Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

ANTPogo, it's very hard to argue with people who are willingly misled by these anti-American, anti-science groups, as you are finding out.

The curious "they aren't American" reply that extended this thread, for instance, is profoundly misleading and dishonest. Facts are facts, regardless of who uncovers and exhibits them, and arguing that the facts were exposed by a foreigner is simply meaningless, intentionally misleading, and unnecessarily disputatious.

Indeed.

I'm also not very impressed by the argument from ignorance: "I can't see more than the abstract of that paper published in a peer-reviewed journal, so I don't believe a word of it!". I guess they think being published in a peer-reviewed journal doesn't correlate with being true.

It doesn't surprise me very much that the same people behind tobacco denial and global warming denial are behind the Tea Party too. They're anti-government zealots who genuinely believe that social control of the excesses of capitalism is inherently evil.

Nor does it surprise me that we've got the odd Tea Partier here to go with the GW deniers.
 
Any stats on how many members of the Tea Party use tobacco contrasted with members of other political groups?

I'm guessing a better hook-up for tobacco would be libertarians. Don't those guys seek a free-market hullaballoo, winner take all?
No. You describe an uninformed or unfair critic's cartoon vision of market processes. Monopoly requires unusual circumstances (e.g., the only oasis in 100 miles) or legal protection. Lawn care services, retail grocers, or retail harrdware stores will not normally become monopolies. Competitive markets typically provide better, more varied goods and services at lower unit cost than will a monopolized industry.
 
Last edited:
... It doesn't surprise me very much that the same people behind tobacco denial and global warming denial are behind the Tea Party too. They're anti-government zealots who genuinely believe that social control of the excesses of capitalism is inherently evil.
Try... "It doesn't surprise me very much that the same people behind tobacco denial prohibition and global warming denial alarmism are behind the Tea Party centralization agenda too. They're anti-government socialist zealots who genuinely believe that social control of the excesses of capitalism is inherently evil good."
Parallel structure. We aren't all that different.
 
Last edited:
Try... "It doesn't surprise me very much that the same people behind tobacco denial prohibition and global warming denial alarmism are behind the Tea Party centralization agenda too. They're anti-government socialist zealots who genuinely believe that social control of the excesses of capitalism is inherently evil good."
Parallel structure. We aren't all that different.

You can deny all you want, change fonts all you want, and make up facts not in evidence all you want, but the planet continues to get warmer, nobody's called for the end of private property, and "the excesses of capitalism" does not call for socialism, merely for moderation.
 
You can deny all you want, change fonts all you want, and make up facts not in evidence1 all you want, but the planet continues to get warmer2, nobody's called for the end of private property3, and "the excesses of capitalism" does not call for socialism, merely for moderation4.
1. What facts have I invented?
2. That depends on the time interval under consideration. According to the British Meterological Office, as I understand the current state of expert opinion, there has been no overall warming in the last fifteen years. It's been up and down since the end of the Younger Dryas. Interglacials vary in duration, around 15 to 30 thousand years. The current one is about 15 thousand years old.
3. Actually, lots of people have called for the end of private property. Read Igor Shafareyevitch, The Socialist Phenomenon, and Norman Cohn, The Pursuit of the Millennium. Additionally, more people apparently envision an end to private property but are reserved about expressing their position.
4. Abstractions don't call for anything. Quite often, advocates for regulation make their case as though there were only benefits and as though disinterested regulators may simply be assumed.
 
I don't recall anything about the tobacco industry, but any number of NPR news segments have detailed the considerable funding of Tea Party activities by the Koch brothers and their various corporations.
Their motive is clear; they are anti-tax, anti-regulation, and so forth.
Of course, the same could likely be said of the tobacco industry, since regulation and taxation both have caused serious dents in their profit margin...At least in this country.
 
Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco.

OTOH, just today I was watching Nova, the science program on PBS, and who do suppose was sponsoring the program? The David H. Koch Fund for Science.
So, you know, it seems to me like these guys have maybe been made into a bit too much of a bogeyman on the left. Kind of like how George Soros is a bogeyman to the right. Having an unorthodox political opinion does not make them mustache-twirling villains.
 
OTOH, just today I was watching Nova, the science program on PBS, and who do suppose was sponsoring the program? The David H. Koch Fund for Science.
So, you know, it seems to me like these guys have maybe been made into a bit too much of a bogeyman on the left. Kind of like how George Soros is a bogeyman to the right. Having an unorthodox political opinion does not make them mustache-twirling villains.

No, but defending tobacco companies DOES.
 
OTOH, just today I was watching Nova, the science program on PBS, and who do suppose was sponsoring the program? The David H. Koch Fund for Science.
So, you know, it seems to me like these guys have maybe been made into a bit too much of a bogeyman on the left. Kind of like how George Soros is a bogeyman to the right. Having an unorthodox political opinion does not make them mustache-twirling villains.

No, they aren't moustache-twirling villains or evil masterminds sitting in their secret volcano lair or anything like that.

But they do more than simply have "an unorthodox political opinion".
 

Because they defended by telling people that cigarettes do not and cannot cause cancer.

When we now know they had absolute knowledge that they were telling a lie.

They convinced many people to use their product with fatal consequences with a known lie.

And made a fortune!

If that is not mustache-twirling evil, then it doesn't exist.
 
No, but I think they should be held strictly liable for any damage caused by their product.

If you did this, no industry would exist.

People would have to grow their own.

Do you feel the same about the alcohol industry?
 
Because they defended by telling people that cigarettes do not and cannot cause cancer.

When we now know they had absolute knowledge that they were telling a lie.

They convinced many people to use their product with fatal consequences with a known lie.

And made a fortune!

If that is not mustache-twirling evil, then it doesn't exist.

If someone knowingly defended by saying cigarettes do not and cannot cause cancer at a time when it was known otherwise they should be liable.
 
Do you feel the same about the alcohol industry?

No. The alcohol industry has never tried to hide that alcohol can hurt you if you don't engage in moderation.

And it is possible to consume a moderate amount of alcohol your whole life without any dire consequences, and at a moderate level it might even have health benefits. Beer, for example, is a nutritious food and a safe alternative to drinking the water you find in many places.

No amount of tobacco use is harmless.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom