supplies to be sent to the Red Cross unit in Hawaii and ordered him not to tell anyone in Hawaii why the medical supplies were being sent. Mrs. Hamman added that her father explained that when he expressed objections to this, FDR told him that he needed to allow the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor in order to spark the American people to support entering the war. The arrival of additional medical supplies to Hawaii shortly before the attack has now been confirmed, adding credibility to Mrs. Hamman's disclosure.

* Congressman Martin Dies of Texas, who revealed in his memoir that his committee, while investigating espionage and subversion, came into possession of a Japanese military map that indicated plans to attack Pearl Harbor. Dies explained that he called Sec. of State Hull about the map and that Hull told him that he had discussed the matter with the president and that Dies should keep quiet about the map because of the sensitive, delicate diplomatic situation with Japan. Dies added that Hull asked him to let the president handle this information as he saw fit, and that officials from the Army and the State Department examined the map.

* Thomas Gillette, the nephew of Senator Guy Gillette, who revealed that his uncle had told him that he had been aware of information that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he had advised senior State Department officials of this information.

* Victor Cavendish-Bentick, the former head of England's Joint Intelligence Committee, who revealed that British intelligence knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that this information was relayed to American officials. For more information on this disclosure and the attempts to discredit it, see Richard Aldrich, Intelligence and the War Against Japan (Cambridge University Press, 2000), pp. 86-88.

Notice the mutually corroborating nature of some of these disclosures.

These disclosures are all discussed in Dr. George Victor's book The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable. Most of them are also discussed in John Toland's book Infamy, in Pearcy Greaves' book Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy, and in Dr. George Nash's book Freedom Betrayed.
 
Last edited:
Let's consider the serious, credible people who have come forward with disclosures regarding foreknowledge of the attack on the part of FDR and certain high officials in his administration:

* James Stahlman, a former Navy officer and a longtime close friend of Sec. of the Navy Frank Knox, who said Knox told him that FDR and other high officials knew positively by December 6 that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that they knew attack would occur the next day.

* Joseph Leib, a journalist who was friends with Sec. of State Cordell Hull, who said Hull told him that FDR and certain others in his administration knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and that FDR did not want this information passed to the Hawaiian commanders because he felt that only a surprise attack would galvanize the American people to support entering the war. Leib said that Hull added that FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover was aware of this information.

* Carlton Ketchum, a retired Army colonel, who said that J. Edgar Hoover told him in 1942 that by the fall of 1941 FDR knew from various sources that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked and that he had decided to allow the attack to occur.

* John Burns, a former head of the Honolulu Police Department's Espionage Bureau and later a governor of Hawaii, who disclosed shortly before he died that several days before the attack occurred the FBI Agent in Charge of the Honolulu FBI office told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked by the end of the week. Burns' account was confirmed by one of his subordinates.

* Helen Hamman, daughter of former senior Red Cross official Don Smith, who contacted the Kimmel family when she heard of efforts to clear Kimmel's name. Mrs. Hamman wrote that her father had told her that FDR had told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and ordered him to secretly arrange for additional medical supplies to be sent to the Red Cross unit in Hawaii and ordered him not to tell anyone in Hawaii why the medical supplies were being sent. Mrs. Hamman added that her father explained that when he expressed objections to this, FDR told him that he needed to allow the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor in order to spark the American people to support entering the war. The arrival of additional medical supplies to Hawaii shortly before the attack has now been confirmed, adding credibility to Mrs. Hamman's disclosure.

* Congressman Martin Dies of Texas, who revealed in his memoir that his committee, while investigating espionage and subversion, came into possession of a Japanese military map that indicated plans to attack Pearl Harbor. Dies explained that he called Sec. of State Hull about the map and that Hull told him that he had discussed the matter with the president and that Dies should keep quiet about the map because of the sensitive, delicate diplomatic situation with Japan. Dies added that Hull asked him to let the president handle this information as he saw fit, and that officials from the Army and the State Department examined the map.

* Thomas Gillette, the nephew of Senator Guy Gillette, who revealed that his uncle had told him that he had been aware of information that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he had advised senior State Department officials of this information.

* Victor Cavendish-Bentick, the former head of England's Joint Intelligence Committee, who revealed that British intelligence knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that this information was relayed to American officials. For more information on this disclosure and the attempts to discredit it, see Richard Aldrich, Intelligence and the War Against Japan (Cambridge University Press, 2000), pp. 86-88.

Notice the mutually corroborating nature of some of these disclosures.

These disclosures are all discussed in Dr. George Victor's book The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable. Most of them are also discussed in John Toland's book Infamy, in Pearcy Greaves' book Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy, and in Dr. George Nash's book Freedom Betrayed.


So another series of second and third hand accounts offered years or decades later? Why when the last tranche of these you offered up influenced no one would you think these would do better?

You've been told what you need; primary sources preferably with solid documentary evidence, when are you going to provide it?
 
Let's consider the serious, credible people who have come forward with disclosures regarding foreknowledge of the attack on the part of FDR and certain high officials in his administration:

* James Stahlman, a former Navy officer and a longtime close friend of Sec. of the Navy Frank Knox, who said Knox told him that FDR and other high officials knew positively by December 6 that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that they knew attack would occur the next day.
Why do you believe this is true? Simply because he agrees with your theory?
* Joseph Leib, a journalist who was friends with Sec. of State Cordell Hull, who said Hull told him that FDR and certain others in his administration knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and that FDR did not want this information passed to the Hawaiian commanders because he felt that only a surprise attack would galvanize the American people to support entering the war. Leib said that Hull added that FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover was aware of this information.
A defeat is preferable to a victory in what fashion?
* Carlton Ketchum, a retired Army colonel, who said that J. Edgar Hoover told him in 1942 that by the fall of 1941 FDR knew from various sources that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked and that he had decided to allow the attack to occur.
Again, why would a defeat be preferable to a victory?
* John Burns, a former head of the Honolulu Police Department's Espionage Bureau and later a governor of Hawaii, who disclosed shortly before he died that several days before the attack occurred the FBI Agent in Charge of the Honolulu FBI office told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked by the end of the week. Burns' account was confirmed by one of his subordinates.
He waited until "shortly before he died" to share information about treason? A cop? Really? With the FBI implicated as well as who knows how many government officials?
* Helen Hamman, daughter of former senior Red Cross official Don Smith, who contacted the Kimmel family when she heard of efforts to clear Kimmel's name. Mrs. Hamman wrote that her father had told her that FDR had told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and ordered him to secretly arrange for additional medical supplies to be sent to the Red Cross unit in Hawaii and ordered him not to tell anyone in Hawaii why the medical supplies were being sent. Mrs. Hamman added that her father explained that when he expressed objections to this, FDR told him that he needed to allow the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor in order to spark the American people to support entering the war. The arrival of additional medical supplies to Hawaii shortly before the attack has now been confirmed, adding credibility to Mrs. Hamman's disclosure.
The Hawaiian medical establishment fully realized the islands would be an important station for wounded GIs returning to the mainland and began stockpiling supplies in January of 1941, even before Yamamoto made first official mention of his plan to attack Pearl.
* Congressman Martin Dies of Texas, who revealed in his memoir that his committee, while investigating espionage and subversion, came into possession of a Japanese military map that indicated plans to attack Pearl Harbor. Dies explained that he called Sec. of State Hull about the map and that Hull told him that he had discussed the matter with the president and that Dies should keep quiet about the map because of the sensitive, delicate diplomatic situation with Japan. Dies added that Hull asked him to let the president handle this information as he saw fit, and that officials from the Army and the State Department examined the map.
Yep, and Dies was a well-known proto-McCarthyite. And again, why did he sit on this information when Congress was holding hearings? The minority would have made him a hero.
* Thomas Gillette, the nephew of Senator Guy Gillette, who revealed that his uncle had told him that he had been aware of information that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he had advised senior State Department officials of this information.
Yet another person who committed the crime of withholding information of a criminal act from Congress.
* Victor Cavendish-Bentick, the former head of England's Joint Intelligence Committee, who revealed that British intelligence knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that this information was relayed to American officials. For more information on this disclosure and the attempts to discredit it, see Richard Aldrich, Intelligence and the War Against Japan (Cambridge University Press, 2000), pp. 86-88.
Maybe he should have told Churchill? It's the kind of information that would have made the British very popular in the US. And, again I ask, why would the British want the USN crippled at the start of the war?
Notice the mutually corroborating nature of some of these disclosures.

These disclosures are all discussed in Dr. George Victor's book The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable. Most of them are also discussed in John Toland's book Infamy, in Pearcy Greaves' book Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy, and in Dr. George Nash's book Freedom Betrayed.
Victor is an idiot. Greaves is an idiot. Nash is an idiot. I hope that people who buy their books used food money.
 
The fundamental problem with this kind of "ante bellum morning quarterbacking" is that it ignores that all these obvious, impossible-to-ignore signs and portents of what was about to happen occurred over a backdrop of many other signs and portents that were also obvious and impossible-to-ignore but suggested other outcomes entirely.

Military intelligence yields a lot of false positives -- something you have to bear in mind when considering people's reactions then to the positives we know today to be true.

Indeed. Obviously only at the beginning of this interesting thread, but already this reminds me of Bush's warnings about bin Laden.
 
In 1941 the FBI got ~50,000 tips regarding attacks against the US by Japan and/or Germany.

Ooooo-k. Got some info for that? I am aware that such leads were known, but 50,000?

Not that I doubt you, but that is a whole shedload of leads. Further, it gives the lie less grounds, as somehow, someone had to select the correct lead for the conspiracy to fly. Which of fifty thousand rumours would one chose to believe? While I was aware there were many, that is a scale up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom